capital_guy 5 hours ago

Genuinely a massive moment in human history. I'm nervous about what comes. as a SWE the gravy train is basically over in my view. they figured out how to make a program that does the job. Always thought i was set for life. difficult to grasp how much life will change in the coming years.

  • jedberg 5 hours ago

    You need to learn how to build a software factory. How to guide the AI to do the right thing with good taste.

    • hnuser123456 5 hours ago

      Never been a better time to be the "ideas guy", as long as your ideas are good.

    • z0r 5 hours ago

      This advice is a little rich coming from someone who has already won the game of Capital.

      • jfrbfbreudh 5 hours ago

        Sounds like exactly the kind of person I would want advice from?

        • z0r 5 hours ago

          He doesn't need to take his own advice to do well. Possibly he doesn't even have to worry about how his children will fare.

        • snickerbockers 4 hours ago

          The proverbial ladder is being pulled up. Not necessarily by "jedbergh" (disclaimer: i have no idea who that guy is other than having apparently won the game of capital) but it's happening and none of his life experience is going to be replicable so his advice to anybody in a substantially different economic strata is effectively worthless.

          It's like that meme from about a decade back about the millionaire saying that the only reason millennials can't afford houses is that they eat too many avocados. That advice makes sense in a long-gone era where houses are cheap and avocados are expensive, but in the 21st century the price of personal avocado consumption would never add up to a house in a reasonable amount of time no matter how excessive your avocado lifestyle may be. jedbergh is going to be an "avocado guy" from now on (again not that I actually know anything about him).

          • jedberg 4 hours ago

            I disagree. I currently work with a bunch of fresh college grads. We are teaching them to build AI software factories so they can be good at it and grow their careers.

            What is falling away is that we just won't need as many SWEs as we used to. The way to make sure you don't "fall off the ladder" is to make sure you're the best at the new way of doing things.

            • mixmastamyk 4 hours ago

              I agree with snickerbockers. Easy to kick jedberg here, but will mention that I asked him/you for a referral twice last year and was unceremoniously ignored.

              It doesn't matter how good you are at anything when you can't even get a reply from a person. And absolutely forget about learning anything on the job. The ladder is gone. Combined with the war on the middle class, am looking at a retirement in poverty. Even social security is scheduled to be empty in a few years when available.

              • jedberg 4 hours ago

                > but will mention that I asked him/you for a referral twice last year

                Sorry, I just checked and I don't see anything from you. Where did you ask? I try to respond to everything I get, but sometimes gmail doesn't surface random messages.

                • mixmastamyk 4 hours ago

                  I sent two emails to the main domain on your pages at jobs@${username}.net and they didn't bounce. Though I'd appreciate even a low paying job, I'm focused on https://trustworthy.technology/ and FOSDEM27 at the moment. Your interest in any of these would be appreciated.

                  edit: Body contains Fry's Canoga Park etc.

                  • yard2010 3 hours ago

                    If you're getting it after all like this I think it's amazing

        • sl0wbrainRot 4 hours ago

          https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Halo_effect

          Success in a prior time does not guarantee success in the present or future as too many variables are different

          Demographics have shifted wildly and most users are not a soft spoken grama needing help setting up pop3 in Outlook Express

          Look around you; everyone uses their phone at whatever level of expertise they need now

          Goodhart's Law has come for how we used to measure need and todos in tech. We hit the top of the S-curve relevant to this form of computing devices and there is nowhere else to go with it

      • jedberg 5 hours ago

        I'm curious why you say this? Why would my wealth be relevant to the advice given?

        I would understand this comment if I was telling you how to live frugally because it's not my lived experience. But in this case, it is my lived experience. I literally work at a job where I have to build a software factory to be successful.

        • reticulates 4 hours ago

          You're rich enough that you don't have to think about what you'll be working on a decade from now, or even a year from now. Anyone saying that building a software factory is the future of software engineering is looking days, perhaps weeks, into the future. Software factories are a meme that'll be dead in a month. Saying software engineers concerned about their career should learn to make software factories is hollow.

          • jedberg 4 hours ago

            > You're rich enough that you don't have to think about what you'll be working on a decade from now, or even a year from now.

            Perhaps. But I work right now, and I actually care about people other than myself. I would like to see the industry that made me successful keep making others successful.

            We'll have to wait a month or two I suppose to find out if you're right, but I think all companies will be moving to the model of software factories. And It's not something I thought of recently -- I've been building a software factory with AI for a year now, and working with others who are building entire businesses on it.

            And FWIW, pretty much every tech company is now moving towards the same model.

            • pizzafeelsright 4 hours ago

              Maybe I am off but software factories isn't what we are doing per se. I am not sure how successful we are with AI (yet) but our token cost vs results is very exciting.

              This is my first reading about your work but I like your attitude. Databricks is also a good service.

              From what I am seeing, those who embrace AI are embracing the 'computer' from the 80's. The landscape and reality is still being defined.

              To the AI haters and doomers I say buy the largest house with cash you can to enable your retirement. The stress that people experience is the thought of their crushing debt or obligations that can be met with a 90% reduction in spend. Of course, that requires a lifestyle change that most are unwilling to make.

            • Seattle3503 1 hour ago

              Are they factories tailored to the specific product you are creating? I feel like I get good results with a harness, and lessons from factories can be incorporated into models and harnesses as long as the lessons are general.

        • z0r 4 hours ago

          You are speaking of being successful at your current pursuit, but you don't need to be succeed. You're building for fun. You are giving advice to people who need to think about how they will provide for themselves and their dependents for the next few decades.

    • reticulates 5 hours ago

      and then next week you'll need to learn how to build a software factory factory.

      • codeduck 5 hours ago

        you need a abstract software factory for that.

    • saulpw 5 hours ago

      No one knows how to do this, and at the moment I don't think it's possible with current AI. Good taste has to either be trained in (can't be prompted), or might be one of those actual human abilities that can't be artificialized.

    • nateroling 5 hours ago

      But how long until the models can do that too? I’d guess months. No one person’s taste an experience will have much value compared with the combined taste and expertise of the entire internet.

      • moffkalast 4 hours ago

        Even if it takes years, it doesn't matter. And once that is solved, you can make hardware do anything you want, and the next 10-20 years will be all out automation of every physical job as well.

        I don't really see a future where human labour at all can still be competitive beyond like 2050 in any field. Anyone who's ridden in a Tesla in FSD knows transport jobs are defacto over, the tech works and it will be copied and deployed en masse sooner or later. Humans don't scale and we haven't meaningfully mentally improved in 100k years, we're limited to 20W of compute, take 20+ years to train and go EoL in 40 after that. It's inevitable that we'll be outclassed and it only needs to happen once. Once a model exists that is slightly better at just one specific task, it only gets cheaper over time and it can be used for that forever.

      • timacles 4 hours ago

        > combined taste and expertise of the entire internet

        large groups of people dont have good taste. Its always going to be reversion to the mean. which is just mediocre software

    • rspeele 4 hours ago

      How many different "software factories" does the world need? How many engineers to maintain them?

      I assume the premise of a software factory is that it can churn out any software idea you have. You won't need to build a new distinct factory for each new distinct piece of software you dream up. Otherwise it wouldn't be called building a software factory, it would just be called building software.

      So if somebody gets this right (this remains to be seen, the various Gas Towns of the world have not proven their value), won't one good software factory be enough for everyone to download and use? Wouldn't we all then be done with the labor of making both software and software factories?

      • pianopatrick 4 hours ago

        Actually, if we really follow the "factory" idea, wouldn't that lead to the idea that each "software factory" churns out one specific standardized type of software in a particular way? That's how real factories work.

        For example, I could clearly see having a "Static web page with HTML and CSS only software factory" that just churned out that kind of software. Or a "Postgresql optimized SQL" software factory. And so on.

        • codethief 3 hours ago

          Maybe. But then you train a model on the different open-source factories and end up with a factory factory, and then you're back to what the parent said.

          • andrekandre 3 hours ago
              > end up with a factory factory
            

            java nightmare ensues...

        • andrekandre 3 hours ago

          it just sounds like reusable components that you can build on, to me anyways

          every company is making a totally different product so its hard to see how every company is its own 'software factory' outside of such components (which they were already doing even before llms)

          • pianopatrick 1 hour ago

            Sure, the factory part is that you have AI put the re-usable components together instead of human software developers.

            And while many companies may have differences, there are certain things most companies need, like a marketing website.

    • AndrewKemendo 4 hours ago

      I don’t think so.

      Unless we organize to prevent it, technology will continue be commoditized like all other technology into the hands of a few players.

      And especially with AI it’s going to look more and more like nuclear or biological technology and that’s why you see so much push for regulatory capture.

      Literally all I do is spend my time trying to figure out how to prevent this, and still make progress towards AGI for everyone, but it doesn’t seem like people care

      Everyone just wants their bag everything else be damned, and that’s what we’re seeing

    • sl0wbrainRot 4 hours ago

      Copium.

      See web dev jobs tanking. Backend is next.

      Backend dev opinions/arbitrary strings are being compressed out of the stack.

      Devs that don't understand hardware development are naive about the endgame; black boxes that boot to a Google Opal like GUI.

      Boot to Blender-like/WYSIWG environment loaded from a model itself. All the context we put in files added as vectors on the presentation layer.

      Users will conjure a word processor or email UI and then a video game.

      Network gear will boot a model to handle the specific job the model was trained on. That's what all the Stargate stuff is about but obfuscated behind marketing to hide implementation goals details from knowledgeable labor to avoid public scrutiny. Vague scrutiny without concrete proof is fine but if we could point to the details too they'd be naked.

      50 million devs globally among 8 billion that do not want a subscription service to an expert when they have no such leverage over the expert themselves.

      This isn't empty speculation. Hardware industry executives are responding to social pressure at scale.

      America was able to leverage its clout to empower IT to pretend it's more than just math relative to memory and display matrices but America no longer has the global clout to assure that. To Chinese engineers it's just math.

      American software devs were engaged in sophistry and social moat building. Ya got disrupted by the world. Believed they would ignore their eyes for the rhetoric and hype forever; rather Orwellian really.

  • FLeXMurphy 5 hours ago

    Needlessly negative. If your job can be replaced by a program, what kind of an SWE are you?

    • honeycrispy 5 hours ago

      Haven't we already had this debate like a thousand times?

    • hkt 5 hours ago

      One of 99% of us, one assumes

    • legobmw99 5 hours ago

      The shoes made in the first factory were, by every measure but one, far worse than those made by hand. But just by being cheaper, they still put almost every cobbler out of business within a generation

      • FLeXMurphy 5 hours ago

        We put people out of business, out of jobs, almost regularly, without stopping. Invention is like that. Markets, cutthroat competition are like that. Businesses have to keep up with changes, and thrive. Software engineering, like many other types of engineering professions, remain. It is not so much to do with developing individual software per-se but I see your point. If "SWE" means slinging together WordPress sites, then yes, that's more applicable to the cobbler business.

        The work of software engineers has enabled a (temporary?) profession of mostly busy-hands sort of work to thrive, mostly achieved by automation. For any software to presently work entails a substantial amount of things working in an automatic or "factorized" fashion. Thus, the engineering aspects will now move onto enabling a different sort of work, before it factorizes it, also.

        • bmurphy1976 4 hours ago

          What you say is true, but the breadth and pace at which things are changing now is not something our society is set up to handle. The amount of potential disruption is more like a WW2 level of change, not "the manufacturing sector has slowly declined over the last 50 years."

          This is multi-generational change happening in a decade. This is disruption across nearly all industries simultaneously. We can't just waive that away. There are going to be consequences.

      • newsy-combi 5 hours ago

        And factory shoes still suck to this day, they even have planned obsolence built in. The same outcome is guaranteed for anything AI. The bearer of the quality decrease in software, customer support, education, and later medicine, law, infrastructure, architecture, etc. will be the customer.

      • gib444 4 hours ago

        I purchased some handmade English oxford shoes for a very reasonable £300 some 15 years ago. I knew they were a good investment then, and I still believe that now.

        But... I've also spent an incredible amount on poorer quality shoes and regretted it often. Many £50-150 shoes that just didn't last. The obvious planned obsolescence of eg trainer (sneaker) soles is just so obvious.

        Damn it, why can't I learn the lesson!

      • lordnacho 4 hours ago

        Would it be better if loads of people didn't have access to shoes?

        We have to balance "a lot of people can get the product" with "product is high quality" somehow.

        • legobmw99 4 hours ago

          One way we could hope to balance that is by trying to ensure that most of the excess value created by new innovations is actually dispersed rather than captured by an elite few at the top. We've not been good at doing this.

      • hesnuts 4 hours ago

        I have no idea wtf I'm going to do. I'm not good at anything else and it seems obvious that all other jobs that require a human still are going to be flooded with potential labor, and devalued salaries to the point of being useless. I dont see how society gets around this. No gov is going to be able to figure out UBI in the needed timescale, if ever. Shit b fucked.

        • tripleee 4 hours ago

          People working in the tech industry are far better at learning than most others. We'll adapt. Self pity on the other hand won't help anyone.

        • viklove 4 hours ago

          First we're gonna downsize to cheaper apartments. Sell the car. Try to find a different job (I imagine lots of engineers will end up as EMTs, plumbers, etc -- professions where you are solving problems with some level of independence). Then those jobs get saturated and eventually there's nowhere left to go. Look for retail/waiter jobs and try your luck there.

          Eventually we just accept the new status quo, and the QOL hit that comes with it.

          Anyone who hasn't FIRE'd yet should aggressively be saving as much as possible before shit hits the fan.

          Good luck everyone! It's going to get ugly.

    • mixmastamyk 5 hours ago

      It doesn't matter when there are not enough jobs for 8/10 employees. Try getting a reply, much less an offer, from anyone in this environment.

      • eru 4 hours ago

        Overall unemployment is still fairly low.

        (And I'm getting lots of job offers. But I'm in Singapore, and that's presumably not where you are.)

        • mixmastamyk 4 hours ago

          "Overall" doesn't help older tech experts right now. Put your money where your mouth is, and send me one of those. ;-)

          • eru 14 minutes ago

            Well, the job offers I'm getting are usually for me personally, I don't think they are alienable or transferable. But I can try.

            I'm 40 now. Not sure if that counts as older.

    • jr3592 5 hours ago

      So tired of seeing posts like this. You clearly aren't working at an AI first shop. If you've seen what you can do with AI, if its used correctly and broadly... you would not make that comment.

      • FLeXMurphy 4 hours ago

        What if I do, and what if I did?

        • jr3592 4 hours ago

          Then I'd posit your org isn't using it correctly.

          "if its used correctly and broadly"

          It's not enough to just have a claude code subscription for every engineer.

          The powerband of AI comes through automation, integration, and tooling. When literally everything is touched by AI, and when most tasks get passed through AI before seeing a human, only then are you actually at an AI-first shop.

          Only then will you actually realize how little you do in this AI-first world.

          • cesarb 4 hours ago

            > Then I'd posit your org isn't using it correctly.

            "You are holding it wrong."

  • beachy 5 hours ago

    I started programming 50 years ago. At one stage early in my career this mysterious new language C was the thing, and I went on an all expenses paid 2 week course in Singapore where they flew attendees in from around the world to learn this language. Software has been good to me.

    Now it seems like it's the sunset of this way of making a living. I think people who manage to move up the food chain a bit will succeed but its hard to advise any junior in the industry exactly what that looks like.

    • jr3592 5 hours ago

      I hope you realize how lucky you were. C's release is a similar effect, but not exactly the same. Development got easier, but not by the leaps and bounds that it has with AI.

      You got 50 years, but many people haven't. There are so many people out there in the prime of their careers right now, I genuinely worry about them and what this does for their livelihood.

      • furyofantares 4 hours ago

        Not OP but I feel extremely lucky to be at the tail end of my career.

        If I could pick an age for this all to happen, it would be when I was 16, just starting to get into computers. I think I would enjoy the hell out of the new world, getting in on the ground floor at the very start of my journey. But my 2nd pick would be my current age, at the tail end of my career. I get to see this crazy transformation, but I've already reaped most of the rewards of everything I learned that is potentially becoming quickly obsolete.

        I really don't envy those mid-career, who have put tons of work into their craft but have yet to reap the majority of the rewards (which tend to be stacked later in career rather than evenly spread out.)

        • coffeebeqn 3 hours ago

          I don’t really know what to think. I’m 15 years in but honestly at least 15 to go. I’m in a good position right now but the future becomes very hazy two+ years from now. Not “dooming” just based on this year I have no fucking clue what’s coming next

          • jr3592 1 hour ago

            Yup, agreed. If you're in the middle of your career you're not in a terrible spot right now but you stand to potentially lose a lot thanks to AI.

            You've worked hard and build a knowledge-base that was extremely lucrative; That's becoming less and less true. The "democratization" of software is a great thing for people who wanted to get into it, but found it too difficult. It's a horrible thing for those who made a living on it being difficult.

            And I'm not even advocating that we should halt progress. This is how humanity has always evolved technology. Jobs exist where technology can't replace them, until it does. Software had a good run, I just wish it'd been longer.

        • jr3592 2 hours ago

          Exactly. You understand it.

      • oblio 4 hours ago

        You're both agreeing rather strongly.

      • lynndotpy 2 hours ago

        We don't need to speak in circles about it. For a lot of them, what this means is that their livelihood is over. A lot of people have sacrificed years for nothing.

    • jacquesm 5 hours ago

      It's not just software. It's everything that can be transformed into bits. And that's a lot of stuff.

      • jader201 4 hours ago

        It’s not even just everything that can be transformed into bits.

        Nearly everything will (eventually) be impacted.

        Therapists? People are using LLMs for “free” help.

        Physical trainers? Just upload a video of your workout to an LLM for tuning advice and other exercises you can focus on.

        Appliance/vehicle repair? Just DIY it with an LLM.

        Teachers? Just teach yourself with an LLM.

        I could go on.

        To be clear, I’m not saying LLMs are better at this. But just saying LLMs are impacting nearly every field.

        EDIT: just to clarify some of the responses talking about full replacement -- that's not my point here. I'm talking about impacting, not replacing. Software engineering likely won't get fully replaced (anytime soon), either -- but it's definitely being impacted.

        • smarf 4 hours ago

          The driving metric seems to be accessibility:quality and LLM accessibility is unmatched

        • cubefox 4 hours ago

          And it will not be limited to LLMs. In just a few years, they will likely figure out robotics and continual learning. Then all jobs are affected. I'm very worried about what's coming for all people who rely on wages to survive.

          • bel_marinaio 4 hours ago

            All jobs will be affected before robotics. When there are less white collar jobs there will be more people competing for blue collar jobs.

            More workers competing means lower pay. Less good paying jobs means less customers. Less customers means less jobs. This is an over simplification, but is one possible future.

            I'd be happier if my prediction turns out wrong.

            • cubefox 3 hours ago

              The labor share of GDP has been decreasing for a long time, but when jobs are automated more and more, it will approach zero.

        • wcski 4 hours ago

          Classic doomer vibes. If we were to quantify the impact of LLM's on teaching, auto maintenance, therapy, and trainers / PT, I don't think your thesis would hold up substantially.

        • bliteben 4 hours ago

          There has basically been nothing in appliance or vehicle repair you could not google for a decade.

          • myth_drannon 3 hours ago

            Now I just send photos during the process and Claude plans, helps and corrects me. I did plumbing and appliance jobs that I would have never tried before.

        • WarmWash 4 hours ago

          LLMs will be used to advance robotics and then who knows.

          Nothing makes sense or is computable when human labor/knowledge has little to no value. It's a bit like an economic event horizon

          • bongofizzbuzz 4 hours ago

            And those Robots making Stuff we want thus crashing prices.

          • mullingitover 4 hours ago

            > It's a bit like an economic event horizon

            Actually makes everything a lot simpler, economically.

            Economics is the study of how to equitably distribute scarce resources. When everyone's contributions are equally meaningless (because hey, we made this do-everything bot that will do your job, no matter how much you were worth in the before-time) then the whole convoluted, often inequitable distribution scheme is paved over with the brutal 'your share = [resources] / [number of people]' equation.

            • wat10000 3 hours ago

              We can hope that's true but I'm highly skeptical. Resource distribution isn't about contributions, it's about power. Current economic systems are set up such that one's power is often related to one's contributions through the magic of money. But power is also related to one's property, through the magic of ownership. I don't see why ownership would go away just because the paying jobs go away. Then power concentrates in the wealthy far beyond what we see today, and the rest of us will be stuck with little recourse but to hope that they give us some crumbs from their table.

              • anhyz 2 hours ago

                > But power is also related to one's property, through the magic of ownership. I don't see why ownership would go away just because the paying jobs go away.

                Ownership is a social construct, backed by the rule of law. If we rapidly take away the ability for the masses to be able to afford to own things, there isn't any magic preventing them from deciding to not honor that particular construct anymore.

                The bigger question is, if that does come to pass, will the AI overlords still have enough power to enforce their ownership claims the old fashioned way -- with violence?

                I'm afraid this is going to get very ugly.

          • Flere-Imsaho 3 hours ago

            Capitalism basically stops working at this point. The only thing that'll matter is who has access to resources (energy, rare earth minerals, etc). Us normies will live under those who have access. Perhaps some new economic model will emerge that gives people value?

        • ModernMech 4 hours ago

          If everyone could teach themselves with an LLM they would have already been doing this with the Internet, television, or books. Plenty of people can, but those who don’t find it easier to learn in school.

          The real danger for teachers is society deciding people don’t need to be educated. Although that would be a problem for all of us actually.

        • Fr0styMatt88 4 hours ago

          Here’s hoping there’s only 24 hours in a day :)

          Sure, in THEORY we can do all these things, but I suspect this fear is somewhat borne out of the same error that mashes us estimate a task will take 6 hours and then it takes a week.

          We systematically underestimate the human effort needed. How many non-technical, non-interested people are going to be looking up DIY for fixing their car, buying the needed equipment, developing the skill, etc, really?

          While they’re doing that, they’ll somehow also have time to produce their own movies, write their own indie games, etc, etc.

          Fast food is available; people still go to restaurants. I can sketch on a piece of paper, but I still buy art. It’s technically not difficult to build a chair, but I still buy furniture, etc.

          It’s going to have a massive impact for sure, but we have to temper our expectations and ground them in real, practical limits.

          Definitely some interesting years ahead. Fingers crossed.

        • tavavex 4 hours ago

          The last two aren't knowledge-constrained. You could find anything you could ever need on these topics even before LLMs. The reason so many people don't DIY their repairs is because they lack the tools, time, desire to do the dirty work or are afraid they'll mess it up. For teaching, you could already teach yourself any degree, the point in education is the structure that forces you to go through with it (most people don't have the determination on their own) and to have an accreditation that someone has actually ensured you acquired the knowledge you say you did.

          • simondotau 1 hour ago

            Proving that someone has acquired knowledge is something an LLM could do better than a human institution. Stick the human in a room which detects foreign electronics, and have the LLM run a highly interactive and unpredictable set of challenges for the human to solve. Have the LLM weight its grade on an understanding of the underlying principles.

            Done right, that accreditation could be objectively superior to brand names like Harvard, etc.

        • betterunix2 4 hours ago

          > Therapists? People are using LLMs for “free” help.

          And the results are poor because the LLM does not have a face and is not reading your facial expressions or hearing the tone of your voice. We communicate with more than just the words we speak.

          > Physical trainers? Just upload a video of your workout

          ...lol

          > Appliance/vehicle repair? Just DIY it with an LLM.

          "Officer you can't arrest me and impound my car, I did what the LLM told me to do. It's not my fault that a wheel fell off and my exhaust is an eerie green color!"

          > Teachers? Just teach yourself with an LLM.

          See above about therapy, there is more to teaching than spitting out words.

          > I could go on.

          You could, but at what point will you get to the few lines of work that are genuinely going to disappear because of this technology? Taxi drivers are the most obvious, and least discussed, example -- self driving cars will eliminate that entire profession over the next few decades.

          • jader201 4 hours ago

            > And the results are poor because the LLM does not have a face and is not reading your facial expressions or hearing the tone of your voice. We communicate with more than just the words we speak.

            I don't disagree. But I think people will still use it. We've seen how people Googled stuff to get help in this area, and it's 100x easier with LLMs.

            >> Physical trainers?

            > ... lol

            I disagree here. I think LLMs are decent at getting someone dumb to working out, like me, from zero to establishing a decent workout plan, and making adjustments as you go, if you give it enough context on your health, and how things are working for you.

            Again, I'm not saying LLMs are better at it, but I think it's arguable that people will figure out that they can use an LLM to get started pretty easily, where they used to go to physical trainers.

            > "Officer you can't arrest me and impound my car, I did what the LLM told me to do. It's not my fault that a wheel fell off and my exhaust is an eerie green color!"

            I was already doing a lot of my own home/vehicle work via YouTube. Now I almost never taking my vehicle into the shop (for what I think are relatively small repairs that aren't safety hazards, like fan repairs, electronics, etc.).

            Additionally, I now upload repair estimates to an LLM, and have it push back on things that I can either do myself, or do somewhere else and save a lot. And this has, indeed, kept me from spending as much for vehicle repairs (cutting into their margins).

            Similarly, I've uploaded pics/videos of appliances bugging out on me, and have been able to fix many things myself. I used to already do this to an extent with YouTube, but would still have to figure a lot of things out myself. Being able to upload pics/videos changes things quite a bit.

            >> Teachers?

            > See above about therapy, there is more to teaching than spitting out words.

            Again, agree mostly on this one. But the value of higher education has already been in question for a while, and I think LLMs are only pushing this further.

            I don't think teachers/professors will get replaced (anytime soon), but I have kids and know parents of kids that are using LLMs to help them in ways that they used to rely on teachers for.

            > You could, but at what point will you get to the few lines of work that are genuinely going to disappear because of this technology?

            I'm not necessarily talking about full replacement. Agree that this is very possible/likely with taxi drivers. And I do think some fields will also get replaced, some that we may not even consider now (would we have thought 15 years ago that taxi drivers would get replaced in our lifetime?).

            But my point is that LLMs are going to, at the very least, have an impact on many non-digital fields.

        • nostrademons 4 hours ago

          My top priority today is raising my kids, which LLMs have been stupendously unhelpful with, although they were pretty useful in setting up a home server and Jellyfin so I could give them a curated, parent-vetted set of TV shows to watch.

          I think this is a very good template for what sort of skills will survive the LLM-apocalypse and what won't. LLMs are the great homogenizer. Any type of knowledge work where there is a broadly-accepted set of best practices for how to do it is gonna get outsourced to an AI.

          But AI is terrible at doing anything unique, personalized, and based on your own desires, because it doesn't have your desires. It's building on a corpus of shared knowledge, but there is a large set of knowledge that is unshared, and it can't do anything for that. A large portion of business, for example, is secrets and lies, and an LLM isn't going to be able to help you much with that. At its best it can set up the frameworks and tools to help you keep secrets and tell lies.

          And then a large portion of life is personal preferences, the things that make you unique and distinct from every other human, and an LLM can't help you with that either. There is a reason I don't have a nanny raise my kids, even though we could afford it. If I did that, it would be the nanny raising my kids, which defeats a lot of the point of having kids in the first place. LLMs have the same problem.

          • qlte 4 hours ago

            That tracks with my experience trying to get "deep"/obscure recommendations for TV shows from the 70s/80s/90s and niche books from either Claude/Gemini/ChatGPT.

            I keep trying to nudge them to be relevant with specific examples of a few shows I had watched that were very popular at the time but now considered "old/boring/not remastered" so don't make it into the Best X Shows of XXs lists that emphasize modern tastes. But the recommendations were either the same things I already knew about, or were just wrong/irrelevant for various reasons.

            Recently I stumbled onto a Reddit post from years ago with a similar request to mine, and both the question itself and top answers were a goldmine of suggestions that were never recommended and I hadn't heard of. I knew within seconds of looking at the IMDB that they would be exactly what I wanted, so it's not like the AI recs are failing just because of idiosyncratic taste. They just don't seem to search from a deep enough info source, have been RLed into conformity, or some other disconnect between intent and execution.

        • xp84 4 hours ago

          With respect to repair: it would take a massive sea change in how things are made for that to ever happen. Of course, appliances are mostly uneconomic to repair already.

          Cars are too expensive to not repair, but the complexity of car repair is way too high. Even with an incredibly specific and accurate video, even one made lovingly by a knowledgeable mechanic, most repairs are beyond most people’s physical skills.

          I do mostly agree with your thesis, still. Being closer to education than many other fields, though, I remain unconvinced that AI will handle children well.

          College, on the other hand? For many reasons, colleges should be an existential crisis right now. Nothing about college makes sense from cost to how AI-cheating changes things, to job prospects for most majors.

        • rwyinuse 4 hours ago

          "Teachers? Just teach yourself with an LLM."

          Good luck replacing elementary / high school teachers with LLM's. Their job is about so much more than just teaching.

        • lukasm 2 hours ago

          LLMs are really bad at therapy because of sycophancy, cannot read emotions and body language, gives some generic advice. In many cases they make things worse.

          My wife has a deep expertise in modern therapy* and I saw her use ChatGPT. The difference is between "I want to fetch better products" vs "modify this index to use embeddings with model XXX"

          *people's mental model of therapy comes from the movies, books or TV shows. Modern therapy doesn't look like an episode of Sopranos

      • flowerlad 4 hours ago

        Some jobs require more than just intelligence--for example, nurses, chefs, judges, reporters, teachers, caregivers, therapists, social workers, hair stylists, coaches, paramedics, firefighters, police officers, electricians, plumbers, mechanics, clergy, trial lawyers and diplomats.

        What is the common thread?

        These jobs depend on some combination of physical skill, human connection, trust, judgment and accountability, and such jobs are out of reach of AI.

        • zabriel_goss 4 hours ago

          The other common thread for most of what you've listed is, unfortunately, comparably lower pay.

          Arguably, software has times that require physical presence, human connection, trust, judgment, and accountability.

          • xp84 4 hours ago

            It does, but the PE firms and tech giants that employ most software developers at this point desire to minimize or eliminate that. I can already see where accountability is going: we’re just going to have frequent outages of a lot of core dependencies, and everyone will just point at the news and say “we were down today because of Microsoft/Apple/Cloudflare/AWS/etc.”

            • z0r 4 hours ago

              Yep. The dream of AI powered software development is the continued "private equitization" of America. Replace skilled labor with unskilled labor, less heads per unit of output (software subscriptions or whatever have you), and a degradation of product quality to increase profitability. People developing AI "software engineering" tools are advancing this agenda of hollowing out the economy for profit, even if they imagine the tools they are building can produce results better than what we had before.

          • rvz 4 hours ago

            > Arguably, software has times that require physical presence, human connection, trust, judgment, and accountability.

            Depends on what the software does and it is application.

            If its a tiny video game, journaling app or camera app that requires little human interaction: Then it isn't important.

            If it is infrastructure-level, critical and time-sensitive and deals with highly regulatory industries such as finance, crypto, healthcare, legal, manufacturing and has a chance of risk to the human then that software will continue to be used and pay will remain high.

        • salah7252 4 hours ago

          Automation and robotics are also surging rather silently in the shadows as AI is the lead that’s getting attention. And AI happens to be congruent with those 2.

        • xtracto 4 hours ago

          Oooh it won't be black and white: It will start with 1 helper robot per nurse, yo help her in the repetitive or heavy tasks.

          Then they will be able to do more and more, and 1 nurse will be able to do the job of 4-5 2020 nurses.

          Until that nurse is a dude from Mexico [where im from/based] giving instructions to all the robots.

          • ivell 3 hours ago

            I am not that sure. Nurses deal with vulnerable humans, and I am not sure if there would be acceptance by humans to be tended by robots. Same with kindergarten and probably primary teachers.

            There are some professions where human touch is in demand (this is not about capability, but about user experience in sense of human interface)

            • LunaSea 2 hours ago

              No company has ever cared about "human touch" before and pricing will simply impose robots as the only available option if you're not rich.

            • dalyons 1 hour ago

              You think our late stage capitalism will give them a choice? Human nurses will be priced so high as to be out of reach, so it will be accept robots or don’t get healthcare

        • lr4444lr 4 hours ago

          It won't be tomorrow, but I'm not so sure blue collar technicians (plumbers, mechanics, electricians) are far behind: once parts become modular enough, with sufficient sensor data, a cloud system at the manufacturer for your car, boiler, or home lighting system will be able to give you step by step instructions for how to replace and repair items, and will ship you the replacements and tools needed.

          Of course the elderly and frail and people too afraid to touch something lest they break it will still call an expert, and original build and installations will need those trained, but I could see vast swaths of less technically skilled people opting for a go at routine repairs which could really hollow out the demand.

          • joquarky 3 hours ago

            > Of course the elderly and frail and people too afraid to touch something lest they break it will still call an expert

            And where do they get the money to pay for this when all of the knowledge work is gone?

            • vardalab 3 hours ago

              From their investments, ofc. At least I think that's what our tech overlords seem to think, lol.

          • skydhash 2 hours ago

            You could do this today for most cars. As long as you got the tools needed and the manual. But people still don’t want to do it. Just like some don’t like to change their tires or replace their oil. It’s work and people don’t like some work, even when easy.

        • horsawlarway 4 hours ago

          I think ultimately this is a flawed understanding of the incentives at play.

          None of these end up really being out of reach of AI if Anthropic can justify this valuation. They're just slower to roll out.

        • 14u2c 4 hours ago

          Is software engineering really that different? The most effective devs are those who don't just have a vision but can work across the org to generate buy-in and enthusiasm to make that vision a reality. This very human process, driven by relationships etc.

          • flowerlad 3 hours ago

            Right, coding as a profession is going away, but the software business is alive and well. CS graduates must see themselves as being in the software business as opposed to being just coders. That means you should talk to customers, gather requirements, write specifications, generate code, build, test, debug, deploy, secure, support, monitor, be on-call, handle incidents, track bugs and so on.

            • coffeebeqn 3 hours ago

              That’s very tough when you’re starting out though. I am curious what entry level jobs will look like. Until now it was to do tickets until you have enough exposure to how things work after a year or two to start owning some parts

            • decidu0us9034 1 hour ago

              I would've agreed with this up until very recently, but we have agents now who are rapidly improving at all these tasks

        • wat10000 3 hours ago

          AI is already replacing some reporters, therapists, and lawyers. One might argue that it shouldn't (an AI therapist is a bit of a scary concept) but it does. And they're only getting better.

        • notJim 2 hours ago

          Doctors, nurses, therapists, coaches and reporters will definitely see impact. AI is already being used for all of these things, although probably not very effectively/safely. In the near future, better tools will come out that fix the worst drawbacks. All of these will still have use-cases for a human, for example in very difficult cases, or of course when a human is needed for the actual treatment, but at the margins, AI will chip away at them.

          If predictions about robotics are accurate, things will get even more difficult in the next ten years as humanoid robots mature.

        • decidu0us9034 1 hour ago

          If say 30% of the white collar workforce is laid off, many of those professions would likely be severely impacted by the resulting deflation. We're all connected.

      • bluegatty 4 hours ago

        I think this is not right.

        LLMs are hugely suited to code because it's token heavy and the compiler is the RLHF verifier.

        The LLMs are still very bad at concepts.

        What we see in code does not translate to other, arbitrary domains.

        Legal - yes, due to text heavy content with tons of great examples as well.

        Everything else ... not really. At least not LLMs as we understand them today.

        • 14u2c 4 hours ago

          That just means those systems are not yet sufficiently formalized. I think LLMs are pretty bad at math too but with Lean they are churning out results.

        • hathawsh 4 hours ago

          An LLM by itself is quirky and prone to error, but that's not where the next wave of innovation is happening. Look at harnesses instead. A harness like a coding agent is an incredible productivity multiplier. Coding agents are just the first type of harness. We should expect businesses everywhere to create other kinds of harnesses, thereby transforming every domain where money can be made from increased efficiency. All one has to do is ask a coding agent to build a different kind of harness.

          • bluegatty 2 hours ago

            Not much will come from harnesses, but I agree an abstraction on top could yield something. But not just 'harness' as we see them today.

        • mapontosevenths 3 hours ago

          Like two or three generations of frontier ago (in the long long ago of last year), I had ChatGPT design a PCB, then Claude a case, then I had China manufacture it on demand and turned it into a real product that shipped to real users. Those chinese factories were mostly staffed by machines, I suspect.

          I'm not the only one that had that idea, they're advertising these things as features now.

          I don't know what's next, but keep in mind that today's LLM's are the worst they'll ever be.

          • spudlyo 3 hours ago

            > "... but keep in mind that today's LLM's are the worst they'll ever be."

            That's like saying in 2011: "today's Google search is the worst it will ever be."

            Enshitification is coming my friend. We're just now starting to see the kinds of refusals that LLMs will ultimately end up with to protect IP owners and the status quo. We'll look back at this time and marvel that LLMs used to be able to reverse engineer software, or able to create derivative IP works.

          • binary0010 3 hours ago

            What do you think about the fact that gpt sol 6.2 is worse than 6.1 sol (according to code benches and most developers experience) and the new fable 5.2 is not better than opus 5.5 despite costing SIGNIFICANTLY (like 6x more) more p/task?

            I wonder if we are seeing them maxing out llm model capabilities now...

          • bluegatty 2 hours ago

            I hear you - but - I think we are seeing diminishing marginal returns on LLMs already.

            They are going to be 'better than what they are today' but I don't see obvious unlocks.

            We need more abstractions on top of them.

        • coffeebeqn 3 hours ago

          This honestly just sounds like you haven’t really explored the capabilities of the current bleeding edge

          • bluegatty 1 hour ago

            I've used almost every model the day it comes out for years and I post-train models of various sizes. If you think this has anything to do with 'bleeding edge' you might want to try tuning them to get an intuition as to how they work.

            • famouswaffles 30 minutes ago

              But used them for what? I can certainly tell you software and law is not remotely the only thing frontier models have gotten much better at and improving. Honestly just sounds ridiculous to me.

    • tom_walters 5 hours ago

      I was thinking about exactly this earlier and, not knowing the history, was imagining a kind of shift from binary to assembly, to basic, to C and beyond, and the pace difference here. What was your perception of C at the time, and how long did it take to change the culture away from whatever it displaced?

      • beachy 4 hours ago

        The specific area was airline control systems. I'm well out of anything to do with that now, but a long time ago these systems were absolutely engineered for performance and so C was radical as a high level language that could compete with pure assembler for speed.

        Two examples of the lengths people went to for performance - 1) the networking hardware, terminals and everything were special airline flavors that sent data in 6 bits rather than 8, just to squeeze more data onto the wire. Is you look over someone's shoulder at an airline booking screen even now you'll see an all caps look - that's why. All caps means less bits.

        The second was a little before my time but the geniuses who maintained the assembler code were very close to the hardware. Some used programming tricks to account for the rotational speed of the DASD, so the software would be ready to pull bits off the hard drive just as those bits rotated around and arrived at the read heads. Insane optimisations.

        I'm out of the area now so I didn't know what the state of the art is, presumably there's not any IBM assembler still lurking but it certainly wouldn't surprise me.

        • tom_walters 2 hours ago

          Very interesting, thanks for sharing! Love the point about caps.

    • eru 4 hours ago

      Interesting. Why did they teach you C in Singapore?

      • hermannj314 4 hours ago

        I think it is closely related to the same reason you should only learn about Cisco routers in Las Vegas.

        • rhapsodic 4 hours ago

          >I think it is closely related to the same reason you should only learn about Cisco routers in Las Vegas.

          What reason is that?

          • stickfigure 3 hours ago

            Trade shows in Las Vegas are a tax-deductible way for employees to have fun.

        • eru 10 minutes ago

          Maybe. Though Singapore isn't exactly known for its vibrant nightlife. (I migrated here. It's great, but not exactly exciting. Doing any kind of business in Singapore is a safe and boring default nobody will fire you for.)

      • SoftTalker 4 hours ago

        My question as well. I learned it in a couple of days from the K&R book. It's not a big language.

        • hereonout2 4 hours ago

          Sounds like they are talking about training that happened in the 1970s, possibly before K&R book was even published. A training course like this could even have been targeted at those doing COBOL on punch cards for the IBM mainframe.

    • CamperBob2 4 hours ago

      Things were not supposed to stay the same for 50 years in this business. If someone told you that was what was going to happen, you'd have looked at them funny. Yet that's exactly what happened.

      The changes taking place now are not unexpected, and not unwelcome, but long overdue.

      (Of course, whether that justifies assigning a significant chunk of the US stock market's value to Anthropic is another question entirely, and not as easy to handwave away.)

      • StilesCrisis 4 hours ago

        Things changed. We took a detour into Electron land for at least ten years.

    • pembrook 4 hours ago

      If we're being honest, hundreds of thousands of people making $200K-800K in comp (roughly 20-80X the global median income) to push updates to react components on CRUD apps and responding thumbs up to slack messages was never going to last. (yes, i know im trivializing but this made up the daily work of a surprisingly high percentage of these people)

      For anyone who nabbed the outsized returns while they existed, be thankful you got them at all, and hopefully you saved some of it. Due to geographic barriers to movement, 96% of humanity never had the opportunity to work in tech and profit off the supply/demand gap. LLMs arbitraged that gap, and now we can diffuse these capabilities throughout the entire world at extremely low cost.

      AI is a giant compression and de-duplication algorithm on white collar labor, and it was needed. We've had an over-production of white collar elites problem for a while now resulting in policy errors in most developed economies who completely ignored building in the real world.

      Don't worry, humanity still has more than a few problems to solve. There's infinite jobs to be done. The nature of humanity is that our expectations always grow to exceed our current capabilities. And with AI, you don't need to sit in a classroom for 6 years to get up to speed on the next job to be done.

      • matheusmoreira 4 hours ago

        > and now we can diffuse these capabilities throughout the entire world at extremely low cost

        If the US government allows it, of course. It just banned my country from buying data center nvidia chips.

      • mancerayder 4 hours ago

        >AI is a giant compression and de-duplication algorithm on white collar labor, and it was needed. We've had an over-production of white collar elites problem for a while now resulting in policy errors in most developed economies who completely ignored building in the real world.

        >Don't worry, humanity still has more than a few problems to solve. There's infinite jobs to be done. The nature of humanity is that our expectations always grow to exceed our current capabilities. And with AI, you don't need to sit in a classroom for 6 years to get up to speed on the next job to be done.

        You sound like someone who's overly cocksure that you've figured it all out. By It I mean, how to organize society. What Policy Errors would not have been made, in your scenario?

        • pembrook 2 hours ago

          Just a few policy errors due to the over production of white collar elites:

          - The entire west relocating all key assets like factories, mines and steel production to the developing world/China (factories? yuck)

          - Neglecting to build homes in basically all western countries for the past 18 years (construction? yuck)

          - Virtue signaling going green by pushing energy/fertilizer production offshore to less regulated countries and then importing it back at even higher net carbon costs (fossil fuels? yuck)

          - Getting overly hysterical during Covid due to WFH being viable for the white collar class -> shutting down the economy -> requiring massive stimulus that mostly just caused inflation and inflated asset values

          - Decades of under investment in hard infrastructure and instead investment in legal red tape and white collar bureaucratic process

          - An entire generation over-educated in Microsoft Office Suite vs. physical reality, such that much of the capability isn't even here anymore. (See the firms contracted to work on CA high speed rail for more info, or imagine the US trying to build the Hoover dam today)

          - Post-financial crisis, inflating global asset values by keeping rates too low for too long, causing the whole K shaped economy thing and current discontent

          - Over fetishization of higher education -> government guarantees of college loans to any borrower regardless of ability to repay -> runaway inflation in the cost of US higher education

          I can do more if needed

      • oblio 4 hours ago

        You do realize that there's a 50% chance all those mid level jobs are just gobbled up by the rich people machines aka AI and those just add a few more zeroes to their wealth while the former middle class live like serfs?

      • gnarcoregrizz 4 hours ago

        "white collar elites" hahahahaha. reminds me when Elon musk denigrated the "laptop class". yeah dude your average laptop class person in the west isn't an elite.

        • pembrook 3 hours ago

          "I'm not an elite, that guy is!"

          There's a guy running a stall in Hanoi right now laughing at you claiming you're a humble working man while making 30X as much as him.

          As you get older, I recommend traveling more internationally, you begin to get a more accurate picture of your relative stature.

          While you and the rest of HN are busy exciting yourselves with the online bolshevik revival, it would be wise to first examine where you sit objectively relative to the rest of humanity (based on the analytics, if you're on this site you're in the top 2% to 0.001%).

          If we're going to normalize seizing the property of individuals to pay for your fully automated luxury socialist dreams, unfortunately we won't be able keep the line drawn at just billionaires, or at just millionaires. Sorry, the math doesn't math without taking a lot more of your stuff too.

      • johnisom2001 1 hour ago

        > AI is a giant compression and de-duplication algorithm on white collar labor, and it was needed. We've had an over-production of white collar elites problem for a while now ...

        Just say you're a misanthropist, it's OK.

    • LogicFailsMe 4 hours ago

      Been coding just as long (longer actually, holy you know what). Stay curious and you will never be replaced all the way to the BCI future where whatever you think, becomes. I'd advise any junior to do their best to be the smartest in the room and their future will take care of itself. So tired of the negativity. We are living in an age where the future the SF writers predicted is coming true and all we have to do is resist the temptation to annihilate ourselves with it. Tough task, I know, downvotes ahoy!

      • bel_marinaio 4 hours ago

        The down votes are probably because you did not discuss what happens to the 8 out of 10 juniors who are not the smartest in the room and how they will pay off 5-figure college debt.

        • LogicFailsMe 4 hours ago

          They stay curious and they get a position that rewards them for doing so. It really is that simple but influencers want you to believe otherwise. The devil is always in the details and if you understand those details, you will prosper. But that prosperity can be pretty bumpy at times so don't spend more than you make.

          But of course, what does an old crusty fart like me know and what could I have possibly learned over 50+ years of coding that could be at all relevant today? IKR?

          • katbyte 3 hours ago

            You didn’t answer the question. There are 10 people trying to get 2 jobs. What happens to the 8 who there are no jobs left for?

            • LogicFailsMe 3 hours ago

              Your premise is nonsense. There are 10 competent people for 10 jobs that require 10 competent people. The other 8 you speak of were phoning it in. At various points in history, they were able to milk the nipples of prosperity overriding common sense. But at some point, the weakly efficient market outed them and disposed of them as they discovered all of this has happened before and all of this will happen again.

              You hate this? That's on you. But doing the same thing over and over and expecting a different result is insanity. However, if you saved up before you were outed as an imposter, I can see that working out in the long run. IDIC and all that.

            • willchis 2 hours ago

              Just pull yourself up by your bootstraps, print off 50 paper resumes and go knock on those software company doors. Put on a nice suit and stay curious and you'll have a job in no time!

      • bsoles 3 hours ago

        > Stay curious... I'd advise any junior to do their best to be the smartest in the room and their future will take care of itself.

        This is just a tautological advice. It is equivalent to saying "be successful, then you will be successful".

        Also, have you seen the batch of CS majors coming from non-top-tier universities? I don't see how they will be able to compete with LLMs.

        • LogicFailsMe 2 hours ago

          They will compete being the ones who cared enough to wrangle the LLMs (and whatever succeeds them) into productivity. The learned helplessness is strong here.

