PaulHoule 6 hours ago

I would like to see this claim justified:

   In the Dewey Decimal System, a book on gardening could potentially be in 
   any of the four places in the system that contained gardening content. 
   With Wayfinder, it’s all in the same place.

I think there is always a question of where to file something, like a book about the history of gardening in England could be filed under gardening or the history of England. You could do better than old systems but you're not getting it right always.

I think the greatest embarrassment in Dewey and Library of Congress (LC) is how they handled computers. Dewey has a trash section at the beginning and computers wind up right after UFOs and bigfoot but oddly most occult subjects end up in the 130's except for a tiny bit in the 398.4 but my witchy friends would be happy to know The Spiral Dance is filed at 299.

LC on the other hand puts almost everything about computers in QA76 except for some clusters in the TK area and some oddly general things in QA75. (In LC The Spiral Dance is filed along with more lurid books on witchcraft that Dewey files at 133.4) Instead of "generic" and "math" and in some alternate universe it would have been reasonable to put computers under electronics in 621.3 and in fact you might find a few books there about how gates are constructed in CMOS there if you're lucky.

The trouble is that computers expanded to embrace everything so books like "How to process your photographs in Adobe Lightroom" ends up in the 0's that really ought to be filed in the 600's (photography as technology) or the 770s (photography as art.) Stuff like that ends up in 0's in Dewey but in LC usually gets filed in the TRs, though if it was like Dewey they'd file photography under the NDs.

The advantage a "bookstore-like" system has is that if it isn't set in stone you can change it.

  • throw0101c 5 hours ago

    > I would like to see this claim justified:

    Perhaps:

        580 – Botany and plant science (scientific study rather than growing)
        631 – Soil, techniques, tools, and equipment
        632 – Plant injuries, diseases, and pests
        634 – Orchards, fruits, and forestry
        635 – Garden crops (Horticulture) and general gardening
        712 / 716 – Landscape design and herbaceous plants in landscape architecture 
    

    * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Dewey_Decimal_classes

    630 is Agriculture, so there's some clustering there.

    • teraflop 4 hours ago

      I don't think anyone's disputing that Dewey Decimal can place "related" books in different places. The question is whether this new proprietary system improves on it.

      Like, consider the parent post's example of "a book about the history of gardening in England". That covers at least two topics, gardening and English history. If you choose to group all the gardening books together in one place, then you force the English history books to be scattered instead. This is just an inherent limitation of reducing a multi-dimensional "topic" space to a linear ordering.

      The meaningful question is whether on average, this system is a more useful grouping than alternatives, based on how well it captures the "related-ness" that people actually care about, and how difficult it is for them to find what they're looking for. You can't answer that question by looking at the classification hierarchy alone. It's an empirical question about how users interact with the system.

      • WalterBright 20 minutes ago

        The solution is classify a book with multiple tags, like imdb.com does with movies.

        • kflynn5 15 minutes ago

          Indeed, although unless we abstract shelving away with some kind of automated retrieval from an indexed, “unordered” store in the stacks, the books will still be linear on the shelves at some level!

          On another note, D is a very cool language. Thanks for your work there.

          • WalterBright 7 minutes ago

            Thank you! People who take the time to use D like it a lot. I'm giving a presentation on Elegant D tonight at nwcpp.org. Anyone withing driving distance is welcome!

  • WorldMaker 5 hours ago

    > The advantage a "bookstore-like" system has is that if it isn't set in stone you can change it.

    The Library of Congress and OCLC (Online Computer Library Center) have the power together to change Library of Congress codes and the two most common sources of Dewey Decimal numbers (Library of Congress Dewey Program and WebDewey respectively). (With the third being the suggested Library of Congress and Dewey codes that publishers just guess at and print in book frontmatter themselves, which are as much there to suggest to Book Sellers where to stack the book, because Book Store orders are still influenced by the Decimal Systems, if no where near as specific in how much they pay attention beyond the first few digits, roughly.)

    The irony is that computers themselves have also reduced pressure on getting the codes as "correct" or "useful" as possible because most people's first search algorithm now is not "find the closest Dewey Decimal number" anymore, but use the computerized catalog.

ilamont 6 hours ago

There used to be an old bookstore just outside of Boston called the New England Mobile Book Fair. It had long ago ceased to be mobile, and was installed in some type of former industrial building consisting of a warehouse like room, winding passages, and former offices, 30k square feet in all (2,787 m2).

It was organized by broad genre (childrens, fiction, etc.), publisher, then author. Niche genres were scattered around in nooks or on certain walls. I don't remember if imprints were handled as individual publishers or mixed in with the parent, or it was ad hoc (very likely!)

