roman_soldier 2 hours ago

Could be an advanced civilisation sucking all the stars energy into the back of their spaceship.

keepamovin an hour ago

Or something just moved in front of it. It did not rage against the dying of the light, the definition of out with a whimper.

amelius an hour ago

What is the timespan of such an event?

  • ben_w 15 minutes ago

    Depends how you define the boundry of the event itself, both in space and in time.

    Stellar cores are relatively small, and the infalling matter is essentially in freefall at high g, gets to a significant fraction of c in about 0.1 seconds.

    The visible disk of a red supergiant — of the kind that can supernova or surprise us by failing — is on the order of multiple AU radius, so speed of light limits there are in the tens of minutes.

bell-cot 3 hours ago

It's been a while since I crawled Wikipedia's rabbit hole on this - but I recall there being regions of the stellar "mass vs. metallicity" graph in which direct collapse to a black hole is the expected outcome.

Is there an astrophysicist in the house?

  • metalman 2 hours ago

    not an astro anything, but the easy question is how does the sun switch off it's light output so suddenly as to cause a perfect garavitational collapse presumably it has to be a large metal rich star and exist without too much local gas or a companion star one thing is clear at this point is that the variety of stelar and galactic variability is much larger than what was predicted even a few decades ago, though the idea of a star just neatly removing itself from this universe when it's done, is very strange indeed

    • madaxe_again an hour ago

      It doesn’t necessarily switch anything off or collapse - it’s possible for a star of the right mass and density to simply end up with a core that is held up only by degeneracy pressure, and the core slowly shrinks as it cools until it lies within its schwarzschild radius, and the rest of the star is either quietly consumed by this relatively slow process, or just escapes as though nothing much happened. Which from the outside looks like the star just turning off.

      • MoonGhost 25 minutes ago

        It cannot just escape without a push as the gravity is still the same?