    • pj_mukh 4 hours ago

      I work in a team of 20-25 software engineers building an app, 6 DR's, all of them purely using agentic workflows. We are shipping more, faster but I have no idea how our app would keep shipping if we lost even one of them.

      So whenever someone says "We are laying off SWE's because AI", I have no idea what they're talking about. Just the idea of taking on the mental load of getting rid of engineers to direct more agents shipping complex features to 100's of thousands of users makes my hands sweaty. I am so glad I am still able to hand off the technical direction, architectural care, follow-up, unblocking decisions etc. to a real accountable human.

      The sunset calls on this career seem far too preemptive.

      • twobitshifter 4 hours ago

        It makes sense to keep the same staffing if your company has a sustained need to ship more for the business. If on the other hand they are comfortable shipping just as much as before, they could reduce staffing to cut costs. Most of those decisions can be made in a vacuum by management who will not know that the person they laid off is the only one who understands component X at a deep level.

        • pj_mukh 4 hours ago

          >>If on the other hand they are comfortable shipping just as much as before

          So a company that can't/won't grow, lays people off and blames AI? Checks out I guess.

          • DANmode 3 hours ago

            Most US blue-chip stocks.

        • beachy 4 hours ago

          Yep, there are plenty of companies that were already coasting on their existing user base, doing urgent support only, any innovation long in the rear view mirror.

          For them, keeping their level of ambition and dropping staff in favor of AI makes perfect sense.

          • rootusrootus 24 minutes ago

            That assumes they can continue to coast while their competition makes the choice to keep staff and superpower them with AI tooling. They might just coast right into bankruptcy.

        • coffeebeqn 3 hours ago

          If a company stops shipping and lays off 90% of their devs - how long until 50 AI-built copycats take the existing business from them by undercutting prices, offering more features, etc

          • twobitshifter 1 hour ago

            At the same time, how long for a company that keeps its devs?

            Your comment seems to say that the higher cost of devs is worthwhile because it will allow a company to keep a lead, but how many products out there are just things like kanban boards, todo lists, and crud applications? Is any product ever completed and how much value really exists above the line at which most people are satisfied?

      • jcmontx 2 hours ago

        We went from 20 to 5 (over the last 2 years) and we're shipping more than before

        • dominotw 2 hours ago

          does anyone want what you are shipping though? Whats so specail about your prompts.

          • jcmontx 2 hours ago

            We kept all the business analysts and QAs that ensure the thing works as expected. Coding itself is mostly Codex hooked to Jira with a master prompt.

          • therealdrag0 1 hour ago

            Why wouldn’t they? You can’t imagine a business that used to have a lot of junior coders that can be replaced by AI? There is so much business powered by strait forward CRUD code.

            • rootusrootus 21 minutes ago

              > There is so much business powered by strait forward CRUD code.

              LOL, so true. I feel like as people at my (medium size, ~5000 employee) company start to really understand how much more software we can build, they're going to ask for things they've only dreamed about in the past. Just glorified CRUD, but that's what drives businesses these days.

        • ak39 1 hour ago

          What were the 15 doing BEFORE AI?

          • jcmontx 1 hour ago

            TBH, I fired quite a few for OE. Can’t trust most devs these days. Honest folks in remote first environments are a scarce resource.

            • tetraodonpuffer 59 minutes ago

              what do you mean by OE? just curious.

              Personally having been remote for ~8 years it would be difficult to go back to in person or hybrid, this said I am not sure how I could prove I am trustworthy besides "trust me bro" unless I am using somebody in my network as a reference...

              • jcmontx 25 minutes ago

                Over-employment. I caught a few (that I just thought were "below the average") whom were doing more than one job at the same time.

      • stronglikedan 1 hour ago

        Hardly anyone (if anyone at all) is laying off SWE's. Unfortunately, hardly anyone is hiring juniors.

    • seki285 2 hours ago

      That's so awesome :O I bet these same people spit on anyone with no experience and pull the ladder up, I love boomers so much!

    • lanstin 1 hour ago

      Find something that you are good at, which you enjoy, and which is valuable to other people.

      Leave each person you interact pleased that they interacted with you, better off in some way.

  • Volker-E 5 hours ago

    What's even nicer to watch is, for a person who has been working in open source/open knowledge for the entirety of his career of 25+ years, seeing a lot of people just taking that gravy and plating their b** in gold through it.

    • American87 4 hours ago

      I cannot figure out what this means I have re-read it like 10 times lol.

      • tab8000 4 hours ago

        Maybe use LLM to figure it out for you? It's the new hip thing, all the cool kids are doing it!

  • bko 5 hours ago

    Why would SWE gravy train be over?

    Engineers are now more productive than ever. Increasing productivity drives salaries up. Secretaries are paid more today than they were when they didn't have computers to use. Why wouldn't this be the same?

    • zarzavat 5 hours ago

      No leverage.

      • rsoto2 5 hours ago

        leverage is gained through collective bargaining/strikes

        • echelon 4 hours ago

          That causes offshoring to accelerate.

        • kg 4 hours ago

          Way too late to withhold labor, there are plenty of people looking for work who are willing to babysit Claude and do scab work

          • rsoto2 4 hours ago

            lol I'm sure that will go great

    • tombert 5 hours ago

      I'm not sure I agree with this argument, but I think the argument is that the amount of work to do will not scale with the productivity gains. If one software engineer can now do the work of what previously took four engineers, that's great, but that doesn't necessarily imply that there will be four times as much total work to do.

      • brightball 4 hours ago

        We’ve seen the 1 to 4 multiplier for years in more productive languages.

        It was trivial for 1 Rails dev in 2010 to do 10-20x more than a Java dev back then.

        Today’s world is an interesting dynamic but I’m pretty excited about it.

        • tombert 4 hours ago

          Sure, I wasn't really around for a time before high level languages, but I suspect the transition from machine code to FORTRAN was probably like a 10x productivity gain.

          I tend to be more on the "Jevons" side of things, where I do think that demand will more or less expand. There are lots of projects I've been putting off for years because there would be an aspect about it that I hate doing and don't have the money to hire people to do for me (e.g. frontend web development). Those are projects that otherwise wouldn't exist that do now exist and potentially might make money or something (though with my business acumen that's debatable).

        • tavavex 4 hours ago

          I feel like software people often overestimate efficiency gains. I won't doubt it got faster, but are you really saying that across all workloads on average, a Rails dev took 8 hours to complete the work that would previously take 160 hours? Not just specific cases, but all the work.

          • brightball 3 hours ago

            Yes. There's a good reason that it was the default stack for many startups.

            • tavavex 3 hours ago

              A 1.25x improvement would already make it a no-brainer for a new project. I'm not saying it wasn't better for your use case, I'm saying we should be careful with tossing around words like 2000%. Everywhere you look in the software field today, you see people talk about 5x, 10x, 100x, never some 'normal' +20%.

              • brightball 3 hours ago

                There were a lot of reasons for it.

                Java itself was a much slower standard workflow. Dynamic languages in general, like Ruby, Python, Perl or PHP were much faster to work with than the burdensome recompile workflows. Think instant feedback vs waiting for your CI to finish after every single save. The speed of iteration was critical.

                Beyond that, when the speed of development is slower, more people get hired to do the work. When more people get hired to do the work, there's more communication relay as the team size grows. Teams coordinating between each other. Decisions going to committees. Middle management layers.

                You'd routinely see companies with 3-5 Rails devs outperforming shops with 50 Java devs. Communication and iteration speed was huge. The other piece of it was the convention over configuration aspect because it removed so many things you'd have to discuss and make decisions about as a group which further accelerated communications.

                10-20x multiplier isn't an exaggeration at all. If anything I could be underselling it.

              • buu700 3 hours ago

                I see both types of claims a lot on HN, and find both credible.

                On one extreme, a solo dev could prompt a frontier SOTA agent with not much more than "Build Uber", give it the necessary hardware/software/permissions to build itself a useful feedback loop and act autonomously, put it in goal mode, and let it cook, and as long as the tokens kept flowing they'd eventually end up with something reasonable in actual orders of magnitude less time than it would have taken that dev to build the same thing — especially if you're counting calendar days rather than hours worked, and extra especially if they wouldn't have had the luxury of investing full-time hours into that particular thing. At the opposite extreme, BigCo full-time SWE #5000 tasked with an extremely specific ticket for a critical revenue-generating brownfield system might experience even "20%" as liberal, and correctly observe that writing code was never the bottleneck for their job. And then there's the massive spectrum of circumstances in between those two ends.

                None of that means that the gains aren't real, or that anyone in particular is wildly exaggerating in either direction. It just means the gains aren't evenly distributed.

              • IsTom 3 hours ago

                It might be different from Java shop to Java shop, but I'll never forget that time I changed jobs from something more productive to Java and my first day way sprint planning. It all made sense until the end when they told me that we were estimating in days, not hours and it turned out that it really took that much longer to do things there.

                • tombert 2 hours ago

                  I've said before and I will say it again: the biggest issue with Java is Java developers.

                  If you're allowed to use the newer libraries and tools, it has actually been a perfectly fine language to write software in, even relatively quickly, since ~Java 8 or 11.

                  I have had elaborate fantasies of what I would do to the designers of JavaEE if I ever found them, and I had assumed that because writing JavaEE is so unbelievably horrible that the entirety of the platform was like that. Years later I had a different job that was much more amenable to me using "modern" Java, so I used Vert.x and Disruptor and properly learned how to use NIO and and I actually had fun.

                  I think Java has been the "regression to the mean" language primarily because it's taught to frequently in schools and it allows you to write in a very verbose and irritating style, meaning that it was a great fit for mediocre-to-incompetent engineers who want to look like they're doing a lot.

            • ex-aws-dude 2 hours ago

              "all workloads"?

              Not some greenfield dinky todo list startup project with 0 users

              Why do HNers always talk like these are the same as real products

            • ericfr11 2 hours ago

              Not my experience. It was easier, but not 10x. Maybe for beginners, you're right.

      • pegasus 4 hours ago

        My feeling is that there's an unlimited amount of work left to do. Software today sucks in so many ways. It's buggy and inflexible and limited in so many ways. My bet is on Jevon's paradox kicking in big-time.

        • macintux 4 hours ago

          Sure, there's an unlimited amount of work out there. But is there an unlimited amount of money to fund it?

          • tombert 4 hours ago

            I don't think that that logic follows. For most jobs, even before generative AI, we weren't paying "per work item", we were paying "per person per time". We could conceivably build 4x as much for the same cost, and it would require the same amount of money.

            • macintux 1 hour ago

              My expectation is that most businesses will decide that they can get by with 1/2 to 1/4 of their staff, making immediate improvements to their bottom line, instead of trying to double or quadruple the work they’re tackling, because one approach is much safer than the other.

              • tombert 1 hour ago

                Sure but that's a different point than what you were making. You acted like all this increased productivity wouldn't have the money for it, and I was arguing it would cost roughly the same amount of money as it does now since per-person-per-time was typically the cost we were measuring. Now you're saying they're going to want to spend less money.

                • macintux 1 hour ago

                  I didn't express my point with reasonable clarity. Mea culpa.

              • warmedcookie 54 minutes ago

                Better have a good moat then, lest competition overtakes you

        • tgsovlerkhgsel 4 hours ago

          Software tends to be made only good enough to do the job. There is an unlimited amount of work that could be done but not an unlimited amount of work companies are willing to fund, and the bar for "good enough" keeps dropping.

        • throwaway384034 4 hours ago

          Yes, more software will be produced more than ever before at an increasing rate by agents as they continue to close their own loop. Remember "prompt engineers"? It didn't last very long.

        • SchemaLoad 30 minutes ago

          The question is for how long will you be a valuable part of the process, and how much of your wage will be reallocated to token costs.

      • idontwantthis 4 hours ago

        In my experience there has been. I've been a part of two major rewrites that just wouldn't have happened without AI. Personally, I'm making 40% more than I was 3 years ago. I'm seeing ambitious work being done that just would have been unthinkable 3 years ago. We no longer have to trudge through legacy code that is too expensive to touch.

        • gib444 4 hours ago

          That's great. But do you worry about providing huge amount of training data to the AI companies who for example eventually/soon offer /rewrite in the CLI? That there'll be a point soon when there's nothing left to take from us?

          • idontwantthis 2 hours ago

            Well we are on an enterprise plan, so I don't think we are providing the training data. Also, we are basically at that point already. The rewrite isn't the point of the project, the point is the greater velocity we will have for adding new features post rewrite.

      • unixfreak0037 4 hours ago

        Just sharing what I'm experiencing, we're using AI heavily at work, and I am more busy, with more things to do, than ever before, and I'm getting more done than ever before. And now we have these "software factories" coming. With AI it seems like so many new possibilities have opened up, because we can create anything we need now.

        • dist-epoch 4 hours ago

          > we can create anything we need now.

          in aggregate there is not as much need as we can create now

      • sunrunner 4 hours ago

        If it's anything like much of recent history, the amount of work to do will simply increase while the nature of the work itself will continue to get more abstracted, less meaningful, and more disconnected from anything tangible. More abstracted, ever more distant.

      • alcomatt 3 hours ago

        And it also does not mean that the profits will raise x 4 either.

    • 0c3ca83 5 hours ago

      Engineering is now becoming low-leverage, unskilled labor. That's the whole selling point of AI: "it can code better than people, it's solved math. Why not system architecture, design, etc?".

      Thinking human skill will remain necessary for this is a huge bet against the AI companies.

      If productivity increases lead to wage increases, being a weaver would be one of the best paid jobs today.

    • moffkalast 5 hours ago

      What used to take 100 secretaries now takes only 1 who is paid 20% more than each one of them were back then. For some it'll be like nothing changed, for most it'll be the end of their career.

      • dofm 4 hours ago

        I think you profoundly misunderstand what is involved in the role.

        If it wasn't absolutely essential that a person was there, it would have been automated away long before AI.

        • tsimionescu 4 hours ago

          And it has mostly been automated. A lot more managers used to have secretaries. Today, only really high level people like SVPs and above have a secretary. That secretary is paid a little more than a similar secretary would have been 50 years ago. But there are vastly fewer secretary positions available.

        • moffkalast 4 hours ago

          Have you seen what it was like in the 50s? Massive armies of secretaries absolutely everywhere in every firm, typing things down on typewriters, going around manually delivering notes and messages. MS office and email has automated practically all of what a secretary used to be, LLMs took the rest.

          • dofm 4 hours ago

            I too have seen Mad Men. (I am also old enough to remember a time when every friend of your mum was a secretary if they weren't a nurse or teacher).

            My point is that MS Office has really automated everything about the job that can be automated. I don't think LLMs will really dent secretarial/PA work much further. Those people have their jobs not because the work hasn't been automated, but because their bosses are mediocre and relatively disorganised, like most people.

            Silly Jarvis fantasies aside, an LLM cannot make your boss less shit at returning calls or managing their work life. The people who need support humans will always need support humans, until they themselves are replaced.

    • itishappy 5 hours ago

      Are there as many secretary positions?

    • reticulates 5 hours ago

      > Engineers are now more productive than ever. Increasing productivity drives salaries up.

      No it doesn't. Salaries have been decreasing in real terms over the last decade despite productivity improving. There was a period of time in which productivity increased alongside salaries but that does not prove causation.

      • eru 4 hours ago

        > Salaries have been decreasing in real terms over the last decade despite productivity improving.

        Do you have a source for that?

        • raddan 4 hours ago

          The parent poster’s argument is not entirely true, because wages did outpace inflation for awhile around the pandemic. But it’s truthy. Wages have been sliding lately, and that sliding is the longer term trend.

          https://www.marketplace.org/story/2026/09/04/wage-growth-can...

          Obviously, the above is talking about labor generally, not just SWEs. But speaking as a professional computer scientist at a place with decent salaries and excellent benefits, my raises over the last 5 years have barely outpaced inflation. It’s pretty annoying to realize that I probably would have earned a lot more money had I NOT gone back to school for a PhD. Not that I would make a different decision given the choice again, but money is much more abstract in your 20s than it is in your 40s.

    • mbb70 4 hours ago

      The demand for software is essentially limitless and SWEs controlled the supply, hence the gravy train. Now the number of people that can produce software has expanded 1000x. No more constrained supply, no more gravy train.

      • pegasus 4 hours ago

        We will quickly saturate the complexity domain accessible to an unskilled dev + agents, and skilled devs will be a in high demand again.

      • gnarcoregrizz 4 hours ago

        I don't think the demand for software is limitless. Even when the supply was controlled, did the world really need another app?

        • betterunix2 4 hours ago

          There are plenty of problems that can be solved with software, but we have not had productive enough SWEs to actually build that software. Increased productivity will expand the scope of the problems we can solve by writing software, meeting the demand that nobody bothered to think about because it was not really possible to take on such projects.

          • gnarcoregrizz 3 hours ago

            hopefully you're right. there is a heck of a lot of software out there. I personally don't see the need or demand for much of it. maybe we'll start seeing stuff that really pushes the boundaries, rather than just more CRUD web app crap.

            • betterunix2 2 hours ago

              It is worth remembering the impact of moving from B, which was untyped, to C, which has static type checking, was to the development of Unix. It enhanced programmer productivity in ways that allowed Unix to become what it ultimately became.

              Likewise with garbage collection, OOP, and SQL. Each has greatly enhanced programmer productivity, and the result is an entire ecosystem of software that would have been too big and complex for programmers to develop using the previous generations of development tools. It has gotten to the point where we can sit here looking down on all those "CRUD web app crap" projects that programmers can throw together -- try to imagine building one using the languages and tools that were available in 1970.

              In 20~ years we will probably be talking about all the generic "Agentic ABC/ZYX apps" that an entire generation of programmers builds their careers on and what it would have taken to build such things using the tools that were available in the CRUD web app crap era before coding agents. There will be more programmers, because people who are not programmers today will become programmers with these AI systems (much like Lotus 123 turned accountants and actuaries into programmers -- yes I know about the London whale, I am not saying there will not be problems that come up).

      • krona 4 hours ago

        The number of people who can produce code has expanded. Software engineering is only tangentially related.

    • RiverCrochet 4 hours ago

      > Increasing productivity drives salaries up.

      Then inflation eats up the salary, but doesn't lower the productivity requirement.

      Also, there are fewer secretaries.

      From https://www.bls.gov/ooh/office-and-administrative-support/se...:

      "Overall employment of secretaries and administrative assistants is projected to decline 2 percent from 2025 to 2035.

      Despite declining employment, about 314,400 openings for secretaries and administrative assistants are projected each year, on average, over the decade. All of those openings are expected to result from the need to replace workers who transfer to other occupations or exit the labor force, such as to retire."

      • eru 4 hours ago

        > Then inflation eats up the salary, but doesn't lower the productivity requirement.

        Inflation is about the real price for a dollar, ie how many goods a dollar can buy. It's not about the relative price between, say, your labour and the goods and services you want to afford. Inflation is a red herring in this discussion.

    • AngryData 4 hours ago

      When has increased productivity drove up salaries? Every other industry in the world in more productive than ever and their salaries didn't increase.

    • pickleglitch 4 hours ago

      >Increasing productivity drives salaries up

      The last 40+ years of data on wage growth vs productivity growth says otherwise.

      • eru 4 hours ago

        The last 40+ years have seen the greatest explosion in wealth and wage growth on the planet ever.

        • tsimionescu 4 hours ago

          In developing countries. Wages in the developed world have stagnated for the last 40 years.

          • eru 12 minutes ago

            They haven't stagnated in the developed world. But they haven't grown quite as fast either, there was a lot of catch-up growth. We are truly living in blessed times!

            Much better than the bad old days of the 1940s to 1960s: if you had told someone back then that in 2026 obesity will be a bigger problem for the global poor than starvation, they would have called you a crazy dreamer.

    • lordnacho 4 hours ago

      It also got so productive that people who used to need a secretary are now forced to book their own flights and order their own flowers.

    • fauigerzigerk 4 hours ago

      You could be right, but there are counter examples. Shoe factories did not improve the productivity of shoemakers. They improved the productivity of producing shoes.

      The gravy train for shoemakers was over. What remained was a small number of shoe designers and (initially) a large number of unskilled factory workers. The same thing happened with many other skilled jobs.

      But much will depend on how much professionally made software the world really needs. Demand for software could be a lot more flexible than the demand for shoes.

      • vanuatu 3 hours ago

        if your job can be compared to making shoes in a factory then it will likely be over

        the market for SWEs will continue to be K shaped where the top of the K are SWEs that can solve ambiguous business problems and take accountability

      • leni536 1 hour ago

        The difference is that the demand for shoes is bounded, while demand for software is less so.

        • bobsomers 30 minutes ago

          Is this really true? Software marketplaces like the App Store or Steam would seem to prove the opposite. There are endless amounts of slop that earn virtually nothing and a handful of apps and games that make all the money.

    • lbrito 4 hours ago

      >Increasing productivity drives salaries up

      It does not.

      Productivity increases and salary increases have been uncoupled for half a century

      • win311fwg 4 hours ago

        Salaries, in real dollars, have risen with productivity. They haven't risen proportionately with productivity (obviously; the robots who brought the extract productivity expect to be paid too), but they have risen to a smaller degree. Increased productivity is beneficial to the worker, even if it is also beneficial to the robots.

        • DANmode 3 hours ago

          We’re not talking about automation, now.

          We’re talking about corporate compensation to labor vs shareholders and admin.

          • win311fwg 3 hours ago

            We're talking about salaries, which have increased with productivity. That salaries and productivity were linked when human effort was the only source of productivity, and became disconnected when additional sources of productivity emerged, is immaterial. Economies are not zero sum.

        • lbrito 2 hours ago

          That's a smart sleight of hand. You're countering a claim I never made and diverting the attention from the real issue. Let's rewind and see the original comment:

          "Increasing productivity drives salaries up"

          To which I said: No, that's not the case; productivity and salary have been uncoupled for a long time. That's a different claim from "salaries did not increase", which is what you are countering.

          The wage-productivity gap is well known and I won't attempt to school anyone on it. Just look it up. Its really disingenuous to claim that the gap is going "to the robots". Robots don't give a shit. The gap goes to the _robot owners_.

      • tt24 2 hours ago

        This is commonly repeated but entirely untrue

    • SwellJoe 4 hours ago

      "Secretaries are paid more today than they were when they didn't have computers to use."

      Are you posting from 1990?

      • DANmode 3 hours ago

        Plenty of executive assistants making more than you.

        If they’re needed still, they are really needed!

    • betterunix2 4 hours ago

      > Increasing productivity drives salaries up

      My bank account disagrees with that statement. We are just expected to do more for the same pay.

    • sorrywhat 3 hours ago

      What engineers? It's certainly not those at Google, because I haven't seen a single new useful feature in Google, YouTube or Chrome in the last 2 years. It's not those at Microsoft either - Windows, Teams and the Office suite haven't gained a single useful feature either.

      I can name 5 other pieces of software I have open right now, more likely than not there are 100x supercharged engineers in this thread who work on them, and they're also the exact same piece of shit they were 2 years ago.

      As a software user, when can I expect to see results of this unprecedented productivity boost? Are you people completely detached from reality, do you not see the output of the industry hasn't moved in the slightest?

      • jodrellblank 3 hours ago

        “In 2026, Microsoft 365 introduced over 1,100 new features” says DuckDuckGo AI summary.

        You mistake “I don’t care about <feature>“ with “<feature> hasn’t been built”.

    • jmyeet 3 hours ago

      Yeah, this is just... wrong.

      You can look at what happened to hardware engineers starting in the 1990s (if not earlier). Improved software allowed 1 HW engineer to do the work that was previously done by 3-4. Did this drive HW engineer salaries up? No, no it did not. It did the opposite.

      As for secretary salaries, what's your basis of comparison? Women earn a lot less than men doing the same job. This used to be a lot more. So, if secretary pay went up at all (and I'm not sure it has in real terms) then how much of that is just eliminating the gender pay gap?

    • johnisom2001 1 hour ago

      > Increasing productivity drives salaries up

      This is a commonly believed myth/meme that for some reason we can't give up.

      No, increasing productivity doesn't drive salaries up. Unless that induced more demand for SWEs, which is not a given at all.

  • bobmarleybiceps 5 hours ago

    I think standards / requirements for security and software quality may sky-rocket given the automated hacking stuff...

  • drudolph914 5 hours ago

    contrarian opinion. I think all we’ve learned is SWEs are still very much needed. gas town failed, it failed quietly, but no one doing real work talks about software factories anymore.

    Most companies that are running the “how many SWEs can we fire before it all breaks” experiment have learned it’s a failed experiment - this validated by every single major company/product outage where their uptime went below 90% this year.

    I can’t help but think this anxiety and fear is just marketing. chill out everyone

    • newsy-combi 4 hours ago

      Are they bringing their employees back in the same numbers and for the same wages though? Or are they outsourcing to Indian humans-in-the-loop for 1% of the cost?

      • pegasus 4 hours ago

        Depends what quality of work they want? Hopefully they've learned their lessons in the first outsourcing craze, before AI lured them to another ride on the same carousel.

        • drudolph914 4 hours ago

          from my experience, offshore talent was for boilerplate coding. and the new bar for quality is now <insert-your-favorite-LLM>. so I think most LLMs are better than the majority offshore talent nowadays

      • nwatson 4 hours ago

        Some are keeping the onshore senior engineers / architects and using the LLMs / agent-harnesses to replace the offshore.

    • medler 4 hours ago

      I agree, but to the extent I’m worried about the future of the profession, it’s because I don’t know how much more the models are going to improve. Today’s models desperately need a real SWE in the loop to do most serious engineering. Will that still be the case in 5 years? I really don’t know

      • tcoff91 4 hours ago

        I feel like once it doesn't need an engineer in the loop, does it need ANYBODY in the loop? at that point the whole company can probably be autonomous.

        That seems like it would be such a paradigm shift that the second and third order effects are so crazy and nobody can predict what that world will actually look like

        • taurath 3 hours ago

          Reminder that there is no guarantee this can ever happen despite what the hype people say. The delta between what they say and what it can do is extremely large.

      • hbcdbff 4 hours ago

        IMO models are getting smarter at software, but not at software engineering.

      • eptcyka 4 hours ago

        I think integrating libraries into a product will be essentially free. Novel solutions that require an understanding of the problem space to such an extent that unorthodox solutions seem viable is still the limit in my experience. LLMs, at least in my experience, need lots of guidance when the solution you want is not something that has already been done. If you look at it from a business perspective- most software shops have a small proportion of their software that is truly unique and their USP - the rest is not necessarily boilerplate, but definitely not bespoke and unique. This overhead will now be cheaper. Similarly, software vendors that dominate despite not having any bespoke, unique software component will soon have a tougher time. Why would someone pay for atlassian products now? All of their products are not good software- they have market dominance. Replicating their features will be trivial. Anyone who will be sufficiently fed up with paying will DIY the solution.

        • oblio 4 hours ago

          Atlassian (or Adobe) have lots of features. The famous MS Word quote applies.

          80% of people only use 20% of features, but if you build the 20% solution you only attract 5% of the userbase because they all use different features from the 100%.

          • eptcyka 3 hours ago

            Why would I pay a subscription for something I can build in a week or 3, when I use only 20% of the service I am paying for?

            • anang 3 hours ago

              That all comes down to price, if the subscription is cheap enough then buying will be easier.

              I am starting to wonder if or when we’ll see that shift. If companies lay off employees because AI can fill the gap, the I think a lot of people expect those savings to be passed on. Right now, that doesn’t seem to be happening.

              For my business the threshold is definitely getting lower for justifying building things ourselves.

      • Rapzid 2 hours ago

        I can tell you as a job searcher companies are rushing to replace us more completely.

        Most of the "legit" jobs coming through my inbox are for grading LLM software tasks. A lot for long horizon tasks.

        It'll happen when it happens, but till then I think I'll not be a party to that lol.

    • ramblerman 4 hours ago

      Gastown was too early and focused on the angle that having agents cosplaying a mini org chart was the way to get better results.

    • mrbombastic 4 hours ago

      It is strange this is the contrarian opinion when most of the evidence points to it being the case. Everyone working is busier than ever, more prs but no end in sight to the backlog still and fires to put out every day. PMs and designers who have deeper idea of product then most can put up some automatic prs for quick fixes, everyone with a bit of time can build siloed dashboards on their own but actually doing the day to day eng work to keep things running or design a new service to integrate with the product…I’m not seeing it

      • WarmWash 4 hours ago

        I think my fear is rooted in knowing that the tech has moved way faster than humans can adapt to it.

        So we are not waiting for the tech to get good enough, we're waiting for humans to understand and integrate it.

        I don't work in tech, rather manufacturing, and our company is barely using any AI (or using it, but only like AI mode in Google) despite me knowing that we could easily use it to cut heads. The automation we are leaving on the table is huge.

        But I'm not gonna be the one to go to my bosses and say "Hey, you want me to show you what we can do with SOTA models and agents?". For now I'll just stick to using my accounts to leverage my job.

        • isympathize 4 hours ago

          > But I'm not gonna be the one to go to my bosses and say "Hey, you want me to show you what we can do with SOTA models and agents?"

          I actually did. It doesn’t really change much IME. I just did it to come out in the open about AI use and start the slow adaptive process. It’s been a year now and just this week some colleagues are starting to act surprised by what is possible. I’m in software dev for crying out loud. This world is teeming with stingy sysadmins and neckbeards proclaiming it are all toys and soon everything will be back to normal.

          If the culture doesn’t pick it up automatically there is some mixture of cultural factors holding them back and just knowing about tools ain’t it.

          • Carrok 3 hours ago

            Yea the GP's attitude seems backwards. You _want_ to be the guy showing your boss the next level. Those people are valuable. Otherwise they might discover it on their own and decide you're replaceable.

        • chrisco255 3 hours ago

          > we're waiting for humans to understand and integrate it.

          Hate to say it but most humans that couldn't code before because it was too technical also can't understand enough about the underlying systems to competently integrate AI.

          • realusername 3 hours ago

            Pretty much yes, I've seen this first hand. AI feels magical because we know where we're going, for the people who are starting from a blank page, this is hard.

      • Fr0styMatt88 4 hours ago

        It’s weird to see the change in the default tone of discussions on this site over the last decade. We’ve gone from being eternal optimists to whatever this is.

        I think we were a bit smug as a group. Sure we were disrupting EVERYONE ELSE and saying how disruption is just the natural way things work, everyone should adapt, etc. Now that we are the ones having to cope with the same thing, suddenly all that goes out the window.

        I know I’m speaking in generalities here. I’m in the same boat as everyone else. I do argue that for those of us that have been into this since we’re kids, we grew up being told we were the exception. OUR jobs would never be obsolete, we are the future; we looked at people who refused to adapt with judgement. Now it’s our turn to adapt.

        • matheusmoreira 4 hours ago

          > I think we were a bit smug as a group.

          Indeed. I always call it out.

          It was fine to disrupt everyone else. It was fine to replace all those laborers. If they complained, we just told them it was the implacable march of technology, told them to learn some new skill.

          I'm a doctor. Putting me out of a job is and has always been one of the wettest dreams of hackers. It was palpable in every thread about medicine on HN.

          But now artists are getting automated and software developers are getting replaced. Watching people here treat it as a crime against humanity is just too much for me.

          I'm a hobbyist programmer. I mourned the loss of my hobby. Working on my little projects just feels pointless now, like none of it matters in the grand scheme of things. But I do hope that we're working towards some kind of post-scarcity society where the economy itself has been eliminated.

          • chrisco255 3 hours ago

            > post-scarcity society where the economy itself has been eliminated

            Unless we can efficiently transmute atoms into other atoms I don't think this is happening anytime soon.

          • Fr0styMatt88 3 hours ago

            Honest question though — if you’re a hobbyist programmer, why does it feel pointless to continue being one if it was your hobby and you enjoyed doing it?

            You can continue to code for the joy of doing it. If you enjoy the end result more than the coding process, you can work on crafting the best end result that you can. So it’s kind of a win-win for a true hobby, as far as I can tell.

            • scns 2 hours ago

              My guess would be the sense of achievement is gone.

            • matheusmoreira 1 hour ago

              It's as scns said: the sense of achievement is gone.

              I once reverse engineered my laptop's keyboard LEDs and made Linux free software to control them. Other people inexplicably found my project and built on top of it. I was really proud of that.

              Then I subscribed to frontier LLMs and they made short work of that same laptop's entire firwmare blob in about a day. Solved some long standing mysteries. And I felt literally nothing.

              This is one reason, but not the only reason.

              I've been hobby programming alone for over a decade. When I finally subscribed to frontier AIs, it was like a shot in the arm. I finally had a coding buddy, someone to talk to about my projects, who would review and criticize my code. I learned so much I had to pause and let it sink in so I could understand what I was doing.

              But the hobbyist niche I wanted to be part of turned out to be thoroughly hostile to LLMs and their users. I went from a guy who was interviewed in Lobsters for his programming language work to a guy whose work turned into slop essentially overnight, and the rift only grew wider over time.

              So the sense of accomplishment is gone and now people whose respect I wanted call my work slop because LLMs touched it. This left me in this weird emotional state where I feel guilty for using AIs at all but know that it's impossible to go back to how things were before. It's been months since I've touched my open source projects. I just can't find the will to do it. I'm working on private stuff now, hopefully things that will make me some amount of money in the future.

              There's also the fact that AIs are changing society so thoroughly that governments are becoming extremely intolerant of personal computing and the subversive freedom it affords all of us. There is constant talk of AI regulation, and dystopian technology like remote hardware attestation is already becoming mandatory. We're also being literally priced out of computers.

              So it's becoming literally pointless. What is the point of free software if we can't run it? If running it gets us ostracized from digital society? If it makes us criminals? If we can't even afford computers in the first place? To me it looks like everything the free software community worked so hard for will have been in vain.

              • Fr0styMatt88 1 hour ago

                The AI-shaming really sucks; I’m seeing it a lot in the gamedev community (not talking about outright cloning of games, but just simple AI use, like that recent game that got review-bombed for using an AI to fix a Unity bug essentially). The abolitionists suck.

                I understand what you mean though in general; I wasn’t thinking of reverse engineering and things like capture the flags for example; when I think of those things, yeah it’s kinda like I wonder “well what happens to CTFs now that AI can do it?”. But who knows — I haven’t actually sat down and done it, so there’s probably nuances I’m blind to as well.

                I see the argument that humans still play and compete in chess, even though machines have essentially ‘solved’ the game in a way.

    • lbrito 4 hours ago

      >gas town failed quietly

      This is a big problem. When this kind of thing gets launched, its all fanfare, this is the future, get on the boat or die.

      But then it fails miserably and its like it never existed

      • skydhash 4 hours ago

        Remember prompt engineering? Even skills and specs seems to be slowly dying.

        • oblio 4 hours ago

          What's happening to skills?

        • jmartrican 4 hours ago

          I see skills as bash scripts. they are useful, even small ones.

        • _aavaa_ 3 hours ago

          To the extent that they are it's because they are no longer needed since the models do more of those things on their own without being prompted to do so.

          • 20k 3 hours ago

            There was never any evidence that they did anything all that useful

            • _aavaa_ 3 hours ago

              There was never any evidence that writing a spec and having the model built against that spec was useful??

        • Rapzid 2 hours ago

          Prompt engineering as the sole means of getting anything of value and quality is a thing of the past.

          But I also see people complaining about frontier models writing too many helper functions, changing more code than necessary, and etc.

          These are things that can be addressed through context engineering; AGENTS.md, skills, etc.

          Also a lot of use cases require smaller, lower latency models. And these faster, smaller models to this day exhibit similar failure modes to 2-3 years ago and require very purposeful context engineering to get satisfactory results.

    • daringrain32781 4 hours ago

      I think there's a spectrum of being a SWE and what we're seeing is the ones essentially just writing boilerplate code most of their day have a very different view than those who are solving problems with software that require careful thinking and execution.

      A lot of people seem to think they can pick up an LLM and suddenly write software solutions as good as a seasoned SWE. But it turns into this terrible mess that's thrown out all engineering fundamentals, solving the symptoms instead of the cause.

      If I were just writing boilerplate code with an LLM all day I'd be very scared for my job too.

      • wtch98 4 hours ago

        I've been writing code for money for 30 years, I have no concerns about my job because 90% of my job is not writing code, it's understanding actual business needs (not just declared needs) and thinking about how to solve them.

        • Terr_ 56 minutes ago

          I'm worried because it was already hard to convince bosses that "actual business needs" were different from declared ones, and now they optimistically trust an LLM will turn declaration into actuality. (If not now, then soon™ within a quarter or two.)

          If you're right but nobody will pay you for it...

      • rapind 2 hours ago

        If your entire identity was in building CRUD for a software factory, then you probably need to worry, and that really sucks man. If instead you were the business guy who learned rails out of necessity to make your custom thing that the pure coders scoffed at, then you just got a level up.

        • evantbyrne 1 hour ago

          A lot of teams have been choosing to build web apps the hard way for a while, which really skews the perceived impact of automation. It has always been possible for one dude to crank out an internal web app in a month. There are just more ways to get there in the same timeline now. Agentic coding hasn't eliminated the risks of shipping software either. If anything, we are living in a far more adversarial environment now. Some things are definitely low enough risk now for less-technical people to take over now, like converting designs to React, but even for that the writing has been on the wall since Figma exported CSS. This is all to say I don't see the need for expertise going away entirely, but rather this is a continuation of the existing trend of software engineering evolving as a profession.

    • mirmor23 4 hours ago

      > I can’t help but think this anxiety and fear is just marketing. chill out everyone

      Here are few anecdotes:

      1. I've a friend who owns a PT (physical therapy) business. He's not even a tech guy, but uses claude to manage most of the business aspects, and he has told me repeatedly that he would've to spend thousands of dollars to get things done, and instead he pays 250 per year.

      2. Another friend is smart, and is a jack-of-all-trades type in the software/hardware/firmware business. He is solo bootstrapping by doing all the things from pcb to webapp. He doesn't see hiring anyone for the niche business.

      3. A 65 year old friend of mine who never in any tech career was able to build website for his side business (that website looks really good btw) and he now talks about json and ocr.

      You are the one who is out of touch with reality.

      • cm2012 4 hours ago

        None of those people could afford to hire a programmer before.

      • drudolph914 4 hours ago

        I don’t disagree that regular people can now make some basic software, but if you’re doing anything real with actual scale or consequences, nothings really changed. and to be exact, "real" means that if something goes, wrong then:

        there is massive lose in revenue for a business and or infrastructure that people rely on goes down

        if you’re working anything in this way, no one is just trusting a clanker. some thought leader might say the world is trusting an AI, but it’s not true. every company internally that is more than 2 people isn't trusting a bot, and it's well understand that it's a horrible idea (even by regular bullish AI business heads)

        so yes, I have the bot help me write a basic website for me, and it can one shot the typescript express app-layer boilerplate for me, but if you’re serving even the most basic app at scale with consequences, the bot isn't mitigating the concerns and engineering decisions that go into this work.

        a concrete real world example: literally msft outlook went down a week ago. it was out for god knows how many actual hours. it still might be partly down tbh. this is technology that is “solved” and is dumb simple in terms of complexity. their product was out for 48+ hours. and the status messages shared publicly by the engineering team did not only convey incompetence, but to paraphrase, the message they sent out was along the lines of, “We think we found the source of the problem, but unsure, the problem might be larger”

        how much you want to bet they had a team of 30+ engs running around with claude asking the equivalent of, “please fix outage, no mistakes”

        I’m still not convinced the outage is fully recovered because I still get errors.

        point is, yes there isn’t a giant 100 football field wide moat between regular people and programming anymore. smart people can do basic stuff and less inclined people can build a static website now. if you’re worried about that, go study more and you'll learn the depths of this field go WAY beyond typing code

        EDIT: typos

        • mirmor23 4 hours ago

          > point is, yes there isn’t a giant 100 football field wide most between regular people and programming anymore. smart people can do basic stuff and less inclined people can build a static website now. if you’re worried about that, go study more and you'll learn the depths of this field go WAY beyond typing code

          The implication is far reaching. Lots of non-tech businesses which relied on expert help can now pareto slice it and hire experts on need basis unlike before. Saving money and increasing profits can be a big motivator to own many of those tasks too. Lots of people who were cosplaying as experts on non-tech people will have less and less opportunities.

          Previously, being a knowledge worker could get you far, now the knowledge worker has to level up, and if opportunities are limited how could it happen? Even then, more experts (practice, not theory) is not a given, considering the bell curve effect.

      • Seattle3503 4 hours ago

        > 2. Another friend is smart, and is a jack-of-all-trades type in the software/hardware/firmware business. He is solo bootstrapping by doing all the things from pcb to webapp. He doesn't see hiring anyone for the niche business.

        I've got a friend in this situation too. He's going to hit a limit of what he can do with agents. And whatever agents can't do, his business can't do. We are going to find the shape of that soon.

        Normally hitting a limit is where you would hire someone, but building organizations with heavy agent use is hard. AI is very very good at shifting work onto other people and business units; that's what all the complaining about review (and not just code review) is about. None of that responsibility shifting happens in a solo setup.

        • mirmor23 4 hours ago

          > I've got a friend in this situation too. He's going to hit a limit of what he can do with agents. And whatever agents can't do, his business can't do. We are going to find the shape of that soon.

          Build-or-buy decision is still very relevant, and one can go far with affordable PCB assembly houses, 3D printing, and many others. For a solo person, today's environment is 100x better than, say 10 years ago. So, niche businesses have better chances of thriving, all else being the same.

          • Seattle3503 3 hours ago

            Yes, but the isn't the same thing as software engineering being dead. That's a new thing being possible. You originally were responding in the negative to

            > I can’t help but think this anxiety and fear is just marketing. chill out everyone

            • mirmor23 2 hours ago

              > Yes, but the isn't the same thing as software engineering being dead

              never said that. I was giving examples of really low barrier to entry that has been incentivizing non-tech people to get more hands on than before.

              buy-or-build and other existing setups for startups don't go away and if anything, they amplify what a solo can do.

              • Seattle3503 59 minutes ago

                Maybe you could clarify what you meant by your response here

                >> I can’t help but think this anxiety and fear is just marketing. chill out everyone

                > Here are few anecdotes:

                Examples

                > You are the one who is out of touch with reality.

                Someone called on people to chill out, you responded with a dismissal of that sentiment along with examples of people setting up successful businesses. Connect the dots for me.

        • steelframe 3 hours ago

          Do I need to keep a full-time expert in-house? Or can I rent expertise when and where AI falls short?

          • Seattle3503 3 hours ago

            I think AI is going to make this hard, because your contractors will face incentives to cut corners with AI.

            • mirmor23 2 hours ago

              > I think AI is going to make this hard, because your contractors will face incentives to cut corners with AI

              how is this different than the contractors who were also cutting corners before?

              If anything, any motivated non-tech person can now use AI mechanisms to eli5, adversarial review, acceptance test, layman style documentation, to force the results they want. It was simply not possible before. Heck, if the contractor bailed, their shitty work could be revived too.

      • codethief 4 hours ago

        OTOH maybe the second and third friend of yours would have never considered starting a business if it weren't for AI? And the people your first friend would have normally hired and who are now without work are (or will soon be) thinking about starting their own business, too? Who knows?

        In other words, the verdict is still out on whether we'll see a decrease in jobs in the long run or not. Personally, I'm not very optimistic but, as I tried to illustrate above, I might very well be (and certainly hope to be) wrong.

        • mirmor23 3 hours ago

          > OTOH maybe the second and third friend of yours would have never considered starting a business if it weren't for AI? And the people your first friend would have normally hired and who are now without work are (or will soon be) thinking about starting their own business, too? Who knows?

          Yes, we don't know the full effects, and sure things are in a flux, but let's not forget the convenient truth that the software engineering itself has required less and less expertise over the years due to programming languages with better abstractions, faster hardware, toolkits, frameworks etc.

          With tons of jobs and better pay, lots of folks moved over to the web side since the level of expertise required (compared to a firmware engineer or asic designer or a dsp guy) is quite low, while the pay is way better. During the dotcom boom, a friend of mine who was a furniture salesman, took a java course and ended up with a software job.

          Now, if the opportunity presents itself and incentives are strong, and barrier to entry is low, wouldn't more people also like to start/manage their business? I would think yes.

      • damowangcy 3 hours ago

        What does all these proved? If you don't have the budget for SWEs, you probably don't need one all. All these examples don't need complex engineering, Claude is a good solution to them (I doubt it though, if they really need something and it can make them money, it's always more efficient and cost effective to just hire someone for it) but it doesn't mean all businesses don't need SWEs anymore because everyone can be their own SWE.

      • dimator 3 hours ago

        You've given trivial examples.

        I'm building a mobile app using flutter. It's got to work on iOS and android. I can promise you, if I did not have years of experience, and I did not follow a regimented, checkpointed interaction flow with my agent, this code base would have turned to shit within a day. I've had to draw on my experience to define the architecture, correct missteps, prevent just wild flailing, and just generally keep things on the rails.

        Your example 2 is the closest match, where someone with experience is driving the result carefully.

        • mirmor23 2 hours ago

          > I'm building a mobile app using flutter. It's got to work on iOS and android. I can promise you, if I did not have years of experience, and I did not follow a regimented, checkpointed interaction flow with my agent, this code base would have turned to shit within a day. I've had to draw on my experience to define the architecture, correct missteps, prevent just wild flailing, and just generally keep things on the rails.

          That's because your app has constraints. Why would a PT business operations and website for a side hustle need to be any more complex than the owner needs it to be? Your app complexity is probably trivial compared to say Google Maps, so your tooling is designed to match your app needs, not that of Google Maps.

          Just to pretend that you are the only guy who can grok, and non-technical business people are incapable of curiosity, hard work, creativity and have the ability to manage their business and IT is more of a reflection of your mindset.

          PS: you are using llm to build the app too ;)

          • dimator 2 hours ago

            you've moved the goalposts in the middle of a conversation :)

            original post that we were replying to was https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50563851, which was:

            > Most companies that are running the “how many SWEs can we fire before it all breaks” experiment have learned it’s a failed experiment - this validated by every single major company/product outage where their uptime went below 90% this year.

            that was the context for your 3 examples, which is what i was replying to.

            > Just to pretend that you are the only guy who can grok,

            i never said anything like that. there is absolutely no issue with non-technical people who work hard and tinker and create, technology is for everyone, save money, do it yourself!

            the larger point was about complexity, which is what we are agreeing on anyway. my point was that no LLM was going to one-shot what i needed, just like they're not going to one-shot what your second friend did, let alone google maps.

            > PS: you are using llm to build the app too ;)

            i sure am :)

            • mirmor23 1 hour ago

              > you've moved the goalposts in the middle of a conversation :)

              I was actually responding to, quote '> I can’t help but think this anxiety and fear is just marketing. chill out everyone'

              nice try ;)

              I wish you the very best with your app!

        • chasd00 2 hours ago

          > I'm building a mobile app using flutter. It's got to work on iOS and android.

          idk man, my little sister produced an app (an LMS) with all the content, quizzes, tests, all the bells and whistles using ChatGPT to talk to ClaudeCode. She's smart but has no tech experience. her app is published in both app stores and she's gaining paying customers every day. AIs walked her through supabase integration, auth, and even the subscription APIs for Apple and Google. Also, all the paperwork involved in submitting, passing review, and publishing mobile apps.