It was fun to browse, but unless you knew the publisher the only way to find certain titles or even types of books was to ask one of the staff who either knew off the top of their head or would do a lookup on a beat up old CRT terminal which listed the publisher.

But the selection was incredible. It might have been the biggest bookstore in New England outside of the Harvard Coop. The only comparable sprawling indie bookstores I've see are Powell's in Portland Oregon and Strand in NYC.

Like 90% of bookstores in America, chain or indie or special like this one, Amazon killed it off.

Photos here:

https://www.shelf-awareness.com/issue.html?issue=1611#m14202

https://mleddy.blogspot.com/2010/08/new-england-mobile-book-...

https://thephoenix.com/boston/arts/130690-under-new-ownershi...

ETA: Just found out via the last link that it was 35k square feet, and was located in a former tennis racket factory.

Re: filing system

Its strange system of organizing books by publisher was designed to serve founder (and Jon's father) Louis Strymish's original clientele of librarians and bookstore owners, there to stock their own shelves.

  • morkalork 6 hours ago

    That's hilarious, I can totally understand it. You'd find me in Penguin Classics and my sibling in the Tor Books sections.

  • Finnucane 5 hours ago

    When I was a kid the NEMBF was our local store. In those days there was no terminal to look up books--copies of Books in Print were left out in the front of the store. Of course, after a while you learned the layout, it wasn't that hard to find stuff. And yes, it had more in stock than just about anywhere else, and a big remainder section in the back.

  • phdp 2 hours ago

    My family would occasionally drive hours from where we lived to visit Boston, and one of the highlights of every trip was the visit to the New England Mobile Book Fair. I have fond memories of that place. Thanks for reminding me of it!

  • gfaure 1 hour ago

    Curiously, Japanese bookstores also often organise fiction tankōbon (and only those) by publisher. I'm unsure whether it's due to contractual requirements or whether consumers really prefer this system.

    • blacksmith_tb 1 hour ago

      Hmm, that seems odd, though on the other hand English bookstores don't really "organize" fiction (other than alphabetically by author), I could see a small benefit in discovering new authors similar to those you already like. But the downside would be needing to check multiple subcategories to find someone if you didn't know their publisher, which seems like it'd outweigh that benefit.

zippyman55 2 days ago

Libraries used to be so amazing to me as a kid, but the quality of books I observe in them now a days seems so much weaker than what I remember from my youth. I'm bit sure if it is because I have gotten older and wiser, or if the material has just dumbed down. I've donated stacks of library quality material but honestly the libraries find it easier to just sell it at their monthly book sale.

  • ahazred8ta 2 days ago

    Ours outright refuses to accept any book more than 4 years old.

    • kombookcha 8 hours ago

      I know this seems strange, but it usually has to do with the scarcity of hands and relative abundance of books, and their life cycles in a library.

      Hardback books can be lent out approximately 25 times before breaking and paperbacks much less - 5-8 times is normal. Libraries often try to protect the books by strengthening the spines and applying an extra layer on the cover and such, but this is more trouble to do and less worthwhile if the book is already used and has had a couple of lending cycles shaved off its lifetime. In most cases it will therefore be a better investment to sell a donation and buy new books of known quality and invest your limited man-hours in those.

      • saalweachter 8 hours ago

        There is also such a thing as a library binding, which is much more rugged than the books you buy at a bookstore.

        • sitkack 8 hours ago

          It is not cheap but the books basically last forever. My fav books i cover with tape.

          • bluGill 7 hours ago

            It sits between hardcover and paperback in price. I have a fair amount of library bound books in my personal collection - if I'm going to keep it on my shelf that implies I want to read it more than once and in turn quality is worth paying for. (though more than once I've found my collection re-arranged by size/color or something else that looks good and makes finding the related books impossible, so there is apparently a large group who thinks of book collections as only decoration)

      • Amezarak 8 hours ago

        It’s not that it’s strange, is that the result is that many libraries today are filled almost exclusively with slop and are deaccessioning anything old. Many of them are just entertainment centers.

  • bradknowles 1 day ago

    I worked in the campus main library, while I was studying to get my BS-CS degree. I worked there for almost five years. It was amazing. And I knew both the Dewey Decimal system, as well as the Library of Congress system. And both made sense to me.

    The way bookstores do it is okay, bust doesn’t make nearly as much sense to me. But then many bookstores have closed, for various reasons.

    So, maybe bookstores aren’t the right model for how a library should be organized?

    • pkthunder 9 hours ago

      Arguably libraries are, well, dense libraries of data. Problem is you need to know what you are looking for to find your data.

      Bookstores, IMO, are more stochastic/discovery-based. I’ve walked into a good number of bookstores without a target in mind, and still walked out with a book or two.

      Recently, I went to our local library and tried to do the same - went in with a general idea of what I was interested in reading. Walked out empty-handed.

