mirmor23 1 week ago

does anyone tracking this know if the accusations of plagiarism are true/false; wiki doesn't say anything.

  • philodeon 1 week ago

    Yes, the plagiarism has been amply demonstrated.

    https://ncofnas.com/p/dei-fraud-and-cover-up-at-cambridge

    • galleywest200 1 week ago

      Anyone who tries to unironically complain about “DEI” in the headline does not deserve a read. It is just a dog whistle at this point.

      • philodeon 1 week ago

        The article has at least a dozen side by side highlighted examples of plagiarism. The title is irrelevant.

      • moralestapia 1 week ago

        Is this what nu-tolerance looks like?

      • nomel 1 week ago

        Practically, I don't think this ends up being true.

        It's like asking Fox news to report something bad about republicans, or CNN to report something bad about democrats. Only the "opposition" will expose the dirtier truths. If you're strongly aligned with a "side", and you avoid listening to the "opposition", you're guaranteed to miss out on truth.

        Get your news from a wide variety of sources, because they all have very intentional blind spots.

      • throwawaypath 1 week ago

        Robert Dingwall, an emeritus professor of social sciences at two universities in Nottingham, recommended an impartial investigation, stating: "In the current climate, it is difficult to comment on allegations of plagiarism against a prominent minority scholar without seeming to take sides" on diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) policies.

        DEI is the singular reason why so many knew the truth about Arday, but refused to do anything about it. It would be heretical to do anything about it.

      • coldtea 1 week ago

        More like it is a well established concern, that moderates on both sides of the political spectrum agree that it was overdone in a way that didn't exactly promote meritocracy.

    • mirmor23 6 days ago

      wow, thanks.

      that side-by-side view was just crushing.

      Instead, if he had gone the route of translate(english->spanish->vietnamese->arabic->english), he could have 1) beat plagiarism 2) gotten few more ideas of how to extend the original thesis to new directions;

  • coldtea 1 week ago

    They are true, and not just plagiarism but blatant fabulist lies about his past accomplishments and life story.

throwawaypath 1 week ago

“If you tell a lie big enough and keep repeating it, people will eventually come to believe it. The lie can be maintained only for such time as the State can shield the people from the political, economic and/or military consequences of the lie. It thus becomes vitally important for the State to use all of its powers to repress dissent, for the truth is the mortal enemy of the lie, and thus by extension, the truth is the greatest enemy of the State.”