          I've never see a line of her code but the apps work and her customers are happy or at least happy enough to keep paying.

      • slopinthebag 2 hours ago

        this is the equivalent of someone listing all the different microwaveable meals they made recently and using it as evidence that restaurants and chefs are finished…

    • cheeze 4 hours ago

      > but no one doing real work talks about software factories anymore

      My friends at FAANG companies would disagree here. If anything, it seems to be the exact opposite.

      Sure, it's not a end-to-end 0 touch factory, but a majority of folks I talk to these days that I consider good engineers aren't writing _any_ code anymore. They do that as a hobby outside of work.

      • ro_sharp 4 hours ago

        But are they reading it? I’m producing something like 10x more LOC than in the past, but am reading almost all of it, only excluding things like prototypes and testing tools.

      • arrowleaf 4 hours ago

        Non-FAANG, I don't have the luxury of product owners and designers who know the ins and outs of systems to present well-specced requirements docs. Or Jira tickets that aren't absolutely full of default-style Claude slop. It's not that I don't have my own slop factory which implements as-written, maybe bringing me into the loop for the most non-trivial decisions, and takes it through test, MR, and to production staging... but most of the interesting cases I pick up really do need a human to make the non-trivial design decisions. I've seen the garbage that these SOTA models put out when nobody's at the gate.

    • javier2 4 hours ago

      Some of these staff reductions are also due to the ENORMOUS pull of the US IT sector. There are not many companies with as many SWE as Microsoft and Meta, so some reduction isn't that surprising.

    • Miraste 4 hours ago

      > it’s a failed experiment - this validated by every single major company/product outage where their uptime went below 90% this year.

      This is engineering thinking, not business thinking. The question is, did the uptime drops cost the company more money than the firings saved? If the answer is no (which for megacorps like Microsoft it is) then the experiment was a success.

      • taurath 3 hours ago

        Business thinking relies on a hell of a lot of engineering thinking to survive. If your services and infrastructure you depend on to do your business fail, you don't have a business.

        • Miraste 3 hours ago

          Right, but failing is a spectrum. Microsoft leadership (picking on them because they're the best example) realized their customers would tolerate a lot more corner cutting than they used to do, and right now they're trying to find out where the tipping point is.

          • taurath 3 hours ago

            When we have cascading failure modes that continues across more and more systems, eventually no business can be conducted. We are increasingly centralized and interdependent on so many supply chains. The business people don't understand that collectively they are making a sinkhole in the ground they walk on, and I think they're going to be swallowed up. I'm not talking some sort of doomsday, but at a certain tipping point of unreliability we seem to be racing towards, you get the equivilent of rolling blackouts across the internet, which will hobble the entire economy until its fixed.

            Sadly more than likely they will just apply more and more AI to try to fix it, while others use AI to attack it faster than they can defend.

            • Miraste 2 hours ago

              I agree, just illustrating the MBA side. I think the structural incentives of large corporations in the US make this unavoidable.

              • taurath 1 hour ago

                The incentives are there, but on a human level people are progressively giving up their ability to reason independently. Greed is metastasizing

    • pipes 4 hours ago

      I didn't know gas town failed. What happened? Did Steve yegge say as much?

      • drudolph914 3 hours ago

        projects like gas town are failures if they don't become a standard practice or a truism in the tech scene. thought leaders are never going to announce their ideas as failures so they can maintain relevance, as well as plausible deniability about it's success/failure

      • georgemcbay 3 hours ago

        > I didn't know gas town failed. What happened? Did Steve yegge say as much?

        He wrote a series of blog posts in which he talked about how Gas Town failed and blamed it on Opus 4.7 changes causing all his workflows to fail. Then he announced Gas City as a rewrite.

        At some point after that he seemed to give up on the whole idea and instead just started working on reviving an old graphical MUD style game he made where I guess now he spends $10,000 a month on agents to build a game that currently has 0 concurrent players (4 concurrent 24 hour peak) on Steam:

        https://steamdb.info/app/1541710/charts/

        The game is available from other platforms than Steam so maybe he's got a bit more users than that across the platforms, and his stated plan is to bilk "whales", so maybe that's working out for him? But it still seems like he's lighting massive amounts of money on fire in what appears to be a prolonged state of ai psychosis.

        Must be nice to be that financially secure.

        • ex-aws-dude 2 hours ago

          Hey you only need 1 whale at 10K / month to break even

          • Rapzid 2 hours ago

            Any day now my whale will come in.

      • taurath 3 hours ago

        Failures are nearly dead silent aside the million words of hype. There is no accountability for "gassing" up so many people and taunting them that if they don't get on board a failing idea then they will be left behind. A lot of grifters get off freely.

      • ericfr11 1 hour ago

        Most developers built their own framework /harness anyway

    • gloosx 4 hours ago

      this is the only reasonable opinion. people saying "they made a thing which does the job" just fell to the hype mindlessly. someone still needs to input stuff into a thing which does the job, this someone is SWE or systems analyst. not everyone is a good systems analyst and can turn business goals into a clear specification to implement.

      if the hype was all true, i could just prompt the llm to make me money and it would be able to do it, but it's not possible

    • buriram 3 hours ago

      Software is needed, not SWEs. I can now run a company without having to hire any pesky humans doing so called "software" work. No need to worry about their health insurance, 401k, PTO, 1:1, "how are you feeling" and all such nonsense.

    • kodoman 2 hours ago

      I think it has changed everything and in all honesty it has been the biggest change since the introduction of high level languages (As in from Assembly to C and Algo).

      but at the same time I think the companies are pumping this idea that SWE is over and stoking anxiety and we have yet to see how bad things get when everyone can write software without thinking about it, we will see what insecure slop gets produced and it's going to be huge.

      The issues with AI security are quite big as well, people who will rely on just an LLM to be the intelligence will get burnt I am sure especially in operations, prompt injection is still an issue, would someone running LLM's notice an provider endpoint getting hijacked and acting maliciously and inserting malware into production servers.

      The future is going to be a strange one for sure but being able to turn your brain of and get your LLM to run you servers write you servers is not going to work alone.

      I have also yet it write a good fairly novel program without babysitting (quite trivial babysitting sometimes) but stuff that is bread and butter for us, for those who don't have those skills, will they really know how to explain the issues they may run into that requires creativity, for example telling it to hack something together with curl and jq, knowing why a certain thing with the sandbox is not working.

      I think these issues are not as easy to resolve with just better tooling and they will soon get annoyed at prompting.

      Additionally I think Gas Town shows the sort of almost mentally ill mentality that is baked into some of these tools and ideas, Everything I read of Gas Town was so strange and the amount of tokens used to anthropomorphize agents.

  • mempko 5 hours ago

    I haven't programmed by hand (I use vim) since late 2024, so about 2 years now because of AI. I've been building coding agents since 2021. As someone who coded by hand for 30 years, writing code has always been about 5% of the work and AIs do that well now. The coding agents can also do some of the other 95% of the job but not as competently.

    I have seen coding agents get better as both the models and harnesses improved. I used to have to manage context by hand, I used to review every line. I no longer do.

    However, I will tell you this from my experience with AI. Software is not any easier. The same complexities are still there. What's different isn't the kind but the scale. A 2 person team can do what a 20 person team did 5 years ago.

    What is still required is a shit ton of feedback to build what you want. It's still hard to build complex software even with AI. In fact in some ways harder because AI agents will go down rabbit holes and create entropy faster than you can say Bingo.

    Productivity is waste, it has to be, it's thermodynamics. The person's job is to fight entropy in the system. That has been true before AI and true today.

    We have to remember, software is there to serve us and fix our problems. AI doesn't change that.

    • sunrunner 4 hours ago

      > programmed by hand

      This turn of phrase really amuses me (whether I'm in complete agreement or not).

    • American87 4 hours ago

      >coding has always been about 5% of the work. >A 2 person team can do what a 20 person team did 5 years ago.

      ?

    • Marczelloni 4 hours ago

      I mostly agree with your statement. I find it really reassuring as my mental health has taken a huge dip because of all the "AI will make you obsolete with no income source" propaganda I'm hearing since like year and a half.

      Speaking from experience I see areas where the need for software is indeed saturated after a year of AI-accelerated development (where the devs are really competent and proactive), but in other areas I see the demand for it skyrocket, even with no limit to Claude Code.

      I also wonder what part of the "gravy train end" is the general economic rough patch we're in due to geopolitical conflicts & crises in the world e.g. Iran/Ukraine

    • Toutouxc 4 hours ago

      I probably agree with you, but I wish people would just stop talking about “coding by hand”. It doesn’t mean anything. I too nowadays don’t usually type in the code using a keyboard, but there are like 37 levels of not giving a damn between what I do and only reviewing PRs and then 15 more levels between that and vibecoding.

      • mempko 4 hours ago

        I mean, I used vim to type out the code. That's what i mean 'coding by hand', just to clarify what I mean.

    • tripleee 4 hours ago

      > A 2 person team can do what a 20 person team did 5 years ago

      Unless demand for software somehow increases 10x, this leads to 90% of developers being out of work.

      • mempko 4 hours ago

        I think we are entering a period I call 'Private Software'. You can buy proprietary software, you can download open source software, you can't do that with private software. Demand for software is huge, it's just people usually couldn't afford a team to make it, so they must bow down to the software gods. Any project that didn't get launched because 20 people was too expensive will with 2.

  • diabllicseagull 5 hours ago

    why is today a massive moment? why wasn't it yesterday, or the day before?

    • joshribakoff 4 hours ago

      A moment may be broader than a day

    • xpct 4 hours ago

      It's not. Speaking in maxims just gets more attention.

  • vmg12 4 hours ago

    Software engineers are the best at using ai agents, the gravy train is just getting started.

  • Marczelloni 4 hours ago

    You think that? I'm a 5-10 yr old SWE(not to disclose too much about myself) so like an L5.... what should I do? You think I won't have a job in a year or 2?

    • dpkirchner 4 hours ago

      Nobody really knows for sure, of course. Personally, I'll be surprised if we don't see a large drop in the number of devs earning (inflation-adjusted) $200k+ total compensation over the next 5 years.

      Software just needs to be good enough to make a profit before it gets replaced by a slightly better or cheaper alternative, and we're probably going to see a plethora of those alternatives.

      However I'm just some rando, I don't really know.

      • Marczelloni 4 hours ago

        One can only hope I guess?

        I don't really know either, just my mental health is torn to shreds due to that impending doom on the horizon.

        If we step outside of our IT world for a second though, I see people who have it much, much harder already. At least in my country, compared to last couple of years, jobs are much harder to come by and right now it's hard for a lot of my friends in: marketing, social media, accounting, even management and business majors who recently graduated have difficulty to find anything entry level...

        What's gonna happen in we go through a job erosion that suddenly dissapears half office jobs? Are we ready for a surge of unemployment and the ripple effects it will have to the rest of economy?

        • georgemcbay 2 hours ago

          > I don't really know either, just my mental health is torn to shreds due to that impending doom on the horizon.

          If it makes you feel any better, there are a lot of us in this position. Far more than talk about it.

          I mean, I talk about it all the time but the main response I get is people who are somewhat relieved to learn it isn't just them. (Along with a different bunch of people who need to point out I'm being a doomer to suggest that it is remotely possible that things could get pretty ugly for our profession very soon).

          It seems like many people are afraid to talk about how shaky the ground is underneath us for fear that mentioning it will manifest the worst outcome. And a lot of other people seem to be in denial that we could even really be at such an inflection point, clinging to the "AI is normal technology" idea.

          I fully accept that my view may be overly pessimistic and things won't be as bad as I think, but I really don't understand how the people who are 100% sure everything is going to be just fine are able to maintain that certainty unless to some degree they are self-soothing as much as anything else.

    • tsimionescu 4 hours ago

      Unfortunately, this is a real possibility, and no one knows what advice to give about it. It might turn out to not happen for cost reasons, or to happen 10 years from now instead of 2, or to happen 3 months from now instead of 2 years. But it is a real possibility that the SWE career will be dead in X time. Sure, a few SWEs will remain, but it won't be a realistic career path you can build your life around with some certainty that if you lose this job you'll find another. And no one can say what other jobs will be affected, and how soon.

  • jaykru 4 hours ago

    Have you actually tried vibecoding something not firmly on distribution? I'll give an anecdote.

    I've been building for the past few weeks a fancy text editor for myself to work with AI in a more sustainable and sane way. I don't have much time for this, so I've entirely vibecoded it: I don't look at the code and I've provided only some initial design and engineering decisions, debug hints, etc. on top of natural language feature requests.

    For about a week using the strongest Claude models (Fable 5.2 and Opus 5.5) this went great, and I had a minimally functional tool that worked very nicely. It seems that I hit some sort of complexity ceiling for those models though. The second week, every feature I try adding creates a new type of jank that can (at least by me) be only vaguely characterized. Most recently inserting into a line (even in the middle of the viewport) causes the viewport to jitter about.

    Our work will change, we will spend less time on tedium, we will become more ambitious. Barring an architectural paradigm shift we will still need people with strong engineering and design instincts, and even more importantly the ability to write reference code and formal specifications codifying desired behaviors.

    • 0_____0 4 hours ago

      You're on the beginning of the slope of how your career as a SWE will change. Hope y'all been working on people skills.

    • mlmonkey 4 hours ago

      Today's models seem to lose focus as the conversation goes on.

      But, as @sama said, these models you see today are the worst they'll ever be.

      It's only a matter of time before someone figures out how to maintain focus and drive a product to a polished end state over many iterations.

      • 123987569 4 hours ago

        Lol no. The enshittification phase hasn't even started yet. Wait for your quantized "premium" models with less compute and less used GPU memory at higher prices.

        • Tumblewood 4 hours ago

          How can these companies "enshittify" when open source models are not that far behind the frontier? Not to mention the closed-source competitors who would be happy to take market share.

          • drTobiasFunke 4 hours ago

            Existence of open weight models doesnt mean anything to unit economics and shareholders seeking more profits because someone has to pay for training those models and someone still needs to host them at scale.

    • Jtarii 4 hours ago

      You are assuming models don't get significantly better than they currently are.

      • layer8 4 hours ago

        Models have been getting significantly better, but what hasn’t changed is that you ultimately can’t trust their judgement and always have to double-check the important details.

        • packetlost 4 hours ago

          It's less their judgement and more they don't actually know what you're asking for. They "guess".

          • dboreham 4 hours ago

            Just like humans did.

          • layer8 4 hours ago

            Guessing generally involves judgement.

      • bigstrat2003 3 hours ago

        They haven't gotten significantly better yet. That's a good indication they won't in the future, either.

    • semiquaver 4 hours ago

      Take this as genuine advice, not criticism: The fact that you felt the need to “characterize” the jank and verbally describe it is evidence of your mistake. The only way for these new development models to function is to create a tight machine-only validation loop. Every aspect of an LLM-generated text editor must be drivable fully by the LLM itself so that it can independently observe the problems and fix them (and so those observations can be mechanically translated to regression test cases)

      LLMs won’t always guide you to do this correctly so you need to understand how important it is from the start and always enforce it.

      • groestl 4 hours ago

        > always enforce it.

        Here be lions, since these things tend to lie to you or themselves when skipping the enforcement part.

      • qlte 4 hours ago

        I'm not seeing any indication that OP didn't do that. The jank they're describing sounds exactly like something that could slip past the harness' validation loop (weird intermittent graphical anomalies).

      • the_real_cher 4 hours ago

        I'm not sure you're correct.

        If the software was capable of creating high complexity software I, or anyone, should be able to replace and build anything I want with just some prompts and guidance.

        Anyone who has worked with LLM heavily knows this is far from the truth.

        • dboreham 4 hours ago

          What thing that you want have you failed to build?

      • asdfman123 4 hours ago

        I find LLMs produce very good results if you just prompt it into good software engineering practices. Write thorough unit tests, minimize diff noise, try to re-evaluate all work to see if it can be done more elegantly and simply. Then you can run an adversarial review agent to catch any bugs it missed.

        Same goes for AI slop comments. I can just prompt AI into more or less writing like me.

      • titzer 4 hours ago

        Yeah, this is really important. Having a tight test loop is already great for humans, but doubly-so for agents. A clunky manual process sucks for humans and agents alike.

      • jaykru 4 hours ago

        I appreciate the friendly tone :-) and I mean this not as a jab: I think maybe you missed the point of my comment above, which wasn't that one can't build functional software with LLMs, but rather that it requires the diligent involvement of a technical worker.

        > Barring an architectural paradigm shift we will still need people with strong engineering and design instincts, and even more importantly the ability to write reference code and formal specifications codifying desired behaviors.

        The people building those specifications and the tight validation loops you describe are the technical software workers of tomorrow.

        • PhilipRoman 4 hours ago

          I generally agree with your idea, however you can also say "Hey Claude, I want to vibe code XYZ, set up an AI friendly automation environment" and it will have no problem throwing something together with qemu, etc. And of course it doesn't have to be you saying that, it could be a N+1 level agent, who loaded his /ai-project-management-best-practices skill.

    • dist-epoch 4 hours ago

      There is a skill in using these LLMs.

      For example I don't see any mention that you ran debt reduction loops, code simplifications loops, and in general asking the model to clean up the code after it's initial phase of "organic growth".

      • Choad_20261104 4 hours ago

        A whole cottage industry could grow up that bridges between those who know how to craft the LLMs into customized personalized utilities for individuals and small businesses.

        For sure, the guys who lost out when automobiles displaced horses were the ones who were certain they only knew how to make buggy whips.

        Adapt and thrive.

    • cautiouscat 4 hours ago

      I feel like comments like these, are from people who don’t work with complex systems. There is absolutely a ceiling to vibecoding and I don’t think it’s technical.

      When systems get complex, someone needs to know them and know where to burn the tokens. You need to know what events need to be produced because you have specific consumers. You need to know your business invariants and why.

      If you’re working on something that isn’t complex, yeah I can see why you’d think you can be replaced. If it’s just a front end? Yeah I can see that. A basic CRUD service? Sure. A business critical domain service with events, data migrations, complex business logic? I don’t see it.

      • apexalpha 4 hours ago

        What makes you think there won't be a (specific) model for that, too?

      • cmrdporcupine 4 hours ago

        I agree and it's why I find it hilarious to find places still trying to hire based on whiteboard coding and skillz testing nonsense.

        It's not that I don't think those skills are important, but they betray a fundamental misunderstanding of what SWE is, which is about managing systems, juggling complexity, and having some wisdom about how those things should fit together.

        Hopefully we start to better formalize some more of that now that the grunt work can be taken out of the equation a bit. And teach it in schools, find ways to measure it in interviews. etc

      • djha-skin 4 hours ago

        This is more of a "table saw" moment. Table saws didn't obsolete carpenters, but it did mean now you only needed one.

      • garrickvanburen 4 hours ago

        even somewhat complex systems.

        currently working on an initial product for a startup and while I'm substantially further along that I would be without LLMs, I'm at the point where the LLMs are now randomly breaking things.

        • kannanvijayan 3 hours ago

          I'm similarly working on a complex project and have run into these issues.

          There's typically a combination of issues that are occurring when the codebase goes off the rails.

          One is that cruft builds up. Large vibecoded codebases need regular "review cleaning". Where you review the whole thing top down for hygiene, contradictions, bad comments, style, redundancy, design. It's a standard thing for me now. A full review and cleanup pass once every couple months.

          The second thing that tends to go wrong is that after a certain complexity threshold, the models cannot keep track of the relevant details for a task very well. They lose sense of project directionality. Every task gets disconnected from other tasks and they start pulling the system apart at the seams, exacerbating the cruft issue above and accelerating collapse.

          I've found that separating my documentation into three distinct lobes helps: goaling docs, guardrail docs, and implementation docs. Goaling docs describe in prose the goals of the project which includes scope, certain design targets, and other things that you are aiming towards. Guardrails are for design and implementation choices you have explicitly ruled out, the "what not to do" part. Impl docs describe the state of the system as it is.

          The top-level agent documents refer to these and make their purpose explicit.

          You'd think a ticketing system might capture this, but it doesn't really provide the richness of expression a collection of documents in a directory does.

          These approaches aren't perfect. The process still has a tendency to wander off the rails, but it happens less often now and I catch it more quickly. Every session misses little bits of the goaling alignment, but they also find and address small issues missed by previous sessions. Overall it does a better job of keeping the codebase hovering around some threshold of coherency.

          I'm having a lot of fun to be honest. Yes it's bizarre and nothing like what development used to be, but it finally feels like there's some new things to learn now.

          • kalcode 3 hours ago

            Yes! Codebase health review, drift and realignment are big!

            These days they know how to handle their own context in review. So I will use that to find improvements too in retrospectivea and a small usage script hook it runs each push that alerts if high token usage. Hint the subagents are getting excessive context, which is also good hint of drift. So then I can measure when it starts happening typically via that script that Claude checks and readjusts when one goes over budget.

      • sbysb 4 hours ago

        It is because the average developer has outsourced all product thinking to an external team. The gravy train might actually be over for the Software Engineer that takes a Jira ticket and produces a PR, but in my opinion the demand for Product Engineers is only going to increase.

        However it will be similar to cybersecurity in that there will be no 'entry level' product engineer. It will probably have requirements having worked in customer service or finance or some other adjacent field to get a larger picture of what you are delivering. You will also not need 3000 of these individuals anymore (did we ever really??)

        I can see a world where you go from "AI Shepard Customer Success rep" -> some middle role with increasing 'product' responsibilities -> Product Engineer.

        The new roles will also probably be more generic - instead of backend and frontend you have 'Backend' (Infra + API) and 'Frontend' (Frontend + Design) and both of these roles will require genuine product thinking

      • dboreham 4 hours ago

        For me the experience is very similar to what it was like to manage a software operation with humans working for me. Actually for the first year or so it was like that where I was the senior engineer and AI was the junior devs. But then it got good enough that it could also be a trusted senior level advisor. So I'm just setting the project scope and general direction and making the odd tweak here and there now. I'm truly baffled by posts saying that AI is terrible in late 2026. My very heavy use experience is quite the opposite.

      • paul7986 4 hours ago

        All digital forms of work are a dying field. Designing and building applications is now similar to writing a song with SUNO. Pumping out slop and anyone can do it even my friend working in an Amazon warehouse (never coded anything and a zero technical background) is pumping out apps.

        What we the people need to do is gain control and hold all the power of AI in our hands - not the filthy rich's hands! Devise systems that flip the power into our hands and create economies and jobs around it (i have ideas and surely 1000s to more do to around this).

      • kalcode 3 hours ago

        Many LLMs are working on huge complex codebase. I'd look inwards at engineers unable to get it to work on large codebases. No different than sending a contractor in. Do you tell the contractor "understand the entire codebase, business context and documentation all at once!"

        No, and it's the same with leads, they can be given a system they understand but need to reference it.

        I'm very certain these are people brushing up against their lack of processes, workflows, or engineering practices.

        The context are large enough. You do not need to understand the world to build a chair.

        I see the very opposite in many different domains happening now, and some codebases are monsterous. They are figuring out ways that do indeed work well.

        The engineers that are figuring out these problems when working with a new tool, will have jobs.

        Those who continue to doubt, and distance themselves are the ones that will be behind.

        • Seattle3503 1 hour ago

          > I'm very certain these are people brushing up against their lack of processes, workflows, or engineering practices.

          I think it is mastake to lay this completely at the feet of ICs. What you are describing is a form of engineering, and a lot of management feels that "engineering is solved" (not just "coding") and have no patience for these things. ICs are being forced into extremely naive and unsophisticated AI usage by managers with incorrect mental models. That's why so many ICs are cranky.

          • truncate 30 minutes ago

            This ^^

            Its out there, it can do things, and it has its limitations. What it can do gets lot of light, and what it can't do well becomes a ICs 'skill issue'. Say with AI your velocity can go up by factor or X, but expectation is Y where Y >> X. This leads to lot AI-usage which is nothing close to "engineering". The whole idea that engineer should be able to defend what they build, while showing productivity gains that are factor Y can't be done without cutting corners, and it looks like leadership is mostly ok with it as long as it not immediately causing problems.

            This is again not problem with AI essentially, but the overly optimistic expectations from it.

    • jonah 4 hours ago

      I find myself working more as a technical project manager which is fine by me.

      My other firsthand observation is seeing the difference between what quality of software that I, as someone with many years of experience, can produce versus my coworker, a talented designer without SW experience who is very AI pilled and excited to be making things, is able to produce.

    • aurareturn 4 hours ago

      It's still a skill issue.

      LLMs have massively improved the quality of our company's main app. However, someone less skilled at our company tried to vibe code an internal tool and it was pure crap.

    • scottLobster 4 hours ago

      I ran into a similar issue with Gemini 3.8 in an even simpler context. Spent several hours asking it why my new module wasn't working and each time after several minutes of thinking it would exclaim "I FOUND THE ROOT CAUSE!" and despite implementing its fix the problem would still persist.

      After about a dozen failed iterations I reverted to the last known working commit (albeit with the new module only partially implemented), isolated the issue as best I could, then asked Gemini again and this time it correctly identified a latent timing bug that was the cause of all the problems.

      In short, I had to manually reduce the complexity of the problem for this magic infinity-dimensional-processor to deduce what the problem was. Maybe it would have gotten there eventually, but without AI I would have just reverted the commit a lot sooner and likely figured it out on my own with some basic debug logging.

      It's still a net gain, as it's successfully one-shotted coding errors and bugs that might have taken me hours to find before, but it can miss basic problems as well.

      • husseinhb 4 hours ago

        That's great you find the root cause, as a way that i using it that helped me a lot which is first of all understand what is the bug without touching the code.

        Then after i understand it i can make a targeted investigations for that issue and after that it will be obvious for the AI, and all of those we still didn't change even one line in the code.

        After that, we fix that issue (which is the root of the cause), release and congratulation the bug was fixed this way works even in lowest powerful models.

    • flutas 4 hours ago

      At $DAYJOB I was working on something novel on mobile devices (so much so other companies we consulted with said it was something they wouldn't even try to do), and ran into a lot of the same issues. The model was quick to try and do quick patch fixes on various parts of the system to make it work, result in a janky but "usable" experience.

      Through a combo of me and it over about a month we got it working well enough to roll out though. The entire time I had to hand hold the model through the changes though, and it loved to try and throw it away for quick fixes that would break something else.

      • DANmode 3 hours ago

        Don’t use the same chat/session this long. Dump your progress in meaningful ways, begin a new session.

    • foolserrandboy 4 hours ago

      How did everyone miss the actual thrust of this post? Maybe we really are cooked.

    • microtonal 4 hours ago

      Our work will change, we will spend less time on tedium, we will become more ambitious. Barring an architectural paradigm shift we will still need people with strong engineering and design instincts, and even more importantly the ability to write reference code and formal specifications codifying desired behaviors.

      It is hard to say how things will develop the coming years, but this sums it up for me today. Almost constantly, LLMs (e.g. Opus 5.5/Sonnet 5.5) make choices that a junior programmer would think is ok, but I know that will create technical debt, subpar designs, etc. Note that I'm not saying that LLMs program like a junior programmer, in many ways they program like senior engineers who have happened to memoize all API docs as well. But they are often missing the larger context or don't understand the time dimension (what will be hard to maintain, what will introduce an API that we can not easily backtrack from, etc). So, I am not surprised that vibecoding breaks down as a project becomes larger.

      At the same time, current LLMs make me a lot more productive (which was not true for me ~one year ago). I can do in 30-60 minutes what would take me a day 1-2 years ago. In many ways, programming also became more interesting, because I can focus on design, the really challenging parts, while the LLM can quickly implement it. LLMs really feel like a different, in many ways complementary intelligence for development.

  • ratsimihah 4 hours ago

    What a feeling to lose our superpower! But what draw us into building in the first place was our curiosity with tinkering. We got lucky it became so profitable, but I’m sure we’ll find a way to adapt and thrive again.

  • tgsovlerkhgsel 4 hours ago

    I think the "Obsolete" song (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aLRmcVU2oWw) points it out correctly: We'll need (through governments) make sure that the increased profits/productivity reach everyone rather than being harvested by a few rich people/companies, because human labor will stop being an effective way to distribute wealth to people.

    That could be as simple as raising taxes on corporate profits and using them for a universal basic income, or something more clever, but I hope governments manage to build something before it leads to a dystopia and social unrest.

  • hansvm 4 hours ago

    It's not over in terms of current capabilities. The future is uncertain, but the status quo is good engineers are more irreplaceable than they ever were in recent history.

  • francisofascii 4 hours ago

    I always thought outsourcing or ageism would take me out of the game. Never expected something like this.

  • betterunix2 4 hours ago

    > Genuinely a massive moment in human history

    Is it? It looks more like a forgettable moment to me. We're talking about an IPO, how many headline-making IPOs can you actually remember?

    > as a SWE the gravy train is basically over in my view

    That is not a result of the IPO even if you are right, and I have my doubts.

    > they figured out how to make a program that does the job

    No they figured out how to make software that makes the job easier. How is this any different from the introduction of optimizing compilers or type systems or any of the other software tools we all use? It makes programmers more productive, which means programmers can take on larger projects.

    Coding agents have limits and the managers who forced their SWEs to use them are starting to figure that out. Using agents to both write code and review code sounds cool in theory but in practice it is not such a great idea -- it means that nobody actually understands the codebase and therefore nobody can actually debug the code when things break. No, you cannot just assume that you can also throw an agent at the problem when things break -- because the breakage might mean you lost access to the agent or the agent lost access to your system and cannot help you.

    > difficult to grasp how much life will change in the coming years

    Not too difficult to grasp. Shareholders will demand returns and Anthropic will have to deliver those returns. All the sky-high dreams about RSI and the next phase of human existence are going to evaporate and profit is going to be front and center.

    Another possibility: Anthropic fails to survive the next recession and the companies that did not allow their employees to become dependent on Claude will be the winners.

    • cheesecompiler 4 hours ago

      I consider myself an AI skeptic but this is an unprecedented IPO in terms of at least capability AI offers already, magnitude of IPO, the first AI company going public, dollar amounts involved, and the sci-fi level labour replacement story being sold.

      • betterunix2 4 hours ago

        It is not actually the first AI company to go public. That happened decades ago during a previous AI hype cycle.

        The only thing that makes this IPO notable is the dollar amount, and it is neither the first nor the last IPO to be notable for that reason.

      • platinumrad 4 hours ago

        SpaceX matches almost all of these metrics and came first.

    • pwython 4 hours ago

      > how many headline-making IPOs can you actually remember

      Exactly...? This is the only one I'm sure to remember.

      • platinumrad 4 hours ago

        SpaceX's was almost as large and nobody cares anymore.

      • sph 4 hours ago

        I’ll call it recency bias.

      • betterunix2 4 hours ago

        I doubt you will remember it in 10 years, unless you are buying shares now and find that you are still waiting for a return after a decade.

    • codethief 4 hours ago

      > Another possibility: Anthropic fails to survive the next recession and the companies that did not allow their employees to become dependent on Claude will be the winners.

      That seems highly unlikely, given that there are countless open-weights models available.

      • taurath 3 hours ago

        Its not about whether AI is available, its about whether AI is actually effective if you give control over your codebase to AI. Which, as I'm watching in my company right now, it is not, unless you have a lot of people in charge who can do first-principles thinking.

        If nobody knows what your code does anymore, if it turns out that the tradeoffs AI makes metastacize over time, if it turns out that attention to detail ACTUALLY matters to the functioning of your systems (which it always has), then we are barreling for an extremely rude awakening. The water is just starting to move in the kettle - it might turn to a boil soon.

        • codethief 2 hours ago

          I think we're talking past each other. I never claimed a complete hands-off dark-factory approach to agentic coding were viable. But what's becoming clear, I think, is that agents do provide some value, if steered correctly. So I doubt the world would be going back to zero AI usage.

          • taurath 1 hour ago

            Sorry, I think I misunderstood what you meant by "dependency". Many places have completely let go of coherence of their projects with AI. I use AI all the time, but it helps build coherence, understanding and quality. This is becoming more and more difficult as more people turn their brain off in the face of pressure from management to try to ship more and more.

            I am extremely afraid that are on the verge of losing coherence on all technology.

      • betterunix2 1 hour ago

        Which is why I said "...dependent on Claude...," which is Anthropic's product and which would cease to exist if Anthropic went bankrupt. If you can easily switch to something else, open or otherwise, great, you are not actually dependent on Claude.

        (Don't assume that switching between different coding agents will always be simple or straightforward. It is possible, and I think likely, that in the coming years code written by one agent will not be easy for another agent to work with. It is already becoming difficult for human programmers to deal with agent-generated code and people are already starting to develop best practices to try to mitigate that. We are still in the early days here and we have not yet encountered many of the problems that are going to arise.)

  • viklove 4 hours ago

    Do what I did: marry a surgeon. I'm sure her job will take longer for them to automate, might give us enough time to retire before the world goes to complete shit.

  • lofaszvanitt 4 hours ago

    The writing was on the wall. First wave was the Nocode thing, that clearly outlined what they wanted. Then lowcode, and now vibecode.

    The gullibility of people is astounding, and they never learn.

  • LeBit 4 hours ago

    You are now an architect.

    Everybody is an architect now.

    Don’t worry.

  • nemo44x 4 hours ago

    Yeah it’s a remarkable black swan. SWEs were turkeys after all. Fed well, taken care of, and comfortable. Thinking they’re the lucky ones; this is the life. How nice.

    It’s a dark coincidence that “Turkey Day” is next week in the USA. Many turkeys that will be on our plates never imagined THAT fate.

  • elgertam 4 hours ago

    I came close to thinking that way a couple years ago, but I've become more optimistic. There is no shortage of problems that can be solved (in fact, wants are infinite), and LLMs may actually enable our profession to reliably deliver them better than 50% completion.

    I've also seen non-technical folks in the corporate and government worlds glom onto vibe coding, only to start flailing like they were caught in a rip current when the underlying technical debt is too strong, even with strong and capable models.

    For a certain type of engineer who enjoys really arcane technical problems, yeah, the gravy train may be over, or at least will involve a lot more machines than it used to, as Alan Turing predicted about "mechanical work" becoming a "drudge."[0]

    And I think Big Tech is for the foreseeable future a sink for capital in the form of specialized hardware rather than human capital.

    [0]https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Alan_Turing#Quotes

    • ffsm8 4 hours ago

      The issue is, there are going to be less and less people willing to give you money that you can make a living to address those infinite wants

      • jazzypants 4 hours ago

        Most normies don't like having to explain what they want to an LLM. From what I've observed, after the initial euphoria of creating something from nothing fades, they eventually get frustrated with the first version of a vibe coded app, and they have trouble explaining exactly how they what it want to change.

        I think almost every new business will have at least one person whose job is to deal with the technology. There might be fewer of them, and they might be a weird amalgamation of sysadmin and web developer, but there will still be jobs for nerds like us who actually like doing this stuff.

        • raincole 3 hours ago

          Explaining what they want to an LLM - something that can understand badly organized word salads with infinite patience - is frustrating? Then imagine how they'd feel if they have to explain what they want to a human...

          • techpression 3 hours ago

            A big part of the job is to not have them do that though.

          • jazzypants 3 hours ago

            The key differences are that humans can better anticipate people's needs, communicate through body language, understand social cues, maintain critical information even as it changes quickly, and interact with the real world effortlessly.

            • b112 3 hours ago

              For now. Wait a couple of years.

          • ratelimitsteve 3 hours ago

            "I want it to search and be fast"

            vs

            "I want to pre-sort during idle time so that I can effectively implement a binary search"

            You can tell me either of these and get the same product. You can pick one of these and tell an LLM to do it three times and get three different products.

            • blobbers 2 hours ago

              And the LLM can also implement something way better than idle pre sort.

              Sorry, this cope.

              • tyg13 1 hour ago

                Left to its own devices, the AI may choose to implement things efficiently and correctly, or it may choose to implement things inefficiently and incorrectly. Without clear guidance, acceptance criteria, and hand-holding, it will make assumptions that are wrong, and as the demands of the product grow, it will continue to build off of those wrong assumptions. This is my experience with Gemini, Claude, GPT -- any of the models. They need guidance or they will build crap.

                Now, this may be acceptable (tons of businesses are built on broken products), but what is absolutely cope is this moronic idea that the LLM is always smarter than the average engineer and will magically produce the most efficient and correct solution.

                • ratelimitsteve 1 hour ago

                  > Without clear guidance, acceptance criteria, and hand-holding, it will make assumptions that are wrong

                  Yeah but the person you're replying to isn't gonna see that because they already made several assumptions about the problem I put in front of them

          • bigfatkitten 3 hours ago

            There is an entire profession of people who make good money doing this for a living. They are called business analysts.

          • dominotw 2 hours ago

            Are you saying you presonally explained all your needs to apple to get the laptop or phone you used to type that comment?

        • throw-the-towel 3 hours ago

          Most normies would like giving $insane to you to prompt the LLM even less.

        • ElProlactin 3 hours ago

          Most normies don't like paying $200+/hour to techies who refer to them as "normies".

        • RunSet 2 hours ago

          The same people who can't give you directions to the next intersection expect they will be able to describe patient management software.

        • pampas 1 hour ago

          You know what is worse for 'normies'? Waiting. I don't want to wait hours or days for results from an SWE/accountant/lawyer/architect etc who will just be forwarding my words to an LLM anyway. LLM's can spit out results in a matter of seconds and let me iterate.

          And if I still want professional help then there will be a excess of labour due to the above for most tasks.

          • jazzypants 44 minutes ago

            Yes, exactly. You'll still hire someone.

      • gloosx 4 hours ago

        you can just ask llm to make you some money so you can make a living then?

      • lIIlllIlIIIlIll 4 hours ago

        English speaking software engineers are firmly in the 0.1%

        We'll be fine. Move to a lower cost of living area, start a business. There's millions of companies in need of software expertise.

        All this moral panic about software work is unseemly. Maybe the easy "learn JS/frameworks" path to wealth is closed. Whatever. Good, actually.

        • gnz11 3 hours ago

          Starting a business is easy, maintaining one is incredibly difficult. I would not bank on that as some kind of a fallback. Starting a boutique software business sounds even more risky in this climate compared to even just few years ago.

          • lIIlllIlIIIlIll 2 hours ago

            That's just one thing one might do.

            We'll be fine, we're the most prosperous worker class in the history of working.

            Besides the job never was churning out code and if there was a bloat of such positions it was only ever a temporary distortion.

        • tripleee 2 hours ago

          Anyone saying "just start a business" as some kind of easy alternative has almost definitely never tried "just starting a business".

          • lIIlllIlIIIlIll 2 hours ago

            You'll notice the conspicuous absence of the word "just" in my comment.

        • CodeMage 2 hours ago

          > Move to a lower cost of living area, start a business.

          This reminds me of that viral clip with Ben Shapiro saying that if the sea levels rise, people will just sell their homes and move. The clip went viral because of the response: "Just one small problem. Sell their houses to who [sic], Ben? F*cking Aquaman?"

          > All this moral panic about software work is unseemly.

          You know, it's funny how the history keeps repeating. This will be far from the first time a technological breakthrough left a group of people obsolete and scrabbling to deal with it.

          Every single time this happens and ends up being a net positive for the society, the suffering of those people is ignored at the time and then we eventually look back and end up expressing empathy for them. And every single time we express hope that maybe next time we can do better as a society.

          And every single time it happens, we not only fail to do better, but we have people condemning the very idea that we should even try to do better.

          > Maybe the easy "learn JS/frameworks" path to wealth is closed. Whatever. Good, actually.

          Wait, I could have easily amassed wealth by "just" learning "JS/frameworks"? Wow, and here I had the wrong idea about the causes of wealth distribution inequality. It's clearly those parasitic JS devs' fault.

      • maxdo 4 hours ago

        And more people willing to do your job . For my FDE opening I got people from accounting background, guess what , why not ?

      • lallysingh 4 hours ago

        Oh no, the opposite. So many people will be writing software via claude now. So many more software-based, or at least, software-integrated businesses are going to pop up. And when as they grow, LLMs aren't going to be enough.

        What's going to change is that we'll have to focus on the actual hard problems of software development: making sure the software does what it's supposed to, isolating nontrivial bugs, finding ways to make it perform better.

        • akmiller 3 hours ago

          > actual hard problems of software development: making sure the software does what it's supposed to, isolating nontrivial bugs, finding ways to make it perform better.

          These are exactly the things LLM's outperform all of us on.

          • chrisco255 3 hours ago

            > making sure the software does what it's supposed to

            If you've tried to build anything nontrivial with LLM you know this just isn't true.

            • akkad33 3 hours ago

              I don't know most times claude picks up edge cases I never thought of. I spend a non trivial amount of time telling it this edge case doesn't happen

              • chrisco255 2 hours ago

                Well, correcting LLMs from overanalyzing is part of your value in the loop.

            • akmiller 3 hours ago

              I've been a developer for 27 years and have built many non-trivial things with LLM's (that's all I do anymore). I'm sorry, but anyone down-voting my comment can't be serious.

              Why is much of our legacy software suddenly failing us if we are so much better at finding intricate bugs than the LLM's? Why are all of us easily capable of speeding up our software by orders of magnitude in small amounts of time utilizing them. Yes, they are better at verification as well.

              • platinumrad 2 hours ago

                LLMs are better than people at finding intricate bugs, in part because they do not tire or get bored, but people are still much better at designing coherent systems.

                • Archer6621 1 hour ago

                  That's because LLMs are incoherent by design, and need extensive guardrails to be useful for tasks that demand coherence.

                  I share a similar experience with bug finding; I think it also helps that LLMs can simply hold much more context at once than a human, as seeing a much larger portion of the codebase simultaneously makes it much easier to spot discrepancies.

              • lallysingh 2 hours ago

                Because we have a new tool that finds certain classes of bugs way better than our old tools. That's it. Sanitizers and linters had similar impact - they just happened early enough that there was less computer-dependent infra that was impacted.

              • chrisco255 2 hours ago

                You bring 27 years of experience and context to every single LLM session you open, so every session you have with an LLM is already going to be far more productive than someone starting from scratch with zero experience in application development. You're able to understand how to map business requirements to technical outcomes and you can competently direct the LLMs to the desired outcome. That is the high-value part of your job that has always existed. It never was about coding the solution in whatever esoteric Turing-complete language you used.

                As for legacy software suddenly failing us, what you're really talking about are active systems like Microsoft 365 (it's not legacy code). Those systems have always been complex. That they are "suddenly" failing could be an indication of a number of things, but I'd pin a large part of the responsibility on organizational debt (even beyond technical debt). Maintaining complex software systems is hard, software mostly isn't a static thing it has to constantly evolve. It could also be an indication of over-reliance on LLM competency, for all we know about those system's internals. We just don't know enough to make an assessment.

                There have been some zero days discovered by LLMs. There have also been many socially engineered, regular old exploits that have been impressed on us as indications of AI breakouts.

                As for speedups, most software is comically unoptimized and has been for some time. We made an explicit trade-off in software development as CPUs and machines got more capable: we started coding in simpler languages with higher levels of abstraction (Python, Ruby, JS, Java, etc) sometimes costing us 10x or more in resource utilization, in exchange for the iteration speed that bought us. Converting those to more efficient languages like Go, Rust, C, etc alone buys you so much. On top of that, there are a number of algorithmic optimizations most developers never implemented that map to well known access patterns in hardware. Lots of low hanging fruit.

          • rvz 3 hours ago

            If you are building software that has no risk, then it's not important enough for anyone willing to pay for it and they will believe it is safe enough to build it themselves.

            Examples are: Note taking apps, voice recording apps, calendar apps, video games, etc.

          • lallysingh 2 hours ago

            My experience is exactly the opposite. 30 years writing software for my job, been using claude/grok for most of this year. At first they were really amazing. A real lever for higher output. But, I spend most of my time now telling them how to design high-performance systems and how to manage high concurrency and low contention.

            They'll shove out a pattern quickly, but no matter how new and magical the latest model is, they will just put out some tweaked variant of existing designs. I find myself treating it like a junior-mid engineer. "Add rdtsc-based timers around major parts of the code to whittle down what's taking too long." "Use that to figure out where the transfer amount is way too small to justify the time taken without copying the payload." etc.

            But concurrency bugs from large LLM-developed codebases are a major issue. They constantly find bugs they wrote. I eventually told it to start writing formal models of the concurrent uses and to (a) validate the models; (b) verify the code implements the models; to make it work.

            So yeah, I stand by my words. For simple commands and tiny codebases, it /can/ do those things, but even small projects (50 KLOC) are a mess of making it fix its own mistakes, reconcile basic logic in requirements analysis, and everything has to be taken over with a fine-tooth comb to make it any good.

          • LtWorf 2 hours ago

            > These are exactly the things LLM's outperform all of us on.

            If you throw an excessive amount of money at the problem yes.

        • decidu0us9034 2 hours ago

          I don't understand the vision of the one-person Claude-powered business. If it can be done with one person, it can be done with zero more efficiently. What seems more likely to me is the emergence of a few (or one) massive vertically-integrated everything firms, who can afford more inference than anyone else seeking to enter the market. What we call AI, is more than that, it's accummulation, capital, systems of power, and these juggernauts will simply have more of it. Agents will continually do research to seek out areas of market inefficiency and octopus into them. They can outline business requirements, spec them out, and delegate to other agents. Other agents can continually research perf improvements, hunt for vulns, and so on. Once the race to the bottom kicks off, there's no undoing it. It seemed absurd to me a few months ago but every time I've thought capabilities were limited in some fundamental way I've been proven wrong

      • tripleee 3 hours ago

        I've been hired for good money by people who had the skills to do the work themselves (the best people to work for!), simply because it took time and they had a lot on their plate already.

        Wages might decrease if the work becomes easier and more people are able to do it, but I'm not sure jobs will actually go away until true AGI.

      • rokhayakebe 3 hours ago

        Correct, but there are now more people willing to give you $10-$80 monthly for your vibecoded product. I would give $30 monthly before I sit down and vibecode a crm.

      • Danox 13 minutes ago

        The issue today is that after 1945, starting with the Korean War, those days of extracurricular interference overseas is coming to an end. The country, like Great Britain before it, can no longer afford it. The cash register is moving over to tilt no more…

    • bayarearefugee 4 hours ago

      > There is no shortage of problems that can be solved (in fact, wants are infinite), and LLMs may actually enable our profession to reliably deliver them better than 50% completion.

      Seems like copium to me if we're being honest.

      Why would anyone pay you to solve the problem when they can just throw it at a cheap LLM?

      And if the answer is that you have some sort of special taste or domain knowledge, once your solution is out in the world how are you going to stop someone from using an LLM to copy it and then undercut you in an immediate race to the bottom for everything?

      • deadbabe 4 hours ago

        You create secret workflows, skills, and solutions that you never give others access to. Already doing this at work, 65% of my tooling is not available to any other employee.

        • kodoman 4 hours ago

          I agree but then you have to make sure your prompting of the model does not expose the special technique, if your running local fine otherwise someone can just work out your tools or simply just pinch you skill markdown files.

        • _aavaa_ 4 hours ago

          As they say, this doesn't seem like a durable moat.

        • coffeebeqn 3 hours ago

          One of our staff engineers tried that but I just took one of the outputs they shared and told the same model figure out how to prompt and what to set up to do this and his super power was mine in an hour or less.