      From my experience, I’d say there definitely seems to be some positive benefits to transitioning away from a strict numbering system and more to something “organic” (for a lack of a better term).

      • imglorp 8 hours ago

        If you know the Dewey numbers of your interests, related stuff you might like is to the left and right of that point so it's not too bad to find related topics.

        What really bugs me about libraries is fiction, knowing what you want, say Asimov. They might have it under Sci-fi, YA, mystery, or any one of a dozen special interest shelves like Robots or Future or whatever.

        • sitkack 8 hours ago

          Both systems are good for browsing a genre. In curation, one needs to do a higher dimensional join. Say for the history of America you might have a recipe book next to Japanese Internment.

        • bluGill 7 hours ago

          Left and right works for closely related. However most books have options. Should "traditional native American wood carving" go with the history books, the native American culture books, or the wood carving books (the above is the obvious possibilities, but likely there are several more)

  • markus_zhang 9 hours ago

    From what I heard libraries rarely accept personal donations and they usually sell them. I think books are less amazing nowadays, just because there are so many of them, so the average quality is...not amazing.

    • lizknope 8 hours ago

      Back in the 90's I would go to library book sales. I was actually shocked that libraries got rid of books but I remember buying 20 books for about $30. It was amazing and I still have them.

      A few years ago I bought a 3 volume set about the space shuttle from someone on ebay. I was surprised to find that they were former library books. It looks like no one ever borrowed them and they were in great shape.

      I've also noticed that at 2 of the used book stores in my city they have signs that say "No former library books."

      Kind of sad but I guess the library and the book store knows what people want more than I do.

      • cucumber3732842 8 hours ago

        >"No former library books.

        "No books that some other book professional deemed not worth it, we only want the stuff from people who don't know what they got"

        • idiotsecant 7 hours ago

          Probably more that they don't want to encourage people stealing library books to make a few dollars selling them. It's probably an enormous hassle for the bookstore and the library both

          • aitchnyu 7 hours ago

            Next time somebody recycles the meme about "the reader doesnt steal, the thief doesnt read" proverb from alleged modern day Irani booksellers who dont lock their wares, I got the perfect reply.

            • afc 7 hours ago

              Well, I don't know anything about that expression but, in this case, the thief (that steals from the library to sell to the bookstore) doesn't read, and the reader who buys them used didn't steal anything.

      • fg137 7 hours ago

        I have been to exactly one book sell and decided to never go again. None of the books on sale interested me, and I realized that, if I want to read a book, chances are that I can find them in my local library or via interlibrary loan. If a book doesn't exist in the catalog, I probably don't want to read it in the first place. (This has held true for me over the past decade.)

        As someone who is VERY heavy in ebooks, borrows many books on Libby and avoids personally owning physical books, this feels a natural choice for me.

        • calvinmorrison 4 hours ago

          Our library has renowned book sales. Their ephemera and sheet music section is quite good

      • The_Blade 6 hours ago

        i bought TONS of books as a teenager from a Cleveland suburb branch funded by Carnegie. it was Christmas in the summer for a nerdlinger between xc workouts solder-hacking his PS1. before that so many Choose Your Own Adventure books then Bill James

        i don't know the specifics, but Denver (also heavily supported by Carnegie) has large book stuff every week and a dedicated little wing. in this age i am very pro-library. i accidentally stumbled up the Blair-Caldwell African American Research Library yesterday. (edit: i forgot i had a postgrad fellowship at a major uni library such is life). on a related note, bookstore drama is peak Denver performance art right now

        to keep today on topic who among the AI Cylon Final Five overlords think they are the Carnegie of tomorrow's libraries

    • SecretDreams 8 hours ago

      Do you have kids/regularly go to the library?

      I rediscovered the library when I had kids and they aged up to reading ages. Libraries are still great. An absolutely wonderful asset to get kids reading without using screens, which is absolutely important.

      The only difference is libraries do host a lot of content, so you should do some exploration of what types of books you're looking for ahead of going to the library. Or, better yet, use your local library app to browser their index at your leisure.

      For young children's books, just grab stuff off the shelf that is engaging and aligns with your parenting approaches. For young kids, you're just trying to make the experience fun - including going to the library. Most libraries also should be doing activities too, which is also engaging for young kids.

      • markus_zhang 8 hours ago

        Yeah we go there frequently. They also sell books very cheaply, like one buck for a book, 75 cents for a children’s.

  • criddell 8 hours ago

    I don't think very many libraries loan out donated books. It's cheaper for them to buy the book from a vendor who prepares it for their system than to pay staff to do the same with a donated book (Ingram is one of these companies, I'm sure there are others).

    • bluGill 7 hours ago

      Libraries have limited space for books. They need to choose the best, donated books might or might not be the best for the people there.