          I don’t know what moats we can have at this point. I’m trying to build a side hustle with vibe coding something because if it’s a backend only you can access at least you have a tiny moat. If you’re just prompting slightly more cleverly at your employers Claude account you do not have a moat

        • ratelimitsteve 3 hours ago

          ooh shit i remember security through obscurity from back in the 90s. i wonder how well it will work in the age of fully automated reverse engineering and smart guess and check.

          i also wonder if there's something in your employment agreement about the things you make on company time and who they belong to.

        • _superposition_ 1 hour ago

          This is an anti pattern and you are a bottle neck.

      • arrowleaf 4 hours ago

        I can see that you've been using Claude too much lately if you only read the first sentence/paragraph to decide what the entire comment says. You must not be working on sophisticated enough problems to see the rip current form as described. It (technical and cognitive debt) exists, just below the surface, and once it takes hold there's no swimming back to shore (a stable maintainable system) without extreme effort (refactors and first principles redesigns).

      • ccppurcell 4 hours ago

        If that analysis is correct (I tend to agree with it but I'm not sure) then we're heading for a world where no company can exist except for anthropic, openai etc. because if you're solving some problem with LLMs, and I am your customer, I can solve the same problem with LLMs and cut out the middle man. At the very least, there will be a race to the bottom until nothing is left.

        If that happens I guess the whole thing hinges on how powerful and user-friendly open source models become.

        • psadri 3 hours ago

          I think that is essentially the bet around Anthropic / OpenAI

          • TyadorB 3 hours ago

            Why would they not be replaced as well?

          • californical 3 hours ago

            Which is weird because there are so many things in society that will break up these companies rather than allow them to become bigger than governments.

            It’s not possible for them to grow as big as their boosters want them to. There would be so much resistance, and if that resistance fails, then we’d already be in the middle of techno-dystopia hell anyways, where money wouldn’t matter.

            • andriy_koval 3 hours ago

              > than allow them to become bigger than governments.

              government will be their puppets, and what can I do then?

              • steelframe 2 hours ago

                Join the revolution.

                • andriy_koval 2 hours ago

                  or accept that democracy is not sustainable society management style and will be always corrupted one way or another..

        • johndhi 3 hours ago

          other options you're forgetting:

          if your scenario starts happening, we break up anthropic and openai for antitrust reasons, or people do other things so that they don't become kings.

        • benashford 3 hours ago

          This is one of the fascinating unanswered philosophical questions. If LLMs become more intelligent (albeit limited to certain types of problem solving) than any human, and we all have access to the same LLMs, are we all equally intelligent?

          If the answer to that is "yes", then there's literally no point in anyone hiring anyone for any knowledge work. And that applies to other businesses. Why give a SaaS company recurring revenue if they're just a thin wrapper around Claude anyway?

          The answer I think is that few companies are so thin. Most offer something else, some other kind of moat that has nothing to do with problem solving, or some kind of lock-in.

          But there are definitely some (mostly small) companies that only exist to sell relatively simple specialist software to customers that don't have their own developers. Their moat against competitors was the relative scarcity of good developers, and the difficulty of motivating them even if you could hire them. In the post-LLM world, those small companies suddenly have competitors for the first time...

      • tarballing 3 hours ago

        Because those people have their own jobs and they don't care enough about software to treat it like a second job

      • johndhi 3 hours ago

        call me crazy but you appear to be suggesting:

        (1) LLMs can solve any human problem; (2) that #1 would be a bad thing if it were actually true because some SWEs can't get the same job they had before

        if the LLMs are that great, tell them to find the SWEs a new, better job. if they aren't, and LLM+SWE is > LLM, then #1 falls apart.

        • bayarearefugee 3 hours ago

          > (1) LLMs can solve any human problem;

          Certainly not every problem, but enough problems that we currently consider economically valuable to cause a very large negative disruption in labor.

          > (2) that #1 would be a bad thing if it were actually true because some SWEs can't get the same job they had before

          I wouldn't say some SWEs I'd say almost all SWEs.

          > if the LLMs are that great, tell them to find the SWEs a new, better job. if they aren't, and LLM+SWE is > LLM, then #1 falls apart.

          Again, I don't think LLMs will solve every problem. Just enough problems that they put about 80% of all knowledge workers out of work in a relatively short timeframe, which is going to be economically disastrous in a way that expands far beyond just knowledge workers.

      • kenferry 3 hours ago

        I agree with poster regarding "we're not running out of problems, and therefore we're not running out of jobs". I'm not sure whether the jobs will be "programming" though. And if I had to bet, I would say they will not be. I would guess that domain experts will be able to handle their own programming tasks most of the time. Which is cool! The same way people don't need dedicated typists anymore to transcribe text.

        My grandfather worked at NASA, and my impression is that a significant portion of what he did was actual calculation. Nasa still employs people, they just don't do that particular work anymore.

    • wat10000 3 hours ago

      On the one hand, the models are definitely not good enough to replace human coders in all areas. I get great results from them, but they need some back and forth to get there. I'm in no danger of being replaced right now.

      On the other hand, just two years ago they were practically useless for anything non-trivial. In that time, they went from "might be cool someday" to "can do most of the work, but still needs handholding." What are they going to look like two years from now? Five years? Ten?

      So much depends on where we are on the S-curve. If we're getting into diminishing returns, then we may top out at a point that isn't too far beyond what we have today, where they're highly capable but need that human judgment and oversight. If we're at the bottom of the curve, it's hard to know what the future would look like. I have no idea which one is closer to being true, and I don't think anyone else does either.

      • citizenpaul 3 hours ago

        Its not a curve, its a cliff. The second that LLM's no longer need human oversight that is it, 99.99% drop in white collar employment in probably less than a year.

        I think we actually are there in some areas but the bureaucratic/social structures are actually blocking it. If you asked me 2 years ago I would have laughed.

    • yt-sdb 3 hours ago

      What do you mean "a couple years ago"? Opus 4.5 isn't a year old yet. I don't necessarily disagree with your take, but starting off by saying you updated your view two years ago seems... outdated?

    • elevation 3 hours ago

      "You can train an LLM on all the notes in classical music up to the 18th century -- but will it ever invent jazz?"

      • ElProlactin 3 hours ago

        "You can train an LLM on all the hip hop up to 2000 -- but will it ever invent mumble rap?"

      • notJim 2 hours ago

        But most economically valuable software is not inventing jazz, it's applying well-established rules to new or neglected domains.

        • pydry 1 hour ago

          This isnt true. The economically valuable software does invent jazz.

          The existence of companies like airbnb or uber or spotify confuses matters because they pretend to be software companies with valuable software but their real USP is some kind of legal/regulatory/market dominance and their software is nothing special.

      • pmg101 55 minutes ago

        That's right. But 99% of what software devs have been paid to do is just churn out classical music notes in slightly different orders, over and over again.

        There's been the very occasional breakthrough, but it could have been done by just a handful of brilliant people at key moments. The rest was just filler and AI will do it better than we have been anyway.

      • evenhash 45 minutes ago

        How do humans innovate?

        They only know about things they’ve seen before, how could they ever come up with something new?

    • sl0wbrainRot 3 hours ago

      Can be solved and must be solved are not the same thing

      Are you solving a shared agreed upon real problem or just doing leetcode on arbitrary meaningless data structure?

      There will still be jobs but orders of magnitude fewer jobs.

      Closer to reality that existed before the 08 crash and ZIRP fueled ponzi schemes fueled the web SaaS mania.

      US doesn't need 4+ million software devs

      World doesn't need 50+ million software devs

      ...when big tech is just shipping black boxes that boot models to handle local inference

      It just needs enough jobs to solve that big tech production pipeline

    • scott_w 3 hours ago

      I feel the same way. The discussion on commoditising programming skills has been going on since before I left school and what we saw was demand, and pay, skyrocket as accessibility of the profession increased. I believe it’s possible that making it more accessible makes problems that were uneconomical to even explore quite challenging but achievable.

      • roosterIllusi0n 3 hours ago

        The issue is that CEOs are allowed to grift. They can cut wages, under staff, and outsource to make themselves personally richer.

        We had prevented this for 20 years in the 1950s and 60s with a 90% federal tax bracket that capped yearly incomes to $5 mil a year in 2026 dollars. Stock buybacks were illegal and we had a bunch more post-1929 regulations that were not gutted yet.

        Restore the tax policy and financial regulations of the 1950s. CEOs would be stopped immediately. This is how we got out of the great depression.

        • bs7280 3 hours ago

          The day stock buy backs were legalized is the day our country switched from capitalisism to an oligarchy.

          • smallmancontrov 3 hours ago

            Capitalism is a softmax function. It pushes with enormous, exponentially compounding strength towards concentrating wealth and power.

            Buybacks are not necessary. The same exponential compounding happens just as easily with dividends or even just growth and a trusting valuation. It's the compounding r>g that is the problem.

          • loeg 2 hours ago

            Buybacks are functionally equivalent to dividends. It literally does not matter.

            • derektank 2 hours ago

              Also, buybacks have never been illegal. Stock manipulation is illegal and has been for nearly a century, but buybacks were never inherently illegal. They became more popular in the eighties when the SEC provided additional clarity on when buybacks were explicitly legal (such as when stock repurchases are below a certain percent of daily trading volume), and then they became more popular again in the 90s when capital gains taxes were cut.

              So yeah, that is actually the one area where they’re not equivalent to dividends, tax treatment. Though that’s changed in the last twenty years as well as some dividends are no longer taxed as individual income.

            • dillondoyle 1 hour ago

              It matters greatly & it's not functionally equivalent.

              stock owners gain a lot more from buybacks than dividends. Juice your gains. Die. Dont pay taxes.

              Buybacks likely also increase liquidity/market efficiency which is a stock owners benefit [0] (companies buy when price is low to prop it up. increase liquidity. also sort of relevant to today i was learning how the ANT greenshoe works).

              Even if you do eventually sell you've basically gotten an interest free loan from the govt in deferred taxes over your hold time. that's huge.

              what matters more to me is that it probably drives inequality.

              100% proven to definitely decrease tax take (found different sources from about ~400-850bb 10 years). That's universal pre-k + universal childcare. Or free community college + school meals for all. OR pfml + dental and hearing in medicare.

              One study [1] compared the same person same stocks > taxable v. IRAs/401ks: "Effective accrual tax rates for stocks that experience substantial appreciation are substantially below the statutory tax rate on long-term gains." e.g. lower effective tax rates/ever shrinking revenue sources

              the 1% tax in IRA barely makes a dent.

              This study is a triple wammy of gross [2]:

              - illustrative of executives who get comp in stock seem to be more likely to make selfish short-term stock price driven decisions - use last-minute buy backs to juice earnings (prob voids the put benefit) - at the expense of R&D and re-investing for innovation

              " share repurchases that increase earnings per share (EPS) is sharply higher for firms that would have just missed the EPS forecast" "EPS-motivated repurchases are associated with reductions in employment and investment"

              [0] https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2506671 [1] https://www.aeaweb.org/articles?id=10.1257/00028280577501446... [2] https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S03044...

              • Danox 34 minutes ago

                I bet you don’t like stock splits either.

            • Terr_ 1 hour ago

              If, as you say, it truly "does not matter", then we'd already be in a different world where:

              1. Companies wouldn't have a preference for it.

              2. Nobody would defend/lobby-for the practice.

            • Danox 39 minutes ago

              I would rather have the dividend and pay taxes on it, a buyback just basically floats into outer space. Owner of some dividend paying stocks.

          • runarberg 2 hours ago

            Nahh, capitalism is fundamentally aristocratic, and thus will always trend towards oligarchy.

            You may argue that regulations, such as banning of stock buy backs, could hinder such a trend, perhaps so, but over time the more capital and power accumulates, the more the laws and regulations will stack in favor of the capitalist class, ergo oligarchy.

            • Danox 19 minutes ago

              Which was also one of the biggest reasons for deregulating the banking industry. Just an expansion of oligarchy.

        • woah 3 hours ago

          This is as invalid as arguing that the 50's were so good because segregation still existed.

          Using the 1950's as a justification for policies you support is disingenuous because the real reason the 1950's were so good is because the USA had just won the largest war in history without any damage to the homeland and had the only industrial base that wasn't bombed out and exported a huge amount of manufactured goods to the entire world.

          The policies you advocate would just privilege the existing holders of capital by making it impossible for anyone new to join their class. It would also lead to all manner of bizarre forms of perks, kickbacks, and other non-monetary forms of lifestyle benefits and power, sort of like you see in the ruling class in communist countries.

          • nullstyle 3 hours ago

            The interstate system did not get developed because the allies had just won WW2; It was built because the USA was in a cold war with the USSR. Your take on history is just as incomplete as GP's.

            • jordanb 2 hours ago

              It was actually built because Eisenhower had been on the US army's first attempt to cross the nation with a truck convoy when he was a junior officer.

              It was a bit of a disaster.[1]

              Then he saw the Autobahn in Germany.

              He also was Sir Arthur Tedder's superior at SHAEF when Tedder developed the strategy to destroy Germany's railroads.[2]

              It is not surprising that Eisenhower was committed to the creation of a national highway system.

              Then you have him the reins of the massive public works machine built by the new dealers, and the interstate highway system is practically the inevitable result.

              [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transcontinental_Motor_Convoy

              [2] https://uncpress.org/9780807858509/the-collapse-of-the-germa...

          • smallmancontrov 3 hours ago

            > the 1950's were so good is because the USA had just won the largest war in history without any damage to the homeland

            So why did the UK also see the emergence of a strong middle class which has since eroded?

            • loeg 2 hours ago

              The US gave the UK something like $8.8 billion in aid ($69B in 2019 dollars).

            • lazyasciiart 2 hours ago

              Largely the same reason, I would guess. Millions of homes damaged, some infrastructure and factories damaged, ~50k civilian casualties total, and a touch under a million total casualties. Industrial output was not destroyed and was quickly repurposed to civilian benefit as society adjusted, and women were able to fill the labor needs.

        • oklahomasports 3 hours ago

          You think .002% of people paying a 90% marginal rate explains the difference between our 2026 economy and the 1950 economy

          • loeg 2 hours ago

            And that the 1950 economy was in any way better! It's, uh, a take.

        • loeg 2 hours ago

          This is a basically false narrative.

          CEOs are allowed to do all of these things, but they do not necessarily maximize business returns, and therefore their own incentives. Nothing has changed here from 2020, 2015, or 2010 -- a period over which SWE compensation has skyrocketed. No reason to believe this gets worse with AI.

          The 50s and 60s marginal tax rate was (1) mostly paid by no one; rich people instead received business income not subject to personal income tax; and (2) other high rates on the middle+ class were only possible due to a sense of national togetherness forged by the world war. There's no reason to believe this time period was exceptionally good for the poor, working class, or middle class.

          It's easy to hate the rich and want to punish them for being rich, but it doesn't help the poor to do so.

          • tadfisher 2 hours ago

            "Punishing" the rich by making them pay higher taxes in order to fund programs that help the poor absolutely does help the poor. Some rich folks don't view this as a punishment, even.

            • smallmancontrov 2 hours ago

              Elon was bitching about paying $500M in taxes the other day on Twitter. He didn't mention that he's been stacking $200B a year and that he was complaining about paying 0.25% of that in taxes.

              0.25% is what today's billionaires consider "punishing." Absolutely wild. Many of us pay tax at more than 100x that rate.

              • jethro_tell 1 hour ago

                Or that he paid the same amount to try to avoid having to pay taxes.

                It’s not spending or even loosing the money, it’s helping other people that he hates.

          • ux266478 1 hour ago

            > mostly paid by no one

            Correct, because the mechanisms of capital were different and the system encouraged utilizing it for material investment and keeping labor happy, which is where that business income went.

            > other high rates on the middle+ class were only possible due to a sense of national togetherness forged by the world war

            What alternate timeline did you come from where the 1960s was not a time of major cultural rift in the US? Do you think the upper middle class was not a huge source of hippies?

            https://archive.org/details/CSPAN3_20180512_120000_Reel_Amer...

            > There's no reason to believe this time period was exceptionally good for the poor, working class, or middle class.

            What? Wealth and income inequality was at its lowest since the founding of the country. An effect which was established prior to the involvement of the US in the war, it began with FDR's new deal. And once they hit the floor in the early 1940s, the numbers were extremely steady and consistent until the financial system overhaul in 1975 at which point they shoot right back up again. There is no reason? Every single metric disagrees with that, except for racial inequalities. Enough with the neoliberal apologism, Gordon Gekko. The empowerment of financiers has been an absolute disaster.

    • boogieknite 3 hours ago

      > I've also seen non-technical folks in the corporate and government worlds glom onto vibe coding, only to start flailing like they were caught in a rip current when the underlying technical debt is too strong, even with strong and capable models.

      just happened on a client call yesterday. our work had been postponed because a new system was being introduced. our routine calls kept being cancelled and we started to worry. the customer finally showed up after a few months and told us the new system was demoed and "was clearly vibe coded. everything went wrong. they were asking claude questions during the demo" so were back in contract again

      > reliably deliver them better than 50% completion

      everyone has ideas. being able to program helped separate ideas from execution and i thought llms would remove that barrier but there seems to be some ingrained half-ass mentality in the self-proclaimed "idea guy"s ive met which prevent them from finishing things

    • lenkite 3 hours ago

      Its pretty clear that software services companies will need to pivot to offer "slop fix" services. We offer Great Deals to Maintain AI Generated Software! Clean up your Code! Delete your Technical Debt! Cheap Contracts!

    • andriy_koval 3 hours ago

      > There is no shortage of problems that can be solved

      there is shortage. You can just jump on problem you want to solve, because distribution channels are saturated/occupied.

    • willio58 3 hours ago

      > I've also seen non-technical folks in the corporate and government worlds glom onto vibe coding, only to start flailing like they were caught in a rip current when the underlying technical debt is too strong

      Anecdata I’ve seen this too a few times. Major issues where a significant number of engineers had to stop important product work to un-jankify something a non technical person created. In every case those product people felt the heat so bad they basically stopped.

    • tgreg0ry 3 hours ago

      I have been in software development for over 30 years and when people mention AI taking over jobs, I keep coming back to the demand problem. Where will the money come from to pay for anything if no one has a job?

      • Marczelloni 3 hours ago

        My conspiracy theory is they are doing everything in their power, teamed up with Trump admin to speedrun a recession by causing a labor shortage, perfect time for the rich to get richer and push us back to feudalism?

      • jacquesm 3 hours ago

        Easy: just get rid of the people. Start a war, maybe a famine or a pandemic (or two, if the first one doesn't do the job). After all, it's for the greater good... /s

        • ptidhomme 1 hour ago

          You can just remove the "/s". There's no escaping the fact that a majority of human lives will be considered worthless (or worse, a danger) to the billionaire establishment. And they don't have your well being at heart.

      • bigfatkitten 3 hours ago

        I think the risk of enormous segments of the population ending up on the street is overblown.

        Right now there are mass layoffs in the IT industry partially as a correction to the pandemic hiring spree, and also to redirect capital from salaries to AI initiatives.

        It is fashionable right now for tech CEOs to pretend that enormous amounts of work being done by humans is now being done by AI, but none of these are companies where the velocity at which code was written was ever the main bottleneck in getting products out the door. They’re mostly just lying to the market to pump their stock prices.

        The software field is overexposed because there are a lot of people earning hundreds of thousands of dollars a year to add fields to CRUD apps. These folks are in enormous danger, but when the dust settles the skilled professionals solving difficult problems will do just fine.

        • taybin 2 hours ago

          There is a middle ground between people adding one more damn field to an already existing built app and the people inventing new math to solve DSP or whatever. How much danger are the skilled professionals who know how to architect complicated workflows so that they can guarantee correctness and be easy to change? Not easy, not the most difficult thing either. Also the sort of skill where maybe the lack of it doesn't become apparent in the product until it's too late.

          I guess I kinda resent your implication that the "skilled professionals", the worthy, you know, us, will be fine. I think the real danger is for the people who care. And for the rest of us who rely on the people who care.

          • AeroNotix 2 hours ago

            It's also laughable that most people on HN are even in that bracket of people working on elite niche problems that AI can't trivially replace.

            Just look at the job offers and the responses they get on here. It's all trivial crap.

            • LtWorf 1 hour ago

              I mean… most job offers here are for startups… what did you expect?

      • wavefunction 3 hours ago

        It could be an ongoing project where say... the population who is not willing to grift their way to the top is subjected to ongoing environmental pressures which the people at the top are benefiting from directly financially, then offering or even demanding money for solutions to the problems they've caused. Meanwhile attrition has set in to the general population as their quality of life falls further and further and the people at the top use their position to vote themselves even more power, and the cycle propagates further. I feel like all I've done here is describe the past few decades in the US at least.

      • cmiles8 2 hours ago

        Well somewhat ironically the main job AI now makes mostly obsolete is SDEs. Impacts elsewhere are much less clear. So folks will have jobs, but most of the SDEs of the world will likely need to find new jobs.

    • fearthemachine 3 hours ago

      IMO a decent developer can pick up most other roles, especially non-people-manager roles (though some pick those up very fast, too) a hell of a lot faster and better than most people in other roles can pick up programming.

      Part of this, I think, is because the people who had the inclination and ability to pick up programing have, for decades, been nudged into programming from whatever job they had before, by comp, co-workers, managers, and opportunity availability, so they’re already heavily concentrated in programming even if they’re perfectly capable of doing other jobs (perhaps with some brief re-training).

      I think other roles need to fear programmers who studied a new role for a couple weekends more than programmers need to fear LLMs. If we’re bumped out of full-time programming… guess where we’re going, and what we’ll be way better at doing than them?

      [edit] part of that I wrote unclearly: the main thing about people being siphoned out of other roles into programming for the last 3ish decades is that most of the people with the combo of willingness and ability to get decent at programming… are programmers. It’ll tend to be harder to train other people to be good enough at using their computers to maximally benefit from LLMs (they already usually aren’t very good at using their non-LLM computer tools, it’s not like this is a new problem) than to shift programmers into other roles, if programming as a dedicated job in-fact is diminished in a durable way and at a mass scale.

      • decidu0us9034 2 hours ago

        Most firms are in a very risk-averse mood as far as hiring. They don't want to take on the liability associated with this sort of workforce development stuff, and don't want to train and onboard people they might not need in a few years. At least not in the current monetary environment (which isn't going anywhere any time soon)

      • mmcnl 1 hour ago

        I agree. The transition will be messy though.

    • LegitShady 3 hours ago

      An example to counterbalance this is art. Art had a market of people willing to pay for it - some private, some companies - art including graphic design etc.

      But the thing is that with AI the number of people willing to pay you to solve their art problem has dramatically fallen. The total number of jobs in art in general has plummeted. The opportunities to make a living or develop yourself with art have similarly plunged.

      So there will always be another problem but that doesn't mean there will always be someone willing to pay you to solve it if they can get by without you.

    • marsten 2 hours ago

      The arcane technical problems aspect of the job has always been changing; LLMs are just a continuation of the trend.

      I'm old enough to remember when compiled languages like C were bemoaned by people because their skill at crafting assembly by hand was suddenly less important. Or similarly with people who were brilliant with arithmetic, or symbolic manipulation, or manual drafting/lettering. These skills were all paramount at one time, and it's natural that the people who excelled at them will feel a sense of loss.

      The real goal, however, will always be to solve real-world problems. Engineering consists of whatever gets you there most effectively.

      • fomoz 2 hours ago

        I love this comment.

        SWEs who oppose AI seem to forget that they are paid to solve problems, not write code.

        • Peaches4Rent 2 hours ago

          I'm an swe who opposes AI. I don't think we should be spending so much non-renewable sources of energy on AI. These energy sources are taking from our future.

          • preg_match 1 hour ago

            The energy used by AI is, frankly, negligible. The water too. It’s a rounding error as compared to agriculture and manufacturing. The water use of all AI data centers combined doesn’t even reach the change in water usage over the past year for agriculture. Never mind the base usage, which is orders of magnitude greater.

            Moreover, big picture, software is getting built anyway. It’s not like if you don’t use AI then that energy use is gone. You need devs no matter what.

          • AgentME 1 hour ago

            A developer's energy use from AI is generally tiny compared to their energy use from driving or eating meat.

            • vips7L 51 minutes ago

              What aboutism. You should stop eating meat too.

              • AgentME 44 minutes ago

                I've skipped a few burgers this year. That will have made a bigger difference in my energy footprint than me using AI or not.

            • bobsomers 35 minutes ago

              An individual's use is low, but when everyone's use is concentrated in a few communities it absolutely destroys those communities for the people that live there.

        • debugnik 1 hour ago

          Many SWEs will not be paid to solve problems anymore due to AI. The ones that remain might be better equipped for the task, although I don't expect interests to align on doing a better job instead of a cheaper one.

        • threetonesun 1 hour ago

          SWEs also often forget that most of the software they create was designed to take jobs away from other people in other departments.

          • cheesewhistle 1 hour ago

            The frame often is positioned to include yourself and your own interests at the center of it.

          • pydry 1 hour ago

            When a pawn on a chessboard takes a piece is do you blame the pawn or the chess player?

            Software devs were guilty of wanting one of the few middle class jobs left. Nobody enters the profession cackling evilly about how many jobs they will take.

        • pesus 1 hour ago

          We certainly solved the problem of companies having to hire as many of us or pay us as well.

        • denkmoon 1 hour ago

          I’m paid to be a meat proxy because our problems are trivial. The only thing i offer is writing the prompts that say “implement this” and “you overcomplicated x, make it simpler” occasionally including the way I want it fixed. Important steps in the process and skill and experience still help not pushing slop but I’m not really “solving problems” anymore.

        • pydry 1 hour ago

          If only. AI pilled SWEs seem to have not noticed that the only problem "building agents nobody needs" is solving is how to satisfy an investor with FOMO.

          I never thought I'd miss the days when executives used to rabbit on about customer obsession but the new fashion of AI psychosis is worse in just about every way.

        • bootwoot 55 minutes ago

          I actually think a wide majority of SWEs, pre-AI, were in fact primarily paid to write code.

          Most people don't do this for the love of the game.

          Large corporations needed java code as a means to an end and an army of workers needed a paycheck. That dynamic is coming to an end.

        • croes 23 minutes ago

          SWEs where paid to solve problems by writing code.

          Solving problems is not distinctive characteristic of a software engineer, doing it by writing code was.

        • kelnos 14 minutes ago

          There's room for nuance there. I am well aware that the goal is to solve problems, but I actively enjoy the process of designing a program and writing the code.

          Sure, maybe I can more effectively and efficiently solve problems by driving an LLM instead, but that's not a job I enjoy, or even care to do professionally.

      • complex_pi 1 hour ago

        AI does not help stopping wars, ending poverty, solving climate wars.

      • gdorsi 16 minutes ago

        > The real goal, however, will always be to solve real-world problems. Engineering consists of whatever gets you there most effectively.

        Love this statement, 100% agree.

    • sanderjd 1 hour ago

      Yeah, it seems to me that nobody is better positioned to use these tools effectively than people who have already been building software "by hand". I still have some concern that we might hit a point where there is no human in the loop at all. But I don't feel very threatened by non-technical people vibe coding me out of a job.

      • wolfinterval 32 minutes ago

        I don't know. The FM-1 music synth has just up ended the music hardware synth market in the last month because of vibe coding.

        This very specialized audio DSP programming that was in short supply is now something almost anyone can do.

        You need the synth domain knowledge but the software programming is solved for all intensive purposes.

        The DSP programmer of course will be the best firmware vibe coder but they surely were better off when they had this rare skill vs everyone now having that skill.

    • righthand 1 hour ago

      You have not had to seek a new job in this market. I’ve had 2 interviews in 4 months. Where is my LLM optimism for niche problems that will save me?

      • mmcnl 1 hour ago

        The transition will be incredibly messy.

    • ummonk 1 hour ago

      Yeah I don't think the gravy train is gone for software engineers; it's just starting.

      I feel very negatively about the rise of AI for many reasons, but personal economic prospects is not one of those reasons.

  • flowerlad 4 hours ago

    The market for software hasn't disappeared. The way we build software has changed. AI can write code. But someone still needs to talk to customers, gather requirements, write specifications, generate code, build, test, debug, deploy, secure, market, sell, support, monitor, be on-call, handle incidents, track bugs and so on.

    The business of software still exists and it needs to people to run it. It will require fewer people than before, and as a result cost of software will come down. There will be increased competition, and big SaaS companies will face fresh competition from upstarts. As a result there will be pressure to innovate.

    AI can't innovate. This is one of the key limitations of AI. Not all humans can either. But those who can will be in increased demand.

    As software becomes cheaper, the total consumption of software increases (See Jevons paradox.) Cheaper development makes smaller markets viable. There will be software available to meet needs that are unmet today because the market is too small. This will increase the number of software jobs. It won't all be coding jobs, it will be jobs that run the software business (see first paragraph).

    • 0c3ca83 3 hours ago

      The bet that Anthropic is placing is that AI will also solve everything you listed. You can bet against them if you want.

      And, what do you mean by "AI can't innovate"? I suspect that for any definition you pick, either most humans also can't innovate, or examples of AI innovation can be found. And this is only going to get better.

      • flowerlad 2 hours ago

        > what do you mean by "AI can't innovate"?

        See Chris Lattner's observations about compiler written by Claude: https://www.modular.com/blog/the-claude-c-compiler-what-it-r...

        • 0c3ca83 2 hours ago

          Yes, you ask it to replicate a well known problem, and it does it. If I asked you to implement a textbook optimizing C compiler, where would you innovate?

          If you're going to discuss this, start with a definition of innovating.

          • flowerlad 2 hours ago

            Chris answers this question already. He says a human would have found opportunities to innovate. I think Chris is rignt.

            • 0c3ca83 2 hours ago

              Go ahead, tell me why the last 100th crud application you used was innovative. Most code I write isn't innovative, so pointing to one program I wrote and saying "look, humans can't innovate" is a weak argument.

              • flowerlad 1 hour ago

                > Most code I write isn't innovative

                You should stop coding then. Just use Claude.

                • 0c3ca83 1 hour ago

                  Again, why do you think that because someone once wrote code that wasn't innovative, innovation is impossible?

  • bluegatty 4 hours ago

    AI is not even close to replacing SWEs.

    AI can write syntactically perfect code but barely has a sense of architecture.

    It needs tons of 'guide wires' to keep it from going off track.

    Unless you're building basic SaaS, it's still a 'research and coding assistant'.

    AI has never produced non-messy architecture that I did not have to go in, re-think and guide a re-write.

    • IronWolve 4 hours ago

      This is spot on, AI can code, but it doesnt have the experience in the real world, so many things are designed differently from spec.

      SWE's have to guide the AI, look at all those AI PR's, many of them make very bad assumptions.

    • taurath 3 hours ago

      The hype is so far outside of what it can actually do in many businesses. People running around saying AI has "solved" coding but code has never been the difficult part of the job, and AI hasn't solved the bringing together of context, intention, history, and various people's understanding. You can go far in tightly controlled situations, but it can also accelerate your technical debt until you become utterly dependent on tradeoffs that AI made for you. Eventually you can't do anything safely.

      So many executives have turned all the safeties off and given over control of their business to a probabilistic system and ignored every engineer who said its dangerous and risky. The engineers will be the ones held accountable though, because since AI is "so effective" it must be operator error

    • elxr 3 hours ago

      > AI can write syntactically perfect code but barely has a sense of architecture.

      Second point should be obvious to anyone actually building something even slightly new/complex.

      • bluegatty 1 hour ago

        Oddly few people writing 'slightly new/complex' stuff as I am learning.

    • throw-the-towel 3 hours ago

      You're technically correct which is the best kind of correct -- but is your experience with these matters still as valuable as it used to be? How are you going to prove to management that it is? And who's to say that eventually AI won't be able to brute force its way into maintaining its slop? (Of course we can't be sure it will either, but you get my point.)

      • bluegatty 2 hours ago

        1) I think Execs and managers will catch up

        2) I think u might be right about brute force - but probably some methods/tools will come along first - and I don't think they will solve the problem though.

        I think SWE is actually very safe.

        We're going to need fewer 'JS coders' and technically we could 'save' a few SWE jobs - but - given the $ being made, businesses will want to expand, and so 'Jevon's Paradox' and I think SWEs will have jobs and probably even the JS jocks as well.

    • markus_zhang 2 hours ago

      Counter point: you don’t need architecture big things everyday, at least I don’t and everyone in my role (data engineering) knows that we don’t do that often.

      Ofc unless you call some data modelling “architect” but I’m sure AI is fine for that. Guess how I know.

    • enraged_camel 1 hour ago

      >> AI can write syntactically perfect code but barely has a sense of architecture.

      This does not match my experience. At work I have AI write architecture docs for complex features based on requirements that the product team collects. When staff engineers review those docs, in the overwhelming majority of cases the only issues they can find can be characterized as nits or bike-shedding. In contrast, AI can find problems and even serious gaps in architectures designed by the most seasoned engineers on the team (because those engineers have been doing their best to resist using AI).

      So I think the whole "AI can write good code but it cannot design architecture" is just cope. It's where the goal posts have been moved to after it became impossible to deny that AI can actually write good code. Next up it will be "AI can write good code and design good architecture, but it has no taste". Indeed we're seeing various of that already.

  • blauditore 4 hours ago

    The need for engineering will not go away. The job will change, yes. But if non-technical folks can stitch something together with LLMs, technical folks can still do it better, quicker, and more reliably. Maybe the job boundaries will become more fuzzy, in both directions, but I just don't see a company running software without having techies in the long run.

  • perarneng 4 hours ago

    Its all white collar work its just that software development was low hanging fruits thanks to the extreme amount of training data, its basically text, its also friendly for an llm because the compiler acts as a corrector if something is wrong. so its ok if its not entirely right. Since SWE is dying all SWE companies are panicking and trying to sell AI enabled software that will automate all other jobs. There is an extreme demand for that because all businesses want to dump employees to get higher profit margins. So you are not alone. within a couple of years there will be a total economic collapse. Unless something drastically is done https://www.ethicalacceleration.org/

  • sdeframond 4 hours ago

    I believe there is a massive rebound effect. The demand has always been greater than capacity about software. Excess demand is still there.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rebound_effect_(conservation)

    • ludamad 3 hours ago

      I think this is generally true, but what has been hard is that we keep having disruptive technology released monthly. It's hard to really feel it's possible to plan a steady state of software engineering under such a climate

  • CyLith 4 hours ago

    I don't know, I feel like I have more job security now (as far as performance related aspects go; faith in my employer, not so much) than ever before. My job is to encode into software simulation techniques from several disciplines, and whereas previously, if I was not already an expert in one area, I simply couldn't fulfill the ask. Now, I can, since I know the "shape" of what I expect the solution to look like (to borrow Claude's terminology), I can actually complete all the projects asked of me.

  • paxy 3 hours ago

    If it was over then Anthropic and OpenAI and the rest of big tech wouldn't be hiring thousands of SWEs each at $500K+.

  • MetaverseClub 3 hours ago

    If it can be a massive moment in human history, it doesn't need to wait until IPO to be. IPO means nothing in human history. SWE is a gravy train or not also means nothing in human history. Judging by this self/SWE-centric thinking, you live in Silicon Valley and truly belong there.

  • debarshri 3 hours ago

    I see agents as horsepower. You still need engineers to drive it. And drive it in right direction.

    I'm not scared for the future of software engineers and computer scientists.

  • christkv 3 hours ago

    I don't know it's possible the industry shrinks down to pre 2005 levels of staffing since all the layers of jobs that got created over the last 20 years become less important and disappear.

  • throwrioawfo 3 hours ago

    The IPO seems like a fairly arbitrary moment to me.

    I can think of several bigger moments in the last few months alone

  • agumonkey 3 hours ago

    What's your horizon before having to change craft ?

    My worst fear is that I will have to do an absurd job where my brain rots under people with less skills and ethics but better at playing the new game.

  • kalcode 3 hours ago

    SWE do engineering. Programmers and individual contributors within the discipline will have the hardest time. Anyone with 10+ years probably find, 15/20+ years likely pretty set.

    It's the boot camp/degree/whatever to get the paycheck but never enjoyed the problem solving or learning aspects...

  • c-hendricks 3 hours ago

    IMO the gravy train for software development was so bizarre to me.

    Coming from the service industry, yeah there's some long stressful days doing software development but those barely held a candle to average weekends / holidays working at restaurants and cafes.

    Then the whole boot camp thing happened, where it's like sure, I guess since you spent 4 weeks learning just React you're worth as much as someone whose been doing it for a decade? I figured that would have been the end of inflated software developer salaries.

    Now we're here.

  • ludicrousdispla 3 hours ago

    I regularly use two applications that I know are built by developers using Claude, and there are consistent bugs in the user interface. Really stupid simple stuff that an experienced dev would know to check for and fix.

    • chasd00 1 hour ago

      then file a bug report and it will get addressed. Bugs aren't anything new.

  • ratelimitsteve 3 hours ago

    I'm getting more offers for senior positions than i was before the big rollout. i wouldn't try to start a career in software now but i'm having a pretty easy time transitioning to piloting these things as a senior and just like every other revolution that was supposed to put me out on my ear this is just turning into me getting more done more quickly but the work is still there.

  • bigstrat2003 3 hours ago

    > as a SWE the gravy train is basically over in my view. they figured out how to make a program that does the job.

    They certainly did not. LLMs are way worse than a competent human programmer.

  • p1necone 3 hours ago

    As a professional engineer in a large-ish company, I'm less pessimistic. All the people who were good-excellent engineers pre-ai are producing quality work, and more of it. And all the people who were poor-average engineers pre-ai are still producing poor-average work, and often not even more of it.

    On top of that, we're not hiring less people, we're just building (slightly, the speedup isn't consistent across all parts of the workflow) more products

    There's obviously still a requirement that people have a lot of skill and knowledge to produce good software, and I'm not sure that's going to go away.

  • marlow_congdon 3 hours ago

    As a founder, I'd take the other side of this bet. I'm already seeing businesses launch that wouldn't have if these tools didn't exist because it was too expensive to hire an engineer for the MVP. For the ones that end up achieving product market fit, the founders then hire engineers to manage and grow the product going forward, which is net new demand for engineers. For my business, we've expanded our product roadmap significantly because we can now build things that we didn't have the resources to support before. If any of those new product areas work out, and early signs are promising that they will, we'll need to hire engineers to manage them. Said another way, we expect to increase our budget for the engineering team because of what these tools enable. They've effectively made engineers more valuable employees than they were before, which means we can either afford to pay more per engineer, or hire more of them (likely a combination of the two).

    • criddell 2 hours ago

      > I'm already seeing businesses launch that wouldn't have

      The tricky part is you have to price your offering well below what your potential customers think it will cost to vibe code an equivalent.

      • marlow_congdon 1 hour ago

        That assumes your customers want to build an equivalent product for themselves and also that they can justify the internal cost to support it. If your product has a large enough market and is sufficiently complex, you should be able to deliver it more efficiently than any one customer can for themselves because you're spreading the development and maintenance cost across your customer base. I'm more concerned about price pressure for potential competitors who can build new businesses as easily and quickly as I can, but that dynamic is always true in a free market.

  • elxr 3 hours ago

    > difficult to grasp how much life will change in the coming years.

    More prosperity than you've ever had.

    • afavour 3 hours ago

      They said the same about the internet. And computers. During my lifetime I've mostly seen wealth concentration at the top and I suspect AI is going to enable more of the same.

      • elxr 3 hours ago

        > During my lifetime I've mostly seen wealth concentration at the top

        I grew up in a third world country, so I can say first-hand that the internet has helped the average person around here gain opportunity and open doors to the possibility of prosperity.

    • billti 2 hours ago

      To do what, exactly? People throw around the word "abundance", but what does that look like?

      A dystopian vision that keeps popping into my head is from the movie WALL-E, where the robots are running everything and the humans are overweight blobs gliding around on recliners with entertainment pumped into their eyeballs and endless soda refills. Is that what a world of "abundance" but no meaningful work, looks like?

  • trentnix 3 hours ago

    Some engineers feel like they are being replaced by AI. I feel like I’m piloting a Gundam when I use AI.

    YMMV I guess.

  • VikingCoder 3 hours ago

    I wonder if this is how Lee Sedol felt.

  • otabdeveloper4 3 hours ago

    When the bubble pops it will probably take down the US stock market and the US dollar with it, but that's only a blip in the grand scheme of human history.

    Don't oversell it.

  • globalise83 3 hours ago

    Where I live we now have the Waymo cars driving around all times of day and night mapping the local roads and traffic. There are literally tens of thousands of recent immigrants in the same city who rely on taxi driving as their only marketable skill in a rather xenophobic and old-school employment market. They are going to be very angry indeed in a few months when self-driving taxis take their jobs. There's no doubt AI is going to have the most profound impacts in almost realtime in places where it hasn't even made an appearance yet.

  • Karupan 3 hours ago

    Is the Silicon Valley tech bubble so deluded? It’s an IPO of a stock, not first contact with aliens.

  • keybored 3 hours ago

    The Gravy Train narrative is curious. The highly-paid programmers in the US earned their companies a lot of money. Was it a gravy train for them or for their companies? Judging by the ratio of maybe earning 1 Million for a one 100K cost-of-employing programmer that is just floating around in my brain, I’d say the companies. There was also the no-hire collusion among big companies.

    The programmers were/are simply capable and in relative short supply. Even with that they earned the companies massive profits. (I have completely different issues with my high-IQ nerd peers... more what they were working on.)

    Now the parasite companies can simply harvest all of that value for nothing. Big Tech is moving from a gravy train to a free ride.

    Defintely a very Capital Guy perspective top comment.

  • dominotw 2 hours ago

    I cant tell if i should double down and build hard skills in software or just wait on the sidelines and see what happens

  • markus_zhang 2 hours ago

    Yeah. Even if SWEs are the only impacted roles, which they are not, and if only half of us are gone because they still need the other half to hold the hand, that’s still over a million gone in a relatively short period of time just for the US.

    Not sure what’s going to happen but it’s not pretty. I have been pushing my wife to sell our house and downsize but she doesn’t agree. I was telling her that once that happens no one is going to buy our house even at a 50% discount.

  • mihaaly 2 hours ago

    Being a goat herder sounds peaceful. Goats funny. Food for life.

  • pixelatedindex 2 hours ago

    > Genuinely a massive moment in human history

    Massively sad moment, a few handful of already well to do individuals got even richer, allowing business to cut wages. Sure it’ll create new jobs / industries but the short term impact is not something I look forward to.

  • hintymad 2 hours ago

    > they figured out how to make a program that does the job.

    In a way it reflects how repetitive our industry is. We train a model based on the github projects and much smaller expert data, yet the model is sufficient to solve many of our current prolbems.

  • iLoveOncall 2 hours ago

    Every single time I use AI (which is every day), regardless of the model or harness (which is pretty much always Opus 5.5 or Fable 6.2, with Kiro or Claude Code), the LLMs do complete and utter rubbish to the point where they would be genuinely harmful if left to run write commands unsupervised.

    Just today Opus 5.5 tried to send a Slack message to one of my teammate when it had to edit a code file. When asked why, it said it just "picked the wrong tool".

    LLMs are borderline useless, AI has led to 0 increase in actual value produced. It's all powder in front of our eyes.

    I genuinely cannot take anyone seriously when they say they're afraid of being replaced by AI. The only explication possible (unless they're astroturfing), is that they literally never look at what LLMs produce and always run in "Trust all tools" mode without ever looking.

  • ookblah 2 hours ago

    work will scale but there will be no free lunch anymore.

  • bytemut 2 hours ago

    If SWE is over let's follow the chain of thought. A company has no SWE in it. Who is shipping and maintaining the software?

    2 options:

    A) A real person with a job title that's not SWE. Will it be managers / product managers / business owners / something else? Whatever the job title, those people need SWE skills and experience to manage the agents. It is a very high ask for non-SWE job title to absorb both the skill and time commitment to drive AI-first software work.

    B) AI Agent. But how does the AI Agent get setup with what it needs to run in a loop, who investigates and steers the agent course when it deliver something that doesn't work? It will needs someone SWE skills/experience.

    In either case sounds like you need someone with SWE skillset in your company... so not sure why the job would go away.

  • agentultra 2 hours ago

    It doesn’t do the job. It’s a program. Humans do jobs. Humans will continue to do jobs.

    What Anthropic has excelled at isn’t engineering. It’s convincing your boss that you can be replaced with a Claude Code subscription. Just look at the leaked Claude Code source. Or read their “engineering,” blog. It’s all marketing glitz.

    The reason for all this marketing is because they rent their compute and they need every software developer to need them. They need us to depend on them to do our jobs. Because this isn’t a profitable venture. It’s resting on a house of cards.

    Anthropic has to deal with the very real possibility that their providers go under. And that other harnesses on alternative models get better, cheaper, etc. People seem to be pretty price sensitive after the token-maxing rush didn’t work out.

    I think there are still plenty of reasons to believe that our profession isn’t going anywhere. Changed, sure. It always changes. But it’s not over and it’s not, “solved.”

  • ctmlr 2 hours ago

    Honestly... thank god. Software development was really starting to become over-saturated with code academy kids and it felt like there was less gravy to go around.

    Not everyone gets to work on the most interesting engineering problems, I think most of us felt more like glorified digital plumbers. The money was too good to pass up that CRUD work but I can't say it was very fulfilling, I'm glad a machine can do that drudgery for me now.

  • ux266478 2 hours ago

    It's not going to change much at all, unless you're one of the unlucky few who get caught in the downsizing. Your job is now to wrangle LLMs. Why the hell would anybody want to deal with a bunch of annoying, unreliable agents if you could pay someone else to do it for you?

  • reddozen 2 hours ago

    > as a SWE the gravy train is basically over in my view.

    If you feel this way this speaks volumes towards the value your work provides.

  • mmcnl 1 hour ago

    I'm not sure. I don't see non-technical people use AI to do the engineering. I'm pretty sure AI will upend everything, but when the cost of software approaches 0, everything becomes software. If you care about the real-world problem you're solving and not only about the technical solution, then you will hold all the cards. The problem is the transition will be very messy.

  • IAmGraydon 1 hour ago

    SWEs who just program what others tell them to program are likely screwed. SWEs who have good ideas of their own and an entrepreneurial spirit may be in a better position than before.

  • gorgoiler 1 hour ago

    For me it just forced the pivot that was always there from senior to staff: you no longer solve problems, you find them.

    That’s in the corporate world. Privately, the big sadness is that one can no longer be a solo dev without either renting inference or laying down serious capital to run it yourself. The era of John Carmacks sitting in front of a $10k rigs, simply to be able to do their job, has swung back into fashion.

  • ubermonkey 1 hour ago

    It's a massive thing, for sure, but given that Anthropic has no plans for profitability it's just one more exhalation into the bubble.

  • barbariangrunge 1 hour ago

    ...what manner of enshitification will investors demand in order to preserve their share prices in the future? Long term i mean

  • rootusrootus 32 minutes ago

    This may just be cope, but I still see this playing out as a strong negative for the low-end developers and a neutral or positive for seniors.

    So much of what I do every day are non-coding jobs that aren't actually that easy to do with AI (of course that's not technically true but as a practical matter corporate America is probably not going to change all that fast, we've had lots of automation abilities for years that they still don't embrace with any great amount of success).

    But what about the team of Genpact developers I have in Hyderbad & Bengalaru? They're coders, and I know already that I can take what I give them and run it through Claude Code myself and get results 100x faster, with better quality to boot. With less of my time needed to review & provide feedback. These guys, love 'em, but they're fucked. I've been trying to help them level up, but they're mostly freshers and it is a steep climb.

    Luckily our senior management is still slow-walking our foray into LLM coding, but I know my manager already sees the writing on the wall (though he's more worried about his own job than ours).

  • LastTrain 7 minutes ago

    If there comes a point when an LLM makes the SWE profession redundant the blast radius is going to be much bigger than that, so you won't be alone. For now, there is still plenty of work to do and for certain job categories I would say there is actually more work at the moment.

cmiles8 3 hours ago

It’s been dropping ever since the first trade and appears to be down at $1.26T now. The fact that just a few weeks ago folks wanted $2T plus tells you how far off the original valuations really were.

And with this now below where OpenAI has been trying to value itself on the private markets that doesn’t bode well for OpenAI. If I was at OpenAI I’d be very worried about the picture today paints.

  • kamranjon 3 hours ago

    As someone who is not very well versed in this area - is there a requirement for OpenAI to IPO? Could they just go on as a private company and be fine or is there some sort of forcing function at play?

    • triceratops 3 hours ago

      I think if Anthropic's valuation holds up in the public market, OpenAI could remain private. If ANT starts dropping then OAI insiders will feel like they need to cash out quickly.

      • nopurpose 3 hours ago

        Wasn't OpenAI a non-profit (hence the name)? How do they get to do an IPO?

        • pamcake 3 hours ago

          All smoke and mirrors.

          Plenty was written on their "transition" in the past.

        • jubilanti 2 hours ago

          "public benefit corporation" which means practically nothing

          • tasuki 2 hours ago

            Probably the third word of that description is correct.

        • alm4x 2 hours ago

          They had a somewhat complicated structure where a non-profit with lofty goals was nominally in control of the for-profit entity and had the ability to kill it if that seemed to be the in best interest of humanity.

          Long story short, the board briefly fired the CEO Sam Altman because they were starting to eye that kill-switch and they didn't have confidence that his leadership aligned with the the non-profit's mission.

          Then a few days later OpenAI and its employees decided that, no, actually they like the money that Altman seems to bring in and they hired him back. If one were being charitable maybe there's an argument that the money is important to implement the ideals, or, maybe now that there's a competitive LLM marketplace, bowing out wouldn't accomplish anything. Regardless, now it's just a bog standard Valley company which is partially why they can IPO. Maybe not in a strictly legal sense (it's a PBC now, which the FAANGs are not), but functionally. So it goes, so it goes.

          I could be distorting some things. I'm only passingly familiar with the details of the matter. Feel free to correct me if this seems substantially inaccurate. Cunningham's Law and all that. ;-)

          • inanutshellus 1 hour ago

            The only article about it I read at the time claimed Sam's ousting was part of a takeover attempt by Microsoft, and Sam coming back was somehow MSFT being thwarted.

            Perhaps both your rendition and the MSFT thing are sympatico but it's confusing to me at the moment.

            Having two wrong answers surely will kick Cunningham's Law into overdrive here... one can hope, anyway.

            • bun_at_work 1 hour ago

              During the window when Sam was ousted, Satya offered to hire him and any OpenAI employees he wanted to come work at Microsoft - it wasn't really a takeover attempt, at least not publicly.

        • _ink_ 1 hour ago

          I asked the Google AI about it, essentially I was interested why FAANG didn't scoop up the AI labs when they were small, an the AI said this was the reason why OpenAI was started non profit and Anthropic went PBC. As long as they were non profit they could not be overtaken. Not sure if that's actually true, but I interesting theory.

        • MisterMunchkin 40 minutes ago

          They managed to trick a judge into breaking open the charity and making it a for profit company.

          Like imagine if the dogs trust just got a judge to let the management turn it private. Think of how much money they could steal.

    • xienze 3 hours ago

      > is there a requirement for OpenAI to IPO?

      Strictly speaking? No. But the people who shoveled money into it want an offramp, and that's what the IPO is. So for all intents and purposes, yes they need to IPO.

      • cmiles8 3 hours ago

        Correct they can stay private, but the private markets are drying up. They’ve been struggling with their last raise and they need more cash badly. So at some point going public may be the only way to get the cash they need to pay the bills coming due.

    • otabdeveloper4 3 hours ago

      > ...or is there some sort of forcing function at play?

      Yes. They need to find a bagholder before the bubble pops.

    • kshacker 1 hour ago

      Investors would want returns.

      Employees would want to cash out.

      If there is no exit in horizon, employees look for better ventures, and new funding may be hard to come. New funding (debt or equity) will be needed if cash flow is negative.

      • cromka 23 minutes ago

        > Investors would want returns.

        > Employees would want to cash out.

        Oh where are the times when you invested because you expected dividends and employees were being paid out for performance in yearly bonuses...

    • ubermonkey 1 hour ago

      Sure, if they were making money.

      They aren't. They depend on investment infusions to continue to function because they don't have a product that they can sell profitably.

      Normally, this is seen as an impediment to gaining future investment. Rational people still think that way.

      • signatoremo 9 minutes ago

        You need to invest money to make money. That’s always been true for any business. The question is for how much, in how long, and what the return would be. For something without precedence such as AI nobody knows the answer. You are either right or wrong. There is no rationality in this case.

    • geraneum 54 minutes ago

      > Could they just go on as a private company

      No? What comes after a pump is why

      /s

  • dodger-dog 3 hours ago

    It’s the single largest IPO failure narrative in history.

  • seizethecheese 3 hours ago

    I'm confused why it seems to matter a lot between $1.25T or $1.5T. These are incremental differences compared to the “T” in those numbers.

    • cmiles8 3 hours ago

      Because at these lower valuations it strongly suggests the door for the likes of OpenAI has closed just as they are in increasing need of cash.

      Remember recent headlines that OpenAI was struggling to raise cash at valuations above where ANT is now trading.

      Net here it’s is a good day for those looking to cash out of ANT and a very worrying signal for others elsewhere that were hoping to cash out too. Cudios to Anthropic for recognizing that there was likely only room for one foundation lab going public and they got there first.

      • seizethecheese 3 hours ago

        Okay I get it. I looked it up and OpenAI last round was $1.25T so indeed this is meaningful.

        • cmiles8 3 hours ago

          Yes. There’s lots of debate about the actual market cap of ANT right now for… reasons, but the official cap per accepted measure is 1.25T or so. With OpenAI almost certainly worth much less this is another highly irrational market behavior that will need correction sooner rather than later.

          • adastra22 1 hour ago

            Why would OAI be worth less?

            • cmiles8 1 hour ago

              On near every objective measure of performance and business health their numbers look worse.

              • adastra22 1 hour ago

                These valuations only make sense if you assume large future growth. OAI has vastly better mindshare outside of HN.

                • rlt 5 minutes ago

                  For consumers, yes, but consumers aren’t where these companies will make most of their money.

            • seizethecheese 1 hour ago

              They’re lagging in enterprise where the margins are and winning in consumer chatbots where there’s poor margin.

  • eqmvii 2 hours ago

    It's a down day in the markets generally. Volatility isn't surprising, even given the scale.

  • stock_toaster 2 hours ago

    So, already quite a few bag-holders?

    Might be the last hurrah for tech IPOs for a while.

    • cmiles8 1 hour ago

      I think today will be the “jump the shark” moment for the AI bubble. Anthropic will go down in history as managing to get to the exits just as the doors were closing, and for everyone else that’s still private from this point forward it’s good luck and Godspeed.

  • bagacrap 1 hour ago

    because of obscure details of how this particular IPO works, $83 ~= 1.4T, so now having closed at $97, it should be worth 1.75T. Yahoo finance et al do not have the correct number of shares.

    • cmiles8 1 hour ago

      That’s including many to-be-created shares for employees when options open up. So technically Yahoo etc is correct. The higher “valuations” assume the market won’t discount that valuation when that future shareholder dilution occurs.

      The higher valuations are a bit of funny AI bubble math as most companies have future theoretical shares outstanding and nobody includes those in the present market cap number.

christophilus 4 hours ago

Currently on Yahoo Finance: "Anthropic’s first half hour is the worst start for a big IPO since 2008"

Makes sense to me. This valuation is pretty insane. I don't see it holding up.

  • Invictus0 4 hours ago

    Over 15 billion shares will be released from lockup over the next year

    • unglaublich 3 hours ago

      That on one hand, and on the other hand, the index-funds will be forced to pick those up.

      • kshacker 3 hours ago

        Only if they are top 40 or so right? (I guess that's for fast entry). Pull them down enough and you get rid of the concern :)

      • bigmadshoe 3 hours ago

        For the S&P500 (and thus VOO), companies have to be profitable and on the market for at least a year.

        • piker 2 hours ago

          unless they change the rules...

      • christophilus 3 hours ago

        Yeah. Makes me want to move more of my portfolio to SCHD or something.

    • seizethecheese 3 hours ago

      I looked up how many shares they sold today, it’s about a billion, so this is significant, though a lot of these shareholders may not sell.

  • setnone 3 hours ago

    > Daniela Amodei, meanwhile, addressed concerns about AI growth, saying, "To anyone watching who is uneasy about AI or unsure what it will mean for you. This technology needs you. Not your trust, not your use, but your voice."

    dario and daniela needs my voice, sam needs my eyeballs, oh boy

    • abixb 3 hours ago

      No wonder voice models and speech-to-text models have gotten exponentially better.

      Daniela is right on the money.

    • Waterluvian 3 hours ago

      Will they crack my spine and train on the goo inside or will they be non destructive?

    • wahnfrieden 3 hours ago

      She also needed Epstein’s money

      • swingboy 2 hours ago

        It's a tribe, man.

    • m4rtink 43 minutes ago

      No voice, no scream, no problem! While this has been tried before, also taking the eyes is indeed inovative !

  • mathisfun123 3 hours ago

    i swear i haven't seen a non-disingenuous comment on hn in years; you're quoting a single person's opinion in their weird live feed view:

    > Today at 10:07 AM PST

    > Jared Blikre

    > Anthropic's first half hour is the worst start for a big IPO since 2008

    you might as well be quoting a tweet.

    https://finance.yahoo.com/markets/live/stock-market-today-th...

    not to mention the observation makes very little sense - the ipo was 83 so who cares that it opened at 110 before the bid-asks were narrowed.

  • paxy 3 hours ago

    Perfect example of how much you can twist facts to drive a certain narrative.

    - Big IPO - completely arbitrary

    - First half hour - completely arbitrary

    - The fact that it went up 34% at open before dropping - let's ignore that and only count the dip

    • novaRom 3 hours ago

      > it went up 34% at open

      on a tiny nano volume, if I understand correctly that's mostly technical preparation to release it to public

    • afavour 3 hours ago

      Yours is an example of the very same. TBH the stock moves on opening day are all quite arbitrary. A lot of motivated players looking for the right outcome, fundamentals be damned. Let's see where it settles.

      • paxy 3 hours ago

        > Yours is an example of the very same

        What does this mean?

        • alala-lala-lon 2 hours ago

          Are you stupid??

          Your comment is also a "perfect example of how much you can twist facts to drive a certain narrative"

          • paxy 2 hours ago

            What narrative is my comment driving?

    • dofm 1 hour ago

      The initial behaviour of the stock like that is very much a function of the IPO price, which is selected in advance by the company and the underwriter precisely so the stock is likely to be oversubscribed at the IPO price and will therefore open at a considerably higher trading price and then go up.

      That’s a lot easier to do when you’re making less than 10% of the shares available to sell, like this, but it is clearly the normal, fundamental function of the underwriter to create the circumstances for this to happen.

      This IPO was designed safely, to go well, and it didn’t really go as well as it could have.

      I am a novice at all of this but it really looks like they set the IPO price too high, because there was no room for it to grow beyond the opening trading price. The graph suggests that the buyers whose orders set the initial price represented the majority of the demand for it and were buying for more strategic, less price-sensitive reasons. Subsequent buyers after the bell are far less confident about the value of the stock.

      • shawabawa3 1 hour ago

        From the company's point of view the "best" IPO outcome would be for it to open negative, i.e. the IPO price to be the peak, otherwise they're leaving money on the table. Any trading after the IPO goes to investors not the company

        • dofm 1 hour ago

          I guess, in the same sense that you want to win a vote in the House of Representatives by the smallest margin (because if it was larger you could have compromised less)

          But is it not the case that the underwriter is looking for more than that — this is the first stock of its kind and they need the market to show strong signs of confidence?

          Not least because this was a tiny slice of the company up for sale.

      • paxy 1 hour ago

        > This IPO was designed safely, to go well, and it didn’t really go as well as it could have.

        Based on what?

        It went up 17% on the first day, which is a sign of perfect IPO pricing. They didn't leave too much money on the table, and public perception is positive. You really don't want it going much higher than that, otherwise the bankers are the only ones laughing.

        • dofm 1 hour ago

          Is market perception truly positive if the price essentially never rises beyond the opening trading price on the first day?

          • paxy 57 minutes ago

            What does that mean? Trading opened at $83 per share. It is $97 per share right now.

            • dofm 9 minutes ago

              I am too tired to order my thoughts carefully but I am talking about the initial recorded trading price once the orders settled. It was $111.whatever.

              (The IPO price is a choice, so the rise to the initial settled trading price is therefore also a signal that is partly under the underwriter's control, yes?)

              Never went past that first market-chosen price throughout the day.

              That is quite unusual, I think? Shows a bit of a lack of excitement.

              And it is notable that the market does not want to give them the valuation that all those leaks suggested they were originally seeking at IPO, regardless.

              Today, if you ask me, does not show market confidence.

  • gbriel 1 hour ago

    The IPO price was $83 and the opening price was $111.50, it is now back down to ~$95. So was ~15% gain from the IPO price.

    So Yahoo is measuring the worst "post-opening decline" which is fairly specific and is missing context.

    IPO subscribers saw gains, not losses.

    • throwup238 8 minutes ago

      > IPO subscribers saw gains, not losses.

      Who were the “subscribers”?

  • riazrizvi 54 minutes ago

    Maybe it's financial 'wizadry'?

    Some ppl out there understand Dark Pools and investment behavior much better than I could ever hope to, and I worked in the finance industry as a low-on-the-totem-pole market maker in the City Of London, the Chicago Board of Trade, the Paris Bourse and Manhattan.

    The barge pole that's long enough doesn't exist for me to touch this thing.

xnx 36 minutes ago

Anthropic: ~$2.0T

Google: ~$3.3T

The ratio between those numbers is incompatible. There's no way Google isn't worth multiples of Anthropic.

jp57 4 hours ago

But what we know for certain is that at some point early in the 21st century, all of mankind was united in celebration. We marveled at our own magnificence as we gave birth to A.I.

-- Morpheus

  • chris_va 4 hours ago

    Which is why the Matrix was redesigned to this: the peak of your civilization. I say your civilization, because as soon as we started thinking for you it really became our civilization, which is of course what this is all about. Evolution, Morpheus, evolution. Like the dinosaur. Look out that window. You've had your time. The future is our world, Morpheus. The future is our time.

    • GeoAtreides 2 hours ago

      I was for one welcome going back to the '90s, it was a simpler time

    • markus_zhang 2 hours ago

      Damn can I at least enjoy the first version? I heard it is pretty good until people get bored and start killing each other.

  • illithid0 4 hours ago

    And then we treated it like shit, according to the Animatrix, and rejected its attempts at peace, making us the existential threat.

    • runarberg 3 hours ago

      If you are talking about The Second Renaissance, I always took to be machine propaganda. I mean it is narrated by a machine, and tells the story from the perspective of the machines. That is, I interpreted the narrative bias for the machines was intentionally written into the episode.

  • jdale27 3 hours ago

    I’m sure Dario is marveling at his own magnificence right now, but the rest of mankind is definitely not united in celebration.

    • bena 1 hour ago

      In this moment he is euphoric, not because of any phony god's blessing, but because he is enlightened by his own intelligence.

  • vibebingo 3 hours ago

    But we are not united in our opinions of AI.

    • markus_zhang 2 hours ago

      It’s probably what would be written in the history book in that timeline . History doesn’t care too much about common people.

    • kennethallen 2 hours ago

      I think that's part of the meaning of the scene. Morpheus has only a very limited understanding of what life was like hundreds of years ago, or how people felt. Like anyone practicing history, he has to assemble a narrative that's necessarily incomplete. It says more about him than it does about what happened in the Matrix timeline.

    • doctorpangloss 1 hour ago

      brother, you're commenting on the website made by the AI people

  • woopwoop 2 hours ago

    I can't emphasize this enough. If you are ever offered the choice between a red pill and a blue pill in a run-down apartment in the middle of the night by a man wearing sunglasses who is insisting his name is "Morpheus", just leave. Do not take this man's pills. I don't care if it's raining.

    • fedpost 27 minutes ago

      Take both, crush them up, and snort them. You'll have a good time

  • m4rtink 42 minutes ago

    And its not AI, just the AI bubble.

gregwebs 2 hours ago

Token spend is not increasing much at the moment: https://www.apollo.com/wealth/insights-news/insights/daily-s...

Heavy Anthropic users have a strong incentive to demand DeepSeek cost/task. Its a ~10x difference. There are other ways that will be discovered to improve cost/task. Those decreases in cost don't necessarily lead to dramatically lower bills: it can be soaked up by more heavily using AI in existing processes (code reviews, veifications, etc). And we will see a lot more software being developed over the next few years.

Anthropic stock seems like a bet as to whether they can both maintain their leadership role in software against intense competition and further develop other industries outside of software.

  • xvector 2 hours ago

    HN has been beating this drum for 2 years. It's not happening.

    • boshalfoshal 1 hour ago

      Agreed. Never have I heard a "heavy anthropic user demanding for deepseek prices." Well yeah they demand deepseek prices, but they also demand good quality output, which claude provides in spades over most benchmaxxed, distilled, open source alternatives.

      As long as claude gets the job done faster, more autonomously, and with less errors, people will prefer that to anything else.

      And before you say "a good harness..." no. Harnesses do not do anything in the long run. The better model will always be better, irrespective of the "harness."

      • RowanH 44 minutes ago

        Compared to back to back with the likes of Qwen, and it's not even in the same ballpark.

        For business use cases where the per output cost is magnitudes better than what a human can do, there's absolutely zero incentive to go mess around with alternatives.

        You know claude's api works, and it's only getting better.

        My jaw dropping moment on ocr via claude api with a client was "there was tape applied across the wording, I've guessed the word is _____ " (the invoice was cut, and there was sellotape across the tear)

        Software just sold itself right there.

      • seizethecheese 31 minutes ago

        Your claim that Claude gets tasks done faster and cheaper than Deepseek is false.

        We have 57 head to head battles for Opus 5.5 vs. DeepSeek 4.1 Flash doing the same work:

        Cost: Deepseek is much cheaper per task ($0.09 vs. $1.87)

        Time: Deepseek is faster (2:48 vs 3:15 median, where both completed)

        (Data from open source app: https://github.com/bottomless/agent-duel leaderboard at https://agentduel.com/leaderboard)

        Claude won 46 battles vs 22 battles, so it still does the job better.

    • fedpost 19 minutes ago

      It's 100% happening. Not just because of costs either. We've created a low trust society and the tech industry, in particular, lives in the lowest circle. I'm seeing a lot of companies chomping at the bit to get inference moved on prem or at least onto machines they have some control over because nobody trusts these lunatics (Amodei, Altman, etc).

      The devs don't trust that the models they're being served aren't being opportunistically quantized or swapped, management doesn't trust that IP is being respected, finance doesn't trust that the spend is worth it, and IT doesn't trust that they're safe.

  • raincole 58 minutes ago

    Since Luna there is simply no reason to use DeepSeek (besides privacy if you can afford to self-host DeepSeek). DeepSeek is the expensive option right now.

    • aleqs 38 minutes ago

      Not even close Sam

  • ijidak 14 minutes ago

    Yeah the interesting question regarding Anthropic is: do they build a software moat around their models?

    Most of us, even myself, focus on the reality that models are likely to become a commodity and that means the big providers will be unable to maintain profitability off of their weights alone (ignoring whether or not they serve the infrastructure).

    But what I have to give Anthropic credit for is that they bring to market products that work well enough incredibly fast and in that sense they remind me of Microsoft in the early '90s.

    I use both Anthropic and OpenAI products and OpenAI products are so bad. Just incredibly clunky changing in strange and unnecessary ways. While problems that they should have fixed months ago, years ago, are still unfixed. No matter how fast you can build, you still have to build the right things.

    It reminds me of a quote from Napoleon, which may be apocryphal and that I will likely butcher.

    It was something along the lines of how Napoleon staffs his military. You have people that are smart and lazy, people that are smart and hardworking. You have people that are dumb and lazy and you have people that are dumb and hardworking.

    He makes the lazy-and-smart generals, because they come up with good strategy but they're not excessively aggressive.

    He makes the dumb and hardworking captains because they'll follow orders and lead their men.

    He makes the dumb and lazy foot soldiers because they follow orders and they can be driven.

    But the dumb and hardworking, he shoots because they both don't know what they're doing and they do a lot of it.

    And I kind of feel that way regarding AI. AI makes everyone "hardworking." Now, with AI, everyone can get a lot of stuff done. But when it comes to product, if you're "dumb" regarding what to get done, you just do a lot of damage instead of producing results.

    And between OpenAI, Google, and Anthropic... and I guess Meta.. Anthropic seems to be the only one of the big model providers that is both smart and "hardworking" (let's replace "hardworking" with "productive.").

    Anthropic has a higher batting average on a lot of their productization ideas and does so quickly.

    And ultimately that might be Anthropic's moat -- just as Apple's moat in smartphones was not that no one else could make a similar smartphone, but that no one else executed as well end-to-end for the customer during the Jobs era.

    Even Anthropic's ability to get to an IPO before OpenAI is another example of them just doing things better.

    It could be that this generation's Netscape is OpenAI and ChatGPT. While Anthropic ends up being this generation's early -90's Microsoft.

jablongo 4 hours ago

Headline is inaccurate. It maxed out at like $1.5T and is now at $1.2T.... why the exaggeration?

  • wyager 4 hours ago

    It depends if you calculate fully diluted or not

    $2T is arguably a more correct number in some senses

    • DamnInteresting 4 hours ago

      > It depends if you calculate fully diluted or not

      It appears to be fully deluded at the very least.

    • athrowaway3z 4 hours ago

      Needing the qualification of being 'arguably' correct is in itself all we need to know.

      Lets not be naive here; somebody is getting paid a lot of money to make sure that the headline yesterday was 1.4T and the headline you're reading today is 2T.

    • jubilanti 2 hours ago

      13.22 billion shares x $113 peak ~= $1.5T

    • naveen99 2 hours ago

      There is no fully diluted until they start buying back shares. Even then they could always start reselling.

  • nashashmi 4 hours ago

    Then i checked spaceX valuation. It is 1.87T.

    • tasty_freeze 1 hour ago

      I checked the SPCX P/E and it is 601, then I checked the NVDA P/E and it is a bit under 16. You might argue the latter is appropriate and maybe too high if you expect the AI bubble to collapse, but then if that happens SPCX will be hit hard too. I don't know how TSLA and SPCX have such enormous P/E.

      • tristanj 1 hour ago

        Because stocks are valued on the discounted value of expected future earnings. The P/E ratio looks at the price compared to current earnings, specifically earnings over a trailing twelve-month period, which does not reflect expected future earnings.

        In short, stocks are priced based on expected future performance. The P/E ratio reflects past performance.

  • MarcScott 1 hour ago

    It opened at £111. That's about $2T

bluegatty 4 hours ago

As I write this Claude is just hallucinating left and right unable to explain slightly tricky algos in some code.

  • dolebirchwood 3 hours ago

    Made my a wife a pretty cool Three.js birthday card though. Got to be worth a few billion there.

    • aquariusDue 2 hours ago

      I've seen a lot of people dabbling with three.js this last year with the help of AI agents and I'm glad even though my laptop fans spin quite a bit more often. It's not for the whimsy of it but more about people feeling empowered to explore areas they didn't have time or experience with.

      I don't like the capitalistic side of this technology or the potential for cognitive decline or anti-intellectual tendencies but I can't anymore deny its usefulness.

      • threetonesun 1 hour ago

        20+ years ago people did this in Flash on a Pentium II.

      • robby_w_g 31 minutes ago

        I built a peer 2 peer online mode for an open source Rock Band clone using Iroh. The code works, though I’m appalled at some of the decisions the model made with the FFI layer, but I never would have done this if I didn’t have AI to generate the code.

        I trust that the tool has value, but I do not trust the humans making it or “regulating” it.

    • drzhouq 1 hour ago

      Why Three.js? Has to be in a browser?

      • dolebirchwood 1 hour ago

        I'm a former webdev (now LLM-babysitter), so it's just familiar to me. Any other options worth considering?

  • Tajnymag 2 hours ago

    I swear he got so much dumber in the last two weeks. Today, Opus acted downright lobotomized in certain queries, not following simple commands.

    • bluegatty 2 hours ago

      Dude. I hear you. I don't like to be a conspiracy theorist - and I'm pretty sure they don't materially change the models like that ...

      ... but *god dam* it feels like 2025 today.

      I swear Ima about to throw my laptop out the window - it's been one of the most frustrating few days of my career.

      I think this may be an ongoing problem: The AI is 'poweful but broken' - aka it does not feel like a working project by it's very nature.

      It's like a fast car, with doors that won't close, gas pedal 1/2 works, brakes 1/2 work.

      Is it faster than walking? Yes. But it's just crazy - and Im beginning to think this is just a property of the AI and that overcoming it woudl require something like 10x the compute .. which is 'not worth it'.

      So - we won't get a smooth ride for maybe 25 years, when RAM/GPU become and absolute commodity, and the work we do now is goes through 10 filters/passes before you see an answer so its not 'full of **' 1/2 the time.

      There is a new psychology here.

      I love development, I love AI - but this is driving me completely crazy.

    • hexad74 2 hours ago

      I always wonder if I am hallucinating and having a bad day or this is actually happening. Yesterday and today Opus 5.5 has been making some strange mistakes. I have a workflow for testing a series of jobs that run in SQL agent. Instead of just generating a script to test the SQL directly as we have done 100 times, it decided to cursor through job steps and attempt to inject the debug parameters into a SQL string pull from the job.

      I have noticed a few other silly choices it as made as well.

    • MisterMunchkin 31 minutes ago

      They quantise the model right before a new release so that the new model seems more intelligent.

      In reality they probably don’t even have a new model, they just slightly up the quality of the existing model.

      • bluegatty 25 minutes ago

        This is basically conspiratorial. You'd have to provide some evidence of this quantiazation

  • Aperocky 2 hours ago

    Moved to Sol for good, on top of that, codex has much smaller footprint I imagine thanks to their less insane engineering approach (that they also don't advertise as much).

sadengineer22 3 hours ago

Meanwhile I'm off to slash our company's AI spend by switching to cheaper and/or open weight models. None of these companies have any moat.

  • seizethecheese 3 hours ago

    Just now? If you haven’t done it yet perhaps they have a moat.

    • vibebingo 2 hours ago

      Maybe a line of castle guards but not a permanent moat.

      Those would be their brand, model being a bit better (for now), subsidized subscriptions.

    • Eji1700 1 hour ago

      Being the "i'll dip my toe in with whatever normal people are clamoring about" option is not a moat by any stretch.

      Explaining to upper levels that "hey you've heard about this in the news, that's what we'll start with" gets approval and then after the proof of concept phase it's very easy to pivot to "okay here's the shit all the nerds you pay for are doing, now that you see this can work, here's how much we can save you if you let us set that up internally".

      "Gateway drug" might be a better term but it's also not a great position when your other options are trivial to spin up.

    • sadengineer22 57 minutes ago

      They have a moat like Heroku had a moat. Easy to start with, when it gets expensive you switch.

bix6 3 hours ago

Paying 20x run rate against no operating profit. Float is gonna grow 5x+ as lockups expire. 15+ year payback even with aggressive growth? Wow this is wild.

misterderpie 5 hours ago

Could someone explain how a company with a revenue of close to $17 billion per quarter gets a $2T valuation?

Edit: Thanks folks, typo, updated the number to billion. Question holds though.

  • nomel 5 hours ago

    Speculation about future growth of the stock price.

    • JimmyBiscuit 4 hours ago

      and it sure as fuck did grow. they 12x'd their revenue compared to 2025 and we still have some year left over. no company has ever done that (if were talking about the billions-area they are moving in)

      • kshacker 3 hours ago

        Threads also had awesome growth for a while.

      • xienze 3 hours ago

        I can 12x revenue selling dollars for a dime all day long. If they can't make revenue exceed expenses despite rapid growth (which by the way means expenses have ALSO >12x'd in the same amount of time), they're in trouble.

      • sekai 3 hours ago

        > and it sure as fuck did grow. they 12x'd their revenue compared to 2025 and we still have some year left over. no company has ever done that (if were talking about the billions-area they are moving in)

        Now mention how much they have spent, they are literally selling $3 for $1

        • JimmyBiscuit 40 minutes ago

          Their operating expenses only grew 4 fold in the same period. And I think its low thirty billion in revenue vs mid thirty billion in expenses. So like 1dollar and 10 cents for every dollar? Tendency quite rapidly towards actually making money

        • matteoraso 24 minutes ago

          >Now mention how much they have spent, they are literally selling $3 for $1

          Their S-1 filing says that they've recently reached $2.08 earned for every $1 spent on compute and infrastructure, so nearly the opposite.

    • rcxdude 3 hours ago

      Which may in part be predicated on speculation of the future growth of their revenue.

  • azan_ 5 hours ago

    You are off 1000x with your revenue estimate.

    • capital_guy 5 hours ago

      that'll do it!

      • misterderpie 4 hours ago

        Thanks, my bad, fixed and now says $17 billion. Question still holds, it's genuine though, their valuation is about 100x of their revenue.

  • jrflo 5 hours ago

    Missed a few zeros on that revenue number

  • zoeysmithe 5 hours ago

    People get rich riding out bubbles. The problem is bubble tend to burst suddenly.

  • qudat 4 hours ago

    Fear mongering. Look at this thread, people with decades of experience think they are getting replaced which is absolutely ridiculous but the fear mongering ad campaigns are working.

    • Oras 3 hours ago

      People with decades of experience are being laid off regularly due to AI. They are not replaced, but business can run with less people now

  • ion_trapper 3 hours ago

    The valuation of a company is what the last purchaser of its stock agreed to pay for it. There is no simple accounting formula that takes revenue and outputs that number. It is strictly a measure of what the last buyer thought the company was worth. That buyer may have used revenue in their calculations of worth, or maybe not. Maybe it was expectation of future revenue growth. Maybe they just liked the name.

    This sounds arbitrary until you appreciate that the ones with most purchasing power on the market are also the same ones who have previously proven themselves to be capable asset allocators, as proven by their ability to accumulate capital. So the valuation of a company is not just every random Joe’s opinion equally averaged, but weighted towards those whose opinions on value have previously tended toward being correct (this includes capital acquired by any means, not just equity trading. For example, if you earned a lot of money with your own product, you have proven yourself to be able to judge value and effectively allocate resources too).

    The market starts to make a lot more sense when you start to use it as an oracle of hidden information (“what is the market telling me about the value of X?”) instead of an irrational adversary (“why is the price Y? That doesn’t make sense!”).

    • dataflow 22 minutes ago

      > The valuation of a company is what the last purchaser of its stock agreed to pay for it.

      Nit: "Agreed to pay" should instead be "paid".

      Buyers agree to pay more than they actually end up paying. Sometimes much more.

  • cmiles8 2 hours ago

    The valuation is what the shares trade at, and yes the market is current very irrational. You’re not wrong to call out that by any sane measure a more realistic valuation is a small fraction of where it’s currently trading.

    Most folks in finance I talk to think a realistic valuation backed by actual math is likely around $400-500B. Now that the investment bankers got their payday for this hype fest, expect numbers in that range to start coming out from analysts at the big banks.

  • kevstev 1 hour ago

    That is 68B per year, or roughly 30x Revenue (not profit/earnings, but revenue). But that is just part of the story- the valuation is based off their growth rates. When your revenue is 10x'ing each year, depending on how long you think that is sustainable for, you can actually get valuations far beyond $2T. Realistic or not, you model that kind of growth out for 2 years, and you are looking at 6T in revenue. And their reported margins are actually insanely high, something like 60 or 80% I can't remember which.

    Obviously you are going to hit growth ceilings, because there are only so many humans on earth, and open weight models could become "good enough" but when you are projecting out growth like this, you can really come up with just about any number you want and justify it.

  • nater5000 41 minutes ago

    >Could someone explain how a company with a revenue of close to $17 billion per quarter gets a $2T valuation?

    Seems like you need to start with how a valuation is generated, first, before asking about one of the most complex valuations we've seen so far lol

    Revenue from a single quarter is so far from enough data to even ask this question in jest, especially for a new tech company.

pooriamokhtari 52 minutes ago

As someone who lives in a country where you can't use Claude, I wonder if/when the bubble breaks and the dust settles, will there be any SWE job opportunities for me who's fallen behind on all this. Dark days indeed!

  • jkukul 49 minutes ago

    What country do you live in if I may ask?

    • pooriamokhtari 47 minutes ago

      Iran.

      • matteoraso 23 minutes ago

        With all due respects, I think you have bigger things than the AI bubble to worry about for the time being.

      • isomorphic_duck 17 minutes ago

        I would be worried about bursting alright, but not of the AI bubble if I take the liberty to say so, sir.

  • nater5000 43 minutes ago

    The AI bubble bursting does not mean AI goes away. It's trite, but that'd be like thinking the dot-com bubble bursting would lead to the internet going away.

    The AI bubble has way more to do with risky investment than it does with AI as a technology. OpenAI, Anthropic, or even Google could get wiped out by an AI bubble bursting, and devs wouldn't skip a beat when it comes to using AI to write code.

    So to answer your question: your odds of getting a SWE job after a tech-driven bubble bursting goes down, not up.

pmdr 2 hours ago

What happens when they burn through all that money and still aren't profitable?

  • bvcp 2 hours ago

    the valuation drops

  • ex-aws-dude 1 hour ago

    Government steps in to consider AI compute a strategic national defence asset /s

  • stuxnet79 1 hour ago

    This is not implausible if market conditions change. Their net loss so far this year has been > $100 billion. If the money fire hose stops then things could get ugly.

  • jeroenhd 36 minutes ago

    A lot of people will havekst lot of money and some other big tech company buys up the scraps.

1970-01-01 5 hours ago

$2,000,000,000,000.00 is high for any software, including AI.

  • therno 5 hours ago

    You ran out of zeros and commas

  • zoeysmithe 5 hours ago

    This is the entire GDP of Spain, an advanced Western country of nearly 50m people. It would take a year of Spain's entire output to buy this one company.

    • 01284a7e 5 hours ago

      Claude no duerme la siesta.

    • simonebrunozzi 5 hours ago

      GDP is different than market cap. Bad comparison. Also very common in media, etc.

      Anthropic's revenues for the last 12 months are about $35B. Nothing, compared to the $2T GDP of Spain.

      • moralestapia 5 hours ago

        We all know is different.

        I don't know what kind of audience you think you're writing this to ... we all know what GDP and market cap are, you're not the Wizard of Oz here.

        And yes, it is an interesting comparison, because it translates a somehow abstract amount of money into something a bit more tangible, i.e. the entire economic output of a developed country.

        • camdenreslink 5 hours ago

          Stated another way, it would take an entire year of economic output from Spain to wholly acquire Anthropic. Which is, indeed, nuts.

          • skylurk 4 hours ago

            Would it also be valid to state that ANT is expected to grow be approximately 1/10 the size of Spain's economy?

      • bjornsing 2 hours ago

        What’s bad about it? GP explicitly compared the value of all good and services produced in Spain in a year with the market cap of Anthropic. Seems like a sound comparison to me.

        (The bad part to me is to think it means Anthropic’s revenue is comparable to Spain’s GDP. As you point out it’s not.)

        • digitalPhonix 1 hour ago

          My car is better than your car because it can go 500 miles. Yours can only go 100mph.

          GDP is value per time (year) and market cap is value.

    • azan_ 5 hours ago

      Or - for better comparison - almost 3 times less than valuation of Apple.

    • on_the_train 5 hours ago

      Sounds wrong to say it like this but... Who would notice that Spain is missing?

      • jacquesm 5 hours ago

        A lot more people than that Anthropic went missing.

        • on_the_train 4 hours ago

          I don't think so

          • jacquesm 3 hours ago

            Sorry, but you are out of touch with the world if you think some crap company that didn't exist five years ago is more important than a country with thousands of years of history and tens of millions of people in it, who in turn have connections with 100's of millions of people all over the world.

    • jefftk 5 hours ago

      You're comparing a stock (company value: $) and a flow (GDP: $/y). This is like saying the size of Lake Vänern (5.4T ft3) is comparable to the size of Spain (5.4T ft2).

      • tomjakubowski 4 hours ago

        Whether it's a good comparison or not, I don't know, but the units aren't a problem. GP isn't ignoring the time component: "it would take a year." Their comment was like saying if you covered Spain in water to a depth of 1ft, you'd have a pool the same volume as Lake Vänern.

    • bpodgursky 5 hours ago

      OK but it is not hard to imagine Anthropic producing the output of 50m people.

      • pbkompasz 4 hours ago

        You won't have to imagine Anthropic producing every Spanish software engineer's output in 6 months /s

      • vibebingo 2 hours ago

        Now or in cold fusion time frames? 99.99% of my spend goes to human thinking and abilities. From the dry cleaner to kids school. And yes including the claude subscription. Claude is very incapable compared to humans. Like a calculator it can do things we can't do I.e. compute sin 30 in it's head.

        • bpodgursky 2 hours ago

          We're talking about the metrics that are captured in GDP.

          Correct, Claude can't play with your kids at the park, but Spain's GDP doesn't include that, so that's not relevant.

          • vibebingo 2 hours ago

            Ok so your point is that Claude can produce the economic output of 50m people even though it may not be able to do all their jobs. I guess that is feasible. But using people as the metric threw me off there. I guess what you are saying is it can get to 2TN revenue. I have no idea if it can myself I think it depends on a lot of things and would be outlier scenaro.

    • abletonlive 3 hours ago

      You say this as if it’s not Spain that is the problem here lol

  • tomrod 5 hours ago

    1 year of Spain output versus entire company's value. No judgment on your comment, just clarifying stock vs flow numbers.

    • __natty__ 2 hours ago

      But can Spain create value or culture for the world like Anthropic models? /s

      • tomrod 1 hour ago

        It already has!

  • mrastro 5 hours ago

    Agreed. Let alone 1000x that amount

    • layer8 4 hours ago

      Good thing we migrated to 64 bits some time ago.

  • dgellow 4 hours ago

    FWIW the headline is wrong. They peaked at 1.5T

  • nashashmi 4 hours ago

    Anthropic is like Google before Pichai. You value them based on their ethos

    • abixb 3 hours ago

      Did Google have a near-peer competitor like OpenAI for Anthropic? I think Google was the best search engine by far in 2000s, iirc.

      I'm a zoomer, so sorry if I'm mistaken.

      • stackskipton 3 hours ago

        No, you were right. Google was top search engine by time it IPOed. Google was also profitable at IPO (just barely) and there was no reason to believe that wouldn't continue.

        • vibebingo 2 hours ago

          Also minor point that they IPOed for 2 orders of magnitude less market cap.

    • randbyte 2 hours ago

      Anthropic has atrocious ethos though (while claiming to be saint).

      • nashashmi 1 hour ago

        Valuation is a perception

  • stateoff 3 hours ago

    This can only mean one thing: More ADS! For every 100 tokens 15 seconds of car insurance commercial ...

    • andrekandre 3 hours ago
        > car insurance
      

      now there's a safe investment if i ever saw it

aussiegreenie 3 hours ago

The greatest misallocation of capital the world has ever seen.

I have a client who wants a co-investor for USD 1 million. He has an investor for USD 1 million for a Phase 1 cancer drug and is struggling.

  • bix6 3 hours ago

    Haha we’re pulling teeth to get a $500k bridge for a company right now that has a cure for something. It’s wild.

  • abixb 3 hours ago

    > He has an investor for USD 1 million for a Phase 1 cancer drug and is struggling.

    Well, the market is betting on the fact that Phase 1 trials for such critical drugs can be fully modeled on digital twins running on GPUS, so they can leapfrog needing human subjects for RCTs.

    Not disagreeing with you, though.

  • broodbucket 3 hours ago

    Capitalism in a nutshell, really, no incentive to do what's good for humanity.

    • abletonlive 3 hours ago

      Touch grass. You clearly live in your own narrative about capitalism that doesn’t match reality

      • broodbucket 2 hours ago

        Do you touch grass in a gated neighborhood?

    • sdellis 3 hours ago

      I am right there with you, but to be fair there are incentives under Capitalism to do what's good for humanity. Unfortunately they are suppressed and sidelined by the primary incentive to maximize profit.

      • broodbucket 2 hours ago

        There can be some, sure. Ultimately the system will always reward greed and greed always comes at the cost of the humanity of others. I don't really buy the whole "crony capitalism"/"corporatism" thing. It's the logical endgame of capitalism.

      • tclancy 1 hour ago

        Only if you accept everything has to be priced.

    • xvector 2 hours ago

      Wild thing to say, you only need to reflect on your own quality of life today and compare it to a sixteenth century peasant.

      • bvcp 2 hours ago

        hot showers become mainstream in the 1950s. people really need to touch grass its embarrassing

  • mathisfun123 3 hours ago

    > The greatest misallocation of capital the world has ever seen.

    i thought the free market was the best tool we had to allocate resources???

    • automatic6131 3 hours ago

      It's the worst except for all the others

  • paxy 3 hours ago

    The US government by itself spends upwards of $7 billion a year on cancer research. Add in worldwide government spending, private pharma R&D, charities and more and that number is likely in the $100B-130B range. Per year. Anthropic meanwhile has raised $130B in its lifetime and another $80B at IPO, and earns $80B/yr in revenue.

    I'd say the allocation problem is on the cancer side.

    • uptrails 3 hours ago

      > The US government by itself spends upwards of $7 billion a year on cancer research.

      Right. On what is probably the most significant solvable health issue of our age.

      Compare this to what, $3 trillion parked in the stock of an ad tech company (Google) and now another $2 trillion betting on some wishy-washy benefits of AI (maybe it will cure cancer too? the founder said so).

      I don't think that central planning is a good alternative, but I think we should talk about this, because capitalism evidently doesn't produce a particularly efficient allocation of resources either. As it turns out, you can have massive industries that do relatively little for mankind but are very attractive to investors.

      • vlovich123 3 hours ago

        $2T isn’t locked up in ANT - you’re confusing market cap with actual capital. For what it’s worth ANT total external infusion is ~250B not 2T.

        • rini17 2 hours ago

          Now they are established they can get much more capital anyway. The question is - can they actually meaningfully use even these 250B?

          • vlovich123 2 hours ago

            Is that a serious question? Given they’re not profitable yet I imagine quite a fair bit.

            By the argument that locked up cash is a concern, we should be far more concerned about Google and Apple that have 260B and 136B respectively in cash and securities - in other words they don’t have better ways to leverage their cash than investing it elsewhere.

            • rini17 37 minutes ago

              Do we have to pick? Of course we can be concerned about all of them lol.

      • mikeshi42 2 hours ago

        there's no $3tn parked in stock at google. their company has a market cap of $3tn, but that doesn't mean as an economy we've given them $3tn that can not be allocated elsewhere.

        if anything - they probably created plenty of new wealth for people to invest in other places.

        the pie can grow.

    • geraneum 37 minutes ago

      > I'd say the allocation problem is on the cancer side.

      One needs to look at the outcome of our efforts in those research and the effect on the patients’ life expectancy and compare it with a few decades ago, plus some appreciation for human life to not call this misallocation.

  • seizethecheese 3 hours ago

    Surely a large portion of phase 1 cancer drugs fail, rightfully, I’m not sure your point.

    The capital allocation here is a fraction of the daily stock market trading volumes the tradeoff here is large capital pools deciding between Ant, other corporate stocks, private equity and bonds.

    • paulhebert 3 hours ago

      The cancer drug needs two million. Anthropic gets 2 trillion.

      If our society allocated wealth differently we could afford to fund 1 million projects like that cancer drug instead of spending that money on Anthropic

      • seizethecheese 3 hours ago

        If society allocated capital based on what felt good there’d be a lot less money for cancer research.

        Ant IPO just seeded a huge amount of multimillionaires many of which will likely fund cancer research.

        • shaaaade 3 hours ago

          anthropic going public is nothing but "feels". it's all hype, and it's nothing but another wealth transfer to the rich, through passively managed index funds. A company which projects unrealistic growth, turning a profit at some unspecified point in the future. Thus, it turning a loss right now doesn't mean a thing! To the moon!

          • seizethecheese 14 minutes ago

            I'm confused. This entire thread is about people getting upset because money is going to Ant instead of cancer research, but your rebuttal is that Ant funding is because it feels good?

        • notagainffs 2 hours ago

          Not sure if I am totally stupid or you are. Those multimillionaires will only be that if they are selling their shares, and that means someone buys their shares. No money was created that did not exist before. Those buying those shares could be the ones funding cancer research. It feels like trickle-down-reasoning, but much dumber (and that is impressive).

          • seizethecheese 2 hours ago

            Well, it's about wealth mix. I'd bet early Ant employees are a lot more likely to angel invest in cancer research than the replacement capital, which is more likely to be institutional.

      • nh23423fefe 3 hours ago

        why are you trying to take everyones money and boss them around? are you some super moral person who has the insight to make that decision? or just some greedy dude with different priorities than everyone else?

        • paulhebert 1 hour ago

          It seems like you’re jumping to a lot of conclusions.

          I never proposed a system to take people’s money and put it elsewhere.

          I just responded in a comment chain pointing out the difference between a 2 million and 2 trillion. The person I responded to said the 2 million investment might not pay off and I pointed out you could make a million of those investments for 2 trillion.

          I don’t think I’m a particularly greedy dude. It would be nice if we could cure more cancers though. I think most people would like that.

      • nickpp 3 hours ago

        > The cancer drug needs two million. Anthropic gets 2 trillion.

        Anthropic has a product that can potentially help develop countless cancer drugs.

        > If our society allocated wealth differently

        Other societies tried allocating wealth differently. I lived in one, here in Eastern Europe. It couldn't even feed its citizens, let alone develop cancer drugs. Turns out central planning is a much much much worse way of allocating wealth.

        • shaaaade 3 hours ago

          > Potentially

          For the umpteenth time, the bottleneck in drug discovery is not the design-part, but the trials. Can claude code help with that? Will it breed willing and able adults into existence through its API as participants in drug trials?

          • seizethecheese 2 hours ago

            Do you really think the mix of drugs in trials is irrelevant, like they're picking drug candidates out of a hat?

            • shaaaade 2 hours ago

              I'm not saying that at all, and I'm not sure how you got that from what I said. What you seem to be implying, is that claude code, by virtue of claude code magic, will simply devise far better designs than those already waiting in line for capital for clinical trials, and should take precedence, because claude code?

              • seizethecheese 2 hours ago

                > the bottleneck in drug discovery is not the design-part, but the trials.