      • criddell 5 hours ago

        The price of a shelf-ready book from Ingram is probably less than the cost for the library to prepare the exact same donated book for the shelf.

  • pushcx 8 hours ago

    I've found it useful to immediately flip to the back of nonfiction books to see if they have an index. If a publisher didn't think the book merited a couple hundred bucks to an indexer, it's probably not worth reading at all.

    • jawilson2 7 hours ago

      My wife, who is an independent book indexer, thanks you!

      It is more like $5-7/page, depending on the topic, depth, etc. She has degrees in Spanish and economics, including a masters, and found a niche doing scholarly books through places like Yale press, on things like Argentinian economics in the 1970s. She should really be charging more, especially since she hasn't upped it in 5 years; some of these books will take several weeks to finish, and she'll make $1.5-2K, but it comes out to like $10-15/hr.

      • pushcx 7 hours ago

        Thank you for correcting my mistake, I hadn't thought about how long ago I heard that stat.

      • electroweak 7 hours ago

        One of my Borland manuals had an index entry of: "Parrots, dead - see dead parrots" (there was no corresponding entry though). I'm wondering, is it common for indexers to have a little fun like that?

        • jawilson2 6 hours ago

          I doubt she would get away with that with the types of books she does. She has done books for the National Restaurant Association (NRA, amusingly), which is really the only place she could do it that I can think of. But, most of the time, they will say "We have space for N entries on X pages", and there might be some back and forth on trimming some entries.

        • KineticLensman 3 hours ago

          My copy of Steele’s Common Lisp used the teenage mutant ninja turtles as an example of something. The index entries for the individual turtles weren’t the page numbers but instead the dates of the respective artists

        • fhars 2 hours ago

          You can always put in an entry for "recursion" pointing to the "R" page of the index.

        • bitwize 2 hours ago

          The Jargon File's entry on "tail recursion": http://catb.org/~esr/jargon/html/T/tail-recursion.html

          Back in the day there was a company called Zenographics that created design, illustration, and presentation software. After the 90s declared winners in that space (Microsoft PowerPoint and Adobe Illustrator), they specialized in printer drivers, and eventually got folded into the chip company Marvell.

          The instruction manual for Zenographics Mirage had a glossary, and the last entry was for Zeno, the Greek philosopher who gave the company its name. It included a brief description of who he was and his famous paradox: "Where is an arrow as it flies through the air? At any instant, if it is where it is, then it's not moving, but it can't be where it isn't!"

    • kccqzy 1 hour ago

      Some modern books also performatively contain an index but the index is too short and does not have many common phrases. It seems like having an index is a checklist item, without paying attention to the quality of the index.

    • bawolff 39 minutes ago

      surely people too cheap to hire an indexer would just use some computer program to do it (?)

  • gib444 7 hours ago

    Many libraries aren't libraries anymore, probably because of the closure of so many other buildings.

    Here's what my 'library' does:

    - Refugee welcome sessions

    - Computer assistance

    - Maker space

    - Kids classroom / events space

    - Local government (council) signposting

    - Hosting of cultural events

    - General hangout areas, you're free to bring snacks and meals etc

    - Public toilets

    - Dedicated warm/cool space for when it's hot/cold

    Unsurprisingly the quality of the books has nosedived as the focus has shifted to a general third space of last resort. Frankly as an older local interested in learning, it's quite alien.

    IMO this mixture of trying to be everything to everyone isn't great: it's too noisy, people make a mess, the homeless hangout all day, staff are stressed from doing 6 different jobs

    The philosophy collection isn't even a whole small shelf. Barely any classic English literature

    • TFNA 7 hours ago

      The central public library in the city I used to live in was renovated to one of these general third places, and it does have the drawbacks you mention* and few actual books. But people who wanted to read serious books and in silence could still visit any of the academic libraries in the city, or the country's national library.

      * (But also advantages. Young people seem to happy to have got a place to hang out in cold months without having to spend money; the only alternative had been expensive eateries and malls.)

    • WorldMaker 5 hours ago

      Many libraries are also the true last standing Blockbuster for things like video rentals, sometimes videogame rentals, and sometimes music rentals. I've even seen board game rentals at one local library especially dedicated to teenagers.

      Commercial interests got bored of these spaces outside of subscription services and subscription services add up in costs to many underserved audiences, so libraries fill the gap. Sometimes an important gap, especially as Syndication has also sort of "died" and a lot of culturally "important movies" and shows no longer show up on broadcast TV because they are "streaming exclusive" but still for collectors are producing physical media, for the moment. (That is shifting, too, with some of the streaming services producing less and less physical media as well, and major stores like Target and Best Buy leaving physical media of movies and TV almost entirely.)