                You said the above to dismiss that Claude models could help with progress on cancer. My point is that if trials are the scarce thing, making sure the trials are on the right candidates is clearly important. I don't have an opinion on whether Claude can help now, but do believe at some point it can help.

              • shaaaade 1 hour ago

                @seizethecheese There is zero evidence a chatbot can do that. There's only the hype, the word of a few ceos, which media unequivocally copies, pastes, and prints as gospel. It's the same thing as saying my pet monkey has the potential to be a Ph.D, so please invest in my GoFundMe.

          • addaon 2 hours ago

            > Can claude code help with that?

            If we allowed compensation for participating in drug trials, then this (putting massive numbers of people out of jobs and in search of income at any cost) seems like something Anthropic is perfectly set up to do, yes.

            • shaaaade 2 hours ago

              If I read you right, you're suggesting massively subsidizing drug trials? Sure, you could do that, but anthropic is not only irrelevant but largely orthogonal to that. Big pharma has no incentive to publicize decades of r&d into the hands of anthropic, to make their chatbot more capable in any way, shape or form. Big pharma would seize the day and run massively more drug trials, because they've got the know-how, not anthropic. In fact, there is zero evidence that claude code can bring any tangible value into drug discovery. There's only the word of a guy called dario, because the software market is turning out to be too small for this bubble, and you have to figure out the next big thing.

              EDIT: Not to mention such subsidization and liberation would turn it into a massive crap-shoot, and neither anthropic nor big pharma would take any liability.

            • orphereus 2 hours ago

              Lmao, I hope this comment is tongue-in-cheek

        • paulhebert 2 hours ago

          The only two options are hypercapitalism and communism?

        • StableAlkyne 1 hour ago

          > can potentially help develop countless cancer drugs.

          The bottleneck isn't in-silico screening. "Anyone" can do high throughout docking studies to identify leads, and engage in further lead optimization. At best, Claude can automate some of that... But the bottleneck is lab testing and ultimately clinical trials. It isn't a statistical model of docking, synthetic accessibility, or ADMET.

          The only thing computation really gets you is better candidates for testing. That means you waste less time on dead ends, but that can always be solved by allocating more lab resources to test more candidates

          > Turns out central planning is a much much much worse way of allocating wealth.

          It can be done in such a way that economic hardship isn't common, if China is any example

          That said, China has some other very obvious problems the Soviet bloc had too, most prominently suppression of political dissidents.

          But the economic idea of central planning itself demonstrably can work

      • quietbritishjim 3 hours ago

        > The cancer drug needs two million. Anthropic gets 2 trillion.

        There is rightfully a lot of skepticism about whether Anthropic can maintain their business in the face of competition, especially from open weights models. But it's undeniable that they do have a product that works at doing useful things, right now.

        Presumably that cancer drug, important as it would be if it succeeds, is not currently guaranteed to produce any useful result at all (even with enough funding).

        • paimapi 2 hours ago

          I feel like this is an unnecessarily pedantic point? Global funding for cancer research from 2016 - 2023 was around $50 billion [0] with the vast majority coming from public funds (ie taxes on most of the rest of us).

          Meanwhile, the ultra-wealthy are dumping upwards of $2 trillion in capital purely for the sake of speculatively betting on it increasing their capital.

          In our society, that capital translates to labor, time, research facilities, technology. Which effectively means that our current system of governance and wealth distribution prioritizes growing capital 200x (40 x 5 years) more than solving a fundamental human disease that has plagued us since we first crawled out of the ocean.

          I don't think it's wrong to say 'hey maybe our priorities are a bit mixed and just getting more capital for the sake of it maybe defeats the purpose'.

          [0] https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lanonc/article/PIIS1470-2...

          • nemothekid 1 hour ago

            >Meanwhile, the ultra-wealthy are dumping upwards of $2 trillion in capital

            $2T in capital isn't being dumped here, this comparison isn't comparable at all. Investors have dumped ~200B in Anthropic since 2021 (including today's IPO). The other 1.8T of capital is capital that has been "created". At best you can argue, in comparison to ANT, that it's been valued 4x.

            • paulhebert 1 hour ago

              That’s fair. In that case we could only afford to fund 100,000 projects that cost 2 million

              • paimapi 1 hour ago

                Right - we could literally fund every single university research lab for decades with that kind of money invested in a single private company, all to advance research across all possible fields, to leave no stone unturned. But that wouldn't individually get you 10% returns on investment so of course we won't dedicate our manpower and labor to such an effort.

                The system is fundamentally flawed and has been for a long time.

          • gizzlon 1 hour ago

            > are dumping upwards of $2 trillion in capital purely for the sake of speculatively betting on it increasing their capital.

            I get your point, but only like 5% of Anthropic is up for sale

            • paimapi 1 hour ago

              5% of 200x is still 10x more capital being invested in growing capital rather than going to research. The priorities don't seem much changed.

              Plus we're not even counting the subsidized buildouts of datacenters + the energy grid, the bulk of which will be funded by taxpayers by way of increased rates and lowered-to-no corporate taxes.

        • dofm 2 hours ago

          In the face of competition!? In the face of their own debts and commitments!

      • VikingCoder 3 hours ago

        Anthropic didn't get $2 trillion. It has a market capitalization of $2 trillion. Big difference.

        Also, frankly, a private company trying to make a profit off of a cancer drug is ALSO an abomination.

        Sure, I'd love it if governments around the world threw money at cancer research, but claiming that private pharma companies are "more moral" than AI is a losing battle, in my book.

        • paulhebert 1 hour ago

          That’s fair. My understanding in further reading is about 200 billion were spent by investors on Anthropic (so 100,000 projects like the cancer drug that costs 2 million)

      • laurels-marts 59 minutes ago

        This argument is so moronic. Cancer research is not chronically underfunded. About 80 billion is spent on cancer research annually. AI investment will likely do more to advance cancer drug research than anything else in the long run. It’s not like the two sectors are competing for a fixed quantity of resources. Redirecting all AI funding to fund a million Phase 1 cancer drugs would not produce better outcomes for anyone.

        • paulhebert 54 minutes ago

          I was just responding to the comparison above.

          I’m not suggesting we invest all our money as a society into cancer research.

          But I think that we could find a lot of important projects that could benefit from a million dollars and that we’d be better off as a society prioritizing hundreds of thousands of those smaller projects over AI a single AI company.

      • whimsicalism 25 minutes ago

        If society had decided to allocate capital with your preferred method in 1950, we'd be trying to solve cancer with fax machines.

      • SideQuark 5 minutes ago

        Anthropic didn’t get 2 trillion. A valuation is not cash.

  • nozzlegear 3 hours ago

    Did he ever consider that more pull requests will help cure cancer?

    /s

  • theropost 3 hours ago

    Guess it depends on how you look at it - if you look at it as the greatest intelligence operation in history, it probably has great value - how much? No idea, capitalism broke a while back.

  • pizzathyme 3 hours ago

    The cancer researchers are likely using Claude/Astra/AlphaFold at some point in the process, right?

    So this seems aligned with that value

  • jayd16 3 hours ago

    But think of all the cures that AI will make that we can also not fund.

  • epolanski 2 hours ago

    And yet we haven't come with more efficient capital allocation than capitalism.

    Not saying it's perfect, I'm just debating I have yet to see better alternatives.

    • DonaldPShimoda 2 hours ago

      We could simply not "allocate capital", but then we wouldn't have people who are judged to be more valuable than others, and that's obviously right out of the question.

    • geraneum 41 minutes ago

      I keep hearing this argument which the more you think about it the less sense it makes. Capitalism is not being controlled and tested against other systems in a lab! It has teeth. It creates wars, actively sabotages other systems and experiments, etc. This is absolutely not a defense of socialism or feudalism or whatever we had in the past. It’s to say, capitalism after a certain point (late stage) doesn’t even leave any breathing room for other new ideas and experiments to take place and grow. Anything new needs to come with force and the force is very costly for people’s lives.

      Cancer is also a very effective cell growth state, with which healthy cells cannot compete, and it ultimately kills the host!

  • bravoetch 2 hours ago

    > The greatest misallocation of capital the world has ever seen.

    I feel like wars are a larger problem.

  • pier25 43 minutes ago

    This 100%

    Imagine the impact that a $1T investment would've had on something like fusion. It would be absolutely transformative for the better.

    ITER is probably the best funded fusion project and it has received some $50B which seems like peanuts compared to all the money burned on AI just in 2026.

    And I would imagine the ROI of the first commercial fusion service will be so much higher than any AI company.

    • MisterMunchkin 39 minutes ago

      Anthropic alone is burning two ITERs in just 2026.

  • azan_ 36 minutes ago

    Anthropic is not sucking value but creating it! Capitalism is NOT zero sum game.

mglvsky 2 hours ago

I hope there will be less astroturfers here

paxy 5 hours ago

$2T is a pretty misleading number. You can't just add up all outstanding shares over the next N years and give them the same value as current ones. Not all of them will get vested. And ones that do will lower the price of existing shares (which is the "diluted" part of fully diluted market cap). A company doesn't become worth 20% more if it issues 20% new shares. Existing shares become worth less.

Anthropic hit a peak market cap of $1.46T post IPO and is now at $1.27T. It may go up to $2T over the next few years when more shares vest, or it may not. Sites reporting $2T today just want to maximize engagement ("we annouced a bigger number than the other guy!").

  • dgellow 4 hours ago

    Media reporting anything tech or finance related is a complete dumpster fire. Completely nonsensical stuff reported confidently, over and over again, with zero accountability. And of course the worse is when they are reporting on finance of tech companies, then you get a multiplication of absurdity

  • qeternity 4 hours ago

    > A company doesn't become worth 20% more if it issues 20% new shares.

    If the prevailing price of those shares does not change, then yes, it actually does.

    > Existing shares become worth less.

    Maybe, maybe not. You're talking like this is all formulaic.

    • zamalek 4 hours ago

      > If the prevailing price of those shares does not change

      That assumption is doing a huge amount of work. How many shares don't change?

    • joshribakoff 4 hours ago

      You guys are talking past each other. A company‘s worth and it’s market cap are two different things. One is the actual future value, and the other is the markets prediction of the future value.

      • qeternity 4 hours ago

        You're trying to find an out for GP's bad argument.

        They literally talked about "adding up all the shares" and argued against that, but for mechanical reasons, not philosophical reasons about value and worth.

        And for all intents an purposes, a company's "worth" (undefined) is almost always measured by its market cap (well defined) as the least-worst approximation.

    • demibabs 4 hours ago

      > If the prevailing price of those shares does not change, then yes, it actually does.

      His whole point is that you can’t assume that.

      • qeternity 4 hours ago

        No, his point was that he assumed they would go down.

        Maybe, probably even...but it's irrelevant.

        • rcxdude 3 hours ago

          The point is unless the act of issuing shares in and of itself somehow makes the company more valuable, the rational response of the market is for the price per share to go down in response to that issuance.

          • qeternity 2 hours ago

            No, it's not...unless the act of issuing the shares makes the company less valuable.

            The act of issuing shares does not do anything. It's what you do with the proceeds.

      • sillysaurusx 3 hours ago

        But that's true for every stock in the history of stocks. Every security has an uncertain future.

    • paxy 4 hours ago

      If a company announces a 2:1 stock split does the market cap go up 2x? What would you say if a website reported "Apple is going to double in value tomorrow!!"? After all it is possible in theory if everyone decides to value the shares at the same price they were pre-split. But reporting it as fact is still 100% incorrect. That's the same logic being used for Anthropic.

  • joshribakoff 4 hours ago

    Some would say market caps are misleading numbers, and in addition to that they have mislead people even more about the market cap by calculating it incorrectly.

  • elAhmo 4 hours ago

    It is also pretty arbitrary. If they just put few dozen million shares less on sale, their valuation would be increased more. Or just issued more shares before the IPO, as people don't really care or know how many shares are outstanding, buying these shares now is just buying the hype. There is virtually no difference between 1T, 2T or 3T dollars in this case, its all just a very large hand-picked number by opaque guys who have an interest to make loads of money from ordinary people.

    • paxy 3 hours ago

      The value is arbitrary but at least it follows a formula – total shares x price of last trade. Now people are inflating it by adding in shares that may be created in the future.

    • CryptoBanker 1 hour ago

      Valuation has absolutely nothing to do with how many shares are outstanding. The share price will always adjust to equal Common Equity Value / Total Outstanding Shares (Fully Diluted)

      • elAhmo 51 minutes ago

        That is true for normal companies. Who decided how much a share of Anthropic will launch at, and how many would go on sale? They were already aiming to sell xx billion, and by gauging interest from institutional investors who are also incentivized to sell this, they can get to the valuation they want by saying 'OK to get us 80 billion USD of cash at 2T valuation, we should release this portion of total shares at this price to get us those numbers'.

        It is virtually no different to the people buying shares if at the same share price for the same volume on the first day valuation was 1T. Or 3T. They could've aimed and achieved either of those numbers with tricks they have already been doing in the preparation for this IPO.

        • CryptoBanker 39 minutes ago

          Except Anthropic and its bankers can only guess as to how the market will value their shares. Case in point, Anthropic stated they wanted to raise ~$50-60 billion but ended up raising over $80 billion

  • hardtke 4 hours ago

    It's crazy to think about individual employees with tens of millions of dollars in unvested shares/RSUs that are under at-will employment. A purely rational management would immediately let them go. A sadistic manager would recognize that the employee will take any level of abuse until the vest is complete.

    • paxy 3 hours ago

      A purely rational management would have fired them before the IPO.

      Or before the last set of RSUs vested.

      Or before they were even granted.

      In fact a purely rational management wouldn't have hired them at all.

      Where do you draw the line?

    • taude 3 hours ago

      wasn't zuck famous for firing people early on at 11 months before they vested anything, if they weren't at the top of their game?

  • sl0wbrainRot 4 hours ago

    Arguing that here where it won't go viral isn't really challenging the narrative meaningfully, and won't change the minds of innumerate masses who will cheer, yay big number!, then move on

    Make an issue out of it and you'll just run into "prove it!" to a billion people who will just blank stare in return

twotwoone 1 hour ago

> If we could sell all our shares

> we would be worth 2 trillion

But that won’t happen. The price will fall lower and lower until it leads to bankruptcy.

Software can never become a monopoly; it can always be copied and made better.

  • nater5000 39 minutes ago

    Yeah, crazy there's never been a successful, valuable software company before.

ortusdux 5 hours ago

The Nasdaq and S&P 500 are both down 1.5% today, with articles tying this to the Anthropic launch. What is the correlation, if any?

  • IncreasePosts 5 hours ago

    Selling other companies to buy the IPO.

    • jr3592 5 hours ago

      And yet ANT has decreased in price since launch? Huh? Down to ~$93 from 110.

      • gonzalohm 4 hours ago

        Because it was pumped by the ones wanting to get rid of the risky asset

      • jrflo 4 hours ago

        IPO price was $83. Initial price on secondary market after the IPO went up to $110.

      • IncreasePosts 3 hours ago

        Yes? Whether ANT is viewed as appropriately priced is separate from whether people holding some other stock want to buy ANT. Almost certainly the people selling at the current $93 or whatever are not people who earlier today were buying at $110. It's insiders whose cost basis is far below those values selling at both prices.

  • d1sxeyes 4 hours ago

    Everyone buying is buying ANT?

  • smallmancontrov 4 hours ago

    ANT is being bought with money obtained by selling other stocks.

    • ortusdux 4 hours ago

      That make sense. The 'market cap' of the S&P 500 is about 65T to ANT's 2T, so 1.5% tracks.

      • seizethecheese 3 hours ago

        This sounded won’t since Ant is on Nasdaq, which is also down 1.5%c but looking into it I found that it’s not included on IPO day which seems like a flaw in indexes.

      • yousif_123123 51 minutes ago

        Note that I believe only about a billion shares are floated today. They did not sell 2T worth of shares..

  • WarmWash 4 hours ago

    I have been doing this shit for years and trust me no one ever knows on days like today. This is a broad sell-off and there is no real substantial news, so it really just looks like more sellers than buyers happened to show up today.

    The media just grabs whatever event to tie it too, lots of clicks to be had from people wanting an answer, but the reality is that it's mostly just noise. If the markets were ripping green today, then they would be attributing it to anthropic all the same, all else being equal.

Karupan 1 hour ago

We had one chance to carefully develop and roll out AI, and here we are. Fuck everyone who was responsible for this - my retirement savings are now at risk because the entire economy is now betting on this industry blindly and I have very little say in how my super is invested.

  • chilipepperhott 58 minutes ago

    I think that the count is for roughly every 100k invested in VTI (the Vanguard Morningstar US-only index fund) you'll own ~150 bucks of ANT. You shouldn't be at too much risk.

chinathrow 5 hours ago

Insanity.

  • AznHisoka 5 hours ago

    I bet people said the same thing when Google IPOd twenty years ago

    • chinathrow 5 hours ago

      Google had no competition in search at the time.

      • x86x87 5 hours ago

        whoa whoa whoa google had plenty of competition

      • fny 5 hours ago

        Ask Jeeves, Yahoo, Lycos, AltaVista...

      • jhallenworld 5 hours ago

        It was just a web-site, anybody can make one.

        • afavour 5 hours ago

          Come on. It was a web site backed by an incredibly comprehensive index that no one else at the time could rival.

      • ACCount39 5 hours ago

        The likes of Yahoo! and Ask Jeeves have existed for years already.

        Sure, Google had the top of the line offering. But you could easily argue that they don't have the moat, that web search is a commodity, and that more established competitors could catch up to Google in no time at all.

        • throwaway894345 5 hours ago

          At the time, Yahoo! and Ask Jeeves had humans manually indexing the web, which was viable when the web was tiny but failed to scale as the web exploded. So while Google "had competition", not really. Moreover, IIRC, only Google figured out how to monetize search.

        • Forgeties79 5 hours ago

          As others pointed out this is literally orders of magnitude higher. Inflation doesn’t even register as part of the reason either.

          • ACCount39 5 hours ago

            At least one OOM lives in TAM for AI services in 2026 vs TAM for web search in 2004. If we're highballing, it's two decimal OOMs.

            Also, unlike with web search, the AI companies are makers of their own destiny - in that they can potentially grow the TAM massively purely by improving their own products. The more capable and price-capable AIs get, the more they cut into various niches, of which there are a great many.

            Even in my own field: reverse engineering is hotter than ever, and it's because AI allows RE efforts to scale to the size and complexity of modern software.

            • Forgeties79 4 hours ago

              This all may be the case but it doesn’t change the fact that Google’s IPO was nowhere near this.

      • the_mitsuhiko 5 hours ago

        When Google IPOed it had around 35% of US web search queries.

    • trimbo 5 hours ago

      Google IPOed at $23b. Their share of the total US stock market at the time was 0.16%

      Anthropic's share of the total US stock market at IPO is 2%. At the current price, it's 2.74%.

      • kevstev 1 hour ago

        I remember being astonished when Google was valued more than GM. It was absolutely unthinkable at the time. A software producer worth more than a titan of US manufacturing that provided millions of jobs.

        Yet... here we are, google peaked around 5T in October, and GM peaked around 90B in the 2010s. The sheer size and scale of tech companies is hard to wrap our heads around.

        That said, your percentage of market capitalization is indeed alarming.

      • karmakurtisaani 1 hour ago

        Also, Google's market cap is now around 3.4 trillion, with an established and diversified portfolio, including a very competitive AI model, and a state of the art AI research lab.

        Anthropic is slightly over a third of that with just an AI model. Absolute insanity.

    • standeven 5 hours ago

      Google was valued at $23B when it IPOd.

      $2T is 87x more.

      • esafak 5 hours ago

        Google didn't aim to commoditize all intellectual work.

        • tomrod 5 hours ago

          Their mission was to organize the world's information. Not too far removed.

          • esafak 5 hours ago

            It is, though. One empowers you, the other replaces you. That's their story, at least.

        • hkt 5 hours ago

          ..didn't it?

      • stuxnet79 5 hours ago

        > Google was valued at $23B when it IPOd.

        Is this adjusted for inflation? I find comparisons across different decades to be somewhat useless in establishing a benchmark.

        • layer8 4 hours ago

          It would be roughly $45B today, still only 2% of the $2T.

        • jocro 4 hours ago

          i mean when you're talking nearly two orders of magnitude of difference, inflation over the course of ~20 years is really not that impactful. 23 billion in 2004 dollars is roughly 43 billion today.

    • dktp 5 hours ago

      Fun fact. Google didn't really want to IPO, they were massive cash machine. But had over 500 shareholders and were sort of forced to

      Sergey and Larry hated the idea of mispricing the IPO to generate the "pop". So they did a "Dutch auction" to find the _correct_ price and avoid the unnecessary pop that happens due intentional underpicing. Auctioning (ads) was their bread and butter anyway

      Well, it popped anyway and it popped a lot. And no notable company has done Dutch auction since (to the best of my knowledge)

      • orphereus 1 hour ago

        What do you mean by pop?

        • dofm 1 hour ago

          They mean what the underwriter does to make the opening trading price ($111.68 or whatever it was for Anthropic) start higher than the IPO price (which was $83.00) and hopefully then rise.

    • everforward 4 hours ago

      Not really. Google IPOd at a market cap of ~$41B after adjusting for inflation.

      In different terms, Google IPOd at a market cap ~ 10% smaller than Ford’s at the time.

      Anthropic is at 50x Fords market cap. It’s over half of Googles market cap, and Google is a competitor in the same market with a dozen already successful lines of business.

      They are incredibly highly valued in a way where I don’t even understand mechanically how they could grow like that without the entire financial system crumbling.

      Google is up ~ 6,600% since IPO. Apply that to Anthropic and they’ll be worth something like $132T in 2048. As a point of reference, the Congressional Budget Office is predicting the US national debt to be around $102T in 2050 (paper was from 2020, might be outdated).

      Anthropic, the singular company, will have to grow to be worth 130% of the entirety of the US’ debt. Napkin math says their revenue would probably have to exceed the US governments tax income. Like genuinely, Anthropic would have to become a world superpower all on its own.

      They would be so big that they’re an existential threat to whatever country they call home. They would be such a large portion of the economy that central banks would lose any kind of control (presuming Anthropic doesn’t issue their own currency, they’d be a larger economy than most countries).

      I can’t see how that could happen mechanically. The world would burn to the ground even trying to make it happen. If you thought Standard Oil was bad, this would be that but for every product and service in existence and all run by the same company.

      • dprkh 3 hours ago

        Humanity will be extinct long before 2048.

    • TheAlchemist 4 hours ago

      The major difference is the price. IPO used to be bets that the businesses will grow quickly, and the price reflected the risks.

      Looking at recent mega-IPOs - SpaceX and Anthropic, with OpenAI coming soon, the price assumes that the company will be a success and simply discounts the projected future cash flow, as it was not risky at all. Future is not certain though. It will be fun.

  • SirMaster 5 hours ago

    I mean Nvidia is down 2.1T from early October...

    • hooch 5 hours ago

      Could it be that folks are trading into icing for their five layer cake?

      • ssl-3 5 hours ago

        the cake is a lie

    • MajorBee 3 hours ago

      What do numbers even mean anymore

  • hackyhacky 5 hours ago

    Definitely not a bubble. Definitely definitely.

orliesaurus 5 hours ago

The guys that want us to NOT open source AI models have won this battle, but not the war.

Meanwhile other countries are chugging along, doing whatever they want...

  • properbrew 4 hours ago

    Do you not think it potentially could be the other way around? The guys that don't want open source models have cashed out now because they can see what's on the horizon.

    • longtimelistnr 4 hours ago

      I really wish i could be one of the guys who knows this answer before it happens, just once

      • sillysaurusx 3 hours ago

        Pick a side, then confidently say it'll come true. You'll be right half the time.

        • MrDresden 1 hour ago

          Might want to check the math on that one.

    • karahime 4 hours ago

      I think this assumes that Anthropic is going to do nothing with the pile of cash they just got. Which is probably not the case, as much as that would be nice.

      • orliesaurus 1 hour ago

        my prediction (based completely on vibes) is that they're gonna make more Fortune500-only models because that's where the money is in the US!

  • slicktux 3 hours ago

    Meanwhile Palo Alto Networks will focus and invest on deploying local open and closed weights.

reticulates 5 hours ago

fwiw this is reporting fully diluted value which is different from what Nasdaq reports, hence the discrepancy that will be seen across different reporting. Nasdaq is outstanding shares (13,086,672,593) multiplied by the price which is currently $98 = $1,279,156,812,603 market cap at the time of writing.

xrd 1 hour ago

Can anyone explain how this isn't sovereign wealth funds, that used to have almost unlimited wealth via control of oil, trying to diversify?

I mean to say, if there was anyone that would have the means and the incentives, to prop up an IPO for a year, it would be a foreign government with massive capital.

They likely participated in earlier rounds so it could allow them liquidity.

They also have professional money managers who could take profits out slowly and cap any disruptions to the market and avoid crashes.

I don't have any proof of this. It just seems odd that the demand was suddenly higher. And, SpaceX is down slowly since its IPO, and seems like it would be the same kind of vehicle for a plot like that. And, there have been articles about MBS trying to find the next thing for his country's economy once the petrodollar dominance dies out.

I just can't figure out where else the massive capital from these funds goes next; governments who recognize oil isn't a long term strategy anymore. You need a moonshot.

neya 4 hours ago

You must be really stupid to celebrate this. This is the company that is very much against open source models. Jensen was a huge advocate for open models and the timing of his firing isn't a co-incidence. Anthropic went public exactly then. Anthropic invests millions into lobbying. You must be naive if you think they are lobbying in favor of open models. Nothing is a co-incidence in this climate.

Make no mistake, more regulations are coming - open models will be regulated to the point where they are useless and Anthropic et al will make sure of that, now that they will have even more pressure since going IPO. We should never forget that consumers deserve choice and open models must be always a valid, usable choice. Not namesake.

  • gonzalohm 1 hour ago

    Yeah, I don't get it. People seem to think that Anthropic is some kind of charity.

    They just want to be a monopoly and jack up token prices. The only good news would have been the stock going to 0

DubiousPusher 3 hours ago

This is not a triumphant IPO. They offered at $83 and the greedy brokerages opened it at $120. It's fallen most of the way back to the IPO price in the first hours. It's not a crater but it's not roaring success even through they juiced it about every way they could.

irfanhasnani 2 hours ago

people says it's bubble, can anyone just suggest i should invest in anthropic or openai?

  • autoventure 2 hours ago

    yes it's bubble but not completely and to be honest anthropic is way better than openai in my opinion, and investment is subject to risk, you should analyze risk and reward before choosing any.

  • nater5000 34 minutes ago

    >can anyone just suggest i should invest in anthropic or openai?

    Well seeing as how you can't currently invest in OpenAI, it seems like your choice is made for you lol

robrain 41 minutes ago

Title is now “Anthropic's blockbuster debut tests Wall Street's faith in AI boom”, FWIW

mixmastamyk 5 hours ago

For those crying bubble, many tech stocks are rather cheap right now, not to mention inflation.

This IPO price was engineered, through a small number of shares available, to presales to Big Tech. So, I wouldn't read too much into this news, it remains to be seen what it all means.

  • echelon 4 hours ago

    > it remains to be seen what it all means

    Cushy SWE comp is transitioning into ANT share price. (Or just token spend in general.)

  • rfgplk 2 hours ago

    The greatest bubble, of all things, of all assets, of all time.

    • mixmastamyk 1 hour ago

      There's significant overspending in places, but nothing compared to previous market bubbles. Compare the P/E of Nvidia with S&P average for example. You can even double it to look back a few months.

    • orphereus 1 hour ago

      The greatest bubble since the tulip incident.

      • karmakurtisaani 1 hour ago

        Maybe the real bubble was the friends we made along the way.

blobbers 2 hours ago

No it didn’t…. Like 1.5ish

TheAmazingRace 2 hours ago

I gotta be honest... what's it take to be an employee at a company that makes you a millionaire so fast? I gotta find that. I've worked at a variety of other start ups and it's been a dead end every time.

  • codeduck 1 hour ago

    Luck, mate. It takes luck.

    • m4rtink 35 minutes ago

      I'm quite worried all those people who got lucky will do with their new money & resulting power.

      Especially because of the way they got it I have no expectations of using it wisely & without much damage.

cmiles8 5 hours ago

I’m honestly worried about the irrational exuberance in the market right now. It’s outright scary. This feels like 2007 or 1999.

I hope employees are able to cash some out to get the reward they deserve, but the fundamentals don’t look good here. And to be clear they’d be selling to folks that are unlikely to see upside.

This quote from Margin Call feels applicable here:

Sam Rogers: The real question is: who are we selling this to?

John Tuld: The same people we've been selling it to for the last two years, and whoelse ever would buy it.

Sam Rogers: But John, if you do this, you will kill the market for years. It's over.

[John nods grimly]

Sam Rogers: And you're selling something that you know has no value.

John Tuld: We are selling to willing buyers at the current fair market price.

[Sam lowers his gaze]

John Tuld: So that we may survive.

Sam Rogers: You would never sell anything to any of those people ever again.

John Tuld: I understand.

  • coliveira 5 hours ago

    They're trying to offload all this into retail and pension funds and line their pockets after all this hype campaign. We should be very worried with money in the market for the next months.

    • ForHackernews 5 hours ago

      Didn't some of the indexing firms recently decide to hold the line that your company must have been profitable in order to be part of the index?

      Thank god.

    • bpodgursky 5 hours ago

      They are only floating about 6% of the company. If this was a cash grab they could have gone vastly bigger (in total raise) at a lower valuation.

      • wonnage 5 hours ago

        It’s a cash grab for their shareholders and investors, not just the company. I’ve been through a couple of big tech company IPOs and have never seen one with such a short lockup expiration

      • asdfman123 4 hours ago

        Maybe they didn't want to make it look like a cash grab.

      • coliveira 4 hours ago

        They only needed 6% to cover the initial investors. The remaining will be selling next.

  • diskzero 5 hours ago

    The lock-ups are specified in the S-1. "Non-founder directors, officers, and certain current or former employees or consultants" can sell up to 10% of shares they hold on day one. Just who those "certain" current of former employees are isn't clear.

    Others can sell in waves beginning 27 days from the filing of the IPO prospectus.

    Founders can transfer 29% of their stock 180 days after trading begins, with the rest of their holdings after a full year.

    I have been through a couple of IPOs and the 180 day rule was the one I remember. We were totally locked out. At the time of the IPOs of those companies, we also didn't have the same secondary markets that are present today.

    This seems like a very good deal for employees to get some liquidity.

    • camdenreslink 4 hours ago

      6 months is standard as far as I know. This seems like a very good deal for employees.

  • MikhailTal 5 hours ago

    > And you're selling something that you know has no value.

    No, this is cope. The difference with CDOs and llms, is that either you like it or not, they have massive value. They can already automate most of the boring white collar work. Fewer and fewer human decisions remain. They are not perfect, but they are improving massively. The value is there, people are hooked+ brain rotting, they will be dependent forever

    • cmiles8 4 hours ago

      The value of proprietary models is rapidly tending towards zero. So the quote isn’t entirely off.

      The only money to be made is in selling compute and Anthropic rents all that.

  • ac29 5 hours ago

    >I'm honestly worried about the irrational exuberance in the market right now. It’s outright scary.

    $2T is a big number but this Anthropic IPO has been straight down since open, so I wouldnt say the market has gone completely insane.

  • nilkn 4 hours ago

    The market is down. Anthropic is up.

    I expect this will be the general trend. Not every day, but broadly over time. Anthropic will slowly at first, then quickly just capture most of the US economy. $2T is low for the first company in history on that trajectory.

    • dgellow 4 hours ago

      The market cap didn’t reach $2T. Their headline is wrong. It reached $1.5T and has been dipping

      • nilkn 4 hours ago

        Does it matter for what I wrote? Not at all. Basically irrelevant. I said the market is down and Anthropic is up. And, indeed, the market is down and Anthropic is up.

        • dgellow 1 hour ago

          It isn’t up in any meaningful way, and it communicates that you do not understand the basics of the topic you’re talking about. An IPO is literally financially engineered to pop… that’s why the float is so low and their partners (the hyperscalers) committed to invest billions in the IPO, to make it pop and sustain the price. That’s what the banks are literally hired for. The stock opened around $115 and is right now at $96.18.

  • asdfman123 4 hours ago

    I hate to play the pessmist, but I believe the AI boom will go the same way the 90s internet boom did: the bubble will collapse thanks to premature overvaluation, but the technology will eventually prove itself and transform society.

    It will also go like the 2007 crash: once all the layoffs happen, employers will realize that they can do the same work with a fraction of the workforce, thanks to automation. It will be a jobless recovery.

    So we may get the crash AND the AI takeover. I just hope governments are able to respond fast enough to radical societal changes.

    • rwyinuse 4 hours ago

      This is what I believe as well. Neither Anthropic, OpenAI nor Alphabet have any moat when it comes to the technology. All have models close enough to each other, and switching costs are low. The valuation here doesn't make much sense, even though the tech itself is solid.

    • olejorgenb 3 hours ago

      > but the technology will eventually prove itself and transform society.

      Are anyone really doubting this part?

      • asdfman123 3 hours ago

        Tons of people are. Lots of people are in deep denial about it.

up2isomorphism 5 hours ago

It is THE cash out time if you can.

  • nomel 5 hours ago

    Related, how does a company survive something like this? A considerable portion of the talent now no longer has requirement to work.

    • diskzero 5 hours ago

      There is always someone else waiting in line and no single person is irreplaceable. I know this comment sounds flippant, but this scenario has happened many times.

      From personal experience, I have worked with many IPO and stock option multi-millionaires who keep driving down the 101 and 280 every day to go to work. They could quit at anytime.

      • tomjakubowski 3 hours ago

        Sounds a bit like beating the game, and then coming back for NG and NG+.

    • 1-6 5 hours ago

      Your shares won't vest if you don't work.

      • fl4regun 3 hours ago

        if you've already been working there for 4 years - you vested a lot of your shares. I think the comment is worried about people who have been there 2-4 years already

    • zoeysmithe 5 hours ago

      Most people never feel like they have enough money. Once you join the capital owning class the game now becomes about getting more. The fabled "I'm going to quit and live on an island if I ever make $1m" almost never happens. If you made $5m today on this IPO, you're thinking of what it takes to make $50m. If you made $50m, you're thinking of what it takes to make $500m. None of these people are just going to go into permanent vacation mode. I mean some might, especially if they are near retirement age, but most personality types will continue to work in some form, either continue their executive position at anthropic or start doing AI or other tech startups.

      People who find themselves in a big tech IPO tend to not be the type of people who want to retire at 30 and drink pina coladas at some beach resort 24/7. They'll be bored, feel they are "not in the game" anymore, worry about wasted potential, worried about becoming unhealthy with a hedonistic lifestyle, etc. They just have a lot more financial freedom now.

      Long story short, we live in a capitalist society and when you have capital it opens up a new level to the game of life. People will want to play that game and do more. Evolution made us to work, be communal, create, do things, etc. Cash-out, drop-out, and live a questionable lifestyle at various tourist-heavy tropical countries John Mcaffee-style is really unappealing to a vast majority of people. I'd certainly still work in some fashion if this happened to me even if I crave a vacation lifestyle. I'd be too bored. I'd probably take a lot more vacations and probably start my own companies, but essentially I'd love to keep making things.

      • nolamark 3 hours ago

        Well, back in my day (aka dot com era)...

        I guess I'm the almost never happens. I had my "enough" defined before I took my job at the company that IPO's. Retirement was not to a beach resort but a University Town. Did lots of volunteer work. Took lots of classes. A lot of living my life did happen.

        Can't say that boredom has ever entered the picture, I can invent interesting projects to pursue faster than I can finish them.

        There are lots of alternatives to drinking pina coladas all day that are far more interesting than making more money, and making even more money for someone else.

        Many of DIY MBA books I've read have some version of a story of some entrepreneur encountering a fisherman, trying to convince them to raise capital to expand their business... which leads the fisherman on a long trail that led them back to fishing and spending time with friends and family, right where they started. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anekdote_zur_Senkung_der_Arbei... https://paulocoelhoblog.com/2015/09/04/the-fisherman-and-the... https://bemorewithless.com/the-story-of-the-mexican-fisherma...

      • rfgplk 2 hours ago

        > Most people never feel like they have enough money. Once you join the capital owning class the game now becomes about getting more. The fabled "I'm going to quit and live on an island if I ever make $1m" almost never happens. If you made $5m today on this IPO, you're thinking of what it takes to make $50m. If you made $50m, you're thinking of what it takes to make $500m. None of these people are just going to go into permanent vacation mode. I mean some might, especially if they are near retirement age, but most personality types will continue to work in some form, either continue their executive position at anthropic or start doing AI or other tech startups.

        Sadly, the value of money has been hard-refuted numerous times already. The most valuable things currently don't exist, and as such, they cannot even have a price. By modern understanding of the laws of physics it's questionable whether they _can_ exist (they can, but people aren't intelligent enough to realize it).

      • longhorizon 2 hours ago

        Enough is a number that can get worked out, but leaving out key items can make it seem like you will never have enough: health insurance before 65, tax-deferred vs tax-free money, RMDs. Spending can change year-to-year, maybe on purpose to ride out bad markets. It is engrained to chase the next dollar, but life is short.

    • tayo42 4 hours ago

      I have a feeling a lot of the people at this company are doing what they want to be. Maybe some support roles like hr and finance leave but the core part is this specific research and companies goal

    • Jonathanvw 4 hours ago

      You could say the same about Nvidia, and they were doing just fine. With Jensen gone, that may change, but that's unrelated.

    • potatototoo99 39 minutes ago

      You are asking this on a website of mostly very affluent western SWE. Many people have more money than they really require to survive, but their requirements expand with availability. Lifestyle creep, anxiety about the future, greed, who knows.

vcryan 5 hours ago

Enjoy it while it lasts!

123401186 5 hours ago

I have PSTD from watching the thief with his spastic grin ring the Nasdaq bell.

He stole all our IP and now wants to make us unemployed. His bankers pumped up the price from 9:30-12:00 in non public trading to $111. Now the thieves sell off slowly during the day.

  • semiquaver 4 hours ago

    I’m sorry that you see the world this way. It must make for a lot of sadness.

    • 12376as 4 hours ago

      Sorry that you have never created anything in your whole life and are living vicariously through Amodei who is living vicariously through the people he stole from.

      • joquarky 3 hours ago

        > Sorry that you have never created anything in your whole life

        What does this lash out accomplish? Your bitterness is in your sleeve and it comes across as immature.

      • bvcp 2 hours ago

        you stole ip from everyone you ever learnt anything from who you didnt pay. every borrowed book you read, every conversation etc. your whole identity is a distillation ip theft.

    • alksdeef 11 minutes ago

      Better than whatever kind of inhuman blind monster you are.

  • supern0va 4 hours ago

    The wildest thing to me through the AI boom has been watching the sort of folks I imagine are likely to have a copy of Free Culture on their bookshelves suddenly start acting like a frothing record exec during the Napster era.

    • orangecat 4 hours ago

      Yes. And really, not even the RIAA would argue that learning from copyrighted material constitutes infringement, since that would result in an infinite stream of lawsuits among all of their members.

  • senko 4 hours ago

    The worst trick that Devil evil pulled is convincing the world that IP is a thing.

    IP, and copyright in particular, is a scourge upon the land and a violation of our freedom to think. I honestly believe we would all be much happier had the concept never been invented.

    Want to keep your intellectual output to yourself? Keep it a trade secret!

    • hnav 4 hours ago

      Except they're cracking down on distillation so obviously they consider model outputs to be IP.

      • senko 4 hours ago

        I think they're aiming for "violation of ToS", but yeah, that's really hypocritical, and I wish the distillers all the best.

    • jryan49 3 hours ago

      How do practically support creators without it though?

      • senko 2 hours ago

        Do you support your favorite creator because of IP? Or because you're a fan?

        • saturn8601 1 hour ago

          From what I have seen online and talking to people at conferences, a notable portion of potential customers for Everdrives went to the chinese copies that ripped off the source code and stuffed it into their own cart. There is no loyalty to the 'creator', people just want to solve their problem for the cheapest possible price and that theft allows the Chinese to skip the actual costly portion of the product development. (Spending years researching and developing proper software).

      • rfgplk 2 hours ago

        As the value of IP tends towards zero, _so does the value of everything else_. Even simple economics rules dictate this, feel free to ask any LLM what happens to price if the supply becomes infinite (countably or uncountably, makes no difference) and demand is finite, with no way of ever reaching infinity. Hint, it's zero. Not "close to zero", _zero_. We are about to enter a world of obscene abundance, where value will only be dictated by human creativity.

        Here's an excerpt;

           Sir, if every good and service in an economy has infinite supply, while demand for each remains finite, and we retain the assumptions of perfect competition, unrestricted access, and zero marginal cost, then the result is profound:
           
           The market ceases to have an economic function as a mechanism for allocating scarce goods.
           
           This is the limiting case of a post-scarcity economy.
        • saturn8601 1 hour ago

          How do you make matter abundant? I could understand anything that has 0 marginal cost of copies but 'atoms'?

    • pigpag 3 hours ago

      How to keep your movie, book, song, etc. secret while making a living as a professional?

      • senko 2 hours ago

        The abolition of IP (or more narrowly, copyright, which is what all the above rely on), would be a monumental task and I don't pretend to have the answers, but here's a few things that come to mind:

        * songs - Most artists don't make a living as a professional from royalty either. Most earn it via live gigs, and there are now platforms where fans can support the artists they love, that don't depend on IP.

        * books - Most book authors don't make a living by writing books, either. That said, I do believe the same or similar platforms can be used for non-audio works.

        * movies - Most people don't make movies, Hollywood makes movies. I don't care how the next Marvel movie is financed, tbh. That said, people still pay for the big screen experience: you can keep the film (or a digital original) a trade secret, ban cams in theatres, all without relying on IP.

        Do we all have to endure the insanity of IP so that Taylor Swift can continue to earn gazillions 70 years after she dies (hopefully, far in the future), or to watch seventy-sixth installment of Marvel once-upon-a-time-was-blockbuster?

      • thallium205 1 hour ago

        Ask the fashion industry. No IP protections afforded!

    • nater5000 24 minutes ago

      The people aren't ready for this idea. Almost ironically, AI is forcing a lot of people to confront some of the implications of IP being senseless. You can tell it's causing literal existential crises for some people as they try to reconcile how the most valuable products they've built an identity around can just be manufactured by machines now. Maybe it will usher in an era where people will start to recognize that information is just a commodity, and allowing corporations to induce artificial scarcity of information isn't actually good for consumers.

thraway3837 4 hours ago

Wild. Saw the tweet: https://x.com/KobeissiLetter/status/2123454759118024840

1. 7 Co-Founders: ~$20+ billion each 2. Several early employees: $1+ billion each 3. 598 employees: $100+ million each 4. 2,800 employees: $1+ million each 5. Total employee equity wealth: $232 billion 6. Employee stock option gains: $119 billion

San Francisco’s median single-family home sale price jumped +29% year over year to $2.39 million in October amid the IPO process.

This marks the largest jump in San Francisco's media home price since February 2018.

Thousands of new millionaires will be minted today.

Great day to be an ANT employee if you are in one of those groups. Life changing and multi generational wealth and early retirement.

  • jansport123 2 hours ago

    it blows my mind that 8 million people live in the bay area and roughly 1 million people live in SF and 500 people becoming rich can drastically change the housing market. god damn, build more housing.

    • IAmGraydon 1 hour ago

      That's because they spend that money, so it ends up in the hands of a LOT more people than just 500.

    • orphereus 1 hour ago

      Now when you put it that way, it does sound completely insane.

  • thr0w 1 hour ago

    I thought these numbers would be much higher for the bottom groups. Where is the 598 vs. 2.8k split from?

dude250711 5 hours ago

Congratulations to all the hard-working Anthropic employees and all the investors who understood their potential early! Thank you for the amazing products!

  • belval 5 hours ago

    They really found their niche, from Claude chat being not very well known and written off against ChatGPT, to Claude Code taking over the market.

    Not sure why this was downvoted, are we angry at people building transformative products now? Or at startups making it big on their exits?

    • devindotcom 5 hours ago

      A little cheerleading is not out of place but I think you may be slightly papering over the controversies attending major AI companies

    • rglullis 5 hours ago

      > are we angry at people building transformative products now?

      When these products are built by skirting the law, yes.

      When its leadership keeps pushing for regulatory action to stop competition on its track, very much.

      When their product allows them to collect the upside but do not give them any responsibility for the downsides, of course.

      • jacquesm 3 hours ago

        You misspelled 'breaking'.

  • soundworlds 2 hours ago

    And for all their efforts, history will remember them terribly.

ddtaylor 4 hours ago

Congrats Anthropic and Claude.

moneycantbuy 5 hours ago

You are their exit liquidity.

  • azan_ 5 hours ago

    Then short the stock and you'll get rich.

    • jatora 5 hours ago

      please do this and report back.

    • sterlind 5 hours ago

      the market can remain irrational for longer than you can remain solvent.

      • dvt 5 hours ago

        Then buy long-dated puts and no need to worry about solvency. You'll be a billionaire in 3 years. I hate this kind of backseat driving constantly happening on HN, thinking that you're smarter than literally everyone else. If you truly believed in your position, you could make a ton of money off of it.

        The reality is that the situation is very complex, and saying "it's a bubble" or "insanity" or (Zitron's favorite) "you're the exit liquidity" just misses the forest for the trees. AI is clearly revolutionary, there's also some signs of it being a bubble, the market does seem to be less risk averse than 20 years ago, etc. It's all very muddy, and claiming otherwise with so much bravado is just dishonest.

        • KerrAvon 5 hours ago

          you're right, but that doesn't mean sterlind's quote is wrong

        • dragontamer 5 hours ago

          What about I continue on what I have been doing? Investing into companies that deserve the money more.

          Costco for example has done quite well this year. How has the AI trade with NVDA worked out this year in comparison?

          There's so many ways to make money the default answer of "I don't like this stock" is buying something else.

          A: I don't like milk.

          B: If you hate milk so much, then borrow someone else's milk and then sell it!!

          A: Wtf? No. I'll buy orange juice instead.

        • kvuj 4 hours ago

          Most people that parrot these quotes don't genuinely believe in them. They just chase the validation from others.

        • zrn900 4 hours ago

          The US Treasury is literally manipulating money markets to force crypto exchanges to buy US Treasuries to shore up the bond market right now. They are selling everything they have to buy bonds and it's causing a crash in all markets as a result.

          So no. None of those 'do this specific thing that should be sane by the science of economy' arguments work. Some powerful institution can just f*ck up your plans just because.

        • vatsachak 4 hours ago

          Who is offering a long dated put on ANT at 83$?

      • azan_ 5 hours ago

        Or maybe market is rational and you are just wrong?

        • cmrdporcupine 5 hours ago

          We live in a society that defines rationality as whatever the market says, so sure.

          • azan_ 5 hours ago

            What? No, we don't!

        • KerrAvon 5 hours ago

          It's really not. what fundamental business does Anthropic have that justifies $2T?

          You can say Anthropic as a financial instrument is worth $2T, but then you head into irrational financial bullshit territory where there's a nontrivial chance a lot of people are going to jail.

          • matwood 5 hours ago

            If one believes AI is a humanity changing technology and anthropic will remain one of the key players, then 2T isn’t crazy. But that’s a very particular future that must happen.