      • my_username_is_ 2 hours ago

        Ironically, the library from the featured article is actually in the same town as the last remaining Blockbuster video

    • bawolff 36 minutes ago

      I think imagining libraries as being "learning spaces" make sense. Having a book on how to make stuff, and a maker space where you can borrow equipment to make the stuff seems very complementary.

      I agree generally on being a shelter - You cant do both and do a good job at doing both.

  • fnordpiglet 4 hours ago

    Libraries have been gutted to become basically entertainment and a place to use computers for free and watch YouTube. The books are nominally there because it’s a library. Instead the library more and more is becoming a community center, especially as fewer communities have community centers.

    The web is part of it, the sense that if I can search google why do I need a book. AI I’m sure just reinforces this. Also though was a trend in making the library more accessible to more people - rather than a place of quiet study, the idea was to make them into a network of community centers with services like training, activities for kids, places for people to meet up, etc; and the books are distributed between branches in a region rather than being shelved in a central library. The books on shelf tend to be the books that are either selected to be picked up by popular demand or to wait for demand at some branch and shipped to the other library. I’ve also found most truly useful books are always checked out with queues very deep. I have a book I’ve been in queue for to borrow for four months. This means the great books of reference or literature don’t show on the shelves because they literally never land on a shelf. They’re constantly in circulation or being held for pickup.

    Finally the digital book thing really sucked money out of acquisition of paper books. The licensing for digital books is expensive and they end up with no lasting copies. To make it worse they also have limited licensing per title so you end up queuing again for titles people want to read or are high quality.

    Digging under all this though you’ll find the real problem - a million priorities and competing demands, and less funding.

  • TFNA 3 hours ago

    Re: quality drop, it's the same in actual bookstores. I am stunned by how much of the non-fiction section consists of books quickly knocked out by, basically, internet content writers, helped or already outright replaced by AI. The quality of the visual presentation (elaborate binding, color scheme) seems to have gone up, because apparently many customers now want a book mostly for decor, but the actual contents are dreck.

jolt42 6 minutes ago

Seems there's a few variables in what they changed and I find it dubious that Dewey was the problem. Looks like new libraries and nice aesthetics could be what drove improvements.

mrweasel 7 hours ago

The internet always seemed completely enthralled by the by the Dewey Decimal System, but it always seemed like a pretty poor way of locating books at the library. Technically my library uses DK5, but same idea. In many cases it's overly specific and in others not specific enough. If you're just looking for something random to read, it's certainly not helping. Bookstores and second hand stores are in many ways much better at exposing you to random literature.

  • MrFantastic 7 hours ago

    Pre-internet it worked well enough. The chess books were in one section, the programming books in another.

    I'm not sure I understand how that's different than Bookstore layouts.

    My library did have display tables for the new books or award winning books e.g. Hugo award winners/ NY times bestsellers

    Learning how to use microfiche was a game changer.

    • Finnucane 5 hours ago

      Bookstores are organized somewhat more broadly by category. Publishers assign BISAC codes to books to tell the bookstore where to shelve a book. A title can have more than one BISAC code, and the code can encompass subcategories.

  • bortimus 7 hours ago

    It work very well when the card catalogue was still a card catalogue.

    And when libraries were maintained by librarians.

    • StillBored 6 hours ago

      The card catalogue was susceptible to misplaced cards, and wasn't great for more generic searches (ex finding the gardening book that is categorized as history), something a modern computer based card catalog should be much better at along with indicating checked out status/etc.

      But this goes back to the basic idea that you shouldn't need to browse the library if you have a specific goal, you look up the topic and pick out the book from the stacks after looking at the book summary in the catalog. OTOH, if your just there for some fiction, then sure go directly to that section and browse.

      • thaumasiotes 3 hours ago

        > The card catalogue was susceptible to misplaced cards, and wasn't great for more generic searches (ex finding the gardening book that is categorized as history)

        Misplaced cards, yes, but the point of the card catalogue is that a history of gardening book is listed under gardening and history.

  • thaumasiotes 7 hours ago

    > The internet always seemed completely enthralled by the by the Dewey Decimal System, but it always seemed like a pretty poor way of locating books at the library.

    Huh? It isn't a way of locating books at the library, poor or otherwise. The point of the Dewey Decimal System is to have a deterministic way to put the books on the shelves.

  • jerf 7 hours ago

    Any attempt to categorize "all books" into some system that by physical necessity will yield exactly one answer for where some book in some specific library will go will be poor. (That is, even if the DDS or some other system yields multiple valid categorizations for some particular book, in some specific library the book has to live in one specific place.) Some may be somewhat better than others, but "poor" is the best you can hope for. Even ontologies far more lively, rich, and constantly being kept up-to-date, like the systems for classifying scientific papers, fail to really correctly capture the full complexity of the real world.