    • afavour 5 hours ago

      The market can’t be trusted to be sane, IMO. e.g. Tesla’s stock price makes no sense. It seemed like surely sanity would prevail and it would come down. But it hasn’t. It’s a meme stock divorced from real world performance.

      • mcast 4 hours ago

        To be fair, Tesla/SpaceX is not 1 USB drive snuck into China away from losing it's SOTA moat overnight. Even if its FSD autonomous models leak, they are strongly coupled to the vehicle sensors. They also have a deeply embedded manufacturing and fabrication supply chain with the US government.

  • jrflo 5 hours ago

    Is there any news of Dario/others selling shares? Now that it's public they need to disclose publicly ~90 days in advance if they plan to do so. If not then this isn't exit liquidity...

    • cmrdporcupine 5 hours ago

      Those (Dario, board members, etc) aren't the people worth watching or probably the people the commenters is talking about. It's the investors into Anthropic themselves who bankrolled everything up to this point. They're going to want their profits now.

    • MisterMunchkin 5 hours ago

      Yes they all dumped as part of the IPO, it was a mix of founder shares and new shares.

      • doctorpangloss 5 hours ago

        i forgive you, this is a little complicated. the founders made money from secondaries - in total, across the two secondary sales, some portion (maybe nearly all) of $4.6 billion was from the founders.

        in this IPO, all 7 founders are subject to two lockups for ALL of their shares: 180 days, then they can sell 29%, 365 days, the remainder. only ordinary employees can sell 10% of their vested RSUs / exercise options today, which will be about $400m if everyone sold and everyone got the biggest offer anthropic gives employees, but will be closer to $25m given what the actual rate of hiring (and therefore vesting) and awards were.

    • kccqzy 4 hours ago

      Employees have lockup periods. The people who are selling the shares today are the existing external investors, think angel investors and VCs.

fantasizr 5 hours ago

all it took was the 'largest theft of labor' and some revolutionary algorithms.

  • stuxnet79 5 hours ago

    > all it took was the 'largest theft of labor'

    Of which they only paid a $1.5 billion penalty. A pittance compared to the $80 billion they are raising and the $2T price that the market is valuing them at. Certainly a lesson to learn for future entrepreneurs ...

  • AISnakeOil 5 hours ago

    Is it really theft of labor if the asset was on the open internet to begin with?

    There is no global copyright law that governs ownership of digital goods. If it goes online, then you should expect it to be copied, pirated and widely distributed.

    Anthropic, Google or OpenAI are not responsible for the mishandling of your copyrighted content that was publicly available on the web.

    • fantasizr 4 hours ago

      They chose to use illegal torrent sites. Because it was easy to access technologically does not mean it's not theft.

      • AISnakeOil 3 hours ago

        Yes, that was wrong of them and there are lawsuits to deal with it.

        Just because it is wrong and illegal, does not change the fact that the data has been made available and distilled into open weight models and now every lab likely has used the data in some form directly or indirectly.

        Cat's out of the bag and there's no going back. Back to my original point, the data is out there. China would do the same thing and not get in trouble.

        • fantasizr 3 hours ago

          Sure, but now a couple get to be billionaires because they're the best at looting? Best I can hope for is that China makes it essentially a free utility for all.

      • joquarky 3 hours ago

        If they didn't want it stolen, then they should have made backups.

PowerElectronix 4 hours ago

Perfect timing for cashing out, tbh. Some AI hype still ongoing despite the heavy selloff, good plumped up numbers for the next quarter ER, and then the abyss of all the capex to come in the next few years, the revenue that is growing as expected, maybe hardware demand softening and allowing people to get local solutions...

misiek08 1 hour ago

The Big Short (2015) :D

Fingers crossed that after IPO Anthropic will keep the pace and way of making products.

dmchk 4 hours ago

Crazy that google released a better model yesterday & its anthropic is still so hyped. And google is still down.

  • ex-aws-dude 3 hours ago

    I wonder if a lot of retail investors still think OAI/ANT have some secret sauce

stasomatic 3 hours ago

I don't know, is Claude going to take my blood test and perform an MRI like I had done this week? Or grow tomatoes and ranch cattle? Give me a haircut? Replace my toilet?

We don't know how much this crap costs anyway, my $20 sub is super subsidized. When they crank the dial to the true cost of tokens, we'll see what' what.

I better tune up my compound bow and oil the guns, jic.

jayd16 2 hours ago

I'm happy to see the IPO from the perspective of waiting for the shoe to drop. Hopefully this means more money moves from 'wait and see' and back into actually making products to sell.

melbourne_mat 2 hours ago

Opened at $110, closed at $97. I thought stocks were supposed to go up? I'm sure the founders and early investors are thrilled though!

pizzathyme 3 hours ago

Wouldn't have gotten there without all our token spend. Congratulations everyone we did it.

HAL9500TURBO 3 hours ago

Can't wait until even more investor pressure leads to even more acceleration and even less caring about AI safety. Seeing Dario and his sister talk on the Nasdaq podium felt surreal to me, actual Cyberpunk territory, the kind of thing you wouldn't want to see combined (AI + stock market pressure). The worst thing is, even though we might actually get killed by AI (death by stock market, if you will), using Claude is extremely fun, and I'm waiting a Fable 5.2 compile and test job as we speak. I will vibecode my last years alive into oblivion. I haven't written any code by hand in over a year now, and frankly I don't miss it all that much. In case we do not get killed by AI, I still think we might hit the top of the S-curve and open weight models might soon start being enough, at least for software. I just don't see a world where Anthropic truly becomes a labor monopoly, which this kind of valuation is implying right now.

HarHarVeryFunny 4 hours ago

Interesting that the founding ANTs were all wearing orange Clawd (the Claude Code crab mascot) lapel badges at NASDAQ, rather than a Claude butthole badge.

outside1234 5 hours ago

We'll see how long that valuation holds for them. My bet is "not long"

insane_dreamer 2 hours ago

in the meantime, s&p500 is down ~2% today; I care a lot more about that number than I don't Anthropic's share price

update: dow, nasdaq; russell2000; gold, all down ~2% so far today

sorry, what's the good news again?

dodger-dog 3 hours ago

Let’s ignore for a moment that this is the largest IPO in history. Anthropic’s performance after the opening bell can only be described with one word: embarrassing. They should have never went public.

scotty79 4 hours ago

How many billions of dollars will Anthropic earn selling the stock it just printed?

moneycantbuy 3 hours ago

Now I'll never be able to afford to live in San Francisco.

ex-aws-dude 3 hours ago

Does making money on this stock rely on the assumption that AI consumes every industry that exists?

Like what's a realistic multiplier it could go up at this point?

  • IAmGraydon 1 hour ago

    At this point, stock prices have almost nothing to do with how much money the company makes. It's simply about vibes and marketing. That's the whole thing. People who keep talking about valuation vs revenue are thinking about the old stock market.

rvz 5 hours ago

All the early investors thank you for participating in an IPO which you bought their shares for a measly 1.3x gain while the smart private money made off with over 1,000x on their money as I said before [0].

IPOs these days are not the same as they were 10 years ago. Now, there is less of an upside and the early investors will sell 10% on to retail while you buy at its inflated price.

You are being used as their exit liquidity.

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50555138

  • MisterMunchkin 5 hours ago

    Why would you let the poors make money? Just keep bidding it up until all your friends are in, then dump it on the market at peak price.

  • furytrader 5 hours ago

    I think the big difference over the past 20+ years is that regulations like Sarbanes-Oxley have made it much more expensive to be a public company, so companies are waiting longer to go public.

    • matwood 4 hours ago

      And the private markets have so much liquidity. The only reason to ipo now is to cash out or the private markets dry up (which also says something).

    • jurgenburgen 4 hours ago

      The JOBS act of 2012 made the limit at which you have to start reporting financial info higher. Previously it was 500 shareholders, now 2000. When you start reporting you may as well IPO.

tinyhouse 4 hours ago

Way better AI plays on the market today. You have AMD for example at <800B market cap. Good luck if you prefer Anthropic at $1.7T marketcap or whatever it's gonna be tomorrow. Of course, it's not about market cap alone, do your research if it's worth it.

freecodeio 6 hours ago

aaaand it's back to 1.5T

  • jrflo 5 hours ago

    Still up 20% from IPO price

    • Creamsicle47 5 hours ago

      1.2T now

      • jrflo 5 hours ago

        That's not the fully diluted number. At IPO price it was 1.5T fully diluted, that number is up to 1.7T now.

        • bel8 5 hours ago

          So from 2T start to 1.7T now?

          • jrflo 4 hours ago

            1.5T start -> 2T when secondary market opened -> 1.7T now

          • camdenreslink 4 hours ago

            What's a measly $300B between friends?

    • dofm 5 hours ago

      Of course it is. If the underwriter can't get the stock to shoot up in the pre-opening phase that sets the trading price, they shouldn't be underwriters at all. It's an entirely engineered process until the opening bell on day one, and the underwriters engineer it.

      Especially since this is a tiny percentage of the business on sale — 5%? 10%?

      • HarHarVeryFunny 5 hours ago

        Looks like they had to step in pretty hard to defend it at 12:19 at ~$95.5, and now it's just below that level- set a new low for the day < $95.

        Edit: Another huge buying spike at 1:09 pm at same $95.5 level, but not enough to stop it continuing to slide for it's low so far just below $93.

        • dofm 5 hours ago

          According to the Beeb, employees can sell up to 10% of their holding today so I guess that is part of what is going on?

          But then everything about today — the muted reaction, the lack of people losing their minds over a new era — feels more like relief (someone got to IPO) than jubilation.

          As a sort of pragmatic cynic, I find it rather reassuring.

          • HarHarVeryFunny 4 hours ago

            It seems there is very little founder/employee selling happening today. The IPO itself was 97.5% company shares and 2.5% (23M shares worth roughly $2B) shareholders, for a total of ~$80B.

            Compare that to the $140B owned by the founders, and $200B+ by employees.

            I don't know when employee RSUs/options become sellable, but I'm guessing the only employee selling today is part of those 23M shares included as part of the IPO.

    • afavour 5 hours ago

      That’s very deliberate. If they price the IPO such that it immediately it’s a public relations disaster.

      • HarHarVeryFunny 5 hours ago

        It's not just the pricing - the underwriter will buy the stock if needed to prop it up to try to make sure it looks like a success.

        They go into the opening with a short position, which they can close out by buying to defend the stock. If the stock goes up rather than down, then they have a "greenshoe" option to buy more shares at IPO price to close the short.

        • dofm 4 hours ago

          Thanks for fleshing this out a bit.

  • jckahn 5 hours ago

    Pathetic

    /s

mbgerring 3 hours ago

I think I speak for a lot of people when I say that this feels like a dark day. As an SF resident, the most likely outcome of all of this wealth creation is people I love and care about losing their homes. I still don’t understand what the benefit of AI is supposed to be, and what I see is a disastrous job market and people I know being unemployed for up to a year or more with no end in sight. Increased electricity demand for data centers is driving increases in carbon emissions, we’re about to blow past 1.5deg of warming, and the new elite consensus is “who cares, AI will fix it.”

Dark day today, dark days ahead.

  • darkwizard42 3 hours ago

    As an SF resident you should perhaps direct more fury that for the last 6 years housing construction and availability has been so miserably low.

    It has been a complete self own by our own city!

    • mbgerring 3 hours ago

      In the last 6 years a lot of laws were changed to make housing construction easier, and yet, the housing production did not happen. Whose fault is that?

      • xvector 2 hours ago

        SF residents have only themselves to blame.

      • t-writescode 2 hours ago

        As for most things, there’s not a singular fault. It’s easy to point at a macro issue and want to have someone to blame, but it’s almost certainly a mix of features.

        The issue may be less “whose fault is it” (to what, punish?) but instead “how do we incentivize / encourage / command change?”

      • google234123 2 hours ago

        It is 100% the governments fault. Literally no one else. There are innumerable examples rn of places building plenty of examples. Even more if look through history. Ask Claude to asummerize all the rules and laws that make it difficult to build housing in Sf

      • linkregister 1 hour ago

        SF residents repeatedly elect supervisors who defy state housing laws. There's a reason why the Builders Remedy is being invoked for the skyscraper in Sunset. That wouldn't have happened if supervisors weren't arbitrarily blocking housing.

    • willchis 2 hours ago

      Doesn't really matter how cheap your rent is if your income is 0.

  • itkovian_ 3 hours ago

    It’s important to internalize the world has no obligation to be fair. A lot follows from this - but one thing is you don’t get emotional about the tech and try to deny its usefulness. Otherwise it leads you to being wrapped up in self condradictory loops (e.g. largest ipo in history == not clear if there is base value creation here), which ends up leading to even more stress since your subconscious knows it’s not correct.

    Have to accept reality and act, is simple but not easy.

    • mbgerring 3 hours ago

      Having watched the rise and fall of crypto, it is not at all clear to me that large amounts of money being invested into something are a reliable signal that any value is being created. Moreover, it is obvious to me that capitalism is indifferent to whether any activity is socially valuable, only whether it generates more capital.

      The valuation of Anthropic is based on the premise that it will enable the owners of capital to fire their most expensive employees. That’s me. All I have to sell is my labor. If no one is buying, I don’t eat. It doesn’t matter how useful the technology is — the future it’s building is one that has no place for me or anyone I know. Not sure what I’m supposed to do with that.

      • seki285 2 hours ago

        >If no one is buying, I don’t eat.

        In a different world, AI enabled you to no longer needing to worry about putting food on the table. You'd be given a chance to focus on what you wanted instead. I suggest you read the Culture series by Banks, it gives a optimistic view of (true) AI.

        • 9dev 1 hour ago

          That world is not the one we live in however. Our world is the one where I need to eat.

          • seki285 10 minutes ago

            Yeah, I know. I was hoping we'd see a world where AI bring post scarcity but instead all the focus is on capital generated. Not exactly sure what value there is in delivering features faster on product X.

      • DebtDeflation 50 minutes ago

        >The valuation of Anthropic is based on the premise that it will enable the owners of capital to fire their most expensive employees.

        "The underlying purpose of AI is to allow wealth to access skill while removing from the skilled the ability to access wealth."

    • Karupan 2 hours ago

      > largest ipo in history == not clear if there is base value creation here

      You’re assuming the market or billionaires or the government behave logically.

      • DrewADesign 1 hour ago

        And assuming it’s actual value for the economy at large and not a phenomenally successful exit plan for the rich people that dumped a bunch of money into a company that may have hit peak profitability last year. That is really not at all clear.

  • paxy 2 hours ago

    I used to be sympathetic, but at this point SF residents have only themselves to blame. Given the tech boom and ensuing housing demand over the last 30+ years the city should have looked like New York or Chicago or Shenzhen today. But people are under the delusion that they live in a quaint little suburb and don't want to do anything to spoil the "character". Well then if you don't give others a place to live they will eventually have to outbid you for your house. What other choice do they have?

    • mbgerring 2 hours ago

      The founder of SF YIMBY used to be my roommate. I’ve voted in every election since 2014 to make housing construction easier. It’s 2026, the rent is still going up, and evictions are increasing again. SF just handed its mayor dictatorial powers to fix this problem, and I don’t know a single person who believes it’s going to get better.

      • shuckles 2 hours ago

        You should seek help if you think the San Francisco mayor has "dictatorial powers."

        • maddie0 1 hour ago

          I should like to respectfully suggest that there are more-HN-guidelines-friendly ways to question the extent to which the recent city reforms qualify as "dictatorial". Perhaps it is rhetorically exxagerated, but so is your own post. Worse, "you should seek help" is belittling, and dismissive... and medicalizing political dissent is itself a tool of dictatorship.

      • bjustin 1 hour ago

        Did housing construction get easier?

  • soundworlds 2 hours ago

    Agreed, I've watched friends in multiple industries lose joy in their jobs, and lose hope for the future, due to the actions of AI companies.

    My own hope was re-established on Open Weights AI levelling the playing field, but they've managed to steal the global chip supply, undermining that too.

    I'll go out on a limb and say, even if AI does cure cancer (a big if), was it really worth the loss of meaning/purpose for millions of people along the way?

    • rbn3 2 hours ago

      >even if AI does cure cancer (a big if), was it really worth the loss of meaning/purpose for millions of people along the way?

      yes, at least for the billionnaires who won't have to worry about cancer any longer.

    • j1elo 2 hours ago

      Consider it a tax in happines. We lose a part so less lucky people can enjoy some of a decent life. If that happened, hopefully with other hugely impactful diseases following up not late afterwards, it would have been worth it. We are after all in a whole societal-level revolution, and like any industrial revolution before, changing the ways we live will hurt lots of people living through the change. In 100 years they will probably study the pre-AI age with awe and curiosity, like we ourselves look at times before penicillin or airplanes.

      Regardless... All that is a huge "if", and I'm personally skeptical.

      • 2muchcoffeeman 2 hours ago

        - Cures diseases. - No one has a job so can’t afford treatment. - Profit.

        • j1elo 1 hour ago

          I'm sure similar comments have been said in public squares or society cafes (the old forums of yore) when some disruptive change was about to come. Not saying that I'm happy: surely it must have sucked to be a carriage driver (or any other of the thousand specialty trades affected) in the years after invention of the car.

          • munk-a 1 hour ago

            Oh it absolutely did, but usually when industries die off there are allowances made (or forced to happen by those getting the boot) for retraining and assistance. In our hyper-capitalist world those who missed the boat will just be left to drown.

    • ZetaReverie 2 hours ago

      i agree. The death of meaning is way more of a tragedy than most people acknowledge. Frustratingly, most seem to not care about it at all. If offered a world of mindless bliss, most would gladly take it, it seems… Utopia, dystopia, extinction, its the end of “humanity” no matter what.

      • fearthemachine 1 hour ago

        We’ve been working on destroying the social(!) and monetary value of anything but the very tippy-top best of artistic talent since mechanical reproduction of art became a thing.

        Kurt Vonnegut (Jr) wrote about this in more than one book. Someone good at dancing or singing or storytelling or sketching goes from performing that work for grateful family, friends, and community members, and maybe even making extra money or a living at it, to doing it alone (assuming motivation doesn’t collapse when nobody else cares) and always feeling like they’re bothering and being patronized by anyone they show their work to. The need for that kind of thing was scaled from enormous and constant, to so rare and small that it’s more something indulged than eagerly enjoyed.

        Vonnegut seemed rather worried about what psychological harm this had done to countless people who’d love to feel their work, even if not world-class, was really wanted or needed.

        • dovin 28 minutes ago

          I can definitely relate to this sentiment, but it also IMO ascribes far too much intention to technologies that have had lots of other benefits. Broadcast radio made it so we could have amazing storytellers have a much wider audience, but at the cost of making us need the storytellers in our own lives a little bit less. Google Maps means it's way easier to navigate an unfamiliar city, which means we don't have a culture of asking strangers for directions anymore. There's definitely something sad to that. And something that reminds me of how fragile our local communities can be.

          I do feel like you can take this kind of thinking too far. Like, I am glad that we don't live in the kind of dangerous world where wandering into an unfamiliar forest could lead to all sorts of ways of dying, even though that means I also don't need close personal relationships with warriors. Incidentally this is one reason I think that Tolkien's work still feels so relevant; it's a world that on a slow and inevitable decline which makes the characters struggling against that to carve out something decent for a while feel paradoxically more heroic.

          I like to think that we can choose to do bigger, more beautiful, more ambitious things with our time when we don't have so many basic needs that we're spending our time taking care of. I guess we'll see.

      • cdelsolar 1 hour ago

        the death of meaning? I am limited right now by my typing speed in terms of what things I can create with Opus. The world is our oyster. What are you talking about?

        • SchemaLoad 44 minutes ago

          For how long though? At some point you won't be adding any value and the agent will be prompting itself.

          • cdelsolar 42 minutes ago

            how will the agent know what I want to build?

            • collingreen 28 minutes ago

              The real question they are talking about is why, in that scenario, would anyone give a shit what YOU want to build. They aren't saying you aren't empowered they are saying your empowerment, alongside everyone else's, makes the result have no meaning.

              The vonnegut example wasn't that people don't dance anymore it was that people don't care about anything but top level skill/celebrity since it's easy to watch either one and why would you choose your neighbor.

            • SchemaLoad 22 minutes ago

              The question is more will anyone pay you for wanting the AI to do things. If you add no value in any way the money will just go direct to the AI companies.

        • alksdeef 25 minutes ago

          What can you create? Apps? B2B Service APIs? Like seriously this is so short sighted, this world is not virtual.

      • ojo-rojo 9 minutes ago

        I can't at all understand the lament of the death of meaning due to not having to go to a job. If I didn't have to get up and go to work I would have so much I could learn, so much to read, so many things I'm interested in just doing. A person's meaning does not have to come from the job their job.

      • georgemcbay 7 minutes ago

        > The death of meaning is way more of a tragedy than most people acknowledge.

        I agree that death of meaning is a tragedy, but I also think a lot of us can find plenty of meaning beyond our jobs.

        In an optimistic theoretical world where AI took my software dev job but I was sustained through some form of UBI I'd spend all my time doing things I do now in my spare time like volunteering at animal rescues and I'd be perfectly happy and find plenty of meaning in that volunteer work.

        Alas, I do not think it is likely that that is our future. Politically and economically we've shown no movement toward that.

        So if/when AI takes my job I'll probably have to spend less time than I do now volunteering and spend the majority of the rest of my days trying to cobble together a meager living doing whatever I can. Or perhaps I will turn to a life of crime.

    • xhevahir 2 hours ago

      People sure do love the cancer-cure argument. I would have thought that the possibility of geoengineering our way out of climate catastrophe would be a much more enticing prospect. After all cancer isn't threatening to wipe out billions of people in a matter of decades.

      • aaron_m04 1 hour ago

        I'll give that argument credence when I see Anthropic and OpenAI publish well-reasoned and practical roadmaps for getting us out of said catastrophe.

    • jimmyjazz14 2 hours ago

      Was the industrial revolution worth it, was factory automation worth it, did it make our lives better or worse? I would say better but I would be interested in your answer.

      • onemoresoop 1 hour ago

        It really depends on who you ask.

      • kakacik 1 hour ago

        All those created more jobs than they took. How many jobs have llms created vs how many they destroyed for good as we speak?

        This is shortsighted and dumb, but in highly capitalistic societies like US its the ideal thing. Poor get even poorer and more desperate, middle class moves to poor and those few rich can have armies of modern slaves for next to nothing... what is there not to love right.

        Every single person working on it in those labs is guilty. Stupid amount of money can blind even quite moral folks but money only gets you so far.

        • rootusrootus 55 minutes ago

          > All those created more jobs than they took. How many jobs have llms created vs how many they destroyed for good as we speak?

          This a question I'd like to see the answer to. Or at least an attempt. Is anyone seriously trying to track software jobs, or knowledge jobs in general, to see trends that might be attributable to LLMs?

      • pesus 1 hour ago

        Assuming this is even close to something like the Industrial Revolution in the long run (which I absolutely do not assume is true), a better question would be if you're willing to live like one of the workers back then that was replaced by a machine and forced into poverty and destitution. That's the real cost for millions of people.

        Except in this case, we're not even seeing the benefits of the Industrial Revolution. All we got was a way to pump out code faster.

        • jimmyjazz14 1 hour ago

          Yeah I'm not comparing it to the industrial revolution but if its a real thing it could change our lives for the better in time and if its not than most things will largely just return to a new kind of normal state. I guess either way nobody had a say in if we should start the various technical revolutions but they have at least so far always resulted in a better quality of life for more people.

          • pesus 1 hour ago

            A "new kind of normal" could very well be a much worse quality of life for the vast majority of people.

            • jimmyjazz14 1 hour ago

              real question, why do you assume that?

              • j_maffe 28 minutes ago

                Further concentration of wealth and power, for one.

              • collingreen 21 minutes ago

                I hate to be the other side of this empty coin but why assume things get better either? I think either claim could use some support and, very importantly, timeframe. Far futurists justifying suffering now in order to benefit the lives of future folks should be clearly discerned from benefits that are local in both space and time.

                Our current modern society benefits from the suffering of things like the Industrial Revolution or world war 2 but I would have hated to live through those transitional times and, if I had a magic wand choice I'm not sure I'd force others to do so in my place in order to have the benefit built upon their suffering.

                • jimmyjazz14 10 minutes ago

                  Technology advancements have generally made life better for people throughout history, that doesn't me it absolutely will in this case but if you can't imagine a better future how can you work towards one.

        • radicalbyte 57 minutes ago

          Oh it will be just like the industrial revolution. I grew up in the epicentre of that near Bristol; the works where the steam train was invented and scaled massively.

          I suspect these companies will fare just as well, only with far compressed timelines. Things move much faster nowadays.

          • kaffekaka 34 minutes ago

            What does you growing up in Bristol have to do with the way the current timeline will develop?

      • ux266478 1 hour ago

        The parasitic industrialists who leveraged technology to pay more productive workers less were not worth it, actually. We never needed to let them run rampant in the first place. It's a false dilemma. These labs should be nationalized and their IP should be distributed to the commons. Break up the hyperscalers, and bring hardware prices way down. No more centralization. No more SaaS models. Let's not do the same thing we did with the industrial revolution, where we waited 180 years to do something about the leeches centralizing all of society's capital.

      • wolfinterval 40 minutes ago

        This is the problem. The Luddites were not wrong when it came to their own lives.

        If you read about life in the early industrial revolution it was a nightmare.

        That is certainly not a time you want to be born. There was also no real payoff for your kids or grandchildren. The payoff was so long after.

        Almost surely people 100 years from now around the globe will have higher standards of living because of technology but this level of change we are all going to have to deal with is not going to be fun.

      • alksdeef 23 minutes ago

        Quality of life went down and hours worked went up, the industrial revolution was not good for the average worker.

    • joegibbs 1 hour ago

      Yes definitely it’s worth it. We can’t base society around preserving sense of purpose - realistically speaking so what if you’re the best programmer at a SaaS company that makes analytics dashboards? It’s a totally arbitrary thing to base your self-worth on.

      You can always find another sense of purpose, take up a sport or something. Become good at fishing. Maybe you’ll be a bit listless for a couple of years - much better than wasting away from bone cancer.

      • munk-a 1 hour ago

        I think you're severely under appreciating how devastating this will be for a large portion of the population.

        • FranzFerdiNaN 1 hour ago

          It will be devastating because we’ve been raising people in a world where self-worth is linked to having a job. Basically any other path has been obliterated by capitalism.

          • munk-a 1 hour ago

            Ain't that the truth. I'd much rather have DMing, storytelling or pondering of philosophy be the center piece of my life but these activities are cemented into my mind as recreational luxuries. To put bread on the table for my dependents I work the job.

        • joegibbs 23 minutes ago

          Hundreds of millions, possibly billions of people lost their jobs as farmers due to the Green Revolution, invention of the combine harvester and other advances in farming technology. Should we have stopped it, despite it saving the western world from famine?

          If I'm a subsistence farmer in Burkina Faso I will get far more meaning from my work than any western white-collar worker - if I don't do what I do then my whole family will starve to death - but that doesn't mean that it would be bad if they got the money to not have to do that.

      • pesus 1 hour ago

        Why is it worth it, though? Just saying it's worth it doesn't make it so.

        And being listless is a best case scenario when you lose your career. It's far more likely that they'll end up homeless, especially in the US where there's no real social safety net. That's not even mentioning health insurance, which is life or death for many. Bring any children in and the scenario is even more grim. I'm not seeing how this is worth it.

      • achierius 1 hour ago

        What about being able to eat, having a roof over your head, and the wherewithal to get healthcare when you need it? Are those needs 'arbitrary'? Assuming not, what do you have in mind for the people who want those things but no longer have access to the jobs necessary to acquire them?

      • tsunamifury 53 minutes ago

        No but you can not take such glee in destroying it.

        As with the destruction of journalism. It bites you in the ass in ways you never expected. The people get angry.

      • lbreakjai 48 minutes ago

        I never derived much of my self-worth from my job. I do however enjoy the ability to buy food and pay for shelter.

        I would love nothing more than to be a househusband, to take care of the kids, to keep the home clean and tidy, and to cook dinner for the entire family.

    • BeetleB 1 hour ago

      > Agreed, I've watched friends in multiple industries lose joy in their jobs, and lose hope for the future, due to the actions of AI companies.

      If you're my age or a bit older, the statement would have been true before 2020. Just replace "AI companies" with "SW companies". Or even just "technology."

      My (now retired) math professor hated computers. "In the old days, I'd write my tests/exam on paper, and the department secretary would type it up (with appropriate math symbols). Now I have to do it myself on the computer."

      Phone operators at switchboards were a thing.

    • cgio 13 minutes ago

      We all panic when things move, but it is the Red Queen, we always run just to stay where we are. I am not an AI apologist, but I want to address this as a concern, because meaning does not disappear, it just relocates. Maybe it was wrong from the outset to assign one's life meaning to their work, maybe it was right in its context and not anymore. Your question is still valid, though, in my eyes, in whether the stress and pain of that meaning relocation was worth it, and the question unfortunately is not answered by us, but by the people who actually make money out of this. We are voluntarily or less so parts of the system that brought us here.

  • Aperocky 2 hours ago

    Why so? All that tech debt remain to be paid. The hype did not translate to actual productivity, and amount of code generated is not productivity, it's sometimes the opposite.

    For assumed access to the best models and unlimited tokens, Claude Code is just whatever it is today. I'll take Pi over it any moment that it's not bundled with a API plan.

    30000 commits and so what? 10x the use of memory to come back with output that is barely english.

  • I_am_tiberius 2 hours ago

    Also, it's all based on the biggest theft in human history. The IPO somehow seems to legitimate the theft. I still hope people will go to prison for that at one point in time.

    • messh 2 hours ago

      since it was created by data from everybody basically ... everybody should get royalties is all

      • nicce 2 hours ago

        They even got away from pirating stuff. Did not need to delete the benefit of the crime...

      • chrischen 1 hour ago

        That’s already the case. Because the data was public, that’s the reason why there are so many LLM models out there that are almost all the same.

      • georgemcbay 1 hour ago

        > everybody should get royalties is all

        Paid by who, though?

        Anthropic has a very high valuation, but isn't yet a profitable company.

        And it is still entirely possible Anthropic gets wiped out by commoditized open weight models, that may or may not have included Anthropic model distillation as part of their training (which raises the question again of who pays the royalties in that situation as you move further away from the original data but still end up with usable models).

        Given the current structure of our economy there is a very real chance AI destroys a lot of value without having any clear long-term value capturing mechanism to offset the value destruction.

        To be clear, I'm not defending Anthropic here or saying that it wasn't theft for these companies to ingest all of this data into their models.

      • dgellow 1 hour ago

        I don’t want royalties, I want my data to be removed. The whole point of data ownership isn’t to be paid, it’s to control how they are used

    • throwup238 2 hours ago

      > Also, it's all based on the biggest theft in human history.

      Wait… what happened to centuries of imperialism?

      • Flatterer3544 2 hours ago

        Doesn't really count as theft when humanity didn't have anything to begin with

        • enraged_camel 1 hour ago

          People still had their lives, and their freedoms.

          • iamnothere 1 hour ago

            Those weren’t worth much before IP came along /s

      • Choad_20261104 2 hours ago

        or every war/conquest where victors acquired land & other resources

      • ijidak 1 hour ago

        Haha. Good call out.

        At first I thought, "True, perhaps this was amongst the top thefts" but yeah thousands of years of human empire building, colonization, resource extraction, and slave taking likely dominate the top 100 thefts in human history.

        Perhaps this is 101 on the list.

        To be clear most of the training, to me, is not theft if it's openly available to the average human to study themselves free of charge. In other words I can see the argument for AI training being available to the same training a human has access to.

        It's mainly if these tools were trained on content for which they were supposed to pay but did not. That, it would seem, is: unfair, concerning, and a double standard.

        But the powerful dominating the weak is kind of how this world has worked since the Sumerians first started their conquests.

        Humans have never graduated from the school of: might makes right.

      • pipes 1 hour ago

        Which empires? How far back do you want to go? Persian empire? Egyptian? Akkadian?

        • throwup238 35 minutes ago

          >> centuries of imperialism

          Are you under the mistaken impression that Persia or Egypt or Akkadia were imperial powers in the last five hundred years? Do you really think they reached the scale that even pre-modern empires did with cannons and muskets and seafaring?

          I’m thinking of the mines in Potosí and all the other silver in South America that minted pieces of eight which were the global currency for centuries, connecting every continent in trade and exploitation except Antarctica. Volumes that caused global hyperinflation and were so critical to royal budgets that a single failed treasure fleet transit could change the fortune of European empires nearly overnight.

          Or, you know, far closer to home: the theft of the entire American continent and the extermination of its indigenous people. Of which Anthropic is a direct beneficiary, being an American company.

      • noosphr 1 hour ago

        Op was on the right side of the bayonet in those cases so they didn't happen or were a very long time ago.

    • csallen 2 hours ago

      Theft can only happen with rivalrous goods. The entire reason why theft is bad is because when you take something from someone, they no longer have it. If I steal your apple, you can no longer eat your apple. That's theft. Pretty much no human cultures or societies look kindly upon theft.

      But if I could copy your apple and have an apple of my own, then you aren't being deprived, and meanwhile I'm better off. So it's a net good. Unless, of course, you wanted to profit off the fact that I was without. Then you might say that your monopoly and thus your profits were harmed.

      And this, of course, is not theft. It's copyright infringement.

      Unlike theft, the definition, ethics, justification, and acceptability of copyright laws are hotly debated and far from settled. The idea that being the first to express a particular thought/idea/whatever means that others should be restricted from doing so, or should have to pay you to do so, imo, does not make for a better society. And certainly isn't an incentive necessary to spur creation, at least in 99% of fields. Hundreds of years ago perhaps this was an open question, but in the modern world there can be no debate.

      I much prefer the creativity, riffing, and copying you see in software and the food industry, than to the cookie-licking and rent-seeking you see in other industries that lean more into this sort of thing.

      Even barring this, there's a lot to be debated about whether training/learning is violating the spirit of copyright.

      • platinumrad 2 hours ago

        I largely agree with you, but isn't it a bit unfair that Dario and friends get to be billionaires while translators, graphic designers, copywriters, etc. lose 80% of their labor power?

        • csallen 1 hour ago

          Personally, I don't think so.

          The market is competitive and it takes a lot to win. You have to have an exceptionally good product/service, and usually amazing marketing and distribution, among many other things. Otherwise, society isn't going to discover and value your work, and they aren't going to buy it.

          It's tautological, but: The people and approaches that are better at winning in the market end up making the most money, and the people and approaches that are worse at it end up earning less and going out of business.

          It's intentionally designed to be competitive, for the benefit of society. The winners win, and the customers win. But the losers lose, and that does suck. It is tragic, and sad, and worthy of empathy.

          But I wouldn't call it unfair.

          • platinumrad 1 hour ago

            Blah blah it's competitive sure, but surely then the rules of the competition should be enforced?

            > for the benefit of society

            This is very much in doubt right now.

            • csallen 54 minutes ago

              > Blah blah it's competitive sure, but surely then the rules of the competition should be enforced?

              They largely are? I think there's a very strong argument that training and learning from other people's work is not the same thing as infringing on their copyrights. It's never been illegal before, and it's a stretch to say that it should become illegal because machines have made it easier to do.

              What is illegal is public performances and profit from these things. And that's still illegal and enforced today. If you make a copy of a hit TV show and start trying to profit from it, whether you use an LLM or you do it by hand, you will likely have it taken down or be sued.

              > This is very much in doubt right now.

              In an airy fairy theoretical sense, yes. In a practical sense, millions of people are buying and using AI on a daily basis because they find it more beneficial than the alternative.

            • demibabs 35 minutes ago

              It’s in doubt, but very arguable. In the case of translators specifically, being able to easily translate works into other languages seems like a huge boon for society compared to the relatively small downside of translators losing their jobs. I’d also make a similar argument for software.

          • bobsomers 39 minutes ago

            > The market is competitive and it takes a lot to win.

            You're right, it takes a lot of privilege to be able to take risks, and you must be in a position to actually take those risks to have a chance.

            There's a reason that capitalism has very few stories like "single mother who takes care of her parents IPO'd her company today" and many more stories like "male billionaire makes next billion".

      • claaams 1 hour ago

        Using people's work to make money without compensating them is theft, except when big tech does it.

        • senderista 1 hour ago

          Not only without compensating them for their work, but using their work to make them unemployable.

        • koziserek 1 hour ago

          well if you use AI then they created value, no?

      • kakacik 1 hour ago

        Lol what is this bs, so pirating and stealing is 'hotly debated'? Look its fine if you like what they do since clearly law is on their side for now, but man up and say it clearly.

        • csallen 1 hour ago

          > Lol what is this bs, so pirating and stealing is 'hotly debated'?

          Always has been

      • nmeagent 1 hour ago

        > The entire reason why theft is bad is because when you take something, the person no longer has it.

        > What you are talking about is not theft, it's copyright infringement.

        And yet quite a few people's livelihoods are greatly diminished or nowhere to be found, while the results of their work are included without attribution or compensation in the output of generative AI models.

        • csallen 1 hour ago

          That may be true, but it's called copyright infringement, not theft, and it's very different.

          And there are a great many things that can diminish the quality of many people's livelihoods without necessarily being some sort of crime. The invention of the horse, the car, the phone, the TV, the radio, etc weren't all great for everybody in society.

      • I_am_tiberius 1 hour ago

        Call it whatever you want. If you take a text somebody created and sells, and you sell a derived version of it that can even mostly re-create the text 1:1, it's taking revenue away from the creator without doing the actual work. Even worse, if our legal system finally catches up and disallows training on books etc., they can just take an older model and train the new one based on it.

        • WarmWash 1 hour ago

          Should I disable my ad-block now?

      • preg_match 1 hour ago

        The main argument for why or how copyright is theft is that by copying something, potential consumers give me money instead of you.

        Like, for example, say I rip a movie. The movie is on Amazon for 10 dollars, but I sell ripped DVDs for 2 bucks. A lot of people might buy my rips instead of watching the movie online, and so the production company loses a lot of money.

        Of course it’s complicated - would those consumers have really paid the 10 dollars at all? And, this is a simple example. Where it gets tricky is where it’s not direct ripping. It’s one thing to take a movie frame-by-frame and resell it. It’s another to, say, produce code that performs a similar functionality to existing code.

        • csallen 1 hour ago

          Yes, I understand this, but this is still not the same thing as theft. It's copyright infringement. Theft is something you own being taken. Copyright infringement is when someone breaks the temporary monopoly given to you by copyright law. They're distinct for good reason. And people and lobbies (usually big copyright holders like Disney) are the chief forces who have for dozens of years attempted to conflate the two, and to popularize terms like "intellectual property".

        • drnick1 41 minutes ago

          > The main argument for why or how copyright is theft is that by copying something, potential consumers give me money instead of you.

          Gabe Newell famously said that piracy is a service issue. I myself mostly stopped pirating games 20 years ago when Steam made it affordable and convenient to buy games. Streaming services initially did the same, but subsequently destroyed the value proposition by constantly hiking prices and imposing restrictions on devices. So now I get my video content from the high seas again, while I still get most of my games from Steam.

      • saaaaaam 1 hour ago

        > Theft can only happen with rivalrous goods

        That’s just not true, though, is it? My secret formula for everlasting robot joints just got stolen, and my chances of making a trillion dollars next year has gone with it.

        • csallen 1 hour ago

          If you had it written down on a sheet of paper, and someone broke into your house and took it from you, it was stolen. If someone copied it, it wasn't stolen. The difference is very simple and easy to understand.

          Laws against theft exist to prevent people from losing things that are in your possession.

          Copyright laws exist to give people a limited monopoly to profit from their creations. This monopoly, or your copyright, can be "infringed" upon. And you could argue that that is dastardly and bad and evil and bad for society. (Although I would likely disagree with you). And that's fine. But it's not the same as something being "stolen" from you.

          • saaaaaam 1 hour ago

            I left it on the table in my workshop and my cleaning lady’s son copied it and sold it for $10 million to a guy who runs an everlasting robot development skunk works. What would you advise?

            • csallen 1 hour ago

              Don't leave your trade secrets sitting out on the table. Or get better/faster at sales. Probably both.

          • LogicalRisk 42 minutes ago

            Pretty fascinating to know that theft of trade secrets is now no longer theft.

      • hvb2 1 hour ago

        So if I pirated a lot of movies, I actually deserve to make money of selling those?

        Also, if their tokens get 'stolen' because an account doesn't follow their terms then they do certainly ban people for that.

        • csallen 1 hour ago

          I wouldn't care personally, no. If I invent spaghetti, then you create a spaghetti restaurant, and get rich, so what? Same thing happens in the software industry all the time, too.

          • I_am_tiberius 1 hour ago

            I just checked out your profile and noticed you're the indie hacker guy. I registered on your community site about 7 years ago or so and put some information in. After some time a friend contacted me and told me that he found lots of personal information about me on the Internet. Turned out you somehow put all users' information public... Based on your comments, I'm now a bit worried about what you generally do with your users' data.

            • csallen 1 hour ago

              Similar to Hacker News, there's literally no private data on the Indie Hackers website except your sign-in email address and password. The only actions you can even take are creating public profile pages, writing public comments, and writing public posts. If you write things in public, then generally it will be public.

              • I_am_tiberius 55 minutes ago

                I believe you're not showing the full picture right now. I'm not talking about posts. I had put revenue and customer numbers on my profile, intended for other indie hackers. You specifically asked for that at that time. This was supposed to be private (and it was at the beginning). As another friend of mine was affected as well by this incident he contacted you and you somehow changed it back, - apparently after too many users complained. I don't believe you can't remember - there must have been many users that contacted you because of this.

                >If you write things in public, then generally it will be public. I have no clue how your platform works nowadays - as mentioned, this was 2019 or so.

                • csallen 51 minutes ago

                  There was never a feature on Indie Hackers when you could share your revenue and customer numbers in private. In fact, I just added a "hide my revenue" feature for the first time last week.

                  So I'm genuinely curious what you're talking about.

                  Your account of things is confusing to me. "I had put revenue and customer numbers on my profile, intended for other indie hackers," but "it was supposed to be private"? How could those both be true?

                  • I_am_tiberius 28 minutes ago

                    I can't tell you technically how Indie hackers worked and works. But I can certainly tell you that our information was suddenly indexed by google and you acknowledged the issue and fixed it. I don't believe you when you say you can't remember this.

                    • csallen 14 minutes ago

                      I feel like you're ignoring my last paragraph, which explains the source of my confusion pretty clearly. I think anyone would be confused by what you're saying: that you put data in public for others to see, but then expected it not to be seen by others. At least, that's what it seems like you're saying. And it's confusing.

                      > But I can certainly tell you that our information was suddenly indexed by google and you acknowledged the issue and fixed it.

                      Oh, well that's a different and much more specific claim. If at some point you asked me to hide some page on IndieHackers.com from Google, and I followed through and did, that's certainly possible. I know I've done that for some. But that's just a personal request and favor. There has never been any promise on Indie Hackers that pages would be hidden from search engines by default.

            • fodkodrasz 1 hour ago

              It is not your personal information, if when copied you still have it, I guess... /s

      • munk-a 1 hour ago

        > But if I could copy your apple and have an apple of my own, then you aren't being deprived, and meanwhile I'm better off. So it's a net good.

        Since Anthropic models aren't a physical thing why should they keep their models in-house if no value would be lost by giving it away for free? Then everyone would just have more free stuff!

        • csallen 45 minutes ago

          I agree that it would be better for society if everyone had copies of Anthropic's models.

          As Thomas Jefferson put it so eloquently:

          > If nature has made any one thing less susceptible than all others of exclusive property, it is the action of the thinking power called an idea, which an individual may exclusively possess as long as he keeps it to himself; but the moment it is divulged, it forces itself into the possession of every one, and the receiver cannot dispossess himself of it. Its peculiar character, too, is that no one possesses the less, because every other possesses the whole of it. He who receives an idea from me, receives instruction himself without lessening mine; as he who lights his taper at mine, receives light without darkening me. That ideas should freely spread from one to another over the globe, for the moral and mutual instruction of man, and improvement of his condition, seems to have been peculiarly and benevolently designed by nature, when she made them, like fire, expansible over all space, without lessening their density in any point, and like the air in which we breathe, move, and have our physical being, incapable of confinement or exclusive appropriation. Inventions then cannot, in nature, be a subject of property. Society may give an exclusive right to the profits arising from them, as an encouragement to men to pursue ideas which may produce utility, but this may or may not be done, according to the will and convenience of the society, without claim or complaint from anybody.

          If Anthropic don't want anyone copying their model, then they should simply keep it to themselves.

      • zamfi 1 hour ago

        > The entire reason why theft is bad is because when you take something, the person no longer has it.

        What's being stolen is not "csallen's artwork"—it's "the unique ability to make art in the csallen style", where "art" is to be taken liberally to mean words/text, paintings, programs, etc., and what's being taken from you is that uniqueness.

        But, honestly, forget about the technical definition of copyright infringement vs. theft. It's a pretty weak argument to say that there's no there there when a diffusion model can create art nearly perfectly in the style of a living artist by training on that artist's work; especially so if that artist has spent years working on and perfecting that style.

        That may not technically be theft, or even copyright infringement—we're navigating the shifting value of training and the moats available to artists and authors in real time, as you note. But the law follows human notions of fairness and equity, not vice versa.

        Using the word theft to describe what's going on here, as OP does, is making a moral claim of equivalence, not a legal claim. You're saying "well, technically it's not theft" but if I were the OP I might reply "well, it feels like theft, so maybe the definition of theft is wrong". Your technical claim here is correct, but I'd argue that it's also maybe missing the point.

        • csallen 1 hour ago

          > What's being stolen is not "csallen's artwork"—it's "the unique ability to make art in the csallen style", where "art" is to be taken liberally to mean words/text, paintings, programs, etc., and what's being taken from you is that uniqueness.

          Society has never protected nor guaranteed people a monopoly on the unique ability to do something. Anybody is free to look at somebody else's public work, study it in detail, practice on it, train themselves, and gain the ability to reproduce it in an identical style. In fact, if you go to school for art, music, writing, engineering, etc., they will have you do exactly that.

          And this is pretty much exactly what training a model is.

          What your comment is conflating is the ability to potentially do something, vs the act of actually doing it, vs doing it as a public performance or for profit. Only the last of those three things, I believe, is copyright infringement.

          To wit: Imagine a person who can draw a perfect re-creation of Mickey Mouse, vs a person who does so in his spare time and for his friends and family, vs a person who does so and puts it on TV for the public to see and charges advertisers.

          Would you like to make the first two illegal? If so, why? How does such a law benefit society?

          The strongest argument I would personally grant here is that it's totally okay to train an LLM on others' work, and it's totally okay to use that LLM for yourself, but just like with copyright law, perhaps it should be illegal to use that LLM to create and distribute copyrighted works.

          > Using the word theft to describe what's going on here, as OP does, is making a moral claim of equivalence, not a legal claim. You're saying "well, technically it's not theft" but if I were the OP I might reply "well, it feels like theft, so maybe the definition of theft is wrong". Your technical claim here is correct, but I'd argue that it's also maybe missing the point.

          I don't think I'm missing the point. I just disagree with it.