    In the 21st century we can use computers to sort on any number of dimensions and by any criteria we want and tell the user where the book is directly. Once we've embraced that, it frees the physical organization of the books being optimized for sheer findability by anyone, ever, into whatever other system we like. "Hey, bookstores seem to have evolved this layout as the best way to introduce books to people over the decades" is at least a decent start. I would expect the library would want to evolve some nuances on that based on the fact they're not looking to maximize profits, but it's probably a good start.

sinuhe69 5 hours ago

I really can not understand why finding a book in a library is still considered a problem when computers are available. When a visitor browse a section, they will find similar books. If they search for a specific book or subject, a computer is the best way to go. Dewey or not is not a problem anymore.

  • dam_jackalopes 4 hours ago

    The article explains that encouraging browsing was a main driver for the change as it resulted in more people engaging with the books. It wasn't that people couldn't find the book they wanted, they just took advantage of an opportunity (their entire library system was reorganized at once) to try to adapt to user behavior basically.

  • dionian 2 hours ago

    I've also always been able to find a librarian who is almost always eager to help

smartmic 9 hours ago

Is there any specification/schematics of the "Wayfinder" system they have introduced?

  • bnj 8 hours ago

    This was my question after reading the article, it calls it “proprietary” which I found puzzling for a public library

    • jawilson2 7 hours ago

      Oh, wait, is this how Project 2025 gets to privatize and enshittify libraries or something?

    • ksymph 7 hours ago

      Dewey Decimal system is proprietary too.

  • Arodex 7 hours ago

    Yeah:

    https://www.deschuteslibrary.org/about/news/news?NewsID=3136...

    Where they say they still use the Dewey decimal system, just under a new 2-layer of categorization... As usual, FastCompany is all fluff and overselling. It should really be throttled down on HN as a low-quality source.

    Back to the Wayfinder system, it is described as "proprietary". I hope it is a broadly inaccurate adjective, one of the good things with the Dewey system is its universality.

    • jt2190 7 hours ago

      > I hope it is a broadly inaccurate adjective, one of the good things with the Dewey system is its universality.

      To be specific, "universal" here means "there was a guy named Dewey who created a taxonomy" and not "there is one true universal taxonomy" (which we all know is false.) Dewey is imperfect, in particular for areas of knowledge that didn't really exist when Dewey created it, e.g. "Artificial Intelligence" today, but even "Radio" or "Motion Pictures", etc. librarians basically have to create whole new categories. Special collections are particularly challenging.

      Without the need to be universal, Wayfinder is free to focus on whatever goals the Bend libraries have for it, unencumbered by the endless toil of trying to build a perfect index.

      • SoftTalker 6 hours ago

        Fortunately there's no shortage of numbers, so a Dewey-like system should be infinitely able to accomodate new subjects.

      • WorldMaker 5 hours ago

        The other place that Dewey was deficient in was Fiction. Dewey assigned no numbers to the entirety of Fiction. Fiction is a huge part of the world of books. Libraries generally have to have large fiction catalogs. Most libraries have always used something like Book Store Categories then alphabetical to organize Fiction. Wayfinder sounds like it is sort of better systematizing that classic 2-system approach to me, based on the broad descriptions I've read so far.

vondur 4 hours ago

Do they teach the Dewey Decimal system in schools in the US now? I remember being taught it as far back as elementary school. I can see why, it's like organizing files on your computer, it can be a challenge to figure out where to categorize them.

  • throwaway27448 4 hours ago

    Well it's certainly more directly useful than pretty much any bookstore's layout I've ever seen. But a bookstore is trying to sell books, a library is not.

lavendermon 8 hours ago

This is one of those changes that I would never think to be a problem until after it has been implemented. Kudos to the librarians who made it happen, I am hopeful my local library picks up on the idea soon.

erelong 6 hours ago

Article sounds confusing, it sounds like they both switched a classification system and way to present the books partially out of some political gripes with Dewey's classifications?

Why not use Library of Congress classification system or are there any others that exist? Why reinvent the wheel?

If there are genuine problems with DDS, why not fork it or just create a version update rather than overhaul for a totally different system?

I guess my issue is the classifications all seem arbitrary at some level, so creating a new system just introduces new arbitrary orderings to memorize.

(Alternatively if these are all "proprietary" systems as some comments suggest, could we create an "open" classificstion system or popularize that kind of system?)

  • beej71 1 hour ago

    > Why not use Library of Congress classification system or are there any others that exist? Why reinvent the wheel?

    Probably to have the flexibility to make changes on the fly and not be tied down to a particular system.