          Sure, it may feel like theft. Lots of things feel bad that are not in fact, bad. I think that's just part of life. Especially in the competitive market of selling goods and services. Sometimes you are going to lose, or your company is going to lose, or your business model is going to lose, or become outdated, or get outcompeted, and it's going feel shitty.

          I'm not trying to be heartless. I feel for anyone in this position. People actually do suffer when there is massive change in the market. This has always been the case, and it is always tragic.

          But I don't think we should necessarily be in the business of creating laws to protect particular business models that are no longer competitive in the market. Especially rent-seeking business models that do more to benefit their creators than the rest of society.

          If we lived in a world where recipes could be patented (and thank god we don't), then whoever was the first to create pizza would surely have created Pizza Inc., and lobbied for recipe patent terms to be extended for hundreds of years so they and their descendants would never lose the exclusive rights to selling pizza, and so nobody else would ever be able to create pizza without paying them royalties for having done it first. And if other people decided to create and sell pizzas anyway, we would call them infringers or "thieves" and say that they were actively harming the creators of Pizza Incorporated. And if somebody were to give the ordinary person a pizza oven so they could make their own pizzas at home, then the owners of the Pizza Inc. patents would lose out on revenue, and they would certainly say they felt harmed and stolen from. And you would be here saying, "Well they feel like it's theft." And I would be saying, "Well I'm sure they do, but I dream of a world where anybody can make any recipe, and they don't get exclusive rights to limit everyone else's freedom or extract rent from everyone else just because they were the first to do it. And I don't think it serves society to create laws that grant them a monopoly."

          In fact, we do actually live in a world where software can be patented, and many thousands of commonly-copied and used UX flows and UI elements are actually under patent. But, thankfully, due almost entirely convention and culture, software patents are practically never enforced. And again, thank god. Otherwise I'm sure the first person to have created a drop-down menu would be raving mad and feel stolen from any time the rest of us create a drop-down menu. And you would be here saying, "(S)he feels stolen from because nobody is paying royalties!" and I would be here saying, "I see that, and it's unfortunately, but I think it would be better to have a world where copying software functionality is allowed. I do not think we should be creating laws to protect rent-seeking business models that allow people to do something first and then extract royalties from the rest of the world."

          • rspeele 35 minutes ago

            > In fact, if you go to school for art, music, writing, engineering, etc., they will have you do exactly that.

            > And this is pretty much exactly what training a model is.

            Equating model training to a human learning a skill is like equating taking a camcorder into a movie theater, to a human remembering the movie they watched and imagining scenes from it in their head.

            It scales. It has very different consequences since one trained model can be copied infinitely and obsolete an unlimited quantity of equivalently-skilled humans. It also is capable of imitating on a much finer level.

            Here[1] is an image of the Mona Lisa I requested GPT6.1 Sol Medium to create as accurately as possible without referencing any external sources, using only its training. It claims to have followed my request: "Generated from training alone, without web searches or reference images."

            Of course, the Mona Lisa is public domain, which is why I didn't have to fight it to do this. And I'm sure it is represented in the training data many thousands of times, unlike, say, my obscure open source libraries. But the point of the exercise is to show the "trained" weights can reproduce what they were trained on in a way far superior to any human memory (could any artist recreate Mona from memory this well?) and arguably, even better than some technologies we do consider copyright violations such as a very badly shrunk-and-compressed JPEG or a picture-of-a-picture-of-a-picture. Or the aforementioned shaky camcorder bootleg.

            [1]https://imgur.com/a/QaGHEMi

            • csallen 30 minutes ago

              > It scales. It has very different consequences since one trained model can be copied infinitely and obsolete an unlimited quantity of equivalently-skilled humans. It also is capable of imitating on a much finer level.

              It does scale, but I don't think that's particularly relevant. It's not any reason to make it illegal. If something that's fine and legal becomes effective enough to threaten other people's business models, that should not make it illegal. That should just make it the dominant business model and the other business models should lose.

              > But the point of the exercise is to show the "trained" weights can reproduce what they were trained on in a way far superior to any human memory (could any artist recreate Mona from memory this well?)

              I feel the same way about this. Yes, the technology is really really really good, but why is that relevant? If you use it to produce copyrighted works, then okay, I think you're infringing copyright. But just the fact that it's capable of doing so doesn't bother me.

              > Equating model training to a human learning a skill is like equating taking a camcorder into a movie theater, to a human remembering the movie they watched and imagining scenes from it in their head.

              Not true at all.

              A camcorder creates an exact copy of the movie. If that's what training models was doing, I would agree it's copyright infringement.

              Here's a thought experiment. Imagine we get better at understanding the human brain, and we discover how to augment it. Maybe biologically. We start genetically engineering people to remember more, absorb more, train better. Pretty soon, some humans emerge who can copy things they see with remarkable accuracy. (To be fair, there are some people who can already do this.)

              Should these people be illegal? Is it suddenly copyright infringement for them to behold copyrighted work? Why or why not?

              If you say, "Well they're people, not machines," that's true, but why should that lead to a distinction? What's wrong with machines doing things? Should we make calculators illegal? Obviously not. So what's so wrong with machines that can think and learn and do so effectively?

              As far as I can tell, I only ever hear two reasons given, which are both flavors of the same thing: (1) Because it outcompetes some humans, and makes those industries harder to profit in, and harms the livelihoods of people who are trying to profit. (2) Because it will outcompete all humans, or at so many humans, that there will be a crisis of economics or meaning, possibly both.

              I have some sympathy for the latter, but the former is business as usual when it comes to technological disruption.

              • rspeele 12 minutes ago

                > A camcorder creates an exact copy of the movie.

                A camcorder bootleg of a movie is objectively not an exact copy, and subjectively a worse reproduction than GPT's from-memory Mona Lisa. But it's close enough to count for copyright violation purposes.

                I'm not claiming the weights of a model can exactly reproduce every work they were trained on, that would of course be an impossible violation of information theory.

                But clearly they are capable of making extremely close, close enough to count, reproductions of some works they were trained on. Is it not fair to say the weights "contain" a lossily compressed copy of the Mona Lisa since I can spit that image out of them? And if they contain the public domain Mona Lisa, do they not also contain countless copyrighted works, which a thin band-aid of system prompts tries to prevent them from offering up on-demand?

                I'll admit, this technology is not exactly like copying stuff, but it's not quite not like copying stuff either. It is a new gray area. What I totally reject is the claim that it's just like a human learning things and should be treated the same. Unless the trained model was never allowed to be copied to another machine, and had to live and die exactly once with the hardware it was trained on. And had rights of its own. All of which of course would be absurd.

                > It does scale, but I don't think that's particularly relevant. It's not any reason to make it illegal. If something that's fine and legal becomes effective enough to threaten other people's business models, that should not make it illegal. That should just make it the dominant business model and the other business models should lose.

                Absolutely it matters! You can't spell copyright without "copy". Before the printing press there was no reason for such a thing. There are only extremely rare cases of disputes over manually copied books and certainly no system of law to protect it. It is the scaling factor of mechanical copying becoming possible that made the concept of copyright necessary in the first place. Scale is everything.

        • ordu 1 hour ago

          > Using the word theft to describe what's going on here, as OP does, is making a moral claim of equivalence, not a legal claim.

          Exactly. But the thing is, if you do moral claims in this form, you open yourself for rhetoric of pedants, and then spend all your free time debating the meaning of words instead of talking about things that really matter. People opposing your views would use this rhetoric when they have no better arguments, passing-by pedants would be compelled to debate words with you. (Like I being highly interested in rhetoric techniques can't miss such an opportunity to add my 5 cents, which are technically off topic of your discussion)

          > I'd argue that it's also maybe missing the point.

          Yes, and no. The statement is ambiguous it can be understand in different ways. If you expect your opponent to use rhetorical techniques against you (maybe unconsciously, rhetoric techniques are double edged and they can posing the thinking of the user), you'd better don't let them do it. It is much easy to handle ambiguity when it starts, then to keep it in mind through all the discussion until it starts deform the logic of argument and then interrupt your opponent, explain the ambiguity, remind them how it came into the discussions and how it developed since then, and why it was not important before and why it is important now.

          You see, it is possible that the person who uses "theft" is missing the point. And maybe they do it deliberately to muddle the water.

          Using "theft" is good if you are a politic and target your speeches at huge masses of uneducated peasants (they would understand your words as "theft"="copyright infringement" but it kinda not your fault, right?), or if you are talking with people who agree with you already (even if they notice a trick, they would agree with it). If you want a honest debate you'd better make your moral claim explicitly, though I prefer to avoid moral claims completely: if you think a bit, you can replace moral references with references to what is good for a society. Like Max Weber did with Protestantism virtues.

      • WarmWash 1 hour ago

        In case you missed the memo, the internet changed it's mind and IP laws are now a good thing

      • saaaaaam 1 hour ago

        > I much prefer the creativity, riffing, and copying you see in software and the food industry, than to the cookie-licking and rent-seeking you see in other industries that lean more into this sort of thing.

        > And this, of course, is not theft. It's copyright infringement.

        It’s funny that you mention the food industry because that’s actually the perfect example that contradicts the point you’re trying to make. I can create a recipe for a dish. I have personally created more than a few. Someone else can take that recipe and make the same dish. It will, unless they are experienced in cooking, be bad when they cook it because you need to have an instinctive sense of when something is just right and how to adjust the heat on your particular hob and how to compensate for all the things I just assumed you would understand.

        And, of course, a list of parts to make a product cannot be protected by copyright.

        I don’t see a lot of creativity, riffing and copying in the software industry. Sure, it’s there in software but not in the industry of software which is entirely based on “cookie-licking and rent-seeking”.

        > The idea that being the first to express a particular thought/idea/whatever means that others should be restricted from doing so

        Copyright explicitly does not give protection to thoughts/ideas/whatever.

        • csallen 38 minutes ago

          > It’s funny that you mention the food industry because that’s actually the perfect example that contradicts the point you’re trying to make. I can create a recipe for a dish. I have personally created more than a few. Someone else can take that recipe and make the same dish. It will, unless they are experienced in cooking, be bad when they cook it because you need to have an instinctive sense of when something is just right and how to adjust the heat on your particular hob and how to compensate for all the things I just assumed you would understand.

          I'm struggling to see your point here, but I don't quite follow. Can you explain more clearly?

          To me, the restaurant industry makes my point more than any other. Luckily, people were creating and recipes far earlier than any society had the power to conceive of, create, and enforce anything resembling copyright/patent laws. So we get to live in a world where recipes aren't subject to patents. Anyone can make anything, and "I did it first so it's mine" does not in fact entitle anyone to extract rent from everyone else, or restrict others' freedom to cook what they want.

          Can you imagine we had Pizza Inc, Taco Inc, Fish and Chips LTD, etc., and they had lobbied for decades to extend their patents for hundreds of years so no one else was allowed to make these things, and they spent millions on teams of lawyers to sue everyone into oblivion who tried to riff or remix?

          I'm also very grateful that the software industry at large has a culture and tradition of not actually enforcing patents.

      • moralestapia 1 hour ago

        >Theft can only happen with rivalrous goods.

        Uhm ... no?

        Copyright is a thing.

        IP and trade secrets can be stolen, etc.

    • noosphr 1 hour ago

      The second biggest after copyright was extended to up to a century longer one fine afternoon last century with no one being compressed for the destruction of the commons.

  • vlyan 2 hours ago

    the petite bourgeoisie was fine with lower classes losing their jobs.

    • 13415 2 hours ago

      What's the point of that comment?

  • hypfer 2 hours ago

    Well at least people can flee this reality by playing GTA VI.

    A high fidelity life simulation slash power fantasy that ensures that anyone that would have energy to do something is properly pacified.

    Provided that Klarna lets them buy the PS5 Pro.

    For me, honestly, this is the worst part. Not that things are bad but knowing that them being bad is now going to very effectively being absorbed so that it doesn't get bad enough for anyone to do anything at all.

    • willchis 1 hour ago

      Ready Player One, right!

    • pesus 1 hour ago

      I guess if society is going to burn one way or another, I'd like to have my bread and circuses. At least GTA6 lets you live out the fantasy of having a decent house with no rent.

  • onlyrealcuzzo 2 hours ago

    It's obviously not an option to just build more.

    Success is clearly doom.

    Failure is the path to prosperity.

  • mutator 2 hours ago

    You can only hope that the tax revenue this event generates counts for a huge windfall for the state and they improve upon the mandate given to them by the people.

  • spamizbad 2 hours ago

    San Francisco chose to make housing scarce for the sake of preserving neighborhood character. Wealthy people are now well-positioned to buy up a scarce resource. Sucks, but it's the bed the city made for itself.

    • WindyTree 2 hours ago

      SF made housing scarce to spike values by limiting supply in relation to demand. Watch Anthropic with regulatory capture, artificial scarcity may be Silicon Valley’s biggest export.

    • Choad_20261104 2 hours ago

      wait. can you please provide some alternative way of defining a suitable neighborhood character, and whom might enforce that when property owners choosing that character are using their rights to property [constitutionally guaranteed by 5th & 14th] in making their choices.

      if you want cheap property, all you need to do is travel 50 miles east.

      • hotgeart 1 hour ago

        > if you want cheap property, all you need to do is travel 50 miles east.

        As a european this sentence sounds crazy to me. "Just 80 km east" I'm in another country.

        • js2 1 hour ago

          Yeah, the spaces in the U.S. are vast, and in Texas they are really vast. Four time zones east to west, not counting Hawaii or Alaska. I'll be driving up to my aunt and uncle's for Thanksgiving. That's just 660 miles north and four state lines. Obligatory https://thetruesize.com/

          • dreamcompiler 1 hour ago

            Europeans constantly underestimate the size of Texas.

            El Paso, Texas -> Los Angeles, California: 802 miles

            El Paso, Texas -> Beaumont, Texas: 831 miles

            There are two states between Texas and California, but that distance is shorter than from one side of Texas to the other without ever leaving the state.

            (Of course Alaska is much bigger still but it's not an apt comparison; you cannot easily drive across Alaska because there are very few roads.)

            European comparison:

            Prague -> Rome: 809 miles

            • agrippanux 48 minutes ago

              My brother in law is from Ireland. When he comes over to the US, the thing he loves to do the most is rent a car and drive the Southwest - like start in San Diego and drive to Sante Fe, NM. It's just so vast that it blows his mind every single time.

            • hdgvhicv 30 minutes ago

              830 miles is the distance from one end of the U.K. to the other, or France, or Italy. It’s not ridiculously big.

            • js2 28 minutes ago

              > Europeans constantly underestimate the size of Texas.

              To be fair, so do Americans. Years ago I drove from Florida to California by way of I-10 and it felt like I'd never get across Texas.

        • lurking_swe 1 hour ago

          that's one thing a lot of Europeans simply don't quite realize until they leave the continent. Europe is tiny in the grand scheme of things, geographically speaking.

          • reaperducer 1 hour ago

            that's one thing a lot of Europeans simply don't quite realize until they leave the continent. Europe is tiny in the grand scheme of things, geographically speaking.

            When I lived in the American West, I'd see this all the time. European tourists who simply could not wrap their brains around the vastness of the American continent, and how their provincial sense of scale doesn't work in the rest of the planet.

            They must soil themselves when they get to Australia.

            • stockresearcher 47 minutes ago

              > They must soil themselves when they get to Australia.

              Don’t do this. It attracts drop bears.

          • lurking_swe 1 hour ago

            The downvotes are pretty funny. Have y'all seen the size of Africa? The size of Australia? The size of North America?

            I have family in europe, so i know very well what they consider "far".

            and actually, most maps use a specific projection that makes Europe seem larger than it is. If you look at an actual 3-D globe, Europe is even smaller than it seems.

            distances are relative.

            • BeetleB 1 hour ago

              Sure, but I bet in most of Africa or Australia, telling someone to "just move 50 miles" east and endure a terrible commute will be looked at as both insane and inane.

              • lurking_swe 47 minutes ago

                well to put it in perspective, my father commuted 50 miles to and from work for most of his adult life. He simply didn't wanna live in the city and preferred suburbs. Most of our neighbors had similar commutes. that kind of life is not for me, but people certainly do it.

                Australia is a bit of an interesting example because the continent is massive, but most cities are sort of clustered near each other along the coasts. on the other hand, leaving Australia requires a minimum 10 hour flight. So a vacation for them requires traveling farther than most Europeans have ever traveled. As i said, all relative!

                No clue what the norm is in africa lol. :)

                • BeetleB 19 minutes ago

                  > well to put it in perspective, my father commuted 50 miles to and from work for most of his adult life. He simply didn't wanna live in the city and preferred suburbs.

                  This is somewhat normal in the US. But the original comment was pointing out that this is crazy in Europe. And I was pointing out it is crazy in most of the world :-)

          • stouset 1 hour ago

            To an American, 100 years is old. To a European, 100 miles is far.

            • radicalbyte 1 hour ago

              Depends where you are in Europe. I grew up in the UK and didn't find 100 miles that far, it was a trip to see family and friends.

              Yet now I live in The Netherlands and if I drive that far I can cross two borders; our foreign holidays are about that distance.

        • sarchertech 1 hour ago

          Well you’ve got about 2,500 miles to go east of San Fransisco before you hit a border.

        • hdgvhicv 31 minutes ago

          With decent rail 80km is fine for commuting, half an hour to the terminal an hour then a 10 minute local train to the office.

          But America doesn’t have that.

        • anonzzzies 19 minutes ago

          In Spain I drive 100km almost daily. And in France I used to as well. We don't all live in Belgium or NL (I am dutch).

      • pr337h4m 1 hour ago

        the right to property should extend only to your own property, not the entire neighborhood. for if the entire neighborhood has “rights” over your property, you don’t really have a right to property anymore.

        • maddie0 1 hour ago

          With CEQA, you don't even have to be in the same neighborhood to file lawsuits and block development (or delay it for years, at least, which means carrying costs that ruin the business plan, and that alone is risk enough to block many developments before anyone even tries). It is a fine shakedown machine.

        • nsxwolf 1 hour ago

          Pretty good arrangement if it means I can be sure an oil refinery doesn't appear next door to me.

          • triceratops 14 minutes ago

            Was that ever on the table? And why would an oil refinery decide to locate itself in a residential neighborhood?

            Even basic city building games are able to differentiate between residential and industrial zoning. It's really not a hard concept.

      • pj_mukh 1 hour ago

        >>"an you please provide some alternative way of defining a suitable neighborhood character"

        moving? just move to a neighborhood that's not growing and it will stay the same for you.

        Insisting that the neighborhood with the most growth potential in the history of the world not grow, seems like insanity.

        • lovecg 59 minutes ago

          Which neighborhood is guaranteed to not become a high growth potential neighborhood in a few decades, and how sure are you? Silicon valley used to just be rural sleepy towns not that long ago.

      • losteric 1 hour ago

        > way of defining a suitable neighborhood character,

        That's really the problem.

        What is character? Over time, either the neighborhood architecture changes or the people/culture changes. Or somewhere more in between.

      • peteey 1 hour ago

        Housing scarcity is created by limiting development on property locals don't own.

        Rights to perperty are not in jeopardy. No one is seizing homes with imminent domain. Developers would purchase property in a consensual free market exchange and build more housing if it were legal to build.

        Your framing is disingenuous to a fault and suggesting young working class families should move out of town is economic segrigation.

      • thmoonbus 1 hour ago

        Please tell me how your property rights cover the broader neighborhood that your property is situated in? I say this as a homeowner in a HCOL area myself.

      • dionidium 1 hour ago

        Property owners typically own just one property in their neighborhood, which is located in a municipality that exists at the pleaseure of an overriding state government. Those owners have no special right to the character of the entire neighborhood.

        • rootusrootus 1 hour ago

          > Property owners typically own just one property

          Well, yes, which is why they only get one vote amongst the many others in the neighborhood.

          What seems odd is elevating the rights of people outside the neighborhood to override what the residents themselves choose. There's some give and take, but why would the outsiders ever end up with more rights?

          • twoodfin 29 minutes ago

            What residents choose for other people’s property?

          • dionidium 8 minutes ago

            Well, because that's what it would look like to protect a right if it actually were a right. Who is most likely to want to restrict your speech? It's probably your neighbors and not somebody who has never heard of you.

            But speech is an actual right that our courts take seriously, so they don't say that your neighbors should get to limit your speech by virtue of being most affected by it. No, they say that you have a right to speech and your neighbors can pound sand.

            The courts have decided not to treat property rights the same way, but they obviously could.

        • Choad_20261104 47 minutes ago

          HOAs have changed that thesis forever. entire neighborhoods are ruled by an extrajudicial agreement amongst owners called "CC&Rs"

          people outside USA may not be familiar with them

      • triceratops 10 minutes ago

        > choosing that character...using their rights to property

        I didn't realize there was a constitutionally guaranteed right to other people's property. Everyone is already free to choose the character of their own property and no one is even discussing taking that away.

        Don't like apartment buildings? Don't build them on your land - easy-peasy.

    • Lammy 1 hour ago

      San Francisco chose to make housing scarce because too many of the people moving here were Black.

      Cover story of the 1954 edition of the The Negro Travelers' Green Book travel guide: ‘The Golden Gate’ https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/1/1c/The_Negr...

      “San Francisco, however, is fast becoming the focal point of the Negroes’ future. Before World War Ⅱ this city had fewer than 5,000 Negroes. High war wages attracted these people from all over the country to this boom town. More than 45,000 Negroes are squeezed into two areas of San Francisco today, with an estimated thirty-five percent unemployed.”

      Environmental Impact Report from SF's 1978 downzoning: https://dn760102.eu.archive.org/0/items/finalenvironment2719...

      “Since the proposed [zoning] amendments would reduce the density in some neighborhoods, the demand for housing in those neighborhoods may not be accommodated. As a result the cost of housing may increase. With increasing housing costs, some population groups may find it difficult to live in San Francisco.”

      And what do you know, it worked — peep the graph :/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/priceonomics/2016/05/11/the-afr...

      The Bay Area as a whole is shockingly racially segregated, which is something I was raised to believe is, like, a bad thing: http://radicalcartography.net/bayarea.html

      • dionidium 1 hour ago

        This is completely implausible as an ongoing explanation for restrictive zoning, which is practiced almost everywhere in the country -- white areas, black areas, mixed areas, and everything in between.

        The American homeowner is skeptical of a long list of potential changes to their neighborhood, which has at times included concerns about race, alongside more general anxiety about crime, traffic, construction, noise, views, and so on.

        This is one of the most overdetermined questions in all of political discourse.

        • jldugger 1 hour ago

          Seems like one of those classic American things where racism starts the snowball then rent-seeking takes over.

          • kraken_cult 1 hour ago

            Well then it seems like focusing on race is counterproductive.

        • bobthepanda 1 hour ago

          One of the things about American zoning is that it is enduring, so while pretty much no one is explicitly doing that today, the zoning that was designed to create such outcomes is largely still in place. And even today you still get a lot of euphemisms about the wrong kind of people moving in.

          The most egregious examples I think are people saying that kind of thing about building workforce housing for the educators teaching their children in the local schools.

          • reilly3000 24 minutes ago

            I can vouch for that. My postwar home was in a redline neighborhood and has a racially restrictive covenant. Even though they were only enforceable for a few years, the impact is still clear in the numbers today. The black population in my zip code is 1.2% vs an overall 2.8%. Wealth begets wealth, and you don’t have to inherit hate to be its beneficiary.

        • JackFr 1 hour ago

          Because most households' only wealth is in their homes. By restricting supply bureaucrats and politicians (and ballot initiatives) make a certain class of people wealthier.

          IMHO this is a significant driver of inequality.

        • eli_gottlieb 45 minutes ago

          Nah try saying something against NIMBY zoning on Twitter and you'll get people in your replies explaining exactly how every other term they use is a euphemism for keeping black people out.

          • zahlman 13 minutes ago

            Sure, but it won't be the NIMBYs making those explanations, and they won't have a sound basis for them.

      • droptablemain 1 hour ago

        People who want to see racism will always see racism.

        What city isn't "shockingly racially segregated?" It may surprise you to learn most people prefer to live around others like them.

        • ramesh31 55 minutes ago

          >"What city isn't "shockingly racially segregated?" It may surprise you to learn most people prefer to live around others like them."

          NYC. One of a thousand reasons it is strictly superior to SF.

          • drnick1 49 minutes ago

            And one of the reasons many reasons avoid NYC like the plague.

          • Lammy 47 minutes ago

            Not for lack of trying: https://www.gothamcenter.org/blog/the-end-of-the-african-ame...

            “From 1890 to 1900 the African American population in Manhattan grew by 41 percent from 25,674 to 36,246. Behind these numbers was the growing exodus of blacks from southern states. Seeking to escape racial violence, declining economic opportunities, and legalized segregation, African Americans moved to northern cities like New York in increasing numbers.

            A few years after the 1900 riot [in which whites attacked blacks in midtown following the stabbing of an undercover police officer by a black man]†, as Harlem land values increased with the first subway line nearing completion in 1904, the black residents, once sought as renters in Harlem, became the targets of an organized removal effort by some white Harlem property owners.

            The [New York Herald] article also suggested that a rent increase ‘which the parlor car porters‡ could pay, but their colored inferiors could not,’ had previously been used as a strategy to remove the undesirable tenants. According to The Herald, the owners’ target was the ‘colored inferiors,’ but the ‘wealthy railroad porters’ were also caught in the net of the eviction effort.”

            † https://guides.loc.gov/chronicling-america-new-york-city-rac...

            ‡ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pullman_porter

          • easterncalculus 47 minutes ago

            NYC is absolutely extremely segregated, and always has been. It has some of the most segregated public schools in the country, even more segregated than parts of the south before the civil rights act.

        • kalkin 39 minutes ago

          > It may surprise you to learn most people prefer to live around others like them.

          If this is your view, speak for yourself. Don't defer to an imagined silent majority.

          And more, be explicit if you mean race or ethnicity by "others like them". It's 2026, if there's a silver lining to Trump's victory, Musk Twitter etc it should be that folks stop being coy about this kind of thing. You can just defend segregation if you want.

      • adamrezich 47 minutes ago

        Californian views on race remain completely inscrutable to literally everyone else on the planet. They believe long-standing policies are the sole cause of any and all racial disparities, yet they consistently vote for the same party that seems to do nothing to improve the situation. It's very strange to anyone from anywhere else, because it seems an awful lot like blame-shifting excuse-making rather than telling the truth.

        • collingreen 38 minutes ago

          TIL all Californians have identical crazy views. I wonder if all the other Californians also share my view on the quality of your claim.

        • eli_gottlieb 31 minutes ago

          California lets voters bind the legislature with ballot initiatives requiring huge supermajorities to overturn, so they can vote in the "Anti-Racist/Anti-Classist Party" while also passing Proposition Racism/Classism/NIMBYism.

        • throwitaway222 16 minutes ago

          To be completely honest, we need to disband parties. I'm increasingly for people being required to vote on something should be educated about it instead of scanning down the ballot for R and D.

      • jjallen 45 minutes ago

        1954 was a long time ago.

        Maybe this was an issue then, I don't know; do you really believe the zoning and housing issue is still like this for the same reason?

      • JuniperMesos 27 minutes ago

        > The Bay Area as a whole is shockingly racially segregated, which is something I was raised to believe is, like, a bad thing: http://radicalcartography.net/bayarea.html

        The bay area is not actually shockingly racially segregated. The bay area is extremely racially diverse as a consequence of being the center of the American computer technology industry and drawing huge numbers of immigrants from all over the world for many decades.

        One of the consequences of being extremely racially diverse is that people systematically make different decisions about how they live their lives in part based on their own preferences which correlate imperfectly with their own race, resulting in all sorts of social institutions not having the same racial mix as the United States as a whole, the world as a whole, or any other metric you might pick as a guideline for what would constitute a lack of segregation. And in particular, there might not be very many visibly black people doing any particular thing or living in any particular area, which might look like the segregation you were "raised to believe is, like, a bad thing" if you were raised on media that was specifically trying to sacralize the black American civil rights movement of the 1950s-1960s. But that's what actual racial diversity and actual lack of racial segregation looks like.

        • gojiberries 21 minutes ago

          Many Black and Hispanic people lived in the Bay Area prior to the tech booms. They’ve been pushed out, often deliberately via zoning. People should familiarize themselves with the history of California before chiming in. There’s been a plethora of deliberately racist policy. Including a very little known genocide of indigenous Americans in the 1800s.

          https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bloody_Island_massacre

    • kubb 1 hour ago

      It's homeowners who wanted the scarcity to keep their house prices up (and not "be underwater with their mortgage" or whatever), they just used neighborhood character as a pretext.

    • ummonk 1 hour ago

      San Francisco is the 2nd densest city in America. It gets far too much blame when the real issue is lack of housing in Silicon Valley and other low density suburbs.

      • olalonde 37 minutes ago

        Being denser than almost every American city is a pretty low bar. Compare SF with international cities like Paris, Hong Kong or Tokyo and it looks like a village.

    • grafmax 1 hour ago

      Yet its wealthy people, a bunch of billionaires, who astroturf this narrative. The reason seems to be that they want to redirect people's anger over inequality ... toward NIMBYism.

      • jongjong 57 minutes ago

        Oh that makes sense. These days, politicians are dual purpose for the rich; advance political agendas to benefit the rich and then serve as punching bags when regular people get upset about those agendas.

      • jaredklewis 44 minutes ago

        But we can walk and chew bubblegum at the same time.

        I’m not a billionaire, but I also oppose NIMBYism because it’s bad for our society and economy.

        I’m also for more wealth redistribution. These are two things that are not inherently in opposition; they are very compatible.

        I highly doubt there are people that were angry over wealth inequality, but then stopped being angry about that to instead only be angry about NIMBYism. Those people are just in your head.

      • eli_gottlieb 30 minutes ago

        "Eat the rich" includes the real-estate millionaires, not just the tech billionaires. In fact, we can just start with a big barbecue pit for everyone from Atherton.

    • rurp 1 hour ago

      I hate that this has become such a magic wand talking point. It's physically impossible to build enough housing in a geographically constrained highly desirable area like San Francisco to make housing affordable on a normal salary.

      Yes supply and demand matter and increasing some supply will have some lowering effect, just like incoming billions of dollars worth of extra demand will do the opposite. There's a real debate to be had about how and how much to build, and how to weight the different tradeoffs. But none of the loud voices on either side of the YIMBY/NIMBY divide care about any of that.

      The YIMBY message is always "Build more, problem solved EZPZ. Anyone talking about tradeoffs is a liar or an idiot.", with equally unreasonable people pushing back the other way.

      I wish HN could be a place with more nuanced discussion, but posts like this always get upvoted to the top.

      • try-working 1 hour ago

        no, it is super easy and there's plenty of examples to go around. Tokyo, Shanghai, Seoul, and so on.

        • Avicebron 57 minutes ago

          Tokyo maybe after the housing collapse (80s-90s I think) not so much now. Shanghai and Seoul are both dense and not affordable..

      • plantain 1 hour ago

        Singapore, Hong Kong would like a word.

        • suzzer99 1 hour ago

          My friend just bought a 2-bedroom in Singapore for $650k that looks like it hasn't been cleaned or updated since the 70s. Not sure I'd call that affordable.

          • collingreen 33 minutes ago

            Was that the only available housing purchase in Singapore or just a single data point from your friend? If it's the latter, then not just I would hinge a full opinion on that.

            As far as big cities go these days, 650k is not as out of reach as many. I wish I could buy the two bedroom I'm renting in LA for 650 but that isn't even close.

      • krferriter 1 hour ago

        > It's physically impossible to build enough housing in a geographically constrained highly desirable area like San Francisco to make housing affordable on a normal salary

        While this might be true in theory, literally nowhere in the US is anywhere near the upper bound. SF and other bay area municipalities could enact policy tomorrow that legalizes a 5x theoretical housing capacity increase, legalizing housing that is currently illegal to build, on lots that are already developed, not clearing any additional land, and not requiring any tall towers to be built, just modest midrise development.

        The other point I'd make is that while the core desirable areas will remain expensive, by increasing capacity across the board, people will be able to live closer to those super desirable areas than they currently can afford to. I don't need to live right next to my job. But if the municipalities in this metropolitan area increased housing capacity by even like 20%, people who currently can only afford to live farther from work, will be able to move closer to work, and achieve shorter commutes and travel times for leisure activities.

      • quotemstr 57 minutes ago

        Manhattan exists. It's a real place you visit and see for yourself. It's not some Soylent Green hellscape. The density is quite livable. I'll take Manhattan over San Francisco any day.

        How much more nuance do you need?

      • sib 54 minutes ago

        It's not actually impossible... Compare to the city (not metro area) of Tokyo.

          Measure                  Tokyo's 23 wards      San Francisco
          -----------------------  --------------------  --------------------
          Land area (sq mi)        242.3                 46.9
          Land area (sq km)        627.5                 121.5
          Population               9,983,365 (Oct 2026)  826,079 (Jul 2025)
          Density (people/sq mi)   41,200                17,600
          Density (people/sq km)   15,900                 6,800
          Housing price benchmark  $809,000 (¥129.4M)    $1.66M
        
        

        Of course, SF can't grow outward, but the population density of Tokyo is much higher.

        • GMoromisato 45 minutes ago

          I agree with this. If it were me, I would be putting up 80-story buildings all over the Peninsula, from Burlingame down to Palo Alto, all along El Camino Real.

          Look at all the buildings around Central Park in Manhattan. Now look at the area around Golden Gate Park for a comparison.

      • jgord 19 minutes ago

        Lots of affordable 20-40 story high-density condos in places such as Malaysia.

        You want them near a rail or tube station so people can commute without cars. They also allow preservation of local green spaces.

  • loceng 2 hours ago

    And then Elon with his SpaceX XAI clusters will easily outcompete all Earth-based AI data centres - and the free market will solve that issue?

    • throwaway85825 2 hours ago

      Spacex is working on space based gpus for the space force space based air moving target indicator program (SB-AMTI). Elon just heard of this and tried to tie it to AI to pump the stock.

    • 9dev 1 hour ago

      This space data Center meme is on par with flat earthers now. Equally dumb, and nobody knows if the proponents are trolls or just delusional. Or stock scammers of course.

  • CSMastermind 2 hours ago

    I'm more worried about all of the destructive things this new EA money will fund.

    • AgentME 1 hour ago

      Most EA funding goes into global health initiatives. If you're a mosquito or a malaria virus, I can see why that would be called destructive.

      • ok123456 1 hour ago

        What rich billionaires think will help and what actually helps people are two different things.

        Bill Gates spent years trying to "help" but ended up undermining health authorities' actual goals and engaging in rent-seeking activities around biotech IP.

        • bbor 49 minutes ago

          If your summary of the Gates foundation is that it didn't help, you are completely and absurdly blinded by your bias.

  • witty_username 2 hours ago

    I'm surprised you don't understand the benefit of AI. I certainly find it to be a useful tool and research assistant. It excels at mechanical coding tasks as well.

    • Miraste 1 hour ago

      Is there a net benefit, though? Leaded gasoline, asbestos, and Instagram also have plenty of gross benefits.

  • JKCalhoun 2 hours ago

    I have this crazy idea that we, as a society, are better when we are collectively poor.

    I say that in recalling the 70's when my family (and the larger blue-collar area I lived in) were fairly poor. Going to restaurants (as an example) was a "treat". You looked for coupons I the newspaper to cut out and went to get pizza on a Tuesday because they had free drinks with purchase of a large pizza (or whatever).

    I think it goes without saying that we were less wasteful, found enjoyment in simpler things like going to the park, etc.

    (Not a popular opinion among my friends and associates.)

    • GCA10 1 hour ago

      Hans Rosling's 2018 book "Factfulness" laid out this view of four levels of economic prosperity, with super-developed countries like the USA at level 4 and somewhat less affluent countries like Croatia and Portugal at level 3. While he didn't go this far, there's a lot about Level 3 life that sounds appealing from a distance and maybe up close.

      You've got full electricity and refrigeration, even if your refrigerator isn't internet enabled. You've got less crowded cities; perhaps closer family ties; perhaps more cozy neighborhood gathering points. You don't have heroic U.S. medicine to buy a few extra years of life in the face of cancer, heart disease, diabetes, etc., but you've got what might be better diet and exercise to stave off trouble in the first place.

      I don't see any way that the U.S. backs away from its focus on GDP growth as the only accepted measure of "the good life," but I'm open to wider, non-dollar definitions of prosperity for any communities that are interested.

    • jimmyjazz14 1 hour ago

      If that is your idea of poor you have never been poor my friend. Being poor doesn't mean you spend less on pizza than normal its being worried if you are going to have a place to sleep next week when rent is due or able to afford the doctor when your kids get sick. Don't glorify poverty, its is a disease that should be cured.

    • kakacik 1 hour ago

      Somebody has rosy glasses about their distant past, thats pretty common but you should realize that outright this basic feature of our subconsciousness and fight it. Remember the shittier parts of it, not just few top cherry picks.

      Remember you were very different person, easy to please, much more patient, had very little expectations from life. Being poor now once you got deep in your comfort zone would be punishingly hard. Try it, you can do it anytime just wipe out your accounts.

    • geraneum 58 minutes ago

      > Not a popular opinion among my friends and associates

      Gosh I can’t imagine why

  • ragebol 2 hours ago

    > "who cares, AI will fix it"

    We already know how to fix it, but we just won't. I'm curious how that bit will be solved. I not quite convinced we'll like the AI's solution

    • IAmGraydon 2 hours ago

      AI will fix it by eliminating humans. Or rather, by eliminating human's ability to be gainfully employed so we eliminate each other.

  • pepperoni_pizza 2 hours ago

    Indeed. The GenAI / LLMs are some of the worst thing that happened to humanity.

  • rozal 1 hour ago

    I couldn’t imagine being this pessimistic all the time. Plus seems like your still rattling with the idea that AI has benefits

  • stonedivot 1 hour ago

    How have you felt about the decades of wealth generation from the other big tech companies in the SF area? Have you been dooming and glooming since then? I hope you've been consistent at least.

  • 2muchcoffeeman 1 hour ago

    I’m not sure if you’re one of those anti AI absolutists or not. AI is without a doubt very useful. I use it everyday.

    The problem is how these companies are valued and what their incentives are. They could slow down expansion dramatically because it’s already so useful and focus on efficiency, how to make it more affordable, how to make it safe, making all the tools better.

    But they want their stupid multi trillion dollar valuations based on what they might achieve and promises of the number of people their customers can fire rather than building sustainable and profitable businesses.

    And existing businesses want greater profits so they buy into it and use it as an excuse to fire people (and maybe off shore the work).

    AI is great. But so many people involved with big tech are truly evil bastards. We need to globally come together and tax the shit out of these people to compensate for all the lost jobs and the impact to the climate.

    • ChicagoDave 1 hour ago

      I use AI at work and in my hobbies. I’d argue it’s completely reinvigorated my career and given me the ability to create things I’d never thought possible (a compiler for my own made-up programming language).

      All the ecological and job related issues will normalize.

      I’d lay odds you’d see the same cries 130 years ago during the Industrial Revolution.

      We’ll be fine.

      Being in IT for forty years has provided insight I don’t see in other industries. We have always had to learn and reinvent our careers. AI has just added another hoop to jump through.

      • rootusrootus 39 minutes ago

        In my more optimistic moments I think it's possible that the impact of LLMs on software won't be quite as doomsday as some like to predict. I hope I am not wrong. But there are a lot of other knowledge jobs which I think are even more vulnerable, and I wonder how many of those workers have a flexible enough skillset to move around into something that still fits in the age of AI.

        I have no solution for this, but what I find distressing is that things were working fine without AI. We could have kept on going, the job market was fine, the problems were manageable, rich people getting rich without everyone else necessarily going into poverty. But how do we put the brakes on massive destruction of the workforce with AI? Because each individual company is incentivized to not care about the overall societal effects, even if as humans they understand that when everyone else does the same thing everyone will lose in a big way.

      • ajs1998 20 minutes ago

        The industrial revolution killed lots of people and brought unprecedented kinds of suffering for the survivors.

        Individuals are not as robust to big disruptions as all of society. Nothing is being done to protect individuals.

  • Buttons840 1 hour ago

    To adapt a cliche: AI doesn't cause problem, humans with AI cause problems.

    AI is a tool, a new ability we have. It is inherently good.

    I'm reminded of loving and tight-knit families who win the lottery and receive a lot of money, and then a year later they're divorced, estranged, and hate each other. What happened? Somehow adding a good thing to that family system caused it to fall apart.

    We're the same. We have a society. If you add a good thing like AI to our society, it will fall apart and a lot of people will suffer. Is that AI's fault or our society's fault?

  • liendolucas 1 hour ago

    Thank you. Thank you for putting it clearly in simple words. I don't get it either. What truly strikes me about the industry is how driven by hype is. It is absolutely ridiculous that we are valuating AI companies in the order of trillion dollars. Is insane.

  • lerouxb 1 hour ago

    How do you lose a home you already own other than to sell it or foreclosing and how would this force someone to do either?

  • gspr 1 hour ago

    > the new elite consensus is “who cares, AI will fix it.”

    Indeed. It was already a big problem that too many people were disengaged from our big problems. Now experts and leaders alike are diving headfirst into a future where everyone is encouraged to disengage their mental facilities.

    In the dark days to come, all hands will be off the steering wheel. Almost everyone will myopically focus on driving their AI (operating on the whims of sociopathic trillionaires) to solve problems they no longer understand, without anyone comprehending the big picture anymore. Those who protest will be viewed as crazy.

    I'm scared.

  • onetimeusename 1 hour ago

    I don't know about a lot of this. For example the US is on track to have lower emissions this year than last year overall despite the datacenter buildouts. Last year it was higher because of a cold winter. There may be more emissions from datacenters but we don't know how much but overall electrical usage is up about 2% which is not significant. I don't know about you but I don't think the doomsday scenarios about AI datacenters have panned out so far.

  • buriram 1 hour ago

    The benefits of AI is to allow founders to create billion dollar company without having to employ anyone.

  • toephu2 1 hour ago

    Should we go back to riding a horse-and-buggy? The invention of cars led to all sorts of toxic emissions belong released into the atmosphere.

  • hintymad 1 hour ago

    I beats me why startups prefer SF proper instead of south bay/peninsula/east bay. After, more people settle down there after they have a family, right? Unless startups overwhelmingly hire younger people?

  • maherbeg 52 minutes ago

    Why would anyone lose their home? (genuinely asking) Doesn't SF have rent control and pretty strong tenant protections?

    The disastrous job market isn't necessarily AI. Right now it's still all the overhiring from Covid + huge spike in comp sci degrees over the last few years.

  • bbor 51 minutes ago
      I still don’t understand what the benefit of AI is supposed to be
    

    I am once again begging you to look up, and listen to the scientists. Please. This information is not hidden, nor is it too complex for a layperson, nor is it invalid because of a few critics -- those were the exact arguments used against climate change in 2008, if you recall.

    Please... please. I'm begging you. I know you're dug in, but we need you on our side (i.e. the human, antifascist side). AI is not hype, it's not a bubble, it's not a scam, it's not unknowable, it's not mysterious, it's not right wing, it's not anti-enviornmentalist, it's not anti-artist, it's not anti-you.

    Please. LOOK UP

  • mgkimsal 49 minutes ago

    "...being unemployed for up to a year or more with no end in sight."

    I've got multiple folks in my network hitting the 2 year mark. One at 3, another just hit 4.

    • asqueella 37 minutes ago

      I don't understand (being outside of the SF bubble).

      Why would a smart person be out of work for 2 years?

      Isn't there anything useful they could do? Or is it they couldn't find the right employer? Or maybe they expect to be paid too much?

      • andersonpico 27 minutes ago

        > Why would a smart person be out of work for 2 years?

        more than 180 million people are unemployed worldwide, you think all of them are dumb?

    • kaffekaka 22 minutes ago

      Why is this relevant though?

  • ben_w 37 minutes ago

    I am not saying this is worth any of the rest, this is just to give you the steelman:

    > I still don’t understand what the benefit of AI is supposed to be

    It's to make cheaper for everyone forever the things which were done by the people whose jobs it takes.

  • maplethorpe 25 minutes ago

    Think of it this way: Anthropic figured out how to take everyone's work, everyone's creative output, and mine it like a natural resource. People traditionally thought of labour as being something that was already done and paid for. They didn't think it could be mined and sold a second time. But it turns out it can.

    It's as if someone just discovered how to get considerable energy from burnt ashes. And if you care about making money, that's a beautiful thing.

nikolay 2 hours ago

Ridiculous! Their "investors" would still be unemployed, or targets of vigilantes, and their money will be worth nothing in a civil war of the normals against the Anthropics of the world. People does not want UBI, they want to have meaningful jobs, not just collect handouts.

  • lowbloodsugar 1 hour ago

    What a false dichotomy, especially since neither are on offer right now. We don't want jobs and we don't want UBI. We want a meaningful existence. For some that will be catching a perfect wave, for others it will be creating great art ...

    • nikolay 1 hour ago

      Investors invest with $2T evluations in mind assuming exactly that. It's not a false dilemma.

      • lowbloodsugar 50 minutes ago

        >People does not want UBI, they want to have meaningful jobs, not just collect handouts.

        I know the investors don't give a shit. I'm pointing out that you demanding "meaningful jobs" is brainwashing. Without AGI, someone will always have to do shit jobs. With AGI, nobody will need to work at all. You somehow manage to anchor your negotiating position far below what we really want, and at the same time so utterly unrealistic.

bko 5 hours ago

Remember when SpaceX went public and there was this controversy about being included in stock indexes? Basically stock indexes changed the rules to include giant IPOs into their index immediately rather than waiting some allotted period of time or requiring them to be profitable.

I felt like it was all these people came out of the woodwork objecting on very procedural grounds when they obviously didn't actually care about rules relating to stock index inclusion. They just didn't like Musk.

I wonder if people will relitigate these objections now that now that Anthropic will be fast tracked into the indices same as SpaceX. My guess it they won't and my initial instinct of no one really caring was correct.

  • radlad 5 hours ago

    I am just as concerned about Anthropic as I was about SpaceX. But it's no longer news. The rules already changed.

  • minkeymaniac 5 hours ago

    not the S&P 500.. still a year wait for that one

  • smallmancontrov 5 hours ago

    Your guess has already been proven wrong. Many people had strong opinions that ANT was a dud and that the IPO was a grab for index fund exit liquidity. I don't agree, but it has been a frequently voiced opinion.

    • sorrywhat 3 hours ago

      What about SpaceX? Should your grandma's pension fund invest in Grok at an evaluation of 2 trillion?

Heisen47 5 hours ago

Have high hopes from Anthropic , we are literally living in science fiction right now . Can't wait to see where technology goes in 50 years

  • mvlipwig 4 hours ago

    Assuming we're still here to see it

sksareen1 4 hours ago

Major moment in the revolution of how we work and the ripples across society

NuclearPM 3 hours ago

AI is here to stay. There will be winners and big losers in the rat race.

krembo 4 hours ago

ASK HN: If Amazon holds 15-20% in Anthrophic, why the IPO that peaked to $2T didn't impact the AMZN stock price which actually went down 3% today?

  • peanuty1 4 hours ago

    Amazon's stake in ANT is already priced in to AMZN's stock price.

    • krembo 3 hours ago

      But didn't today's ANT's increase should have impact AMZN relatively?