    Having been to this particular library, I can safely say it's incredibly easy to find books.

floren 6 hours ago

> Wayfinder eliminates the Dewey reliance on mere numbers, and instead organizes into broad categories and subcategories. A book on growing tomatoes, for example, would be in the Arts and Crafts category, in the gardening subcategory. In the Dewey Decimal System, a book on gardening could potentially be in any of the four places in the system that contained gardening content. With Wayfinder, it’s all in the same place.

This section seems like a misunderstanding of how taxonomies work. Does a book about the architecture in SF's Castro neighborhood belong in History or LGBT or Architecture?

  • WorldMaker 4 hours ago

    In the Dewey Decimal System the book's publisher picks one that they think is most relevant to sales, but also maybe lists the other options, in the book's frontmatter. Eventually the OCLC picks their favorite for WebDewey and the Library of Congress their favorite for the Library of Congress Dewey Program, though often they defer to OCLC.

    But even in the history of paper catalogs books would often have secondary indexes in other parts of the taxonomy. Instead of walking the Dewey Decimal Numbers directly in the stacks you might walk to a card catalog that itself was organized by Dewey Decimal number, scroll through that and find a reference card to that book that would say "See this other Dewey Decimal number for this book in the stacks". (Computerized catalogs make secondary indexes even more common, obviously.)

    The Dewey Decimal taxonomy was never "total" or perfect, it was just often "well indexed", for paper versions of good indexing.

  • bawolff 33 minutes ago

    It sounds like the same thing could be accomplished by just sticking with dewy but adding some human readable signs to the shelves.

bsoles 1 hour ago

I am rather stuck at

> After passing a $195 million bond measure in 2020...

anArbitraryOne 8 hours ago

I guess if one can look up what specific shelf something is on, this is fine, but hopefully it's not hard to find an arbitrary book. But optimizing for browsing does sound like a great idea

hatthew 1 hour ago

This is a very subjective take, but the photos make it look like the space is too open and the shelves too small. My favorite part of libraries is the feeling of delving deep into back corners, surrounded by tall stacks of books, with nobody else in sight. Claustrophilia?

kwertyoowiyop 8 hours ago

This looks like a great idea for browsing. My local library has all fiction shelved together alphabetically (even in their display of new books) which means you can’t browse in a genre. But on the plus side, they now have genre-specific “staff picks” areas so you can easily grab a popular choice that you’ll probably like.

  • criddell 8 hours ago

    Alphabetical by author or title?

    • ygjb 8 hours ago

      By title seems psychotic :/

      • bookofjoe 7 hours ago

        My daughter (43) arranges hers by spine color.

        • dcss_gardener 4 hours ago

          It makes perfect sense for a personal library. Almost no one's personal collection occupies categories completely enough to be worth using even an approximation of dewey or another formal system.

          In a personal collection you're not trying to find an arbitrary volume by author or contents you're looking for a specific physical object you've handled before. "Get within three feet and then look for what it looks like" beats nearly every system at that scale. I learned this from a librarian, who organized their personal library by color as well.

          • WorldMaker 4 hours ago

            I had fun imagining the kind of large-ish library where this would make sense as an intentional design and wrote a short story about it a few years back [0].

            I enjoyed imagining it as an older library with a card catalog system and providing decimal numbers based on cover/spine colors. (Pantone numbers post-date the imaginary date I had in mind for the creation of the library so the story involves a more ad hoc system.) The paper card catalog would even include swatches of color to help navigate.

            It's no worse a system than Dewey Decimal in terms of looking up specific books [1]. It's just worse at browsing a given stack and finding meaningful connections between books, but that was a feature rather than a bug in my fictional library, for reasons explained in the story. (To maybe spoil it, the short answer: Many of the books were problematic and you don't want grouped together next to each other for fear of giving them a weight they don't deserve.)

            [0] https://blog.worldmaker.net/2023/11/16/prismatic-decimal-sys...

            [1] And arguably better in some regards because for instance Fiction books generally have spine colors, but never have Dewey Decimal numbers.

          • thaumasiotes 3 hours ago

            > In a personal collection you're not trying to find an arbitrary volume by author or contents you're looking for a specific physical object you've handled before. "Get within three feet and then look for what it looks like" beats nearly every system at that scale. I learned this from a librarian, who organized their personal library by color as well.

            Somehow I don't believe you. Organizing your books by color means splitting up series. Who's going to do that?

            • dcss_gardener 3 hours ago

              No one obviously. "organize by" doesn't mean "rigidly apply as the only criterion" come on.

              If no one would do something for the very obvious reason I'm not suggesting that you should do the thing no one would do. Only on this site do people go so far out of their way to find a reading of a comment that makes no sense whatsoever.

          • bombcar 28 minutes ago

            Sorting books by color has the same problem as sorting Lego by color - it looks really nice, but then you realize the hard part isn't finding the red, it's finding the piece you want.

            Sorting by anything else makes color useful - "it's the green book on the sci-fi shelf" is much more actionable than "it's the sci-fi book on the green shelf".

        • helterskelter2 3 hours ago

          At least she isn't arranging them with the pages facing outwards so you can't see the spine. This is apparently very popular nowadays.

  • WorldMaker 4 hours ago

    This also relates to the biggest failure of the Dewey Decimal System was that Dewey didn't care for Fiction and there are no numbers assigned to the entirety of Fiction, which is fascinating given how big a proportion of all books published are Fiction.

Animats 1 hour ago

There used to be a video rental store in San Francisco which organized videos by cover art. "Guy with gun". "Girl with gun". "Helicopter shooting". "Man kissing woman" It took only about 20 categories to cover Hollywood's output.

sl0wbrainRot 2 hours ago

Is this permanent or a short term bump due to a bit of viral attenuation?

New Shiny Thing! messaging drawing a crowd that will eventually realize it's still books. Just a new sorting model.

fastaguy88 7 hours ago

The Dewey Decimal System -- haven't seen that since I graduated from high school. Colleges and Universities almost universally use Library of Congress.

phendrenad2 1 hour ago

Dewey Decimal hails from an age before computers and barcodes. Nowadays, there's no reason to use numbers, when we could use a usenet-like classification system instead.

propter_hoc 9 hours ago

This is really lovely. Now I want to visit the Bend OR library!

  • jvert 3 hours ago

    You should! It really is a lovely building and great for browsing around. Also a MakerSpace and an indoor playspace for the little kiddos.

johnea 1 hour ago

We still have some great book stores here in San Diego.

Like Verbatim Books, where staff can instantly determine if a book is in stock, and go straight to the exact location where it is shelved.

Or, DG Wills, which has an incredible collection, and where the staff will show you to a general section of a room, and say "If we have it, it should be somewhere around here" 8-/

Two rows of books on each shelf (one behind the other!), and you'll be on your knees, with your face next to the floor, trying to go through those books on the bottom shelves.

Bookstore organization varies widely. Dewey Decimal and Library of Congress filing systems were developed to overcome the ambiguity.

Unless they're trying to recover that $195M bond by selling $8 lattes to wandering readers, I don't think abandoning Dewey decimal is a good idea.

I wish someone would index and organize the books at DG Wills, they have some truly great books in the collection, if you can find them...

rbobby 3 hours ago

Quality over quantity?

bitwize 1 hour ago

This is the kind of thing I expect LLMs to be really, uniquely good at: taking a book's content and distilling it into a vector in a multidimensional "topic space". A book about, say, Neil Armstrong could point strongly in the "biography" and "space exploration" directions in topic space, and a querent would be able to search on these topics and pull it up. Books might be organized physically according to their strongest few vector topic components; directions as to where the book might be found in the library could be provided by the querying system.

insane_dreamer 1 hour ago

> the libraries’ proprietary Wayfinder system

there is no reason this should be proprietary; that's a step backwards

readthenotes1 2 hours ago

I worked in college libraries and they were all Library of Congress Classification scheme because Dewey was so bad for large collections.

Kinda surprised Dewey is still around

tokai 6 hours ago

They changed to another kind of classification. The ddc vs bookstore-like is bogus. If you get the funds to reclassify your collection in-house specifically for your users, it better be an upgrade.

  • beej71 1 hour ago

    As a user of that library, it feels like an upgrade to me. FWIW.

nekusar 7 hours ago

Good on them. Dewey Decimal is a hot pile of garbage. Of course initially, it looks good.

     1. Women's work is separate from jobs.
     2. African American culture is separate from American culture.
     3. LGBTQ was initially under "Abnormal psychology" in 1932, then later "Social problems" in 1989, and now "306.7 Sexual orientation, transgenderism, intersexuality" right next to child exploitation and BDSM.
     4. Looking up black poets? Its under 326 Colonization, not american poetry. 
     5. “Working animals,” such as cows, sheep, and horses, are in an entirely separate category from animals including lions and tigers.
     6. Diseases are separate from their cures. 
     7. Boats are found hundreds of decimals away from the sinking of the Titanic.

We can do better. And that doing better is dumping the racist and sexist Dewey Decimal system once and for all.

  • snailmailman 4 hours ago

    There are so many problems with it. Another obvious one is that the “Religion” group spans the entirety of 200s. 200-220 is general topics. Then 220-290 is Christianity-specific. But only 290-300 is “Other religions”. And Islam specifically gets limited to 297-298, despite being the world’s second largest religion. Meanwhile, whole swaths of the 200s are dedicated to specific aspects of Christianity. Like 220-230 is entirely dedicated to the Bible.